המן- The Architect of his Own Demise

Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) פורים no. ⁨16⁩ Pocket Guide p. 66 תשס"ה (2004–05) English 35 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 35 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav shows that in the Megillah, where Hashem hides His face, Haman himself prepared every step of his own downfall, and that Amalek's attack on 'the end' fails because the Jewish people have no end.

The Rav opens with the twelve months, which correspond to the twelve tribes arranged in four camps. Nisan, the month of Yehuda and of the miracles of Egypt, comes first; the months descend until Adar, the last, whose Megillah has no open miracle at all. This is hester panim: Hashem hides, yet controls everything, and every small story in the Megillah is a wheel in one mechanism. The Rav reads Chazal's identification of Memuchan with Haman as a signal to watch Haman, who unknowingly prepared Esther's rise, Mordechai's honor, his house and his own gallows. Adar means a cloak, and Dan is the last and most removed tribe, yet his son Chushim killed Esav. Amalek attacks those at the end, outside the camp, as Haman rejoiced when the lot fell on Adar; but the Jewish people have no end, and Purim protects those at the end.

Topics: Megillas Esther · Hester Panim and Suffering · Chodesh Adar · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek · Netzach Yisroel

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Twelve months, twelve tribes, and Adar

    The Rav matches the twelve months to the twelve tribes in their four camps, from Nisan and Yehuda to Adar at the end. He notes that Amalek has no future, and that the months descend from Nisan's miracles to Adar's Megillah, where no open miracle appears.

  2. 5:51 Hidden face: Haman prepares everything listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Gemara's source for Esther in the Torah, hester panim, and explains that every small story in the Megillah is a wheel in one mechanism. From Chazal's identification of Memuchan with Haman he shows that Haman prepared Vashti's removal, Mordechai's greatness and his own gallows.

  3. 11:35 Only Haman knew how to do it listed in the guide

    The Rav calls it a mockery of avodah zarah that it prepares its own demise. Mordechai, a tzaddik with rachmanus and no taste for honor, could not have devised the cruel gallows, the royal honor or the mansion; Haman did all three, unknowingly for Mordechai.

  4. 16:17 Adar the cloak; Dan and Chushim

    Returning to the months, the Rav explains that Adar means a cloak, as with Esav's mantle of hair: the miracles are covered. Dan, the last and most removed tribe, still bears a permutation of the Shem Havayah, and it was Dan's son Chushim, deaf and mute, who killed Esav at Yaakov's burial.

  5. 20:00 The last generation: hester panim today

    The Rav calls the generation before Moshiach a generation of Chushim and of great hester panim. He recalls that in his youth there were universally accepted leaders, the last being the Chazon Ish, while today great men are accepted only by their own factions.

  6. 23:12 Amalek attacks the end; Adar Sheini listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that those of Dan expelled from the camp were outside the Clouds of Glory, so Amalek could strike the stragglers. Haman, like Amalek, rejoiced when the lot fell on Adar, the month of the end, and a leap year's Adar Sheini, likened to the last eight pesukim of the Torah, seemed even more outside the camp. His mistake: these too belong to the camp.

  7. 31:18 No end for Yidden; Shushan Purim

    The Rav concludes that the Jews have no end: when they finish the Torah they begin Bereishis again, and Purim protects those at the end of the camp. He then speaks of the special holiness of Shushan Purim, kept today only in Yerushalayim, and of his plan to be there.

The shiur, written up

Twelve months, twelve tribes, and Adar

0:30

The Rav opens by matching the twelve months to the twelve tribes, arranged like the four camps in the desert, three tribes to each. Nisan, the new year for kings, belongs to Yehuda, the tribe of kingship, and the last month, Adar, comes at the end. On falling, he brings the passuk in Michah: when Knesses Yisrael falls it rises again, but the enemy who falls does not rise, and Amalek's end is destruction (Bamidbar 24:20). a,b

4:31

The months descend from Nisan, named for its miracles, down to Adar. Just as the Exodus came with open miracles, the Megillah of Adar has none: no splitting of the sea, no manna, no earth swallowing anyone. Everything happened naturally.

