bachurim toldos
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current תולדות no. 4 תשע"ג (2012–13) Yiddish 38 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav speaks to bachurim about the danger of jealousy and of shaming another person, through Rebbe Elimelech's tefillah, the story of Kayin and a series of stories of tzaddikim.
The Rav opens with the line in Rebbe Elimelech's tefillah asking to be saved from jealousy, which he calls the hardest thing in the world and common at every age. He traces kinah from creation: the moon envied the sun, the nachash envied Adam, and Kayin, a great man to whom Hashem spoke, killed Hevel out of envy. Through the Midrash on 'Am I my brother's keeper?' he shows Kayin blaming Hashem for the trait. Kinah led to the sale of Yosef and the churban. He tells bachurim to say that part of the tefillah many times. He then turns to bein adam lachaveiro: the Chernobyler who protected a thief from shame, the Berditchever on the matzah bakers' widows, and the Chasam Sofer's responsum about reburying Reb Mordechai Banet, who was penalized for shaming a kallah though he was right. Reb Shlomo Bloch's story of a young ilui who shamed a rav, and Reb Hershele Rimanover's story with the Yeshuos Yaakov, close the shiur.
Topics: Middos Tovos · Bein Adam LaChaveiro · Stories of Tzaddikim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Kinah from creation to Kayin
The Rav opens with the plea against jealousy in Rebbe Elimelech's tefillah, calls kinah the hardest thing in the world, and traces it from the moon and the sun through the nachash to Kayin, a great man to whom Hashem spoke before and after he killed Hevel.
-
4:18 Kayin's complaint and Rebbe Elimelech's tefillah
The Rav contrasts the cheder translation of 'Am I my brother's keeper?' with the Midrash, where Kayin asks Hashem why He gave him such jealousy. He shows kinah behind the sale of Yosef and the churban, explains Rebbe Elimelech's plea to see others' virtues, tells bachurim to say it many times, and tells how Reb Aharon Roth praised the Vizhnitzer Rebbe for being free of jealousy.
-
9:53 The Chernobyler's spoon and the Berditchever's matzos Story
Turning to good middos between man and his fellow, the Rav tells how the Chernobyler said he gave a stolen silver spoon to a poor man rather than shame him, and how the Berditchever Rav warned the matzah bakers not to put the blood of the overworked widows into their matzos.
-
14:12 The Chasam Sofer and Reb Mordechai Banet's grave Story
The Rav tells the story behind a responsum of the Chasam Sofer about reburying Reb Mordechai Banet, the Rav of Nikolsburg. The ruling waited six months because Reb Mordechai Banet came to him in a dream: he had to lie six months beside a kallah he had shamed by breaking off a shidduch, though he had been right al pi halachah.
-
23:04 The ilui who shamed a rav Story
The Rav tells Reb Shlomo Bloch's story of a seventeen-year-old ilui who refuted a visiting rav's pilpul in public and shamed him; he grew into a gadol but never had children, which Reb Shlomo Bloch called his punishment. The Rav concludes that care for the honor of others brings all blessings.
-
29:18 Reb Hershele Rimanover and the Yeshuos Yaakov Story
The Rav tells how Reb Hershele, a tailor's son, became the shamash and then the successor of Reb Mendel of Rimanov, and how the Yeshuos Yaakov, who would not honor him, removed the chairs, until Reb Hershele stopped at the doorway and the mezuzah was found to be pasul.
The shiur, written up
Kinah from creation to Kayin
The Rav recalls the plea in Rebbe Elimelech's tefillah to be saved from jealousy, a trait common among bachurim, young men and the very old, and the hardest thing in the world. It began at creation: the moon envied the sun, since two kings cannot share one crown, and was diminished. Then the nachash envied, and Kayin killed Hevel, though Kayin was a great man to whom Hashem spoke before and after. a,b,c,d
Kayin's complaint and Rebbe Elimelech's tefillah
The cheder reads 'Am I my brother's keeper?' as a denial, but the Midrash explains that Kayin complained to Hashem, the Keeper of the world, for not holding him back and for giving him such jealousy. Kinah also led to the sale of Yosef and, with sinas chinam, to the churban. d,f
Rebbe Elimelech therefore asks to see the virtues of friends, not their faults; the Rav says a bachur who struggles should say it a thousand times. Reb Aharon Roth praised the Vizhnitzer Rebbe as free of jealousy, a wondrous rarity, for breaking one middah is harder than learning all of Shas. a
The Chernobyler's spoon and the Berditchever's matzos
On middos between man and his fellow, the Rav tells how a poor man stole a silver spoon from the Chernobyler; caught, he said the Rebbe gave it, and the Rebbe agreed, so as not to shame him, then even paid him for the shame. The Berditchever warned matzah bakers not to put blood in the matzos: the blood of the widows they rush.
