דרוש בענין: מעשה ברבי אליעזר וכו' ובני בניו של המן שלמדו תורה בבני ברק

Catalog entry: זמנים פסח no. ⁨9⁩ Pocket Guide p. 28 תשס"ט (2008–09) Yiddish 1 hr 12 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 12 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains how Timna's desire to cling to the family of Avraham survived, hidden and untouched, through Amalek and Haman until it produced Haman's descendants who learned Torah in Bnei Brak, and how the Tannaim of the Haggadah came there to repair them.

The Rav opens with the Sfas Emes on the Tannaim in Bnei Brak who lost track of time, and with the question why Amalek was only weakened. He then takes up the Gemara that Haman's descendants learned Torah in Bnei Brak, though no convert may be accepted from Amalek. The answer lies in Timna: her desire to join the family of Avraham was a real bond, and since she came to Elifaz only as a pilegesh, her line passed through Amalek like an insulated wire without becoming Amalek. Haman's joy at Esther's feast freed that spark, which became Rav Shmuel bar Shilas. Shaul's sparing of Agag and Moshe's lowered hands left a remnant for Purim. The people of Bnei Brak struggled with the morning Krias Shema, a flaw from Zeresh, and the Tannaim, sharing their flaw by missing the matzah, repaired them. He closes with Birkas Hachama on erev Pesach and the power of a Jew's desire.

Topics: The Seder Night · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Bnei Brak, Amalek and Haman's descendants listed in the guide

    The Rav cites the Sfas Emes that the Tannaim lost track of time, asks why Amalek was only weakened, and brings Menashe's mockery of the verse about Timna. He then cites the Gemara that Haman's descendants learned Torah in Bnei Brak and asks how, when no convert may be accepted from Amalek.

  2. 6:27 Timna's desire and what a pilegesh is listed in the guide

    Citing the Rambam that every verse is equally from Heaven, the Rav explains that Timna had a desire for kedushah, that desire means clinging, and that a desire shows a real connection. A pilegesh, though, has no true bond, and as the beginning of a thing holds all of it, her tie to Elifaz stayed separate, like an insulated wire.

  3. 13:57 Timna's line passes through Amalek listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that from Timna came Amalek and Haman, and from Haman's descendants Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, the model teacher of children. Since Timna's line only passed through Amalek, the oath against converts from Amalek does not apply; he adds the Gilgulei Neshamos that Timna was reincarnated in Bilaam's donkey.

  4. 17:48 Haman's joy at Esther's feast listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Kedushas Levi and Tiferes Shlomo, who ask how Haman could feel joy, and answer that the holy feast of Esther gave him vitality, from which his righteous descendants could come. The Rav adds that this freed the spark of Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, compares it to Agag fathering a child the night Shaul spared him, and notes that the feast was a Pesach meal.

  5. 22:53 Zeresh saved, and Haman's war on the moadim listed in the guide

    The Rav explains why Zeresh escaped: the spark destined for Haman's descendants passed through her. He reads 'yavo hamelech veHaman hayom' as holding Hashem's Name and the words 'they learned Torah in Bnei Brak', and explains that Haman hated the Yamim Tovim and the schoolchildren that sustain Klal Yisrael, while Timna, as Bilaam's donkey, spoke in favor of the three festivals.

  6. 29:37 Blessing Haman on Purim listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Gemara that one must drink on Purim until he cannot tell 'blessed Mordechai' from 'cursed Haman', and the Arizal that a blessing said on Haman by mistake goes only to the spark of holiness in him. The same holds for Zeresh, from whom came Shilas, the mother of Rav Shmuel bar Shilas.

  7. 32:55 Why Agag and Amalek were left alive listed in the guide

    The Rav asks why Shmuel never rebuked Shaul for sparing Agag, and brings the Ruzhiner: by leaving Agag, from whom Haman came, Shaul brought Purim to the world. This also explains why Moshe lowered his hands and Amalek was only weakened, so that a remnant would stay until Moshiach ben Yosef; Haman fought the moadim and the schoolchildren, the two things that come from Timna.

  8. 39:43 Bnei Brak's struggle with Krias Shema listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that the people of Bnei Brak, descendants of Haman, struggled with the morning Krias Shema, as many people today complain they cannot concentrate on it. This was a flaw from Zeresh, who sought to stop Mordechai's morning Krias Shema, and a gentile's flaw passes to his descendants even after conversion; Amalek also had a hold on the tribe of Dan, in whose land Bnei Brak lay, so the sages came from the Galil to help them.

