bachurim vayera

Catalog entry: Y 05 Current וירא no. ⁨2⁩ תשע"ג (2012–13) Yiddish 42 min

Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.

Listen

  1. Download · Length 42 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav shows from Chazal, Rashi and stories of tzaddikim how severe it is to shame another Jew, and how far the Torah goes to protect the honor of every person.

The Rav opens with an old mussar sefer: one who shames his friend in public must fast forty days, and today, when nobody can fast, Hashem sends the sincere penitent great mitzvos to repair it. He brings the Gemara that one who shames another publicly loses his share in the World to Come, worse than a murderer, because he does not feel his sin and never repents. Boaz lost his sixty children for not inviting Manoach, even with good intent. Kavod habriyos overrides the Kohen Gadol's Yom Kippur service, forbids steps to the mizbeach, shields the fearful soldier, and even spared Bilam disgrace. After the story of the chol bird, he tells how Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin refused to sign the cherem against the chassidim, and how Rabbi Avraham of Slonim tied his chain of great descendants to this.

Topics: Bein Adam LaChaveiro · Middos Tovos

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Forty days of fasting for shaming a friend

    The Rav cites an old mussar sefer that one who shamed his friend in public must appease him and also fast forty days. Since nobody can fast today, he explains, Hashem sends a sincere penitent great mitzvos to repair the blemish, just as He finds ways for a thief who cannot find his victims.

  2. 3:45 Worse than murder; Boaz and Manoach

    The Rav brings the Gemara that one who shames his friend in public has no share in the World to Come, and asks why this is harsher than murder. He then tells the Gemara's account that Boaz lost his sixty children because he never invited Manoach to their weddings, and stresses that a good intention is no excuse for shaming a Jew.

  3. 10:09 Kavod habriyos: the met mitzvah and the mizbeach

    The Rav explains the mitzvah of kavod habriyos, greater still for the dead: a Kohen Gadol on the eve of Yom Kippur who finds a met mitzvah must bury it and lose the Yom Kippur service. He then brings the prohibition of steps to the mizbeach and Rashi's kal vachomer: if the Torah protects the honor of unfeeling stones, how much more a person, so one may not embarrass any Jew, even to teach him a lesson.

  4. 17:59 The fearful soldier and Bilam's donkey

    The Rav brings Rashi that the newly married man and the one who planted a vineyard are sent home from war so that the one who fears his sins is not shamed when he returns. He then brings Rashi that the angel killed Bilam's donkey so it would not be a disgrace to Bilam, and asks how much more one must honor a Jew.

  5. 24:30 The chol bird in Noach's teivah Story

    The Rav tells the Midrash of the chol bird that hid in a corner of the teivah rather than trouble the busy Noach for food, and was blessed by Noach to live forever. He connects this to the words 'like the chol' and concludes that one never loses through good middos.

  6. 28:21 The Ba'al Shem Tov's path and the Chofetz Chaim Story

    The Rav describes the new path of the Ba'al Shem Tov, serving Hashem with love and joy, and the opposition of the great misnagdim led by the Vilna Gaon, while later honest Litvaks came to respect the chassidim. He tells, as he heard from talmidim, how the Chofetz Chaim had two grandsons of the Berditchever Rav admitted to his full yeshivah so they would be in his shul on Rosh Hashanah.

  7. 33:38 Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin and the cherem listed in the guide

    The Rav tells how Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin refused to sign the Vilna Gaon's cherem against the chassidim, answering from the akeidah that to harm a Jew an angel is not enough, though to save one even an angel is obeyed. He brings Rabbi Avraham of Slonim's observation that the greatest leaders left a chain of great descendants, and that among the Litvaks only Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin did, because he would not harm a Jew.

