A יו”ט for the Latecomer - Don't Waste it!
Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) פורים no. 6 Pocket Guide p. 65 תשס"ב (2001–02) English 53 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Purim is a Yom Tov for the Jews at the edge of the camp, the latecomers and those who stumbled, because Hashem never rejects any Jew, and he urges his listeners not to waste it.
The Rav opens with Haman's ten thousand kikar of silver, which Tosafos matches to the half-shekels the Jews gave, and with the extra 1,775 shekels whose use Moshe Rabbeinu forgot. He explains that the Torah's 600,000 letters correspond to 600,000 Jewish souls; the Jews beyond that number were those of Shevet Dan whom the clouds expelled, and Amalek attacked them thinking Hashem had rejected them. Achashverosh's feast celebrated that the Beis HaMikdash would not be rebuilt, and Haman, repeating Amalek's mistake, thought sinning Jews were ownerless. The extra silver became the hooks outside the holy courtyard, matching the last eight pesukim of the Torah, pesukim of forgetting; Moshe forgot, but Hashem forgets no Jew. Purim is therefore the Yom Tov of the latecomers, the Adar Jews of the last generation. The Rav closes with a call to use Purim for tefillah, tzedakah beyond one's strength and acceptance of Torah.
Topics: Purim · The Greatness of Every Jew · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Haman's silver and the forgotten shekels
The Rav brings Tosafos's calculation that Haman's ten thousand kikar matched the half-shekels, asks how that fits the hundred kikar in Parashas Pekudei, and explains that Haman's money was charity meant to neutralize the Jews' merit. He then describes how Moshe Rabbeinu forgot what he did with the extra 1,775 shekels until he was reminded.
-
6:55 Why Moshe forgot; 600,000 letters listed in the guide
The Rav asks how Moshe Rabbeinu, who never forgot Torah, could forget. He explains that the half-shekels counted 600,000 Jews, matching the 600,000 letters of the Sefer Torah, so that one should see the letters at hagbah, and notes that the count came to a few thousand more than 600,000.
-
11:23 Amalek attacks the expelled Jews listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Amalek attacked the Jews of Shevet Dan whom the clouds of glory had expelled, thinking Hashem had rejected them. He answers that every Jew is dear to Hashem, compares it to a parent who alone may discipline his child, and says these Jews will yet do teshuvah.
-
16:49 The sin of Achashverosh's feast listed in the guide
The Rav describes the extravagance of Achashverosh's feast, where everything was kosher, and asks why the Jews were punished for attending. He explains with the Gemara that Achashverosh calculated the seventy years had passed, and the feast celebrated that the Beis HaMikdash would not be rebuilt, which touches on denying the geulah.
-
23:05 The extra silver outside the courtyard listed in the guide
The Rav says Haman repeated Amalek's mistake, thinking sinning Jews were ownerless, and so paid only for 600,000. He then explains that all the silver went into the holy courtyard except the vavim, the hooks that protruded outside the hangings, and that this was the silver of the extra Jews who had been expelled from the camp.
-
28:40 The last eight pesukim: verses of forgetting listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the last eight pesukim of the Torah stand outside the rest of it and speak of forgetting: Moshe's passing, when halachos were forgotten, and the breaking of the luchos. The extra souls belong to those pesukim, so Moshe forgot their silver, but Hashem, who forgets no Jew, reminded him; Haman made Amalek's mistake by not paying for them.
-
32:42 Purim, the Yom Tov of the latecomers listed in the guide
The Rav concludes that Purim is a Yom Tov for the nechshalim, which is why those less careful rejoice most on it. He points to the Megillah's name 'Yehudim', written five times with an extra yud, and to the halachah that a Megillah with letters half rubbed out is still kosher, and explains with Onkelos that the nechshalim are the latecomers.
-
36:50 Nisan Jews and Adar Jews listed in the guide
Bringing Sefer Yetzirah's teaching that the world was created in time, place and soul, the Rav explains that the months, like the letters, correspond to Jews: Nisan Jews who are zealous like those baking matzos, and Adar Jews who are last. Jewish history too runs from Nisan to Adar, and the generation before Moshiach are Adar Jews; Haman erred in thinking the Jewish year ends with Adar.
-
42:04 Our generation and the chizuk of Purim listed in the guide
The Rav says his generation, as Adar Jews, feels Purim more than earlier ones, and that Parashas Zachor gives Jews simchah because Hashem loves them and fights for them. He points to the miracles in Eretz Yisrael, says one should know what is happening with fellow Jews as Moshe went out to his brothers, and calls Purim a source of chizuk for every Jew.
-
45:53 Don't waste Purim: tefillah and tzedakah listed in the guide
The Rav calls Purim a time when tefillos are accepted and urges davening for Jews everywhere, not wasting the night on drinking. He urges tzedakah beyond one's strength, tells how the Satmar Rav had his congregation pledge a second round beyond their means, and compares Purim tzedakah to an esrog elevated on Sukkos.