  9. 45:16 Why the Tannaim missed the matzah listed in the guide

    Returning to the Sfas Emes, the Rav asks how Hashem let the great Tannaim miss eating matzah on Pesach night, and explains that the telling of the Exodus takes a Jew out of all his troubles, which made the night right for helping the people of Bnei Brak. He then develops that at a great success something must be given to the Sitra Achra, like the se'ir la'azazel, mayim acharonim and kaparos, and suggests that the fast on Pesach in Esther's time was such an appeasement for the Purim miracle.

  10. 54:15 The Tannaim repair Haman's descendants listed in the guide

    The Rav brings from the Ba'al Shem Tov that a tzaddik can only lift a sinner if he has some share in the sin, and explains that the Tannaim, by not eating matzah as the Jews could not in Haman's time, gained that share and freed Haman's descendants to say Krias Shema. He returns to the Rambam that the verse about Timna equals Shema Yisrael, and concludes with the power of a Jew's desire.

  11. 1:02:19 Birkas Hachama: the sun belongs to Yaakov

    The Rav turns to the year's Birkas Hachama, approached with great desire. He explains that Hashem gave the sun, nature, to Esav and the moon to Yaakov, yet in truth everything belongs to Yisrael, and only in this world does Esav seem to hold nature, as Yerushalayim is written without a yud during the exile.

  12. 1:06:12 The sun's return, erev Pesach, and desire listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that when the sun returns to its first point, as before the sin, it is revealed that the world was made for Yisrael, and Birkas Hachama comforts the sun that it will return to Yaakov. A Birkas Hachama on erev Pesach is greater, since the war against Amalek, Shaul's war with Agag and that of Moshiach ben Yosef, is erev Pesach. He closes that Pesach is desire, that Timna's desire survived until Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, and with a tefillah for the coming of Moshiach.

The shiur, written up

Bnei Brak, Amalek and Haman's descendants

0:05

The Rav begins with the account in the Haggadah of the Tannaim who sat in Bnei Brak telling of the Exodus all night, and brings the Sfas Emes that they were so absorbed that they lost all sense of time, until their students came to say that the time for the morning Krias Shema had come. He then asks why Yehoshua only weakened Amalek rather than destroying it, and why Moshe let his hands down at all. b,a,c,d

2:53

He brings the Gemara that King Menashe mocked the verse 'and Lotan's sister was Timna', asking what it teaches. In truth, the Rav explains, Timna wanted to join the family of Avraham, and when Avraham would not accept her she became a pilegesh to Elifaz, son of Esav, and bore Amalek. The Gemara also says that descendants of Haman learned Torah in Bnei Brak; the Rav asks how, since no convert may be accepted from Amalek. e,f,g,h

Timna's desire and what a pilegesh is

6:42

To explain, the Rav brings the Rambam in his commentary on the Mishnah that every verse is equally from Heaven, so the verse about Timna is as important as Shema Yisrael. Timna had a desire for kedushah. Desire, he explains, means clinging, as in 'for he desired Me' and 'hooked with silver', like the embrace the Tanya describes in Torah study. The Zohar teaches that a good desire is never lost, and the Tzidkas HaTzaddik that a desire for something is a sign of a connection to it. i,j,k,l,m,n

10:49

Yet a pilegesh, unlike husband and wife, has no true bond: no kiddushin and no kesubah. Since the beginning of a thing holds its whole nature, Timna's tie to Elifaz was never real. The Rav compares it to the light that comes down through the worlds without changing, and to an insulated electric wire that runs through a building while its current stays inside.

Timna's line passes through Amalek

13:59

From Timna came Amalek and Haman, and from Haman's descendants came Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, whom the Gemara holds up as the model teacher of children. Timna's spark passed through the generations of Esav insulated, never mixing in, because it began as a pilegesh. So the oath against accepting converts from Amalek does not apply to her line: it was never of Amalek, it only passed through it. He adds the Gilgulei Neshamos that Timna was reincarnated in Bilaam's donkey, which merited to speak. o

Haman's joy at Esther's feast

17:54

The Kedushas Levi and the Tiferes Shlomo ask how Haman could go out 'joyful and glad of heart', when joy is a holy trait, and how converts could come from him. The Tiferes Shlomo answers that his joy came from Esther's holy feast, and through it righteous men could descend from him. p,q,r

19:15

The Rav notes that this does not yet answer the question about converts, and adds that by enjoying the feast, which Esther had prepared as a Pesach meal, Haman freed the spark of Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, the head of all teachers of children. He compares it to Agag, who fathered a child the night Shaul let him live. q