Hidden face: Haman prepares everything

5:51

The Rav brings the Gemara (Chullin 139b) that finds Esther in the Torah in Hashem's hiding of His face. The Megillah teaches that even when no miracles are seen, Hashem is there, hidden, and controls everything. Its many small stories are like the wheels of a watch, each needed for the mechanism to work. d

7:34

Following the Gemara (Megillah 12b) that Memuchan, who advised removing Vashti, was Haman, the Rav asks why that name appears only at the start. It signals to watch Haman: he removed Vashti so that Esther replaced her, he raised Mordechai, he devised the royal honor and he built the gallows. Nothing in his downfall came from outside; Haman made the whole Megillah. e

Only Haman knew how to do it

11:39

The Rav calls this a mockery of avodah zarah, which itself prepares its own demise. Had Mordechai, a tzaddik with rachmanus, prepared Haman's death, he would have made it as painless as possible; only cruel Haman could make a gallows fifty amos high with painful ropes.

14:24

Likewise, asked about honor, Mordechai might have suggested a good aliyah next Shabbos, but Haman knew what honor is. And when Esther set Mordechai over Haman's house (Esther 8:2), he moved into a palace Mordechai would never have built for himself. h

Adar the cloak; Dan and Chushim

16:32

Returning to the months, the Rav explains that Nisan is named for miracles and Adar for their concealment: Adar is a cloak, as with Esav's mantle of hair (Bereishis 25:25). Each month and tribe carries a permutation of the Shem Havayah; Dan, the last, is the most removed from holiness, yet still connected to it. i

17:54

Dan had one son, Chushim, who could neither hear nor speak, yet he killed Esav when Esav blocked Yaakov's burial (Sotah 13a). j

The last generation: hester panim today

20:00

The generation before Moshiach, the Rav says, is a generation of Chushim and of great hester panim. In his youth there were leaders all of Klal Yisrael accepted, such as the Chofetz Chaim and Rav Chaim Ozer, and the last was the Chazon Ish. Today there are great men, but each faction accepts its own, and this is how the Torah says it will be before Moshiach.

Amalek attacks the end; Adar Sheini

23:14

Dan always gets into trouble. Those of Dan who were expelled from the camp were outside the Clouds of Glory, and so Amalek could attack them; the Rav reads this into the pesukim of Amalek's coming at Refidim and its striking the stragglers (Shemos 17:8, Devarim 25:18). Amalek always starts with the one at the end. l,m

26:07

Haman too saw himself at an end of time: the Megillah closes shortly before the second Beis HaMikdash, at the close of the first exile. Like Amalek he thought he could start with the end, and he rejoiced when the lot fell on Adar, the month of the end.

27:51

Adar Sheini stands outside the twelve, outside the camp. The Rav compares it to the last eight pesukim of the Torah, written by Yehoshua or by Moshe in tears (Bava Basra 15a). Haman rejoiced that the lot fell where Moshe died (Megillah 13b), but they are not outside the camp: Moshe lives on in Yehoshua. o,p

No end for Yidden; Shushan Purim

31:24

The Rav concludes that Amalek has an end but the Jews do not: when they finish the Torah they begin Bereishis again. Purim is the protection for those at the end of the camp. He adds that Shushan Purim has special holiness, kept today only in Yerushalayim.

Sources

Torah

  1. b Bamidbar 24:20 text index In the write-up: 0:30
  2. i apparently Bereishis 25:25 index In the write-up: 16:32
  3. l Shemos 17:8 text index In the write-up: 23:14
  4. m Devarim 25:18 text index In the write-up: 23:14
  5. q apparently Devarim 33:21 31:42 index

Nevi'im

  1. a Michah 7:8 text index In the write-up: 0:30
  2. k Ovadiah 1:21 19:47 text index

Kesuvim

  1. c apparently Esther 6:13 2:34 index
  2. f apparently Esther 8:15 9:34 index
  3. g Esther 6:6-9 9:49 text index
  4. h Esther 8:2 text index In the write-up: 14:24