-
49:55 The holiness of Purim and its seudah listed in the guide
The Rav urges hearing every word of the Megillah and giving matanos la'evyonim, brings the Kedushas Levi that every bite of the Purim seudah should carry a kabbalah to keep the Torah, and the Chasam Sofer that the holiness of Megillas Esther exceeds that of the Torah. He closes by calling Purim a gift to use for oneself and for Klal Yisrael.
The shiur, written up
Haman's silver and the forgotten shekels
The Rav opens with Haman's ten thousand kikar of silver (Esther 3:9), which Tosafos calculates as matching the half-shekels the Jews gave in the Midbar. He points out a difficulty: Parashas Pekudei counts a hundred kikar for the sockets plus 1,775 extra shekels, so Haman gave a hundred times more. He leaves the question, noting that the commentators work it out. a,b,c
Following the Yaaros Devash and the Chasam Sofer, he explains that Haman's money was charity, meant to neutralize the merit of the shekalim. Moshe Rabbeinu, he relates, forgot what he did with the extra shekels, until, as the Midrash tells, the Shechinah reminded him that they had become hooks for the pillars. e,d,c
Why Moshe forgot; 600,000 letters
The Rav asks how Moshe Rabbeinu could forget a matter of Torah, when, as Rashi brings, the Torah was given to him like a bride so that he would not forget. He explains that the half-shekels counted 600,000 Jews, matching the 600,000 letters of the Sefer Torah, so every Jew has his letter. That is why the Arizal advises standing near at hagbah to see the letters. Yet the count came to over 600,000. f
Amalek attacks the expelled Jews
Amalek, the Rav explains, attacked the Jews of Shevet Dan who had idolatry with them and were expelled from the camp, beyond the clouds of glory, as Rashi brings. Why was he not afraid after the miracles of the Sea? He thought Hashem had rejected them. g
But no Jew is rejected, the Rav says; even a sinner holds a hidden chamber in his heart that loves Hashem. Like a parent who alone may discipline his child, Hashem tells Amalek these are His children, and they will do teshuvah.
The sin of Achashverosh's feast
Turning to Shushan, the Rav describes Achashverosh's lavish feast, where each guest drank wine from his own land, older than himself, and everything was kosher. Why, then, were the Jews punished for going?
The Chasam Sofer explains, and the Rav brings the Gemara, that Achashverosh calculated the seventy years of exile had passed and wrongly concluded the Beis HaMikdash would never be rebuilt. The feast celebrated this. Attending it, the Rav says, touches on one of the thirteen principles of faith, belief in the geulah. h
The extra silver outside the courtyard
Seeing the Jews sin, Haman repeated Amalek's mistake, thinking Hashem had abandoned them as ownerless. He offered ten thousand kikar to match 600,000 Jews, but nothing for the extra ones, whom he considered sinners.
The Rav then explains that all the Mishkan's silver went into the holy courtyard except the vavim, the hooks on the pillars that protruded outside the hangings. That silver came from the Jews expelled from the camp, so Hashem arranged that it, too, landed outside.
The last eight pesukim: verses of forgetting
The last eight pesukim of the Torah also stand apart; the Gemara debates who wrote them. They speak of forgetting: at Moshe's passing three thousand halachos were forgotten, and the final words allude to the breaking of the luchos, which brought forgetting of Torah. The expelled souls belong to these pesukim, so Moshe forgot their silver, but Hashem forgets no Jew and reminded him. i,j,k,l
Purim, the Yom Tov of the latecomers
Purim, therefore, is the Yom Tov of the nechshalim, which Onkelos renders as the latecomers, and the Rav notes that the less careful rejoice most on it. In the Megillah, Jews are called Yehudim, five times written with an extra yud that is not read: even such a Jew belongs. Likewise, a Megillah with letters half rubbed out stays kosher. n,m
Nisan Jews and Adar Jews
The Rav brings Sefer Yetzirah that the world was created in time, place and soul, so Jews correspond to months as they do to letters. Nisan Jews are zealous, like those baking matzos, who cannot be lazy; Adar Jews come last. o
History too runs from Nisan to Adar: the generation of the Midbar were Nisan Jews, and those before Moshiach are Adar Jews. Haman thought the Jewish year ends with Adar, but it is round, and Nisan returns.
Our generation and the chizuk of Purim
The Rav says his generation feels Purim more, being Adar Jews whom the yetzer hara has spoiled. Parashas Zachor brings simchah: Hashem loves them and fights for them, as the miracles in Eretz Yisrael show. Like Moshe, who went out to his brothers, one should know what happens with fellow Jews. Purim gives chizuk: Hashem loves every Jew, whatever his report card. p
Don't waste Purim: tefillah and tzedakah
Purim is a time when tefillos are accepted, so the Rav urges davening for Jews everywhere, and not drinking at night only to sleep through the Megillah. He urges tzedakah beyond one's strength, recalling how the Satmar Rav had his refugee congregation pledge a second round. Purim tzedakah, like an esrog on Sukkos, is of a higher kind.
