bachurim vayetzei
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current ויצא no. 5 תשע"ג (2012–13) Yiddish 42 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
Through a chain of true stories about gedolim, the Rav shows bachurim how grave it is to shame another Jew and how far great people went to spare others even a moment of distress.
The Rav opens by stressing that the stories he tells come from reliable sources. He tells of a brilliant Slabodka bachur who publicly exposed a friend's borrowed chiddush and, though he became a gadol, died childless; the mashgiach there saw it as punishment for shaming another. He then tells of a soul that came to Reb Moshe of Savran for a tikkun because its owner had shamed a chassan before his father-in-law. A series of stories about Reb Akiva Eiger follows: honoring the Rav of Lissa, hiding his greatness during another chassan's sheva brachos, spilling his own wine to cover a guest's mishap, and conceding a kashya to Reb Mordechai Benet in Nikolsburg. The shiur closes with Reb Yisrael Salanter: his call to account for rabbanim who did not teach middos, his view on asking forgiveness for lashon hara, and his shortening of a Shabbos meal for the sake of a tired maid.
Topics: Bein Adam LaChaveiro · Stories of Tzaddikim · Chazal and Gedolei Yisroel
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The Slabodka bachur who exposed a stolen chiddush Story
The Rav stresses that his stories come from reliable sources, then tells of a brilliant Slabodka bachur who bought copies of a sefer in Vilna to prove publicly that a rival's chiddush was copied. The mashgiach was deeply pained; the bachur became a gadol but died childless, and the Rav warns bachurim to be very careful not to shame anyone.
-
7:45 A soul punished for shaming a chassan Story
Reb Moshe of Savran told of a soul, a talmid chacham who had done teshuvah, kept out of Gan Eden because he had corrected a chassan's mistaken word in shul in front of his father-in-law. Along the way the Rav tells how his own rebbe, Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, once corrected an old man's reading in shul and the man became angry.
-
12:25 Reb Akiva Eiger hides his greatness Story
Reb Akiva Eiger asks the Rav of Lissa to forgive him for receiving the more honored aliyah in Posen. Then, as a young chassan, he gives only simple divrei Torah for a whole Shabbos, nearly losing his shidduch, so as not to outshine another newly engaged chassan in town until that chassan's sheva brachos ended.
-
20:27 The spilled wine and the kashya in Nikolsburg Story
Reb Akiva Eiger spills his own cup at the Seder so a poor guest who stained the tablecloth would not be ashamed, and in Nikolsburg he lets a kashya of Reb Mordechai Benet stand in public, revealing the answer only privately so the local Rav would not be lowered. The Rav concludes that great people had middos and derech eretz and would rather suffer than shame anyone.
-
26:23 Reb Yisrael Salanter on shaming and forgiveness
Reb Yisrael Salanter leaves a yeshiva so a fellow maggid shiur would not be hurt, and after a wealthy man shames a former shoemaker at his daughter's wedding in Vilna, he says the rabbanim of the previous generation are being judged for not teaching good middos. The Rav then describes Reb Yisrael Salanter's disagreement with the Chafetz Chaim on whether one must ask forgiveness for lashon hara when it would only cause the victim pain.
-
34:09 A two-hour seudah for the maid's sake Story
A wealthy host describes his five-hour Shabbos meal with glatt kosher meat, zemiros and divrei Torah; the Rav explains along the way what glatt kosher means and how it came to New York. Reb Yisrael Salanter agrees to come only if the meal lasts two hours, then asks the exhausted maid for forgiveness and shows the host that his extra zemiros came at her expense.
The shiur, written up
The Slabodka bachur who exposed a stolen chiddush
The Rav first stresses that his stories come from reliable sources about tzaddikim and gedolim. He then tells of a brilliant bachur in Slabodka who vanished from the yeshiva for a whole day, until the mashgiach pressed him to reveal why.
A bachur he envied had said a chiddush at a chaburah, which he knew came from a sefer the yeshiva lacked. He traveled to Vilna, bought many copies, and left one open on the other's shtender, so everyone saw the chiddush was copied. The mashgiach was deeply pained that a Jewish soul had been shamed in public. The bachur became a gadol b'Yisrael but passed away childless, which the Rav calls his punishment, and he warns young bachurim to be very careful never to shame anyone.
