The Lesson of the מגילה: Find 'ה Peeking Through the Cracks of Your life. Explanation of פורים קטן
Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) פורים no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 65 תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 1 hr 29 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav teaches that Purim and its Megillah train a Jew to find Hashem hidden behind nature, rulers and events, peeking out through the cracks, and explains Purim Katan of a leap year.
The Rav opens with the greatness of Purim, compared with Yom Kippur, and explains Purim Katan: in a leap year the moon has fallen far behind the sun, so in the first Adar we are too weak to keep Purim, and Hashem has the Megillah read in heaven; the second reading, in the second Adar, accomplishes more. He then explains Amalek through three readings of 'karcha': cooling a Jew's fervor, making him impure, and teaching that everything is chance. This is the 'double hiding' of 'haster astir', which is why Hashem's name seems absent from the Megillah and hides in the word 'hamelech', whose gematria equals the incomplete 'kes Kah'. Through the Bnei Yissaschar's parable he shows that a miracle inside nature is greater still. The Megillah trains the eye to find Hashem through the cracks, in history, in the news and behind every costume. He closes with Adar as the month of laughter at the world, Yaakov's complaint, Mordechai, and David's response to Shimi.
Topics: Megillas Esther · Hester Panim and Suffering · Hashgacha Pratis · Purim Katan and the Leap Year · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The greatness of Purim listed in the guide
The Rav introduces Purim Katan this Shabbos and says Purim is greater than any Yom Tov: Yom Kippur is only 'like Purim', and in the future Yom Kippur will rise to Purim's level. Purim is 'masked', different from how it appears, like a child in costume.
-
3:51 Purim Katan and the second reading listed in the guide
The Rav asks why the Megillah says 'hasheinis' in the feminine if it refers to the second month, and explains with the moon falling behind the sun: in the first Adar we are too weak to keep Purim, so Hashem has the Megillah read in heaven, as Michael offers on the altar above, and the second reading is greater.
-
13:02 Amalek cools off: the pulse of life
The Rav explains that Amalek represents the Satan and that 'asher karcha' means he cooled the Jews off. All life pulses up and down like a heartbeat or a pause in music, and the war against Amalek is to hold on through the cold until Hashem sends warmth again.
-
20:08 Karcha as impurity and as chance
The Rav brings two more readings of 'karcha': Amalek made the Jews impure, and Amalek teaches that things happen by chance ('mikreh'), denying Hashem's individual providence. He brings the Midrash calling Haman 'son of Korcha' and notes that Amalek equals 'safek', doubt, in gematria.
-
24:32 Haster astir: the double hiding
The Rav brings the Gemara that Esther is hinted in 'haster astir' and the Ba'al Shem Tov's parable of a father who hides from his child, and then hides that he is hiding. This double concealment was the setting of the Megillah and, he says, is the state of most of Klal Yisrael before Moshiach, caused by Haman's philosophy of chance.
-
30:54 Hashem's name hidden in 'hamelech'
The Rav notes that Hashem's name is absent from the Megillah alone among the 24 books, because its setting is hester panim, and brings the Midrash on 'evel gadol', a mourning that grew as the decreed day approached. Yet, per the Midrash, every 'hamelech' in the Megillah refers to Hashem.
-
34:56 Kes Kah, the puppet king and the gematria of hamelech
The Rav brings Rashi on 'ki yad al kes Kah': Hashem's name and throne are incomplete until Amalek is erased, so His rule is concealed and we credit events to rulers. Achashverosh was a marionette moved by strings from above; 'hamelech' equals 'kes Kah' and Haman in gematria (95), and 'machi Amalek' equals 'kisei Havayah'.
-
45:20 Hidden miracles every day
The Rav says there are no open miracles in the Megillah, unlike Nisan, yet every person has hidden miracles daily, as said in Modim; the body is far more complex than a car and keeps working. In Adar the same miracles are cloaked in nature, and the Megillah story could have been reported in the newspapers.
-
50:17 The Bnei Yissaschar's parable: a miracle in nature listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Bnei Yissaschar's parable of a dying patient for whom the one doctor and the one medicine arrive just in time, showing that someone directs events without breaking nature, which is an even greater miracle. Adar is the season of such natural miracles, and 'Megillas Esther' means revealing the hidden.
-
56:28 Peeking through the cracks listed in the guide
The Rav compares reading the Megillah to a surgeon reading an x-ray and brings 'mashgiach min hachalonos, metzitz min hacharakim': Hashem watches through the cracks. He retracts his earlier statement: Hashem's name is in the Megillah, hidden in the initial and final letters of key phrases, as in 'yavo hamelech v'Haman hayom'.
