Bachurim Lech Lecha

Catalog entry: Y 05 Current לך לך no. ⁨4⁩ תש"ע (2009–10) Yiddish 35 min

Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.

Listen

  1. Download · Length 35 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav teaches bachurim, from a letter of the Ba'al HaTanya, why a tzibbur should daven aloud, together and word by word around a fitting chazan.

Continuing last week's talk on tefillah, the Rav recalls the Ramban that the world was created so that Jews should daven and proclaim aloud that they are Hashem's creations, and the Ba'al HaTanya's call to daven aloud around the chazan. He then reads a letter in which the Ba'al HaTanya begs his chassidim to daven together, word by word, as Klal Yisroel sang the Shirah at the sea. To explain why, he shows that every word of davening carries great depth: lashon hakodesh is Hashem's language, tzaddikim speak a holy language others cannot follow, as a story of the Sanzer Rav and the Ruzhiner shows, and the Chasam Sofer brings from the Ba'al Shem Tov that every word is a heichal. He discusses who should go to the amud, the Ba'al HaTanya's takanos for chazanim, why the crowd and chazan strengthen each other like the angels, answers objections to loud davening, and closes with a story of R' Aharon of Karlin and a call to daven aloud with nusach without disturbing others.

Topics: Davening with the Tzibbur and the Beis HaKnesses · Kavanah in Davening

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Davening aloud and together

    The Rav recalls last week's Ramban and Tanya on davening aloud around the chazan, then reads a letter of the Ba'al HaTanya begging his chassidim to daven together word by word, as Klal Yisroel sang the Shirah at the sea.

  2. 5:46 The holy language of tzaddikim

    He explains that every word of davening has great depth: lashon hakodesh is Hashem's language, as Yosef told his brothers, and tzaddikim speak in a holy language others cannot follow, shown by a story of the Sanzer Rav's visit to the Ruzhiner.

  3. 11:20 Every word is a heichal

    The Rav brings the Chasam Sofer quoting the Ba'al Shem Tov that every word of davening is a heichal, and explains that this is why the Ba'al HaTanya wants all to say each word together; he criticizes latecomers and talking or silence during davening.

  4. 15:01 Who should go to the amud

    Following the Ba'al HaTanya, the Rav says the amud is not ownerless: only one who can daven with nusach and geshmak and lift up the tzibbur should go, even on a yahrzeit, and he tells the bachurim to remember this when they are older.

  5. 20:40 The Ba'al HaTanya's takanos for chazanim

    The Rav reads the Ba'al HaTanya's advice to appoint set, fitting chazanim who daven word by word aloud without rushing, a weekday davening of about an hour and a half, and his cry of 'gevald' over chazanim who rush.

  6. 24:34 Gathering around the chazan, like the angels

    He explains why the tzibbur gathers around the chazan: the loud crowd and the chazan strengthen each other, as the angels receive from one another and as the Shirah was sung together; he answers those who object to loud davening with a comparison to the shouting at a baseball game and calls for a good eye toward others.

  7. 31:33 R' Aharon of Karlin and davening with nusach Story

    The Rav tells of R' Aharon of Karlin, whose loud davening brought him before a beis din, and concludes that one should daven aloud with the tzibbur and its nusach, while someone without a good voice should not shout and disturb others.

The shiur, written up

Davening aloud and together

0:20

Continuing last week's talk on tefillah, the Rav recalls the Ramban that the world was created so that Jews should daven and proclaim aloud that they are Hashem's creations, and the Ba'al HaTanya's call to daven aloud with all gathered around the chazan. For this reason, he says, the best seats around the chazan in his shul are given to bachurim, to accustom them to daven loudly and with geshmak. a

2:54

He then reads another letter in which the Ba'al HaTanya begs his chassidim to daven together, word by word, not one here and one there. So Klal Yisroel said the Shirah at the sea, each word together, as the Gemara in Sotah says. b

The holy language of tzaddikim

5:57

Why must every word be said together? The Rav explains that each word of davening holds great depth. Although the Gemara allows davening in any language, lashon hakodesh is the language of Ribono shel Olam; Yosef proved himself to his brothers by speaking in it. c,d

7:38

Tzaddikim, he adds, speak a holy language others cannot follow. When the Sanzer Rav visited the Ruzhiner they spoke of oxcarts and soldiers' red uniforms, yet the Sanzer Rav later said it had been great secrets of the Torah. Such speech is lashon hakodesh even in Yiddish.

