Peeking Under the Costume of פורים
Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) פורים no. 10 Pocket Guide p. 65 תשס"ט (2008–09) English 1 hr 22 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Adar, the lowest and most hidden month, carries the Megillah's personal message that Hashem is near even to the lowest Jew, and that in a year of a second Adar Hashem Himself completes what is missing.
The Rav opens the month of Adar by saying that Purim is widely misunderstood: its clowning and wine are an anesthetic for a remedy too strong to take awake. Purim has its own masechta, and Rav Masna opens the Megillah with the passuk that Hashem is near to us. Rashi calls the Megillah a letter, and the Rav explains that a letter is addressed to one person: the Megillah speaks to each reader privately. He then describes the ladder of souls, places and times. Our generation is the heel, yet still bound to the head, as the fingernail was once in the embryo. Nisan, from nes, is the month of open miracles; Adar, from aderes, a cloak, is the month of hidden ones. Adar matches the tribe of Dan at the rear of the camp, whom Amalek attacked as rejected. The Megillah answers that Hashem forsakes no Jew. In a leap year Adar Sheni has no permutation of the Divine Name, and Hashem Himself is the added one, so Purim belongs to the lowest.
Topics: Purim · The Greatness of Every Jew · Megillas Esther · Purim Katan and the Leap Year · Chodesh Adar
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Adar transformed; Purim misunderstood listed in the guide
The Rav says the whole month of Adar was turned to joy, and that Purim is misunderstood as a kind of Jewish Halloween when it may be the greatest day of the year. Its clowning and wine are like an anesthetic for a remedy too strong to take awake.
-
5:56 A whole masechta for a small Yom Tov
The Rav notes that Purim, a weekday Yom Tov with few halachos, earned its own masechta, unlike Chanukah or Shavuos. The Gemara explains the whole Megillah and opens it with about fifteen Sages, each bringing a passuk as a key to it.
-
10:40 Rav Masna's key: Hashem is near
Rav Masna opens the Megillah with the passuk about a great nation to whom Hashem is near; the Rav explains that the events of the Megillah could have made Jews think Hashem was far, and the Megillah teaches the opposite. He then asks why Rashi, usually so terse, poetically calls the Megillah 'the letter of Purim'.
-
15:51 A book and a letter
The Rav contrasts a book, written for whoever picks it up, with a letter, addressed privately to one person and read with closer attention. The Megillah is both, and its message is meant personally for every reader, even one who thinks Hashem's blessings are for others.
-
23:10 The ladder of souls and generations
Recalling the three dimensions of creation, space, time and soul, the Rav describes souls arranged on a ladder in each generation and across history, from the Avos and the dor hamidbar at the head down to our generation, 'ikvesa d'Meshicha', the insensitive heel.
-
29:57 The embryo, the fingernail and Yerushalayim
The Rav explains that the heel is no less part of the person: in the embryo every limb, even the last-formed fingernail, was included. So the last generation is still bound to the beginning, just as every place in the world is nourished from Yerushalayim, as shown by Shlomo HaMelech's planting.
-
38:54 Nisan the flag, Adar the cloak listed in the guide
In time, Nisan, when the world was created, is the head of the months; its name comes from 'nes', a flag on a high pole, because Hashem shows Himself openly with miracles then. Adar, furthest away, comes from 'aderes', a cloak, the time when a person is in the dark and Hashem hides.
-
44:50 Hidden miracles: uncovering the hidden listed in the guide
The Rav contrasts the supernatural miracles of Yetzias Mitzrayim with the Megillah, where every event is natural and could appear in a newspaper. Yet taken together the plot shows a guiding hand, so the Megillah is full of miracles; following the Avodas Yisrael, 'Megillas Esther' means revealing the hidden, recognizing Hashem behind the mask.
-
50:59 Dan at the rear and Amalek
Adar draws from Nisan as the toe from the head. The Rav describes Dan, the tribe at the rear of the camp, gathering what others lost, and its failings; Amalek attacked those expelled from the clouds, thinking Hashem had rejected them. Adar, like Dan, is at the bottom, and Parshas Zachor teaches that Hashem never forsakes any Jewish soul.