-
1:02:10 The whole world is a Megillah listed in the guide
The Rav says that after Purim one should read the newspaper between the lines and see Hashem behind the world's leaders, and points to Eretz Yisrael always being in the headlines. The whole world is a Megillah to be revealed, and the Purim costumes teach to look beneath every disguise.
-
1:08:03 Adar, the month of laughter
The Rav brings Sefer Yetzirah, which assigns each month an organ and activity: Adar's is laughter. The plague of locusts fell in Adar, where Hashem says He 'made sport' of Egypt. In Adar one laughs at the passing material world, as the Kotzker said the whole world is not worth a sigh, because Hashem directs everything.
-
1:15:23 Yaakov's complaint and Mordechai the 'troublemaker'
The Rav brings the Midrash that Yaakov once forgot himself and blamed his sons, while Hashem was making Yosef king. He then retells the nine years of the Megillah: Mordechai opposed going to Achashverosh's feast and refused to bow to Haman, and was blamed as a troublemaker, but in the end it was clear he was right all along.
-
1:22:57 David, Shimi and the lesson of the Megillah
The Rav explains that people blamed David for not killing Shimi, Mordechai's ancestor; in truth, because David saw that Hashem told Shimi to curse, Mordechai was born to teach hashgachah pratis and write the Megillah. He concludes that the same Achashverosh brought mourning and joy: all are puppets, and nothing happens without Hashem.
The shiur, written up
The greatness of Purim
The Rav opens by noting that this Shabbos leads into Purim Katan, the small Purim. Purim, he says, is greater than any other Yom Tov: the Zohar links Purim with Yom Kippur, and Yom Kippur is only 'like Purim'. When Moshiach comes, Yom Kippur will rise to Purim's level. Purim is masked, like a child in costume who is not what he appears to be. a
Purim Katan and the second reading
The Megillah calls itself 'the second letter of Purim', and from the word 'hasheinis' the Gemara, as Rashi explains, learns that in a leap year Purim is kept in the second Adar. The Rav asks why the word is feminine if it means the second month; it must refer to the letter, the Megillah itself. b,c
He explains that the moon, to which Klal Yisrael is compared, falls behind the sun, Hashem, by some ten days a year. After three years we are far from Him, and in the first Adar we are too feeble to accomplish what Purim's mitzvos accomplish above. When we cannot do what is needed, Hashem, like a loving father, does it for us.
Amalek cools off: the pulse of life
The theme of Purim is the eradication of Amalek, who represents the Satan as the Jews represent the Shechinah, and whose very existence spreads the yetzer hara. On 'asher karcha' in the passage of remembering Amalek, Chazal give three explanations; the first is that Amalek cooled the Jews off. e
The Rav explains that all life pulses: the seasons, the heartbeat, breathing, even the pause in music that makes it pleasant. Everyone serious about serving Hashem goes through periods of coldness. The war against Amalek is to hold on to the conduct of the good days and wait for the next beat, which comes back stronger. He reads 'who will ascend the mountain of Hashem' this way: the struggle is not to slip back down. f
Karcha as impurity and as chance
A second explanation of 'karcha' is that Amalek made the Jews impure, while Hashem wants purity of body and mind. A third reads it as 'mikreh', chance: Amalek teaches that things happen randomly, denying individual providence, one of the thirteen principles. The Midrash calls Haman 'Korcha son of Korcha', and Amalek equals 'safek', doubt, in gematria. g,h
Haster astir: the double hiding
The Gemara finds Esther hinted in the Torah in 'haster astir panai'. The Ba'al Shem Tov explains with a father who hides from his child to punish him. Worse is when the child knows the father is hiding but cannot see him; worst is when the father hides his hiding, so the child does not even know he is there. i,j
The Ba'al Shem Tov said this double concealment would come before Moshiach, as in Esther's time, shortly before the second Beis HaMikdash. Through the exile Jews knew a Father was hiding; today, the Rav says, most of Klal Yisrael do not know there is a Father in heaven. The cause is Haman's philosophy that everything is chance.
Hashem's name hidden in 'hamelech'
Hashem's name, found in all the other twenty-three books of Tanach, is absent from the Megillah because its setting was hester panim. The Midrash on 'evel gadol' explains that this mourning grew as the decreed day approached. Yet, the Midrash teaches, every 'hamelech' in the Megillah refers to the King of kings. k,l
Kes Kah and the puppet king
Why 'hamelech'? On 'ki yad al kes Kah', Rashi explains that Hashem's name and throne are incomplete until Amalek is erased. Hashem still runs the world, but hidden, so people credit events to presidents and general secretaries. m,n
So in the Megillah everything was credited to Achashverosh. The Rav compares him to a marionette whose invisible strings are pulled from above: from the tax relief at the Megillah's start to the tax at its end, Hashem acted in his guise. On Purim one must find Hashem between the lines.