A soul punished for shaming a chassan
Reb Moshe of Savran, a friend of the Ruzhiner, told of a soul kept out of Gan Eden that came to him for a tikkun. The man, a talmid chacham, had done teshuvah before his death but forgot one sin: he had corrected a chassan's mistaken word in shul in front of the chassan's father-in-law. The Rav adds that his own rebbe, Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, once gently corrected an old man's reading, and the man grew angry. Reb Moshe brought the soul into Gan Eden, but only after it suffered for shaming a chassan.
Reb Akiva Eiger hides his greatness
When Reb Yaakov of Lissa, author of the Nesivos HaMishpat, visited Posen, Reb Akiva Eiger as Rav received shlishi, the aliyah the Shulchan Aruch counts as most honored (Chassidim, following the Zohar, honor shishi). Afterwards he asked the Rav of Lissa's forgiveness, saying sincerely that the honor was only for the bigger city. e,c,d
As a young chassan taken by a wealthy man, Reb Akiva Eiger said only simple words all Shabbos, and his father-in-law wanted to break the shidduch. He asked for seven more days, then said a pilpul that amazed the lomdim. Another chassan in town was in his sheva brachos, he explained, and outshining him would have pained that father-in-law. The Rav notes he was very young, yet already preferred to seem unlearned.
The spilled wine and the kashya in Nikolsburg
When a poor guest at Reb Akiva Eiger's Seder spilled wine on the white tablecloth, Reb Akiva Eiger soon spilled his own cup and said the table was shaking. In Nikolsburg, Reb Mordechai Benet asked a strong kashya during his derashah; Reb Akiva Eiger conceded it, and told him the answer privately the next day, so the local Rav would not look small in his town. Reb Mordechai Benet repeated it all publicly and declared him a tzaddik.
Reb Yisrael Salanter on shaming and forgiveness
Reb Yisrael Salanter left a yeshiva when he noticed the bachurim preferred his shiur to that of the other maggid shiur, so the other would not be pained.
In Vilna, a poor shoemaker who had grown rich made his daughter's wedding in the hall of the wealthy. One of the rich men took off his shoe on the way to the chuppah and asked what a new heel would cost. Hearing of it, Reb Yisrael Salanter said the rabbanim of the previous generation are now being judged for not teaching the people good middos and not to shame others.
The Chafetz Chaim rules that one who spoke lashon hara must ask forgiveness. Reb Yisrael Salanter, though he admired the sefer, disagreed: hearing it would only pain the victim. To the objection that the Rambam requires asking forgiveness, he replied that one should rather bear the punishment oneself. g
A two-hour seudah for the maid's sake
A wealthy host invited Reb Yisrael Salanter and described his Shabbos meal: glatt kosher meat, a G-d-fearing maid, and five hours of courses, zemiros and divrei Torah. The Rav explains that the Mechaber forbids a lung with a sircha, a covered lesion, while the Rema permits it, and recalls that glatt meat first came to New York in his youth. h
Reb Yisrael Salanter came on condition that the meal last two hours. Afterwards he asked the maid's forgiveness; she blessed him, saying she was always exhausted after five hours of serving. He then told the host that zemiros and divrei Torah must not come at her expense.
Sources
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 6:21 The Rav says that shaming another Jew in public is so grave that Chazal say such a person has no share in the World to Come, and the punishment can follow a person all his life.
- 6:51 He warns that young bachurim in particular must be very careful, because they do not yet grasp the severity of shaming another.
- 9:05 Even a correction that seems harmless, made in front of someone's father-in-law, can keep a soul out of Gan Eden.
- 19:44 Reb Akiva Eiger repeatedly gave up his own honor, even letting himself look unlearned, so that no one else would feel slighted.
- 25:50 The Rav says it is better to suffer, even to throw oneself into a fiery furnace, than to shame another.