Zeresh saved, and Haman's war on the moadim

23:04

The Rav brings the Targum on the Megillah that Zeresh escaped, and asks why she was spared when she had advised building the gallows. He answers that the spark destined for Haman's descendants passed through her, so she had to survive. He reads 'let the king and Haman come today' as holding the initials of Hashem's Name: Haman's coming to the feast freed his spark, and the words equal in gematria 'they learned Torah in Bnei Brak'. s,t

25:27

Haman, he continues, set himself against two things that sustain Klal Yisrael: the Yamim Tovim, as he complained 'today is Pesach, today is Shavuos', and the schoolchildren, whom he planned to destroy first. The Rambam writes that the festivals depend on Jews living in Eretz Yisrael. Timna, as Bilaam's donkey, said 'you have struck me three times', which Rashi reads as a defense of the three festivals, the opposite of Haman. u,v,w,x

Blessing Haman on Purim

29:49

The Rav brings the Gemara that one must drink on Purim until he cannot tell 'cursed is Haman' from 'blessed is Mordechai', and the Arizal that when one says 'blessed' over Haman in confusion, the blessing goes only to the spark of holiness hidden in him. The same applies to Zeresh, from whom came Shilas, the mother of Rav Shmuel bar Shilas. y

Why Agag and Amalek were left alive

33:17

The Rav asks why Shmuel, rebuking Shaul, never mentioned Agag, though leaving him alive led to Haman. He brings the Ruzhiner that Shaul's words 'I have fulfilled the word of Hashem' meant that by sparing Agag he had brought Purim into the world, and the Rav says Shaul was right. The Chasam Sofer writes that the Megillah holds a greater light than the Torah of Moshe itself. aa,ac

36:29

From here the Rav answers his opening question. Amalek could not be wiped out until the true war of Moshiach ben Yosef, because Purim and Haman's descendants still had to come. When Moshe saw the war becoming so fierce that nothing would remain, he lowered his hands so that a remnant would survive. Haman fought the moadim and the schoolchildren, and both, the Rav says, come out of Timna.

Bnei Brak's struggle with Krias Shema

40:19

The Rav explains that the people of Bnei Brak, Haman's descendants, had difficulty with the morning Krias Shema, just as people complain to him today that they become confused when they try to concentrate on it. The cause was Zeresh: the Midrash says she advised hanging Mordechai in the morning to stop his Krias Shema, and a gentile's flaw passes to his descendants even after they convert. ae,af

43:48

Amalek also had a hold on the tribe of Dan, and Bnei Brak lay in Dan's portion. So the sages came from the Galil to help them say Krias Shema. ag,ah

Why the Tannaim missed the matzah

45:33

Returning to the Sfas Emes, the Rav asks how Hashem could let the holy Tannaim, the heads of Klal Yisrael, miss eating matzah on Pesach night, a mitzvah on which a Jew's existence depends. He explains that telling of the Exodus takes a Jew out of all his troubles, as the Chasam Sofer writes, which is why it is mentioned twice daily. Pesach night was therefore the right time for the sages to help the people of Bnei Brak. a

48:55

He then brings the se'ir la'azazel: at times something must be thrown to the Sitra Achra so it will not accuse the Jews. The Pri Tzaddik and the Ramban explain that the Jews are only Hashem's messengers in sending it. The same is found in mayim acharonim, which the Arizal calls the portion of the wicked, and in kaparos. aj,ak

53:16

Since Purim brought down a new light that no Yom Tov has, the Rav suggests that the fast on Pesach in Esther's time was the appeasement given to the Sitra Achra, so that the miracle and the establishing of Purim could succeed.

The Tannaim repair Haman's descendants

54:20

The Rav brings the Me'or Einayim in the name of the Ba'al Shem Tov: a tzaddik who wants to lift a sinner must have some share in his sin, as Chazal say, one who is not obligated cannot exempt others. He shows this in Moshe Rabbeinu, who could pray for those who served idols only once he too had a link to their sin. ao,ap

56:08

Haman's descendants had two obstacles to Krias Shema: Zeresh's wish to stop Mordechai's Krias Shema, and that because of Haman the Jews missed the matzah, when Esther asked them to fast three days on Pesach. By not eating matzah themselves, the Tannaim gained a share in that flaw and could repair them. When the students announced the time of the morning Krias Shema, their repair was complete. aq,b

1:00:43

He returns to the Rambam: the verse about Timna stands at the level of Shema Yisrael, and in Bnei Brak it was lifted to that level in Haman's descendants through the power of her desire. Desire, he repeats, is clinging, as in 'for he desired Me'. i,j