'Hamelech' is 95 in gematria, like 'kes Kah', 80 and 15, and like Haman. Haman pollutes the atmosphere so that we do not see the strings. When Amalek is erased, the Rav says, it will be the complete 'kisei Havayah', which equals 'machi Amalek'.
Hidden miracles every day
Nor are there open miracles in the Megillah, unlike Nisan. Yet every person has hidden miracles daily, as Jews thank Hashem in Modim for the miracles that are with them every day. The body is more complex than a steel car, yet it mostly repairs itself. In Adar the same miracles are cloaked in nature; the Megillah could have been reported day by day in the newspapers. o
A miracle within nature
Why then the fuss? The Rav brings the Bnei Yissaschar's parable: a dying patient needs the one doctor and the one medicine, each six months' journey away, and both arrive at the door just in time. No law of nature was broken, yet clearly someone directs events; such a miracle is even greater. p
Nisan is the season of supernatural miracles, Adar of natural ones, hidden under a cloak one must search beneath. 'Megillas Esther' means revealing the hidden, and the Megillah's miracle is countless pieces falling into place.
Peeking through the cracks
The Megillah, the Rav says, teaches that Hashem makes miracles with us every day, as in Modim, and whoever searches will find them. Like a surgeon reading an x-ray, one learns to read, training the eye to find Hashem, who plays hide-and-seek with us. As 'mashgiach min hachalonos' teaches, He peeks through the cracks. o,q
The whole world is a Megillah
After Purim, the Rav says, one should read the New York Times between the lines: when Bush, Gorbachev or Shamir act, it is Hashem doing it. Over history, Eretz Yisrael is always in the headlines, the pivot around which everything turns.
The whole world is a Megillah to be revealed. That is the meaning of Purim costumes: when a costumed figure with a sword bursts in, no one panics; one asks which yeshiva he is collecting for. World leaders are costumes, and Purim is no Halloween.
Adar, the month of laughter
Sefer Yetzirah, written by Avraham Avinu, assigns each month an organ and an activity; the Maharal made a golem with it, and Amoraim created a calf for Shabbos. Adar's organ is the techol, the organ of laughter. s,t
By Rabbeinu Bechaye's order of the plagues, locusts came in Adar, and only there does Hashem say He made sport of Egypt. Adar exercises the organ of laughter: to laugh at the material world, which lasts seventy or eighty years. u
The Kotzker said the whole world is not worth a sigh. A person came here to prepare for Olam Haba, and Adar teaches that Hashem directs everything; no one can help or harm without Him.
Yaakov's complaint and Mordechai
Even Yaakov Avinu, the Midrash says, slipped once, asking his sons why they harmed him by revealing they had a brother. The Navi rebukes him for thinking his way was hidden from Hashem, who was busy making Yosef king. The Rav says one cannot blame a person; Hashem directed him. v,w
The Megillah spans nine years. Achashverosh's feast celebrated seventy years without the Beis HaMikdash, which he feared, refusing it even within 'half the kingdom'. Mordechai warned not to attend, yet eighteen thousand went, and the Gemara says the decree came partly from that feast. Later he refused to bow to Haman, to atone for bowing to Nebuchadnezzar's idol, and was called a troublemaker; in the end he was right. x,y
David, Shimi and the lesson of the Megillah
The Gemara gives two explanations of Mordechai's lineage. People blamed David for sparing Shimi, Mordechai's ancestor, who cursed him; David had said Hashem told him to curse. Just the opposite, the Rav says: because David saw Hashem behind Shimi, Mordechai was born, taught hashgachah pratis and wrote the Megillah. z,aa
Sources
Torah
- d Vayikra 9:4 text index In the write-up: 10:48
- e Devarim 25:17-18 text index In the write-up: 13:02
- j apparently Devarim 31:18 index In the write-up: 24:32
- m Shemos 17:16 text index In the write-up: 34:56
- u apparently Shemos 10:2 index In the write-up: 1:10:16
- w apparently Bereishis 43:6 index In the write-up: 1:15:34
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
- c Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 3:51
- i apparently Chullin 139b index In the write-up: 24:32
- t apparently Sanhedrin 65b index In the write-up: 1:08:36
- y apparently Megillah 12a index In the write-up: 1:18:00
- z apparently Megillah 12b-13a index In the write-up: 1:23:13
- ab apparently Megillah 11a index In the write-up: 1:27:12
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 5:46 In a leap year the first Adar is too far from the 'sun' of Hashem for us to keep Purim, so Hashem has the Megillah read in heaven, and the second reading in the second Adar accomplishes more.
- 14:34 Amalek 'cooled off' the Jews; life always pulses up and down, and the war against Amalek is to hold on through the cold periods until Hashem warms a person again.
- 21:24 Amalek and Haman stand for the belief that everything is chance ('mikreh'), which is the double concealment of 'haster astir' that marks the Megillah and the time before Moshiach.