The shiur, written up

Forty days of fasting for shaming a friend

0:21

The Rav opens with an old mussar sefer: one who shamed his friend in public must appease him, and besides asking forgiveness should fast forty days. Today, he says, nobody can be told to fast, yet the blemish remains. But Hashem measures each generation by its abilities, and to one who sincerely wants to do teshuvah He sends great mitzvos that redeem the sin as if he had fasted, just as He finds ways for a thief who no longer knows whom he robbed. a

Worse than murder; Boaz and Manoach

3:49

The Rav brings the Gemara in Bava Metzia that one who shames his friend in public has no share in the World to Come, which is not said even of a murderer. Why is it harsher? A murderer, like Kayin who killed Hevel, knows he did something terrible and comes to teshuvah with a broken heart. One who shames another does not feel it is a great sin, so he never repents. b

5:50

He then tells the Gemara in Bava Basra: Boaz married off sixty children and never invited the childless Manoach. The Rav explains that Boaz meant it for the sake of Heaven, so that Manoach would daven harder, yet Boaz lost all sixty children. Shaming a Jew for the sake of Heaven, he stresses, is no excuse. c

Kavod habriyos: the met mitzvah and the mizbeach

10:15

Next the Rav explains kavod habriyos, the honor due to every person, which is even greater toward the dead, so that leaving a body unburied is a disgrace. The Gemara learns from a passuk that a met mitzvah, a body with no one to bury it, overrides other mitzvos. e

12:36

He pictures the Kohen Gadol on the eve of Yom Kippur, reviewing the laws of the service on which all Israel's atonement depends, who finds a met mitzvah. He might reason that his assistant knows less and he should wait for someone else. But he must bury the body himself at once, become impure and lose the service, because the Torah is particular about kavod habriyos.

15:43

The same is seen at the mizbeach, which the Torah says may not be climbed by steps but by a ramp. Rashi explains: the stones feel nothing, yet they must be honored, so all the more a person who feels his disgrace. Therefore, the Rav says, one may not embarrass any Jew, even to teach him a lesson. f,g

The fearful soldier and Bilam's donkey

18:32

The Rav brings the Torah's exemptions from war: one who betrothed a wife, one who planted a vineyard, and the one who is afraid. Rashi explains that the fearful man fears the sins he committed. Why then must the others go home, when the war is for Klal Yisroel? So that the one who returns for his sins will not be shamed: people will think he too has a vineyard or a wife. h,i

23:01

Further, the angel killed Bilam's donkey. Rashi says it was so people would not say the donkey argued with Bilam and won, a disgrace for Bilam. Hashem cared even for the honor of a rasha who defied Him to curse the Jews; how much more must one honor a Jew. j

The chol bird in Noach's teivah

24:44

The Rav tells a Midrash: Noach fed every creature in the teivah on its own schedule, day and night. He found the chol bird hidden in a corner and asked if it had eaten; it answered that it did not want to trouble him. Noach blessed it to live forever. The Rav connects this to 'like the chol' in Iyov and in Hamavdil, where chol means the bird, not sand, and concludes that through good middos one never loses. k,l,m

The Ba'al Shem Tov's path and the Chofetz Chaim

28:31

The Rav describes how the Ba'al Shem Tov replaced the earlier path of fasting and self-affliction with serving Hashem with love and joy, and knowing that every Jew is precious. The misnagdim, great tzaddikim led by the Vilna Gaon, opposed him because they did not understand him, but later honest Litvaks saw the chassidim's yiras Shamayim and honored them.

30:30

He tells, as heard from talmidim, how two grandsons of the Berditchever Rav were turned away from the Chofetz Chaim's full yeshivah. The Chofetz Chaim had them admitted, explaining that before Rosh Hashanah he wanted the grandsons of a meilitz yosher in his shul.

Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin and the cherem

33:58

The Vilna Gaon called for a cherem against the chassidim, and only Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin among his talmidim refused to sign. Asked how he could refuse his Rebbe, he answered from the akeidah: Hashem Himself told Avraham to bring Yitzchak, but sent an angel to say 'do not stretch out your hand'. To harm a Jew, even an angel is not enough; to save one, even an angel is obeyed. His Rebbe, he said, is holy, like an angel, but not for this. o,p

37:18

Rabbi Avraham of Slonim observed that the greatest leave a chain, as with Dovid Hamelech, to whom the passuk in Bereishis 49:10 alludes, whose descendants were nesi'im generation after generation, and the Ba'al Shem Tov's talmidim such as the Maggid, whose line continues through the Ruzhiner dynasty, each great in his own right. Among the Litvaks only Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin left one, down to the Brisker Rabbonim, because he would not harm a Jew. q

Sources

Torah

  1. f Shemos 20:23 text index In the write-up: 15:43
  2. h Devarim 20:5-8 text index In the write-up: 18:32
  3. o Bereishis 22:2 text index In the write-up: 33:58
  4. p Bereishis 22:11-12 text index In the write-up: 33:58
  5. q Bereishis 49:10 text index In the write-up: 37:18

Kesuvim

  1. l Iyov 29:18 text index In the write-up: 24:44

Talmud Bavli

  1. b apparently Bava Metzia 59a index In the write-up: 3:49
  2. c apparently Bava Basra 91a index In the write-up: 5:50
  3. d Gemara Berachos (place not identified) 11:03 index
  4. e Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 10:15

Midrash

  1. k Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 24:44

Rishonim

  1. g apparently Rashi on Shemos 20:23 index In the write-up: 15:43
  2. i apparently Rashi on Devarim 20:8 index In the write-up: 18:32
  3. j apparently Rashi on Bamidbar 22:33 index In the write-up: 23:01

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. n Noam Elimelech (place not identified) 30:01 index

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. m apparently Hamavdil (zemer for Motzaei Shabbos) index In the write-up: 24:44

Other

  1. a Orchos Tzaddikim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 0:21

Key points

  1. 4:26 Shaming another in public is worse than murder in one respect: the murderer knows he sinned and repents, while the one who shames does not feel the gravity of what he did.
  2. 8:41 Shaming a Jew is forbidden even when it is meant for the sake of Heaven, as Boaz's punishment shows.
  3. 13:09 Kavod habriyos, human dignity, is so great that burying a met mitzvah overrides even the Kohen Gadol's Yom Kippur service.
  4. 16:59 If the Torah cares for the honor of unfeeling stones and even of a rasha like Bilam, all the more must every Jew be honored.
  5. 34:27 Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin refused to sign the cherem against the chassidim, and Rabbi Avraham of Slonim attributed his chain of great descendants to this.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 4:26 Why does one who shames his friend lose his share in the World to Come, when even a murderer does not?

    Answer: 4:40 The murderer knows he did a terrible sin and comes to teshuvah with a broken heart; the one who shames does not consider it a great sin and never repents.

  2. Question: 6:57 Why did Boaz lose all his children?

    Answer: 8:41 Because he shamed Manoach by not inviting him, even though he meant it for the sake of Heaven.

  3. Question: 19:48 Why should one who planted a vineyard or betrothed a wife leave the battle, when he goes to fight for Klal Yisroel?

    Answer: 20:13 So that the one who returns out of fear of his sins will not be shamed; people will assume he too returns for a vineyard or a wife.

  4. Question: 23:01 Why did the angel kill Bilam's donkey?

    Answer: 23:12 So that people would not point at the donkey that argued with Bilam and won, which would be a disgrace for Bilam.

  5. Question: 35:34 Why did Hashem Himself command the akeidah but send an angel to stop it?

    Answer: 36:02 Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin answered that to harm a Jew an angel is not enough and only Hashem Himself can command it, but to save a Jew even an angel is obeyed.

  6. Question: 40:29 Why did Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin alone among the Litvaks merit a chain of great descendants?

    Answer: 41:24 Rabbi Avraham of Slonim said it was because he did not sign the cherem, fearing to harm a Jew.

Stories

  1. 5:50 Boaz did not invite Manoach

    Boaz had sixty children and married them all off, but never invited his neighbor Manoach, who was childless at the time. The Rav explains that Boaz meant it for the sake of Heaven, so that Manoach would feel it and daven harder. Still, Manoach was shamed, and Boaz lost all his children. Later Boaz had a son from Rus, from whom came the house of David, and Manoach was answered with a son, Shimshon, who saved Israel from the Plishtim.

