“גם ושתי המלכה עשתה משתה נשים” - “להיות כל איש שורר בביתו”
Catalog entry: זמנים פורים no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 23 תשל"ה (1974–75) Yiddish 1 hr 29 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Adar, whose combination of Hashem's Name is hidden in the final letters of a passuk about the donkey, is the dark end-time when the 'feminine' force of the sitra achra rises, and that Vashti's party and Memuchan's decree, Purim's unity and a Jew's root in the 'beginning' turn it all around.
The Rav opens with the idea that each month has its own combination of Hashem's Name, and Adar's is hidden in the final letters of 'osri lagefen iro' (Bereishis 49:11). Through the Ohr HaChaim he explains that in the sitra achra the female is stronger than the male, and that before Moshiach this force rises, as the Megillah shows. Vashti's separate women's feast was a push for 'equality', and Memuchan's decree that every man rule his home, which the Gemara attributes to Haman and Tosfos' Midrash to Daniel, restored the right side over the left. He then builds on reishis and acharis: Israel is the true 'beginning', Amalek a false one; the last generations, like the last pesukim of the Torah, are bound to Bereishis. Adar is the month of earth and the donkey, yet a Jew's emunah comes from his root. He closes with Moshe's soul in every generation, unity through mishloach manos, and knocking on the gates of mercy on Purim.
Topics: Chodesh Adar · Purim · Megillas Esther · Kedushah and Kelipah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Adar's Name and the Ohr HaChaim's dream
The Rav explains that each month has a combination of Hashem's Name, and Adar's is in the final letters of 'osri lagefen iro'. He brings the Ohr HaChaim that the passuk speaks of two redemptions, and that in the sitra achra the female is stronger, illustrated by the Ohr HaChaim's own dream.
-
8:06 The female force before Moshiach
The Rav says that before Moshiach the female side of the sitra achra fights hardest, links the seven nations to the seven bad middos, and explains why Canaan corresponds to chesed. He then shows why 'iro' ends with a heh.
-
12:51 Adar as the end of days; Manoach and Shimshon
The Rav describes Adar as the last, darkest part of the night before Nissan and the Megillah as the program of the footsteps of Moshiach. He explains that in holiness the man leads, why honoring one's wife comes from a different root, and how Manoach following his wife spoiled Shimshon's chance to be Moshiach.
-
19:24 Vashti's separate feast for women listed in the guide
The Rav reads 'gam Vashti hamalkah asesa mishteh nashim' as a separate convention of women demanding equal rights, and points out that the Megillah writes 'Vashti hamalkah' with her name before her title, showing her claim to equal rank.
-
23:38 Memuchan: Haman or Daniel? listed in the guide
The Rav brings Memuchan's advice that every man rule his home, the Gemara that Memuchan is Haman, and Tosfos citing a Midrash that he is Daniel, and asks why Tosfos mentions it. He explains that Vashti's success would have made din prevail over chesed above, so Hashem prepared the cure before the blow.
-
28:50 The court below rules, and Daniel's ruling listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the court below rules and the court above follows, with a story of the Ruzhiner and the Sanzer Rav. Daniel's ruling that every man rule his home was really a ruling for the heavenly court that the right side prevail, so the Gemara and the Midrash do not conflict.
-
32:29 Israel the true 'reishis', Amalek the false
The Rav asks on Rashi why the Torah begins with Bereishis and answers that Israel is called 'reishis'. Amalek is 'reishis goyim' but has no 'acharis', while the last pesukim of the Torah, which speak of the last generations, are joined to Bereishis.
-
37:07 The donkey of Avraham, Moshe and Moshiach
The Rav brings Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer that Avraham, Moshe and Moshiach ride the same donkey, the symbol of utter materialism, which tzaddikim subdue. He ties Amalek's claim to be 'reishis' to materialism and explains the sanctity of redeeming a firstborn donkey.
-
41:29 Amen, and reading the Megillah backwards
The Rav asks what Rabbi Chanina adds by saying 'Amen' stands for Kel Melech Ne'eman. He then explains that reading the Megillah draws down the same miracles each year, which is why reading it backwards is invalid, why Haman's ten sons fill a whole column, and how the plagues in the Haggadah work the same way.