-
1:01:00 The Megillah's hope for the last generation listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Gemara that the Jews joined Achashverosh's feast, celebrating the apparent end of the seventy years, and lost hope; that generation at the end of the first galus corresponds to ours. The Megillah's personal letter tells every Jew that Hashem is near and has not forsaken him, and it ends with the Jews' teshuvah and with gentiles becoming Jews.
-
1:07:25 A second Adar: the moon falls behind
The Rav leaves the halachos of drinking for later weeks and turns to this year's second Adar. Hashem is the sun and Jews the moon, so they count by the moon; when the moon lags, a thirteenth month is added, taking the Jews even further from Nisan. The Yerushalmi says the original Purim miracle happened in Adar Sheni.
-
1:12:03 The thirteenth month and the kolel
The twelve months and twelve tribes match the twelve permutations of the Divine Name; the thirteenth month, like outcasts belonging to no tribe, has none, and is counted as the 'kolel', the added one. The Rav asks where the right to add one comes from and answers that the One is Hashem, as in the Midrash that Hashem completed the seventy souls and the six hundred thousand.
-
1:18:01 Purim Gadol: the Yom Tov of the lowest
The Rav concludes that in a leap year the second Purim is a 'great Purim', when Hashem joins those left out and completes Klal Yisrael, so no Jew is rejected. Unlike Shabbos, felt most by tzaddikim, Purim is made for the lowest, and the lower one is, the more Purim can lift him.
The shiur, written up
Adar transformed; Purim misunderstood
The Rav opens the month of Adar by noting that the Megillah speaks not only of a day that was turned over, from the day the enemies hoped to destroy the Jews into a day of their victory, but of a whole month. This is why the Gemara says that when Adar comes, joy increases: Purim already begins with the month. a,b
Yet Purim, he says, is badly misunderstood. Some treat it as a Jewish Halloween, when it may be the greatest day of the year, above all for a generation at the threshold of the Geulah. What Purim gives is so strong that it comes with an anesthetic: the clowning and the wine. People forget and do not see what Purim is, but it works whether they feel it or not.
A whole masechta for a small Yom Tov
Purim is a one-day Yom Tov on which work is permitted, and its halachos are few, yet it earned a masechta of its own, while Chanukah and Shavuos have none. Masechta Megillah holds the dinim of Purim, much aggadah, and an explanation of the entire Megillah.
Rav Masna's key: Hashem is near
A book and a letter
In the Megillah itself it is called both a sefer and the 'igeres', the letter, of Purim, and the Gemara derives halachos from each name. A book is written for whoever buys it; a letter is addressed to one person, so private that reading another's mail is forbidden by the ban of Rabbeinu Gershom. g,h
A person reads a letter differently: because it was sent to him, he studies every word. A medical book may not apply to the reader, but a private letter is meant for him alone. The Megillah has a loud message, and lest anyone think it is for others, it is a letter: it means you.
The ladder of souls and generations
The Rav recalls the three dimensions of creation, space, time and soul. In every generation souls stand on a ladder, from the greatest at the top to the lowest at the bottom, as explained in the Tanya. History has the same order: the Avos, Moshe Rabbeinu and the generation that received the Torah were the head, and each generation since has been smaller. i
The embryo, the fingernail and Yerushalayim
Is the heel less the person than the head? The Rav answers with the embryo: a full-grown person, down to the heel, is already contained in one tiny nucleus. As it develops, each part stops at a stage. The head forms first; the fingernails and hair last, passing through months of descent until they can be clipped without pain. The Gemara therefore treats nails and hair as signs that an infant is fully formed. k
So too, our generation of toes and fingernails, some of whom are being clipped off unfelt, was once included in the head and stays bound to the beginning.
Nisan the flag, Adar the cloak
In time, the world was created in Nisan, which is why Birkas HaChamah is said then. Rosh Chodesh Nisan is the head of time, containing and directing everything as the brain directs the toe. m
Nisan comes from 'nes', a flag on a pole, seen by all. In Nisan Hashem shows Himself openly, and most of the miracles listed at the end of the Haggadah happened then. The months descend to Adar, furthest from Nisan. Adar comes from 'aderes', a cloak: it stands for the times when a person is in the dark and Hashem hides. n
Hidden miracles: uncovering the hidden
Yetzias Mitzrayim is full of supernatural miracles; the Megillah has none. A king makes a party, kills his queen, Esther replaces Vashti, Mordechai overhears a plot, Haman seeks to destroy the Jews, Esther invites him to a feast and the king changes his mind: all natural, the stuff of newspapers, stretched over about nine years.