    In the story: Boaz, Manoach, Rus, Shimshon

  2. 24:36 The chol bird in the teivah

    Noach was busy day and night feeding every creature in the teivah on its own schedule. Making his rounds, he found a bird called chol hidden in a corner and asked whether it had eaten. The bird answered that it saw how busy Noach was and did not want to trouble him. Noach blessed it that it should live forever.

    In the story: Noach

  3. 30:30 The Chofetz Chaim and the Berditchever's grandsons

    The Rav heard from talmidim that two grandsons of the Berditchever Rav wanted to learn in the Chofetz Chaim's yeshivah in Radin, but the menahel turned them away for lack of room. They went in to the Chofetz Chaim, who heard who they were and had the menahel admit them. Asked why, he answered that Rosh Hashanah was coming and a meilitz yosher was needed, and since the Berditchever was a meilitz yosher for Jews, he wanted his grandsons in his shul for the Rosh Hashanah davening.

    In the story: the Chofetz Chaim, Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev

  4. 33:58 Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin refuses to sign the cherem

    When the Vilna Gaon called for a cherem against the chassidim, it was passed among all his talmidim to sign, and only Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin refused. Asked how he could refuse when his Rebbe had ordered it, he answered from the akeidah: Hashem Himself told Avraham to bring Yitzchak, but sent an angel to tell him to stop. His Rebbe is holy and like an angel, he said, but to harm a Jew an angel is not enough. Rabbi Avraham of Slonim later said that this is why Rabbi Chaim merited a chain of great descendants, down to the Brisker Rabbonim.

    In the story: the Vilna Gaon, Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, Rabbi Avraham of Slonim

Insights

  1. 4:40 The Rav explains why shaming is punished more harshly than murder: precisely because the shamer does not feel he did anything terrible, he never comes to a broken heart and teshuvah.
  2. 8:17 He reads Boaz's failure to invite Manoach as an act meant for the sake of Heaven, to stir Manoach to daven harder, and still Boaz lost all his children, showing that good intentions do not permit shaming.
  3. 20:13 According to Rashi as the Rav explains it, the exemptions of the newlywed and the planter of a vineyard exist mainly as cover, so that the soldier who returns because he fears his sins will not be recognized and shamed.
  4. 26:38 He explains that the chol bird's refusal to trouble Noach is the meaning of 'we will multiply like the chol' in Hamavdil: it refers to the bird, not to sand, and teaches that good middos bring eternal life.
  5. 35:34 Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin learned from the akeidah that the command to slaughter Yitzchak came from Hashem Himself while the command to stop came through an angel: to harm a Jew even an angel's word is not enough, but to save one even an angel is obeyed.
  6. 37:18 Rabbi Avraham of Slonim observed that a chain of great descendants, each great in his own right and not merely by inheritance, is the mark of the greatest leaders, and that Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin merited it for refusing to harm a Jew.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 9:07 The Rav says one may not shame any Jew even for the sake of Heaven; a good intention is no excuse.
  2. 17:33 He says one must be careful not to disgrace any person, even when one thinks the other should learn a lesson.
  3. 28:02 He teaches that one never loses through good middos; one only gains.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Bilaam, Boaz, Dovid HaMelech, Hevel, Hillel HaNasi (author of the calendar), Kayin, Manoach, Noach, Rabban Gamliel, Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel, Rabbi Avraham HaMalach, Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, Rabbi Shalom of Prohobisht, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Rabbi Yitzchak of Volozhin, Rus, Shimshon, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Chofetz Chaim, the Maggid of Mezritch, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), the Vilna Gaon, the Yismach Moshe, Yitzchak Avinu

Terms כבוד הבריות, מלבין פני חבירו ברבים, מליץ יושר, עקידה, רבונו של עולם

Report an error on this page