Birkas Hachama: the sun belongs to Yaakov

1:02:29

The Rav turns to this year's Birkas Hachama, which Jews approached with great desire. Hashem gave the sun, nature, to Esav and the moon to Yaakov, yet everything belongs to Yisrael, as Rashi says the world was created for Yisrael. Only in this world does Esav seem to hold nature, just as, the Tzvi LaTzaddik writes, Yerushalayim is written without a yud in exile and will gain it when Moshiach comes. ar,au

The sun's return, erev Pesach, and desire

1:06:56

When the sun returns to its first point, as before the sin, it is revealed that the world was made for Yisrael, and Birkas Hachama comforts the sun as Kiddush Levanah comforts the moon. A Birkas Hachama on erev Pesach is greater, since the war against Amalek is on erev Pesach, as the Zohar says: Shaul counted the people with Pesach lambs, and Moshiach ben Yosef's war will also be then. aw,ax

1:09:10

He concludes that Pesach is desire, and that Timna's desire survived Amalek until it became Rav Shmuel bar Shilas. The Rav says a mitzvah must be done with desire, and that one must daven for a desire for Torah and tefillah. He closes with a tefillah for the redemption, when 'saviors will ascend Mount Zion'. at

Sources

Torah

  1. c Shemos 17:13 text index In the write-up: 0:05
  2. d Shemos 17:11 text index In the write-up: 0:05
  3. f Bereishis 36:22 text index In the write-up: 2:53
  4. g Bereishis 36:12 text index In the write-up: 2:53
  5. k apparently Shemos 27:17 index In the write-up: 6:42
  6. w Bamidbar 22:28 text index In the write-up: 25:27
  7. ab Shemos 17:14 34:56 text index
  8. ai Devarim 7:17-18 47:46 text index

Nevi'im

  1. aa Shmuel I 15:13 text index In the write-up: 33:17
  2. ad Shmuel I 15:20 35:17 text index
  3. ah apparently Yehoshua 19:45 index In the write-up: 43:48
  4. as Yeshayahu 30:26 1:04:53 text index
  5. at Ovadiah 1:21 text index In the write-up: 1:09:10
  6. av Yehoshua 24:4 1:06:26 text index
  7. ax Shmuel I 15:4 text index In the write-up: 1:06:56

Kesuvim

  1. j Tehillim 91:14 text index In the write-up: 6:42, 1:00:43
  2. r Esther 5:9 text index In the write-up: 17:54
  3. t Esther 5:4 text index In the write-up: 23:04
  4. al Iyov 20:29 50:45 text index
  5. aq Esther 4:16 text index In the write-up: 56:08
  6. ay Koheles 3:2 1:10:26 text index

Targum

  1. s Targum on Megillas Esther (place not identified) index In the write-up: 23:04

Talmud Bavli

  1. e apparently Sanhedrin 99b index In the write-up: 2:53
  2. h Gittin 57b text index In the write-up: 2:53
  3. u apparently Megillah 13b index In the write-up: 25:27
  4. y Megillah 7b text index In the write-up: 29:49
  5. af apparently Sanhedrin 94a index In the write-up: 40:19
  6. ap Rosh Hashanah 29a text index In the write-up: 54:20

Midrash

  1. ae Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 40:19
  2. ag Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 43:48

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. m Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 6:42
  2. aw Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:06:56

Rishonim

  1. i apparently Rambam, Commentary on the Mishnah, Sanhedrin ch. 10 (Thirteen Principles, eighth principle) index In the write-up: 6:42, 1:00:43
  2. v apparently Rambam, Sefer HaMitzvos, positive commandment 153 index In the write-up: 25:27
  3. x apparently Rashi on Bamidbar 22:28 index In the write-up: 25:27
  4. z apparently Tosafos, Megillah 7b 31:50 index
  5. ak apparently Ramban on Vayikra 16:8 index In the write-up: 48:55
  6. am Sefer HaChinuch (place not identified) 51:07 index
  7. ar apparently Rashi on Bereishis 1:1 index In the write-up: 1:02:29

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a Sfas Emes (place not identified) index In the write-up: 0:05, 45:33
  2. l Tanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 6:42
  3. n Tzidkas HaTzaddik (place not identified) index In the write-up: 6:42
  4. o Gilgulei Neshamos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 13:59
  5. p Kedushas Levi (place not identified) index In the write-up: 17:54
  6. q Tiferes Shlomo (place not identified) index In the write-up: 17:54, 19:15
  7. ac Derashos Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 33:17
  8. aj Pri Tzaddik (place not identified) index In the write-up: 48:55
  9. an Mishnah Berurah (place not identified) 51:24 index
  10. ao Me'or Einayim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 54:20
  11. au Tzvi LaTzaddik (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:02:29