-
46:49 Rabbi Yehuda, Rabbi Yose and Rabbi Shimon
To explain Rabbi Yehuda's simanim, the Rav retells the Gemara of the three Tannaim who spoke about Rome and brings the Chiddushei HaRim that they carried the souls of Yehuda, Yosef and Shimon, which explains each one's fate.
-
50:58 Four elements and burning the chametz
The Rav connects the four letters of Hashem's Name, the four elements and the four camps, with Yehuda corresponding to fire, the root of all. From here he explains Rabbi Yehuda's view that chametz is destroyed only by burning, and why he gave simanim of initials for the plagues.
-
57:36 Emunah in the dark; Har HaBayis and Machpelah
The Rav calls Adar the element of earth, a time of darkness, and answers the question on 'Amen': a Jew can believe because he is rooted in Kel Melech Ne'eman. He contrasts Har HaBayis as Israel's 'reishis' with Me'aras HaMachpelah as its 'acharis', both holding the same Adam and Avos.
-
1:03:08 Adar's final letters reversed; Moshe in every generation
Returning to the opening, the Rav explains why Adar's Name is in final letters about the donkey, and how Purim turns final letters into first letters. He then explains that Adar is the month of Moshe's passing and birth, that Moshe's soul is in every generation under another name, and why Moshe's name is absent from Tetzaveh.
-
1:10:13 Haman's thought of despair and its answer
The Rav explains that the despairing thought 'what connection do I have to Torah' is Haman's thought within a Jew. The answer is to strengthen oneself in emunah, connect to the root and to Moshe's soul, and feel newly born in Adar.
-
1:15:21 Mishloach manos as one great eruv
The Rav urges connecting with good friends, against Haman's 'mefuzar umeforad', and explains mishloach manos as an eruv joining all Jewish families into one. He adds that Purim's light is above the world and that Yom Kippur is only 'like Purim'.
-
1:19:22 Purim and the level of yechidah
The Rav explains that Purim's holiness is so great that one drinks until he cannot feel, and that on Purim all Jews rise to the level of yechidah, 'ish Yehudi' as 'ish yechidi'. He compares Purim's rhymes and music to a wedding and says Hashem Himself sends mishloach manos to every Jew.
-
1:24:12 The Gostininer knocks; Esther's request
The Rav tells how the Gostininer became a great Rebbe by knocking on the Kotzker's door on Purim, and derives that on Purim one must knock on the gates of mercy. He closes with Esther's 'she'elasi uvakashasi' as the axis of the Megillah and Adar as a time of 'v'nahafoch'.
The shiur, written up
Adar's Name and the Ohr HaChaim's dream
The Rav opens with the idea that each month has its own combination of Hashem's Name, hidden in a passuk. Nissan's is in the first letters of 'yismechu hashamayim v'sagel ha'aretz', while Adar's is in the final letters of 'osri lagefen iro' from Yaakov's blessing to Yehuda. He notes that months connected with din usually take their Name from final letters. c,a
He brings the Ohr HaChaim that the passuk speaks of two redemptions: at Yetzias Mitzrayim the male donkey, 'iro', was subdued, but the female, 'asono', will fall only at the final redemption. In the sitra achra the female is stronger than the male, the reverse of holiness. The Ohr HaChaim tells of a dream in which he threw down the male easily, while the female cost him all his strength. b
The female force before Moshiach
Before Moshiach, the Rav says, the female side of the sitra achra fights hardest, since it knows its end is near. The seven nations are the roots of the seven bad middos, and Canaan corresponds to chesed because in the sitra achra the male is subdued. He sees this in the world's push for equality for women.
Adar as the end of days
Just as Nissan, when the world was created, is the beginning, Adar is the end of days: the last and darkest part of the night, as Chazal call Esther the end of all miracles. The whole Megillah, says the Rav, describes the footsteps of Moshiach, since it took place just before the second Beis HaMikdash, a time of hiddenness without Hashem's Name. d,e,f
Vashti's separate feast
The Megillah opens with Achashverosh's feast for everyone, and then 'gam Vashti hamalkah asesa mishteh nashim', a separate feast in the royal house. The Rav reads it as a convention of women demanding equal rights. Achashverosh is always 'hamelech Achashverosh', title first, but Vashti is 'Vashti hamalkah', her name first, marking her claim to equal rank. j
Memuchan: Haman or Daniel?