The holiness of Purim and its seudah
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- d Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 4:32
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 8:50 The Torah's 600,000 letters correspond to 600,000 Jewish souls, and each Jew has his letter in the Sefer Torah.
- 13:29 Amalek, and later Haman, attacked on the assumption that sinning Jews are rejected and ownerless; the Rav says no Jew is ever rejected by Hashem.
- 20:07 The Jews in Shushan were punished for attending Achashverosh's feast because it celebrated the Beis HaMikdash not being rebuilt.
- 32:47 Purim is a Yom Tov for the nechshalim, the stragglers and latecomers at the edge of the camp.
- 40:01 Just as the year runs from Nisan to Adar, Jewish history does too, and the generation before Moshiach consists of Adar Jews.
- 46:09 The Rav urges using Purim for tefillah, for tzedakah beyond one's strength and for hearing the Megillah properly, not wasting it on drinking.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 6:55 How could Moshe Rabbeinu, who never forgot Torah, forget what he did with the extra silver?
Answer: 31:00 That silver came from the souls outside the camp, which correspond to the last eight pesukim, pesukim of forgetting; Moshe forgot them, but Hashem, who forgets no Jew, reminded him.
-
Question: 12:44 Why did Amalek dare attack the Jews after the miracles of the Exodus and the Sea?
Answer: 13:29 He attacked only those expelled from the camp, thinking Hashem had rejected them and would not mind.
-
Question: 19:26 Why were the Jews punished for attending a feast where everything was kosher?
Answer: 21:54 The feast celebrated Achashverosh's calculation that the Beis HaMikdash would never be rebuilt, and taking part touched on denying the geulah.
-
Question: 24:18 Why did Haman not pay to match the extra Jews beyond 600,000?
Answer: 24:23 He made Amalek's mistake, thinking sinning Jews were rejected and ownerless, so they needed no payment.
-
Question: 28:00 How could silver given for the Mishkan end up outside the holy courtyard?
Answer: 28:09 It was the silver of the extra Jews who had been expelled from the camp, so their silver too landed outside.
Stories
-
47:21 The Satmar Rav's double appeal
The Rav recalls that when the Satmar Rav came to America and was building up a Chassidish community among refugees fresh from the camps, an appeal was made in his small shul on Bedford Avenue. The Satmar Rav told the people to give beyond their strength, and the gabbai went around announcing each pledge. When everyone had pledged, the Satmar Rav told the gabbai to start over so they would pledge again, beyond what was already beyond their strength.
In the story: the Satmar Rav
Insights
- 4:32 Haman's ten thousand kikar were charity, given to neutralize the merit of the Jews' half-shekels.
- 27:48 The only silver of the Mishkan that ended up outside the holy courtyard, the protruding hooks, came from the extra Jews beyond 600,000 whom the clouds had expelled.
- 30:39 The last eight pesukim of the Torah are pesukim of forgetting, and the souls outside the camp correspond to them; that is why Moshe Rabbeinu forgot their silver, while Hashem forgets no Jew.
- 34:00 The extra yud in 'Yehudim' that is written but not read, and the kashrus of a Megillah with half-erased letters, show that imperfect Jews still belong in the Megillah.
- 41:41 Haman rejoiced that the lot fell on Adar because he thought the Jewish year ends there, but the Jewish year is a circle and Nisan follows Adar, as Moshiach follows the last generation.
- 49:09 Tzedakah given on Purim is elevated above ordinary tzedakah, as an esrog on Sukkos calls for a different brachah than an esrog eaten on Purim.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 9:37 The Rav says it is good to stand close enough at hagbah to see the letters of the Sefer Torah, since one may see the letter of one's own soul.
- 43:36 The Rav says a person should know what is happening with fellow Jews, through suitable publications, as Moshe went out to see his brothers.
- 46:09 The Rav urges using Purim to daven for Jews in Eretz Yisrael, America and the world, and not spending the night drinking so that one sleeps through davening and the Megillah.
- 47:04 The Rav says to give tzedakah on Purim until it hurts and then beyond.
- 50:52 Following the Kedushas Levi, the Rav says that with every bite of the Purim seudah one should accept upon oneself to keep and learn the Torah.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Avraham Avinu, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Moshe Rabbeinu, Onkelos, Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, Rashi, the Arizal, the Chasam Sofer, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), Yehoshua bin Nun
Terms אדנים, ווי העמודים, מחצית השקל, מתנות לאביונים, נחשלים, עולם שנה נפש, ענני הכבוד, עת רצון, שבירת הלוחות, שכחה