מעשה ברבי אליעזר וכו - What our Sages Accomplished in בני ברק
Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) פסח no. 7 Pocket Guide p. 67 תשס"ט (2008–09) English 39 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that the descendants of Haman who learned Torah in Bnei Brak carried a hidden holy point from Timna, and that the Tannaim came to Bnei Brak on Pesach to lift them to the level of Krias Shema.
The Rav opens with a sefer's words that on Pesach a Jew can leave his straits not step by step. He then asks how descendants of Haman could learn Torah in Bnei Brak, when Hashem swore no converts would come from Amalek. His answer runs through Timna: she longed to cling to Avraham's family, and as a mere pilegesh to Eliphaz her holy point never merged with Amalek. Bringing the Kedushas Levi, he explains that Esther's seudah, prepared from Pesach food, drew Haman briefly out of tumah, and suggests that Zeresh, who escaped, carried that spark to the forebears of Rav Shmuel bar Shilas. Haman's descendants could not say Krias Shema of Shacharis, because of Zeresh's advice to hang Mordechai at daybreak. The Tannaim therefore came to Bnei Brak on Pesach and lifted Timna's children to Shema Yisrael. He closes with the father's descent to his children on Seder night.
Topics: The Seder Night · Krias Shema
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Timna and the descendants of Haman in Bnei Brak listed in the guide
After opening with a sefer's words that on Pesach one can leave his straits all at once, the Rav brings the Gemara about Menashe mocking the passuk of Timna and the Gemara that Haman's descendants learned Torah in Bnei Brak. He asks how this fits with the Midrash that no converts are accepted from Amalek.
-
6:53 Timna's longing and the pilegesh who stays apart
The Rav explains that a real longing shows a connection and is never lost, and that the first point of a thing endures even when hidden. Since Timna was only a pilegesh, who keeps her own identity unlike a wife, her point of longing for Avraham's seed stayed separate from Esav's seed and came out in Haman's descendants in Bnei Brak.
-
12:54 Haman's simcha and the escape of Zeresh
The Rav brings the Kedushas Levi's question how Haman could leave Esther's seudah happy when simcha exists only in kedusha: the seudah drew him out of tumah to the border of kedusha, leaving him no source of life. Comparing this to Agag, he suggests that Zeresh, who escaped, carried from that night the spark of Timna that later surfaced in Haman's descendants in Bnei Brak.
-
19:23 Ad d'lo yada: giving life to the holy spark
The Rav brings the Ari HaKadosh's explanation of drinking until one does not know between cursed Haman and blessed Mordechai: a blessing on Haman said in drunkenness gives life to the holy point in him without feeding his klipah. He adds that a Jew who blesses Zeresh, perhaps Shilas the mother of Rav Shmuel, helps bring forth such a child.
-
22:48 Esther's Pesach seudah and Rav Shmuel bar Shilas
The Rav notes that Rav Shmuel bar Shilas is the source of the teaching that when Adar enters one increases simcha. Esther's seudah was made from the Pesach food she had prepared and not eaten during the fast, and Achashverosh loved such food; that kedusha gave Haman his simcha and roused the point of Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, so that his descendant taught the law of simcha.
-
27:38 Why Haman's descendants could not say Krias Shema listed in the guide
The Rav suggests that Haman's descendants in Bnei Brak could not say Krias Shema of Shacharis, comparing it to people who tell him they cannot say Krias Shema from overconcentration. He traces it to the Midrash on Zeresh's advice to hang Mordechai at daybreak, to stop his Krias Shema, and repeats that on Pesach a Jew can leap out of tumah.
-
31:28 The Tannaim come to Bnei Brak on Pesach listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the Tannaim chose Pesach to come to Bnei Brak and tell of Yetzias Mitzrayim, intending to benefit the souls of Haman's descendants and break Zeresh's klipah. He brings a sefer that mentioning Yetzias Mitzrayim relieves distress, and the Rambam in Perek Chelek that Shema Yisrael and 'va'achos Lotan Timna' are equally Torah.
-
35:12 From Timna to Shema; going down to the children listed in the guide
The Rav concludes that the Tannaim lifted the children of Timna, the 'lowest' passuk, to the level of saying Krias Shema, with the power of Pesach. He describes the holiness of Seder night and says that the Torah asks a great man to go down from his heights to tell his small children of Yetzias Mitzrayim, joining 'va'achos Lotan Timna' to Shema Yisrael.
The shiur, written up
Timna and the descendants of Haman in Bnei Brak
The Rav opens with a sefer that says a Jew must believe that on Pesach he can leave his straits not step by step: just as the idol worshippers of Mitzrayim were transformed overnight into a holy nation, this comes again every year.
He then brings the Gemara in Sanhedrin that Menashe mocked the Torah, asking why it must say 'va'achos Lotan Timna' (Bereishis 36:22). Chazal answer that the passuk shows Avraham's greatness: Timna, a princess, wanted to join his family, was refused, and preferred to be a pilegesh in Esav's family; from her came Amalek. a,b
Timna's longing and the pilegesh who stays apart
Haman's simcha and the escape of Zeresh
The Kedushas Levi asks how Haman left Esther's seudah happy, as Esther 5:9 says, when simcha exists only in kedusha. He explains that the seudah, made in kedusha, drew Haman out of his tumah to the border of kedusha, which he could not enter. g,h
Every being needs a source of life: tzaddikim draw from kedusha, the wicked from tumah. Esther left Haman with neither, and that was his downfall.
Recalling that on the night Agag was spared a child was conceived, the Rav suggests the same happened here. Haman's family was killed, but Zeresh escaped; perhaps that night she conceived the ancestor of Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, carrying Timna's spark to Bnei Brak, where his descendants converted.