Memuchan advised that every man rule his home. The Gemara says Memuchan is Haman, and Tosfos brings a Midrash that he was Daniel, whose wife had dominated him. The Rav asks why Tosfos mentions it at all. k,l,m
Had Vashti's convention succeeded, what happens below would have made din prevail over chesed above. So Hashem prepared the cure before the blow. Daniel, whose soul's root was the redemption, could not bring it while subject to his wife.
The court below rules
The court below rules and the court above follows. The Ruzhiner asked the Sanzer Rav whether he may move to a nicer dwelling; when the Sanzer said yes, he realized too late that the Ruzhiner meant leaving this world. So Daniel's ruling was a ruling for heaven that the right side prevail, and Haman ruled the same below; there is no contradiction. l,m
Israel, the true 'reishis'
The donkey of Avraham, Moshe and Moshiach
Amen, and reading the Megillah backwards
The Rav asks why Rabbi Chanina explains 'Amen' as Kel Melech Ne'eman, when its simple meaning, 'true', is enough. He leaves the question open for later. v
When the Megillah is read, the same miracles return each year and Haman's power is broken again. So one who reads it backwards, as a story of the past, has not fulfilled the mitzvah. Haman's ten sons, the ten powers of the sitra achra, must fill a whole column, so their downfall is complete. The plagues in the Haggadah work the same way. w,x
Rabbi Yehuda, Rabbi Yose and Rabbi Shimon
Four elements and burning the chametz
The Mishnah records Rabbi Yehuda's view that chametz is destroyed only by burning, while the Chachamim allow scattering to the wind or throwing into the sea. The Rav explains that the four letters of Hashem's Name correspond to the four elements and, following Rabbeinu Bachya, to the four camps. Yehuda corresponds to fire, the yud, the root of all, and so his camp comes first. ab,ac
Everything is built of the four elements, and, as the Ohr HaChaim says, removing one undoes the others, so chametz can be destroyed through any of them. Rabbi Yehuda, true to his root in fire, insists on reaching the root itself. That is why he gave the plagues as initials: the first letter holds the whole word. ad
Emunah in the dark
Final letters reversed; Moshe in every generation
Now the Rav returns to his opening. Adar's Name is in final letters, and in words about the donkey, the lowest earth. Yet Hashem's Name is there too, and Israel has an 'acharis' joined to its 'reishis'. On Purim the final letters turn into first letters. a,ah
Haman's thought of despair
The Rav describes a Jew who thinks: what has become of me? I don't learn, I don't daven, my mind is full of foolishness and sins; what connection do I have to Torah and to Hashem? This, he says, is Haman's thought inside a Jew, the death of Moshe within him.
Instead, the Rav says, one must connect to the beginning and the root, and feel in Adar that he is newly born, as Moshe was born then. In this month the final letters can become first letters, Haman's power can turn into the King's, and the left yield to the right.
Mishloach manos as one great eruv
The Rav urges connecting with good friends and Rebbes, found in every generation. Haman's plan was that Jews are 'mefuzar umeforad'; Mordechai and Esther answered 'lech kenos'. Mishloach manos, like an eruv chatzeiros, makes all families one, sharing each other's food without minding. Amalek's mockery cannot bear this unity. al,am
Purim and the level of yechidah
The Gostininer knocks; Esther's request
Sources
Torah
- a Bereishis 49:11 text index In the write-up: 0:37, 11:45, 1:03:08
- i Bereishis 49:17-18 text index In the write-up: 15:45
- q Bamidbar 24:20 text index In the write-up: 33:22, 38:53
- r Devarim 34:5 text index In the write-up: 34:45
- u apparently Shemos 13:13 index In the write-up: 38:53
- aa Bereishis 37:26 text index In the write-up: 48:37
- ae Bereishis 36:31 text index In the write-up: 1:00:12
- at Bereishis 22:3 text index In the write-up: 37:07
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
- c Tehillim 96:11 text index In the write-up: 0:37
- j Esther 1:9 text index In the write-up: 19:39
- k Esther 1:16-22 text index In the write-up: 23:47
- n apparently Tehillim 81:5 29:08 index
- o Esther 1:13 32:29 text index
- af Mishlei 20:21 text index In the write-up: 1:00:12