- 39:43 Reb Yisrael Salanter taught that sensitivity to others, such as a tired maid, comes before extra zemiros and divrei Torah at one's own table.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 18:54 Why did Reb Akiva Eiger say only simple divrei Torah on his first Shabbos as a chassan, letting his father-in-law think he could not learn?
Answer: 19:15 Another chassan in town, taken by a wealthy man as a great talmid chacham, was in his seven days of feasting, and outshining him would have distressed that father-in-law.
-
Question: 24:33 Why did Reb Akiva Eiger leave Reb Mordechai Benet's kashya unanswered in public?
Answer: 24:44 Answering it would have shown that the kashya was no kashya and made the Rav of Nikolsburg look small before his own townspeople.
-
Question: 32:17 Why did Reb Yisrael Salanter hold that one should not ask forgiveness for lashon hara, against the Chafetz Chaim?
Answer: 32:40 Telling the victim that lashon hara was spoken about him would only cause him distress; better to bear one's own punishment than pain him.
-
Question: 40:03 Why did Reb Yisrael Salanter insist the Shabbos meal last no more than two hours?
Answer: 40:28 So that the exhausted maid, who cooked all Friday and served the long meal, would not suffer for the sake of extra zemiros and divrei Torah.
Stories
-
1:17 The bachur who exposed a borrowed chiddush
In Slabodka a brilliant bachur disappeared from the yeshiva for a whole day, and the mashgiach pressed him until he told why. A fellow bachur he envied had said a chiddush at a chaburah, and he knew it came from a sefer that the yeshiva did not have. He traveled to Vilna, bought ten or fifteen copies, brought them to the yeshiva and laid one, open to the chiddush, on the other bachur's shtender, so that everyone saw the chiddush was taken. The mashgiach was very pained that he had shamed a Jewish soul in public; the bachur later became a gadol b'Yisrael but passed away without children, which the Rav calls his punishment.
-
7:45 The soul that came to Reb Moshe of Savran
Reb Moshe of Savran, a great tzaddik and a friend of the Ruzhiner, told that a soul came to him for a tikkun because it was not let into Gan Eden. The man had been a talmid chacham who confessed his sins and did teshuvah before he died, but he forgot one thing: a chassan once sat next to him in shul, brought by his father-in-law, and he corrected a word the chassan said wrongly, shaming him before his father-in-law. Reb Moshe gave him a tikkun and brought him into Gan Eden, but he first had to pass through the punishment of gilgul for shaming a chassan.
In the story: Reb Moshe of Savran, the Ruzhiner Rebbe
-
10:15 Reb Shraga Feivel and the old man in shul
The Rav's rebbe, Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, told that he once sat in shul on Friday night next to an older man who said a word in the bracha of Hashkiveinu wrongly. After davening he quietly showed him how it is written in the siddur. The man became angry, saying he had been saying it that way for sixty years.
In the story: Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz
-
12:39 Reb Akiva Eiger and the Rav of Lissa
Reb Yaakov of Lissa, author of the Nesivos HaMishpat, came to Posen, where Reb Akiva Eiger was Rav. The Rav of the town was called up for shlishi and the Rav of Lissa received a different aliyah. After davening Reb Akiva Eiger went over and asked him not to hold it against him: although he could learn much more from the Rav of Lissa, the honor went to him only because Posen is a bigger city. The Rav stresses that Reb Akiva Eiger meant this sincerely, not as flattery.
In the story: Reb Akiva Eiger, Reb Yaakov of Lissa
-
15:21 Reb Akiva Eiger as a young chassan
As a young illui, Reb Akiva Eiger was taken as a chassan by a wealthy man who gave a large dowry and expected a great pilpul. All Shabbos he said only simple words on the sedra, and afterwards the father-in-law wanted to break the shidduch. Reb Akiva Eiger asked to stay seven more days, and the next Shabbos he said a wondrous pilpul that amazed the lomdim. He explained that another wealthy man in town had just taken a chassan known as a great talmid chacham, and had he spoken better than him during the seven days of feasting, that father-in-law would have been distressed.