Talmud Bavli

  1. d apparently Chullin 139b index In the write-up: 5:51
  2. e apparently Megillah 12b index In the write-up: 7:34
  3. j apparently Sotah 13a index In the write-up: 17:54
  4. o apparently Bava Basra 15a index In the write-up: 27:51
  5. p apparently Megillah 13b index In the write-up: 27:51

Talmud Yerushalmi

  1. n Yerushalmi (place not identified) 28:05 index

Key points

  1. 4:31 The months descend from Nisan, named for its miracles, to Adar, whose Megillah contains no open miracle at all.
  2. 6:02 The message of the Megillah is that even when no miracles are seen, Hashem is hidden but controls everything.
  3. 8:10 Haman prepared every element of his own downfall: Vashti's removal, Mordechai's honor, his house and the gallows.
  4. 17:28 Dan, the last tribe, is the most removed from holiness and always gets into trouble, yet he remains connected to the Shem Havayah.
  5. 24:09 Amalek attacks those at the end, outside the camp, and Haman likewise hoped to prevail in Adar, the month of the end.
  6. 31:24 The Jewish people have no end: Amalek has an end, but when the Jews finish they begin again.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 7:58 Why does the Megillah call Haman by the name Memuchan only at its beginning?

    Answer: 8:10 To signal at the outset that Haman is preparing something; everything in the Megillah that brought his downfall, he himself prepared.

  2. Question: 12:22 If Haman wanted Mordechai hanged, why was it not Mordechai who prepared the gallows for Haman?

    Answer: 12:43 Mordechai was a tzaddik with rachmanus and would have made a painless, comfortable death; only cruel Haman could design a gallows fit for Haman.

  3. Question: 27:13 Why was Haman happy when the lot fell on Adar?

    Answer: 30:55 He thought, like Amalek, that he could attack the Jews at the end, outside the camp; his mistake was that they are not outside the camp, for the Jews have no end.

Stories

  1. 18:55 Chushim kills Esav at Yaakov's burial

    At the burial of Yaakov Avinu, Esav came running and claimed the Me'aras HaMachpelah belonged to him, and he tried to stop the burial. Chushim, the son of Dan, who could not hear or speak, asked what was happening, and was told by signs that Esav was not letting his grandfather be buried. Chushim took a rod and struck Esav, killing him.

    In the story: Chushim ben Dan, Esav, Yaakov Avinu, Dan

    told in 4 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 16:32 Adar, the last month, mirrors Nisan in reverse: Nisan is named for its open miracles, while Adar means a cloak, the covering of miracles, and its Megillah has none.
  2. 7:58 The Megillah names Memuchan, Chazal's Haman, only at its start, to signal the reader to watch Haman, because Haman is the one who made the whole Megillah.
  3. 12:43 Mordechai's greatness had to be designed by Haman: a tzaddik full of rachmanus would have made a painless death for his enemy and asked for little honor or house, while only cruel, honor-seeking Haman knew how to make a fifty-amah gallows, a royal parade and a palace.
  4. 18:25 The lowest tribe, Dan, produced Chushim, who could not hear or speak, yet he is the one who killed Esav; the Rav links this to the generation before Moshiach, a generation of Chushim and hester panim.
  5. 27:51 Adar Sheini stands outside the order of the twelve months, like the last eight pesukim of the Torah, which have a separate status; Haman thought the Jews there were outside the camp, but they too belong to it.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Chushim ben Dan, Dan, Esav, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Memuchan, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Naftali, Rabbi Chaim Ozer Grodzinski, the Chazon Ish, the Chofetz Chaim, the Imrei Emes (Rabbi Avraham Mordechai of Ger), Vashti, Yaakov Avinu, Yehoshua bin Nun, Yehudah (son of Yaakov), Yeravam ben Nevat

Terms אדר שני, אחרית הימים, הסתר פנים, ליצנות, מחוץ למחנה, נחשלים, ענני הכבוד, שבטים, שושן פורים, שם הוי"ה

Report an error on this page