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. b apparently Haggadah shel Pesach, Maggid (Maaseh b'Rabbi Eliezer) index In the write-up: 0:05, 56:08

Key points

  1. 9:17 Timna's desire to cling to the family of Avraham was a sign of a real bond, and a good desire is never lost.
  2. 15:25 Because Timna began as a pilegesh, with no true bond, her line only passed through Amalek, so the ban on accepting converts from Amalek did not apply to Haman's descendants who came from her.
  3. 34:41 Amalek was deliberately not wiped out, by Moshe's lowered hands and by Shaul sparing Agag, so that Purim and Haman's righteous descendants could come about.
  4. 40:58 The Tannaim came to Bnei Brak to repair Haman's descendants, who could not properly say the morning Krias Shema.
  5. 1:09:08 The Rav says one must daven to have a desire for Torah, tefillah and mitzvos, since Pesach is the time of desire.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 2:03 Why did Yehoshua only weaken Amalek, and why did Moshe lower his hands?

    Answer: 36:29 A remnant of Amalek had to remain so that Purim and Haman's righteous descendants could come, until the true war of Moshiach ben Yosef.

  2. Question: 5:35 How could Haman's descendants convert, when no convert may be accepted from Amalek?

    Answer: 15:46 They came from Timna, whose line only passed through Amalek as a pilegesh without truly becoming part of it.

  3. Question: 18:06 How could Haman, of all people, feel joy, a holy trait?

    Answer: 18:50 His joy came from the holy feast of Esther, and from that vitality his righteous descendants could come.

  4. Question: 23:15 Why was Zeresh saved when all of Haman's sons were killed?

    Answer: 23:30 The spark destined to produce Haman's righteous descendants passed through her, so she had to survive.

  5. Question: 33:17 Why did Shmuel never rebuke Shaul for sparing Agag?

    Answer: 34:01 Because from Agag came Haman and Purim, and later Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, so Shaul was right.

  6. Question: 47:01 How could Hashem let the great Tannaim miss eating matzah on Pesach night?

    Answer: 56:44 To repair Haman's descendants they needed a share in their flaw, and missing the matzah, as the Jews did in Haman's time, gave them that share.

Insights

  1. 13:34 Because a pilegesh has no true bond, Timna's line ran through Amalek like an insulated wire: the spark of her desire for Avraham's family passed through the generations without mixing in, which is why Haman's descendants could convert.
  2. 24:03 Esther invited Haman to her feast so that, by enjoying it, the holy spark in him would be freed; 'yavo hamelech veHaman hayom' holds Hashem's Name and equals in gematria 'they learned Torah in Bnei Brak'.
  3. 33:17 Following the Ruzhiner, Shaul's 'I have fulfilled the word of Hashem' meant that by sparing Agag he had brought Purim into the world, which is why Shmuel never rebuked him for it.
  4. 41:32 The difficulty of the people of Bnei Brak with the morning Krias Shema was inherited from Zeresh, who wanted to hang Mordechai in the morning before his Krias Shema.
  5. 55:31 Following the Ba'al Shem Tov's rule that one not obligated cannot exempt others, the Tannaim had to share the flaw of Haman's descendants; by missing the matzah, as the Jews did in Haman's time, they could repair them.
  6. 53:43 The fast that cancelled Pesach in Esther's time was the appeasement given to the Sitra Achra so that the great success of Purim could be established.
  7. 1:08:14 A Birkas Hachama on erev Pesach is greater than usual, because the war against Amalek, Shaul's against Agag and Moshiach ben Yosef's, falls on erev Pesach.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 1:09:12 The Rav says a mitzvah should be done with desire, and that one must daven to have a desire for Torah and tefillah.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Agag, Avraham Avinu, Bilaam, Elifaz, Esav, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Menashe, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah, Rabbi Eliezer (ben Hurkenos), Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, Shaul HaMelech, Shmuel HaNavi, the Arizal, the Baal Shem Tov, the Chasam Sofer, the Rambam, the Rema MiPano, the Sfas Emes, the Tiferes Shlomo (Rabbi Shlomo of Radomsk), Timna, Yaakov Avinu, Yehoshua bin Nun, Zeresh

Terms ברכת החמה, השתלשלות, מועד, ניצוצות, סטרא אחרא, סמאל, עמלק, שעיר לעזאזל, תינוקות של בית רבן, תשוקה

Report an error on this page