The Chasam Sofer and Reb Mordechai Banet's grave
Reb Mordechai Banet, the Rav of Nikolsburg, died in Karlsbad and was buried in nearby Lichtenstadt. His community demanded that he be brought to their city, and asked the Chasam Sofer. In the responsum he ruled that the grave should be moved, but ended with one line: the matter is not yet clear to me. Six months later he sent word to move him. h
The secret: while writing, the Chasam Sofer dozed, and Reb Mordechai Banet appeared to him. As a bachur he had broken off a shidduch because he could not have sat and learned; al pi halachah he was right, but Heaven ruled that for shaming the kallah he must lie six months in Lichtenstadt, beside her grave. Being taken from one's grave is great pain for the departed, yet he had to bear it. Even when one is right, the Rav says, shaming another carries a price.
The ilui who shamed a rav
Reb Shlomo Bloch, a great talmid of the Chofetz Chaim, told of a seventeen-year-old ilui who toppled a visiting rav's public pilpul with a sharp question. When the rav would not concede, the ilui told him he could leave town. The ilui became a gadol but never had children, and Reb Shlomo Bloch called it his punishment for shaming the rav. i
The Rav notes that the boy had not yet had time to work on his middos, yet he was held responsible. One who is careful with others' honor merits all blessings.
Reb Hershele Rimanover and the Yeshuos Yaakov
Reb Hershele, a tailor's son devoted to learning, became shamash to Reb Mendel of Rimanov. Once he made the Rebbe's bed in the gabbai's place, and the Rebbe sensed such kedushah that he told him to make it every night; Reb Hershele later succeeded him, and tzaddikim like the Sanzer Rav came to him.
He once came to the city of the Yeshuos Yaakov, author of a commentary on Shulchan Aruch. Not wanting to honor him, the Yeshuos Yaakov had all the chairs removed. Reb Hershele touched the mezuzah and would not enter. The Yeshuos Yaakov, who had just had it checked, had his son take it down: the sofer's nail had pierced its letters and made it pasul. From then on he honored Reb Hershele, who said this was not ruach hakodesh; a kosher Jew can recognize such a mezuzah. j
Sources
Torah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- f Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 4:18
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 0:55 Kinah is the hardest trait in the world; it is found at every age and even among tzaddikim, and it goes back to creation.
- 5:17 Kayin was a great man, yet jealousy brought him to kill his brother; jealousy also caused the sale of Yosef and, with sinas chinam, the churban.
- 6:33 Rebbe Elimelech's tefillah asks to see the virtues of one's friends and not their faults, and the Rav tells a bachur struggling with jealousy to say it many times.
- 10:01 Good middos between man and his fellow include taking great care never to shame another person.
- 22:31 Even when a person is right, shaming someone carries a heavy price, as with Reb Mordechai Banet and the young ilui.
- 28:18 One who is careful with the honor of others merits all the blessings.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:18 What did Kayin mean when he answered Hashem, 'Am I my brother's keeper?'
Answer: 4:42 The cheder translation reads it as a denial, but the Midrash explains that he was complaining to Hashem, the Keeper of the world, for letting him kill and for giving him such jealousy.
-
Question: 17:38 Why did the Chasam Sofer end his responsum saying the matter was not yet clear to him, and only six months later rule to move Reb Mordechai Banet?
Answer: 19:00 Reb Mordechai Banet came to him in a dream and said the ruling was right, but he had to lie six months beside the kallah he had shamed.
Stories
-
7:51 Reb Aharon Roth visits the Vizhnitzer Rebbe
Reb Aharon Roth traveled from Yerushalayim to Vizhnitz, to Reb Yisroel of Vizhnitz. He said afterwards that the Rebbe was an awesome tzaddik with a virtue no other tzaddik had: he had worked the trait of jealousy out of himself and was not jealous at all. The Rav calls it a wondrous thing for a person not to be jealous.
In the story: Reb Aharon Roth, Reb Yisroel of Vizhnitz
-
10:15 The silver spoon
A poor man came to the Chernobyler for tzedakah and received a generous gift, and on his way out he took a silver spoon from the table. The household noticed, ran after him, found the spoon, and were about to beat him, when he claimed the Rebbe had given it to him. They brought him to the Rebbe, who said he had indeed given him the spoon, so as not to shame him. The poor man then demanded payment for the shame he had suffered, and the Rebbe gave him another fine gift and asked his forgiveness.