- ah Esther 9:22 text index In the write-up: 1:03:08, 1:26:40
- ak Esther 2:5 text index In the write-up: 1:08:09, 1:24:22
- al Esther 3:8 text index In the write-up: 1:15:21
- am Esther 4:16 text index In the write-up: 1:15:21
- ap Tehillim 22:21 text index In the write-up: 1:20:23
- ar Esther 7:2-3 text index In the write-up: 1:26:40
- as Tehillim 122:8 1:23:15 text index
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
- d apparently Rosh Hashanah 11a index In the write-up: 13:13
- e Chullin 139b text index In the write-up: 13:13
- f Yoma 29a text index In the write-up: 13:13
- g Yevamos 62b text index In the write-up: 15:45
- h Berachos 61a text index In the write-up: 15:45
- l Megillah 12b text index In the write-up: 23:47, 28:53, 1:24:22
- v Shabbos 119b text index In the write-up: 41:32, 57:42
- z Shabbos 33b text index In the write-up: 46:49
- ai Megillah 13b text index In the write-up: 1:05:43
- ao Megillah 7b text index In the write-up: 1:19:22
- aq Shabbos 88a text index In the write-up: 1:20:23
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 2:18 Adar's combination of Hashem's Name lies in the final letters of 'osri lagefen iro... bnei asono', and the ending heh of 'iro' hints that in Adar the male yields to the female.
- 6:07 Following the Ohr HaChaim, in holiness the male is stronger, but in the sitra achra the female is stronger, and its final subjugation comes only with Moshiach.
- 15:15 The Megillah describes the period before the second Beis HaMikdash as a time like the footsteps of Moshiach, and Vashti's separate women's feast was the female force pushing for equality.
- 24:06 Memuchan's decree that every man rule his home strengthened the right side over the left; the Gemara says Memuchan was Haman and the Midrash in Tosfos says Daniel, and the Rav explains both are true.
- 34:07 Israel is the true 'reishis', while Amalek is a false 'reishis' with no 'acharis'; the last generations, like the last pesukim of the Torah, are joined to Bereishis.
- 58:07 Even in the darkest time a Jew can believe, because 'Amen' is Kel Melech Ne'eman and he is rooted in Hashem Himself.
- 1:13:31 In Adar, the month Moshe was born, every Jew can connect to Moshe's soul, to good friends and to all of Klal Yisrael, and on Purim one should knock on the gates of mercy.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 11:40 Why is Adar's combination of the Name found in the final letters, and why must 'iro' end with a heh?
Answer: 12:35 Because Adar is the end-time when the female of the sitra achra rises, so the male yields to the female, and the word 'his donkey' is written as 'her donkey'.
-
Question: 25:09 Why does Tosfos cite a Midrash that Memuchan was Daniel, when the Bavli says he was Haman?
Answer: 31:34 Both are true: Daniel, the soul of redemption, ruled for the heavenly court that the right side prevail, and Haman ruled the same below.
-
Question: 33:20 Rashi's answer, that the Torah tells of creation to show that Hashem may give the land to whom He wishes, does not explain why it begins with Bereishis rather than the mitzvos.
Answer: 34:04 The world was created for Israel, called 'reishis', and the Torah's last pesukim, about the last generations, must be joined to Bereishis.
-
Question: 41:47 What does Rabbi Chanina add by saying 'Amen' stands for Kel Melech Ne'eman, when its simple meaning is 'true'?
Answer: 58:56 He explains where a Jew gets the strength to believe even in darkness: he is rooted in Kel Melech Ne'eman, in Hashem Himself.
-
Question: 46:49 Why does Rabbi Yehuda give simanim of initials for the plagues?
Answer: 56:17 He follows his own view that chametz must be burned: as the soul of Yehuda, linked to fire, the root of the elements, he wants to reach the root, which the initials are.
-
Question: 1:08:09 Why is Moshe's name absent from Parshas Tetzaveh?
Answer: 1:08:15 Because Moshe's soul appears in every generation under another name, so in the parshah of his yahrzeit his particular name is not written.
Stories
-
6:35 The Ohr HaChaim's dream
The Rav relates that the Ohr HaChaim told of a dream in which he fought the male of the sitra achra and threw him down easily. When the female of the sitra achra came, he had to strain with all his strength, and he threw her down many levels, but not as far as the male. The Ohr HaChaim connects this to the passuk about the two redemptions.