- 34:01 Hashem's name is hidden in the Megillah in the word 'hamelech', because His name and throne are incomplete ('kes Kah') while Amalek exists.
- 49:33 Adar is the season of miracles cloaked in nature, and reading the Megillah is an exercise in finding Hashem behind that cloak.
- 1:02:11 After Purim one should be able to read the news and all of history between the lines and see Hashem directing everything; the whole world is a Megillah.
- 1:16:57 Nothing happens without Hashem, so one may not blame a person for what happens to him, as seen from Yaakov's complaint and from David's response to Shimi.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:58 Why does the Megillah say 'hasheinis' in the feminine if it refers to the second month?
Answer: 5:25 It refers to the letter, the Megillah: on Purim Katan it is read in heaven, so the reading in the second Adar is a second, more powerful reading.
-
Question: 31:29 Why is Hashem's name absent from the Megillah?
Answer: 31:41 Because its setting was hester panim; yet the name is hidden in 'hamelech', which always refers to Hashem.
-
Question: 42:21 Why does the Megillah say 'hamelech' rather than Hashem's name?
Answer: 42:30 Because while Amalek exists the name and throne are incomplete, 'kes Kah', and 'hamelech' equals 'kes Kah' in gematria.
-
Question: 50:09 If the Megillah has no supernatural miracles, why make such a fuss about it?
Answer: 52:56 As the Bnei Yissaschar's parable shows, perfect timing within nature reveals that someone directs events, and such a miracle is even greater.
-
Question: 1:21:06 Why did Mordechai refuse to bow to Haman and provoke him?
Answer: 1:21:23 To atone for the Jews who had bowed to the idol in Nebuchadnezzar's time, being ready to be killed so that this would be their kaparah.
-
Question: 1:24:59 Was David to blame for Haman's decree because he did not kill Shimi?
Answer: 1:25:27 Just the opposite: because David saw Hashem behind Shimi, Mordechai was born, brought about the eradication of Amalek in his generation, and taught hashgachah pratis.
Stories
-
1:18:23 Mordechai warns against Achashverosh's feast
The Rav tells that Achashverosh's feast celebrated seventy years without the Beis HaMikdash being rebuilt, and that kosher food was provided. Mordechai went around warning the Jews not to attend, calling it a chillul Hashem, but eighteen thousand Jews of Shushan went, saying it was unpatriotic to stay away. Four years later Mordechai refused to bow to Haman, and he was again blamed as a troublemaker. At the end of the nine years it became clear that Mordechai had been right all along.
In the story: Mordechai HaTzaddik, Achashverosh, Haman
Insights
- 5:08 The feminine 'hasheinis' refers not to the second month but to the second reading of the Megillah: in a leap year it is read first in heaven on Purim Katan, and the second reading is therefore more powerful.
- 5:58 The leap year is read as the moon (Klal Yisrael) falling behind the sun (Hashem); in the first Adar we are too far from Him to keep Purim properly.
- 16:00 The pauses in spiritual life are like the beat in music or the pause between heartbeats: they are part of life, and after the pause the fervor returns stronger.
- 43:11 'Hamelech', 'kes Kah' and 'Haman' all equal 95 in gematria: Haman's existence is what reduces Hashem's revealed name to the hidden 'king', and 'machi Amalek' equals 'kisei Havayah'.
- 53:22 A miracle that comes through perfect timing within nature is greater than one that breaks nature, and the Megillah's miracle has countless such pieces falling into place.
- 1:06:24 Purim costumes embody the lesson: just as one is not alarmed by a costumed visitor, one should see that world leaders are costumes over Hashem's hand.
- 1:25:35 Because David saw Hashem behind Shimi's curse and spared him, Mordechai, Shimi's descendant, was born to defeat Haman's philosophy of chance and to write the Megillah.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 15:31 The Rav says that when a period of coldness in serving Hashem comes, one should hold on to one's conduct from the good days and wait for the next beat, which will come back stronger.
- 56:38 The Rav says one should search for Hashem and His miracles in daily life, and whoever searches will find them.
- 1:02:11 The Rav says that after Purim one should read the newspaper between the lines and recognize Hashem behind every leader and event.
- 1:12:01 The Rav says Adar teaches to laugh at the passing material world and not to give it value.
- 1:16:59 The Rav says one should not blame a person for what happens to him, since Hashem directed that person.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Nevuchadnetzar, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rashi, Shimi ben Gera, the angel Michael, the Baal Shem Tov, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chofetz Chaim, the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), the Maharal of Prague, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms הסתר, הסתר פנים, השגחה פרטית, טבע, מחיית עמלק, מיעוט הירח, מקרה, ספק, פורים קטן, רבונו של עולם, שנה מעוברת