Yet we read it with a bracha over miracles, because taken together everything fell into place exactly when needed, revealing a hand behind it. The Avodas Yisrael explains 'Megillas Esther' as uncovering the hidden, as if saying to Hashem: I have found You. Adar holds as many miracles as Nisan, only concealed, and the Megillah identifies Hashem behind the mask. o
Dan at the rear and Amalek
Adar draws its miracles from Nisan, as the toe draws from the head. So it was in the camp in the Midbar: when traveling, Dan, a numerous tribe, went at the rear and gathered whatever the others lost. Dan was often in trouble: they carried the idol of Michah, they were expelled from the clouds, and the one woman whose sin the Torah exposed in Mitzrayim was from Dan. p,q,r,s
Moshe Rabbeinu warned in Nitzavim that a tribe turning from Hashem would be erased from under heaven, and the Midrash applies this to Dan. Adar is to the calendar what Dan is to the tribes. Amalek attacked the stragglers expelled from the camp, for the others were protected, while Dan seemed rejected, and he reasoned that Hashem would not defend them. For this Hashem's anger still burns at Amalek. t,r,u
Amalek told Dan they need not be Jews anymore and cooled any spark left in them. To this day he is the voice telling a Jew he is lost and too steeped in sin to return. Parshas Zachor, read in Adar, teaches that Hashem forsakes no Jewish soul, however far, and it is Amalek who will be erased. u
The Megillah's hope for the last generation
Adar brings hope to every Jew at the bottom of the ladder. In the Megillah's time Jews sinned and joined Achashverosh's feast. The Gemara explains it celebrated the seventy years Yirmiyahu foretold, which the king miscounted. The Jews too thought the time had passed and lost hope, rejoiced at the feast, and so Haman's decree came. v,w
That generation, at the end of the first galus, corresponds to ours, when most of the nation has fallen away. Like Dan at the rear and Adar at the year's end, it receives the miracle of Purim and the unveiling of what was hidden: even in concealment Hashem is with us.
A second Adar: the moon falls behind
Why one must drink on Purim, the Rav says, is still to be explained in the coming weeks. This year has a deeper meaning: a second Adar, thirteen months away from Nisan. Hashem is the sun, the source of life and light; Jews are the moon, receiving from Him, and count by it, while the nations, thinking themselves the source, count by the sun.
The thirteenth month and the kolel
The twelve months correspond to the twelve tribes and to the twelve permutations of the Name Havayah, twelve because one letter repeats. Yet there was a segment, outcasts, under no tribe and no permutation. Adar Sheni is their month and has no permutation, so it is counted as the 'kolel', the one added to a gematria.
But by what right may one be added? A storekeeper asked for thirteen dollars will not take twelve plus a kolel. The Rav answers that the One is Hashem. The Midrash says only sixty-nine souls went down to Mitzrayim and Hashem completed the seventy, and likewise the six hundred thousand, as He said He would go down with them. He is the thirteenth month. z,aa
Purim Gadol: the Yom Tov of the lowest
When a Jew feels shut out of the camp, Adar Sheni comes and Hashem joins Klal Yisrael to make up what is lacking. Hence a leap year has a Purim Katan and a Purim Gadol, when Hashem comes down to the outcasts: no Jew is rejected, even when the computation says he is out.
The more of a tzaddik one is, the more he feels Shabbos. Purim is the opposite: it is made for the low and distant, so the lower one is, the bigger the Purim he should prepare for, and Purim will lift him up.
Sources
Torah
- e Devarim 4:7 text index In the write-up: 10:45
- p apparently Bamidbar 10:25 index In the write-up: 51:16
- s apparently Vayikra 24:11 index In the write-up: 51:16
- t apparently Devarim 29:19 index In the write-up: 54:10
- u apparently Devarim 25:17-19 index In the write-up: 54:10, 57:31
- aa apparently Bereishis 46:4 index In the write-up: 1:15:29
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
- b Taanis 29a text index In the write-up: 0:23
- c apparently Megillah 10b-11a index In the write-up: 9:24
- d Megillah 11a text index In the write-up: 10:45
- h apparently Megillah 19a index In the write-up: 16:00
- j apparently Sotah 49b index In the write-up: 26:37
- k Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 30:00
- m apparently Rosh Hashanah 11a index In the write-up: 38:59
- v apparently Megillah 11b-12a index In the write-up: 1:01:00
Talmud Yerushalmi
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 4:27 The Rav says Purim's clowning and wine serve as an anesthetic for a spiritual remedy too strong to take with open eyes, and Purim works whether or not one feels it.