In the story: Reb Nachum of Chernobyl
-
12:33 The Berditchever and the matzah bakers
When the Kedushas Levi became Rav of Berditchev, the communal leaders asked for takanos in the matzah bakery because the women worked slowly. He gathered the bakers and told them that the goyim say Jews put blood in matzos, and he asked them not to put blood in the matzos: the blood of the widows who work hard all day and are rushed. A Jew should not eat matzos for which the widows' blood was spilled.
In the story: Reb Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev
-
14:40 Reb Mordechai Banet's six months in Lichtenstadt
Reb Mordechai Banet, the Rav of Nikolsburg, died while away in Karlsbad and was buried in nearby Lichtenstadt. The people of Nikolsburg demanded that he be brought to their city, and the question went to the Chasam Sofer, who wrote that he should be moved but ended that the matter was not yet clear to him. Six months later he sent word to move him. The secret was that Reb Mordechai Banet came to him in a dream: as a bachur he had broken off a shidduch because he would not have been able to sit and learn, which was permitted, but since he had shamed the kallah, Heaven decreed he must lie six months in Lichtenstadt, right next to her grave.
In the story: Reb Mordechai Banet, the Chasam Sofer
-
23:11 The young ilui and the visiting rav
Reb Shlomo Bloch, a talmid of the Chofetz Chaim, told of a seventeen-year-old ilui in the yeshiva who later became one of the gedolei hador, whose name is not told. When a distinguished rav came to town and gave a pilpul in public, the ilui asked a strong question that toppled it, refused the rav's answer, and a heated debate followed. When the rav would not concede, the ilui told him he could leave town. The ilui grew into a great talmid chacham but never had children, and Reb Shlomo Bloch said this was his punishment for shaming the rav.
In the story: Reb Shlomo Bloch, the Chofetz Chaim
-
31:24 Reb Hershele Rimanover and the mezuzah
Reb Hershele, a tailor's son who learned Torah with great strength, came to Reb Mendel of Rimanov and became his shamash; once he made the Rebbe's bed in place of the gabbai, and the Rebbe felt such kedushah that he told him to make it every night, and Reb Hershele later became his successor. When he came to the city of the Yeshuos Yaakov, who did not want to honor him, the Yeshuos Yaakov had all the chairs removed. Reb Hershele put his hand on the mezuzah and would not enter; the mezuzah was taken down and found pasul, because the nail had been driven through its letters when the sofer put it back. The Yeshuos Yaakov then honored him, and Reb Hershele said it was not ruach hakodesh but that a kosher Jew can recognize such a mezuzah.
In the story: Reb Hershele of Rimanov, Reb Mendel of Rimanov, the Yeshuos Yaakov
Insights
- 1:42 Kinah is the first flaw in creation itself: before any human sin, the moon's envy of the sun caused it to be diminished.
- 2:42 The Rav stresses that Kayin's murder is no newspaper item about ordinary people: Kayin was a great man, a son of Adam, to whom Hashem spoke, and this shows how far kinah can drag even a great person.
- 4:50 According to the Midrash Kayin's 'Am I my brother's keeper?' is a complaint against Hashem, the Keeper of the world, for not holding him back and for giving him such jealousy.
- 13:17 The Berditchever turned the blood libel around: the 'blood' that must not go into matzos is the suffering of the widows rushed in the bakery.
- 20:13 Heaven judges the shame caused to another even when the act was permitted: Reb Mordechai Banet was right al pi halachah to end the shidduch, yet he was penalized for shaming the kallah.
- 27:42 The Rav notes that the young ilui is held responsible even though at seventeen he had not yet had time to work on his middos.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 7:09 The Rav says a bachur in yeshiva who struggles with jealousy should say that passage of Rebbe Elimelech's tefillah many times, until Hashem helps cool the trait.
- 22:41 The Rav says that even when one is right, one must take care not to shame another person.
- 28:18 The Rav says that one who is careful with the honor of others merits all the blessings.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Hevel, Kayin, Rabbi Aharon Roth (the Shomer Emunim), Rabbi Elchonon Wasserman, Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Rimanov, Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl (the Me'or Einayim), Rabbi Mordechai Banet, Rabbi Shlomo Bloch, Rabbi Tzvi Hirsh of Rimanov, Rabbi Yisrael of Vizhnitz (the Ahavas Yisrael), Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech), the Chasam Sofer, the Chofetz Chaim, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), the Yeshuos Yaakov, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms בין אדם לחבירו, כבוד הבריות, מזוזה, קנאה, רבונו של עולם, שנאת חנם