Ad d'lo yada
The Rav brings the Ari HaKadosh on the obligation in Megillah 7b to drink until one cannot tell cursed Haman from blessed Mordechai. There is a holy point in Haman that needs life; a blessing said in drunkenness reaches only that spark, while a sober blessing might feed the klipah. A Jew who blesses Zeresh, perhaps Shilas, Rav Shmuel's mother, helps bring forth such a child. i
Esther's Pesach seudah and Rav Shmuel bar Shilas
Why Haman's descendants could not say Krias Shema
The Rav suggests that Haman's descendants could not say Krias Shema of Shacharis, like people who tell him they cannot say it because they concentrate too hard. Why? On Zeresh's advice to hang Mordechai 'in the morning' (Esther 5:14), the Midrash says she wanted to stop his Krias Shema. That klipah passed to her descendants. n,o
The Tannaim decided to help them, and the Rav repeats for latecomers that on Pesach a Jew can leap out of tumah at once.
The Tannaim come to Bnei Brak on Pesach
From Timna to Shema
This happened in Bnei Brak: the Tannaim lifted the children of Timna to say Krias Shema, by the power of Pesach. Seder night is full of kedusha, a 'leil shimurim'. Yet the Torah asks a great man then to go down to his small children, tell them of Yetzias Mitzrayim and teach them emunah, joining Timna's passuk to Shema Yisrael. t,w,r
Sources
Torah
- b Bereishis 36:22 text index In the write-up: 1:56, 33:53
- c Bereishis 36:12 text index In the write-up: 10:17
- p Devarim 7:17-18 text index In the write-up: 31:39
- r Devarim 6:4 text index In the write-up: 33:53, 35:13
- t Shemos 12:42 text index In the write-up: 35:13
- u Shemos 20:2 38:09 text index
- v Bereishis 2:23 text index In the write-up: 10:17
- w apparently Shemos 13:8 index In the write-up: 35:13
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 0:00 The Rav quotes a sefer that on Pesach a Jew can leave his straits all at once, not step by step as at other times.
- 7:46 Timna's longing to join Avraham's family was never lost; because she was only a pilegesh, her point stayed separate from Esav's and Amalek's seed.
- 12:40 That separate holy point is what allowed descendants of Haman to convert and learn Torah in Bnei Brak, among them Rav Shmuel bar Shilas.
- 14:21 Esther's seudah, made from Pesach food, brought Haman to the border of kedusha and roused in him the point from which Rav Shmuel bar Shilas would come.
- 30:03 Haman's descendants could not say Krias Shema of Shacharis, a trait from Zeresh's advice to hang Mordechai at daybreak; the Tannaim came to Bnei Brak on Pesach to lift them out of it.
- 37:30 On Seder night a father must go down from his highest levels and tell his young children the story of Yetzias Mitzrayim.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:54 How could descendants of Haman learn Torah in Bnei Brak, when Hashem swore that no converts would come from Amalek?
Answer: 6:53 They came from Timna's holy point, which as a pilegesh never merged with Amalek's seed and remained independent through the generations.
-
Question: 12:59 How could Haman leave Esther's seudah happy, when simcha exists only in kedusha?
Answer: 14:21 The seudah, made in kedusha, drew him out of his tumah to the border of kedusha, and there he felt simcha.
-
Question: 20:00 Why must one drink on Purim until he does not know between cursed Haman and blessed Mordechai?
Answer: 20:14 According to the Ari HaKadosh, a blessing on Haman said in drunkenness gives life only to the holy spark in him; said soberly, it might feed his klipah.
-
Question: 29:32 Why did Zeresh advise hanging Mordechai at daybreak, rather than later when more people would see?
Answer: 29:37 The Midrash says she wanted to prevent his Krias Shema of Shacharis.
-
Question: 34:43 Why does the Rambam choose 'va'achos Lotan Timna' as his example of a passuk equal to Shema Yisrael?
Answer: 34:52 Because it seems the lowest passuk in the Torah, the very one Menashe picked to claim the Torah speaks of trivialities.
Insights
- 10:30 The Rav reads the halachic status of a pilegesh spiritually: unlike a wife, who merges with her husband, a pilegesh keeps her own identity, so Timna's holy longing passed through Amalek's line without ever becoming part of it.
- 14:40 Esther's seudah destroyed Haman by drawing him out of tumah to the edge of kedusha, which he could not enter, so that he was left with no source of life at all.
- 22:52 Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, a descendant of Haman, is the one who taught that when Adar enters one increases simcha, because his root lay in the simcha Haman drew from Esther's Pesach seudah.
- 29:41 The Rav connects the Haggadah's Bnei Brak to Haman's descendants: the talmidim who could not reach Krias Shema of Shacharis carried Zeresh's attempt to stop Mordechai's morning Shema, and the Tannaim chose Pesach to free them.
- 34:51 The Rambam's pairing of Shema Yisrael with 'va'achos Lotan Timna' becomes the story of Bnei Brak: the Tannaim lifted the children of the passuk Menashe mocked to the level of Shema.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 30:49 The Rav says, citing a sefer, that a Jew must believe that on Pesach he can leave his tumah and straits all at once, even if yesterday he was low.
- 37:30 On Seder night, the Rav says, a great man must go down from his high levels and tell his small children the story of Yetzias Mitzrayim, teaching them emunah.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Agag, Amalek, Avraham Avinu, Elifaz, Esav, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Lotan, Menashe, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, Rav Yehuda (bar Yechezkel), Shaul HaMelech, the Arizal, the Rambam, Timna, Vashti, Zeresh
Terms גרים, יניקה, יציאת מצרים, ליל שמורים, נקודה, עד דלא ידע, קליפה, תשוקה