- 10:49 The key to the Megillah, from Rav Masna's opening passuk, is that Hashem is near to us even when events make Him seem far.
- 18:29 Because the Megillah is called a letter, its message is addressed privately to each Jew who reads it.
- 42:06 Nisan is the month of revealed miracles and Adar the month of hidden ones, yet Adar holds as many miracles as Nisan.
- 55:19 Amalek attacked Dan, the rejected tribe at the rear, and Parshas Zachor teaches that Hashem never forsakes even the lowest Jew.
- 1:13:53 In a year with a second Adar, the thirteenth month has no permutation of the Divine Name, and Hashem Himself is the 'kolel', the added one who completes Klal Yisrael.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 14:28 Why does Rashi, normally terse, call the Megillah 'the letter of Purim' rather than simply the Megillah?
Answer: 18:29 A letter is addressed privately to one person and read with special attention; the Megillah's message is meant personally for every reader.
-
Question: 47:27 If the events of the Megillah are all natural, why do we say there are miracles in it?
Answer: 48:13 Taken together, everything fell into place at the right moment, showing a hand guiding events: the miracles are hidden, not absent.
-
Question: 56:17 Why did Amalek attack Dan and not the rest of the camp?
Answer: 56:25 The other Jews were protected in the camp, but Dan had been expelled, so Amalek thought Hashem had rejected them and would not defend them.
-
Question: 1:15:29 By what right do we add the 'kolel', one more, to a count?
Answer: 1:16:02 The One who is added is Hashem Himself, as the Midrash says He completed the seventy souls and the six hundred thousand.
Insights
- 4:05 The Rav compares Purim's clowning and wine to an anesthetic: the remedy Hashem gives on Purim is so strong for the soul that it must be taken without seeing it, and it works regardless.
- 15:33 Rashi's unusual, almost poetic term 'the letter of Purim' signals that the Megillah is a personally addressed letter: each reader must study it as if written to him alone.
- 32:46 The last generation is like the fingernail: formed last and least sensitive, yet once contained in the embryo together with the head, so the end remains bound to the beginning.
- 41:41 Nisan comes from 'nes', a flag on a high pole where Hashem shows Himself, while Adar comes from 'aderes', a cloak; Adar holds as many miracles as Nisan, only concealed.
- 54:55 Adar corresponds to Dan, the tribe at the rear that Amalek attacked because it seemed rejected by Hashem; Amalek is the voice telling a Jew he is lost, and the Megillah and Zachor answer that Hashem forsakes no Jewish soul.
- 1:14:00 Since the Divine Name has only twelve permutations, Adar Sheni has none and is counted as the 'kolel'; the One who is added is Hashem Himself, who joins Klal Yisrael and makes up whatever is lacking.
- 1:20:42 Shabbos is felt most by tzaddikim, but Purim is the opposite: it is made for the lowest and most distant, and the lower a person is, the more Purim he has.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 22:38 The Rav says that one who studies the Megillah diligently, searching every detail, will find that Hashem is near to him and that it was written for him.
- 1:06:53 The Rav says one should not tell himself that Hashem was close only in the days of open miracles and has now abandoned us; Hashem has never forsaken the lowest Jew.
- 1:21:29 The Rav tells those who feel low to prepare themselves for a bigger Purim, since Purim can lift them up and transform them.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Amalek, Bigsan and Teresh, Dan, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Naftali, Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, Rashi, Rav Masna, Shlomo HaMelech, the Avos, the Kozhnitzer Maggid (Rabbi Yisrael of Kozhnitz), Vashti, Yirmiyahu HaNavi
Terms אבן שתיה, אגרת, אדר, אדר שני, אדרת, הסתר פנים, ונהפוך הוא, נס, עולם שנה נפש, ענני הכבוד, עקבתא דמשיחא, פורים קטן, רבונו של עולם, רמ"ח אברים, שם הוי"ה