In the story: the Ohr HaChaim
-
29:28 The Ruzhiner asks the Sanzer Rav about moving
The Rav tells that the Ruzhiner asked the Sanzer Rav whether he may move to another, nicer dwelling, and the Sanzer answered, why not. Then the Sanzer realized that the Ruzhiner meant he wished to leave this world for the upper world, and wanted to take back his answer, but the Ruzhiner said it was too late, he had already ruled. The Rav brings it to show that the court below decides.
In the story: Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz)
-
47:08 Rabbi Yehuda, Rabbi Yose and Rabbi Shimon on Rome
The Rav retells the Gemara: Rabbi Yehuda praised the Roman kingdom for its roads and works, Rabbi Yose kept silent, and Rabbi Shimon said they did everything only for themselves. When the words reached the government, it decreed that Rabbi Yehuda be raised, Rabbi Yose be exiled to Tzippori, and Rabbi Shimon be killed. Rabbi Shimon fled and hid in a cave for thirteen years.
In the story: Rabbi Yehuda, Rabbi Yossi (ben Chalafta), Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai
-
1:24:12 The Gostininer knocks on the Kotzker's door
The Rav relates that the Gostininer was once not so great. In the Kotzker's last years he had locked himself in, and people were afraid to approach him. One Purim the Gostininer took courage and knocked hard until the Kotzker opened and asked what he wanted; he answered that he was poor and wanted 'matanos la'evyonim'. The Kotzker let him in for several hours, and he came out a different person and later became a great Rebbe.
In the story: Rabbi Yechiel Meir of Gostynin, the Kotzker Rebbe
Insights
- 9:54 The Rav explains that Canaan corresponds to chesed precisely because in the sitra achra the male side is subdued ('nichna'), the reverse of holiness, where gevurah yields to chesed.
- 11:45 The kri/ksiv of 'iro' shows the hidden tziruf of Adar: only because the word ends with heh is the Name complete, hinting that in Adar the male yields to the female.
- 30:54 The Gemara's 'Memuchan is Haman' and the Midrash's 'Memuchan is Daniel' do not conflict: Daniel, the soul of redemption, ruled for the heavenly court that the right side prevail, and Haman ruled the same thing below.
- 56:17 Rabbi Yehuda's simanim for the plagues follow his view that chametz must be burned: as the soul of Yehuda, corresponding to fire, the root of all elements, he insists on reaching the root, the initials.
- 1:00:52 Har HaBayis, bought from Aravnah, whose name begins with the letters of 'or' (the element of fire), and Me'aras HaMachpelah, bought from Efron, whose name spells 'afar' (earth), are Israel's 'reishis' and 'acharis', and both hold the same Adam and Avos.
- 1:08:09 Moshe's name is missing from Tetzaveh, read in the week of his yahrzeit, because Moshe takes a different name in each generation; in Haman's time he was Mordechai.
- 1:16:31 Mishloach manos makes all Jewish families one, like an eruv chatzeiros, where a shared meal unites separate households, and Amalek's power of mockery cannot bear such unity.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 8:55 The Rav cites sefarim that one who feels a bad trait overpowering him should say the passuk naming the seven nations, which subdues the seven bad powers.
- 1:12:09 The Rav says that when a Jew thinks 'what connection do I have to Torah and to Hashem', he must know this is Haman's thought, and instead strengthen his emunah and feel that he is newly born in Adar.
- 1:15:21 The Rav says one should connect with good friends, good bachurim and Rebbes, who are found in every generation.
- 1:25:17 The Rav says that on Purim one must not be bashful but knock on the gates of mercy and ask Hashem, until He opens.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Daniel, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Manoach, Memuchan, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rabbi Chanina, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, Rabbi Yechiel Meir of Gostynin, Rabbi Yehuda (bar Ilai), Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Rabbi Yossi (ben Chalafta), Rashi, Shimshon, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, Vashti, Yaakov Avinu
Terms ארבע יסודות, יחידה, משלוח מנות, סופי תיבות, סטרא אחרא, עקבתא דמשיחא, צירוף, ראשי תיבות, שם הוי"ה