In the story: Reb Akiva Eiger
-
20:52 The wine spilled at the Seder
At Reb Akiva Eiger's Seder a poor guest accidentally spilled wine on the beautiful white tablecloth and was surely embarrassed. Reb Akiva Eiger pretended not to notice, and a few minutes later he lifted his own cup and spilled it, saying the table was shaking. He did it on purpose so the guest would not feel bad.
In the story: Reb Akiva Eiger
-
23:07 The kashya of Reb Mordechai Benet
Reb Akiva Eiger spent a Shabbos in Nikolsburg, where Reb Mordechai Benet, a great illui, was Rav, and gave a derashah. In the middle Reb Mordechai Benet asked a strong kashya on the pilpul, and Reb Akiva Eiger said it was a kashya. The next day, escorting him on his way home, Reb Akiva Eiger told him the answer, explaining that saying it in public would have made the Rav of Nikolsburg look small before his own people. Reb Mordechai Benet went back, gathered the town, repeated the pilpul, the kashya and the answer, and said: this is a tzaddik.
In the story: Reb Akiva Eiger, Reb Mordechai Benet
-
26:23 Reb Yisrael Salanter leaves a yeshiva
Reb Yisrael Salanter was given a position in a yeshiva together with another great talmid chacham, each saying the shiur on alternate days. When he noticed that the bachurim liked his shiur more than the other one, he left the yeshiva so that the other would not be pained.
In the story: Reb Yisrael Salanter
-
28:13 The shoemaker's wedding in Vilna
In Vilna there was a lavish wedding hall where only the very rich made weddings. A poor shoemaker who had become wealthy made his daughter's wedding there, and the established rich men were displeased. As he walked his child to the chuppah, one of them came over, took off his shoe and asked him how much it would cost to put on a new heel, shaming him. When Reb Yisrael Salanter heard the story, he said that the rabbanim of the previous generation, now in Gehinnom, are being taken out and judged for not having taught the people good middos and not to shame others.
In the story: Reb Yisrael Salanter
-
34:27 The five-hour seudah and the tired maid
A wealthy talmid chacham asked Reb Yisrael Salanter to eat the Shabbos meal at his home, and described it: glatt kosher meat from the best shochet, a G-d-fearing maid supervised by his wife, and a meal of courses, zemiros and divrei Torah lasting late into the night. Reb Yisrael Salanter agreed on condition that the whole meal last no more than two hours. After bentching he called in the maid and asked her forgiveness in case she had to stand longer in the kitchen because of him; she blessed him, telling how every week she cooks all Friday and serves a five-hour meal until her feet give way, and tonight she could go to sleep earlier. Reb Yisrael Salanter then told the host that this was why he had asked for two hours: zemiros and divrei Torah should not come at the expense of an exhausted maid.
In the story: Reb Yisrael Salanter
Insights
- 4:15 In the Slabodka story the Rav sees the bachur's childlessness, despite his becoming a gadol, as the punishment for publicly exposing a friend, showing that being right about a stolen chiddush does not justify shaming him.
- 8:56 A man who did full teshuvah before his death was still kept out of Gan Eden for one forgotten act of embarrassing a chassan, which he never asked forgiveness for.
- 19:33 Reb Akiva Eiger preferred that his own father-in-law think he could not learn, at the risk of losing the shidduch, rather than cause another father-in-law distress over his chassan.
- 23:52 Reb Akiva Eiger let a strong kashya stand against his pilpul in public, revealing the answer only privately, because answering it would have lowered the local Rav in his own town.
- 30:28 Reb Yisrael Salanter held that the rabbanim of a generation are held responsible above for not teaching their communities good middos and not to shame others.
- 32:51 According to Reb Yisrael Salanter, asking forgiveness for lashon hara when it would only pain the victim is wrong; one should rather bear the punishment oneself than cause the other distress.
What the Rav says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Rabbi Akiva Eiger, Rabbi Mordechai Banet, Rabbi Moshe of Savran, Rabbi Yaakov of Lissa, Rabbi Yerucham Levovitz, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Rabbi Yisrael Salanter, Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, the Chofetz Chaim
Terms אור כשדים, גן עדן, מלבין פני חבירו ברבים, פלפול, קושיא