Every word is a heichal

11:38

The Rav brings the Chasam Sofer quoting the Ba'al Shem Tov that every word of davening is a heichal above; a foreign thought, such as which shoes to buy for Yom Tov, pushes a person out. This, he says, is the Ba'al HaTanya's intent: when all say the same word together, the whole tzibbur stands in one heichal.

13:53

He criticizes those who come late or daven each at his own pace, and those who stand silent or talk idly during davening.

Who should go to the amud

15:42

Following the Ba'al HaTanya, the Rav says the amud is not ownerless: only someone who can daven and lift up the tzibbur should go there. He tells the bachurim this now so that they remember it when they are older.

16:37

In his shul not everyone may go to the amud, even on a yahrzeit; the chazan should daven with nusach and geshmak, especially on Shabbos, with a good niggun. A chazan who cannot daven, he says, gives no benefit to the neshamah he davens for, and harms the tzibbur.

The Ba'al HaTanya's takanos for chazanim

20:47

The Rav reads the Ba'al HaTanya's advice to appoint specific, fitting people as chazanim, as is done in his shul, who daven word by word in a loud voice without rushing. A weekday davening, he notes, should not be too long, about an hour and a half.

23:56

The letter ends with a cry of 'gevald' over chazanim who rush.

Gathering around the chazan, like the angels

25:19

Why gather around the chazan? When the tzibbur davens aloud it strengthens the chazan, and his loud davening strengthens them. So it is with the angels, who receive from one another as the siddur describes, and with the Shirah sung together. Even someone who walks in without enthusiasm gets an 'injection' and begins to daven well. e,f

26:44

Some people object to loud davening; the Rav traces this to a bad eye that does not want another to be better. He told one such man that at a baseball game the crowd screams over a home run; standing before Ribono shel Olam is our home run.

30:01

He calls for a good eye that rejoices when another is better.

R' Aharon of Karlin and davening with nusach

31:41

The Rav tells of R' Aharon of Karlin, a talmid of the Maggid, whose minyan davened loudly. Summoned before a beis din headed by a great talmid chacham who was a misnaged, he greeted him as 'Avrahaml'.

34:00

He concludes that one should daven aloud with the tzibbur and its nusach; someone without a good voice should not shout and disturb others.

Sources

Torah

  1. d apparently Bereishis 45:12 index In the write-up: 5:57

Talmud Bavli

  1. b Gemara Sotah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 2:54
  2. c Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 5:57

Rishonim

  1. a apparently Ramban, Shemos 13:16 index In the write-up: 0:20

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. e apparently Shacharis, Birchas Yotzer Or index In the write-up: 25:19
  2. f apparently Shacharis, blessing after Krias Shema (Ezras Avoseinu) index In the write-up: 25:19

Key points

  1. 0:20 The Rav brings the Ramban that the world was created so that Jews should daven and proclaim aloud that they are Hashem's creations.
  2. 3:19 The Ba'al HaTanya asks that the whole tzibbur daven together, saying each word at the same time, not one here and one there.
  3. 11:46 Every word of davening is a heichal above, so when all say the same word together the whole tzibbur stands in one heichal.
  4. 15:42 The amud is not ownerless; the chazan must be someone who can daven with geshmak and nusach and lift up the tzibbur.
  5. 25:19 When the crowd davens aloud it strengthens the chazan and his loud davening strengthens them, as the angels receive from one another.
  6. 34:00 One should daven aloud with the tzibbur and its nusach, but not shout off-tune in a way that disturbs others.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 5:29 Why does the Ba'al HaTanya insist that all say each word together, and not just daven at the same time?

    Answer: 11:46 Because every word of davening is a heichal above; when all say the same word together, the tzibbur stands in one heichal.

  2. Question: 26:53 Why do some people object to loud davening?

    Answer: 26:44 The Rav attributes it to a bad eye: a person feels he is fine and does not want someone else to be better than him.

Stories

  1. 7:38 The Sanzer Rav visits the Ruzhiner

    The Rav tells, as R' Shlomo Eliezer heard it through his family, that the Sanzer Rav went to visit the holy Ruzhiner, before whom even the older Sanzer Rav made himself small. Seated together, the Ruzhiner spoke of oxcarts going out from a town in Hungary, and the Sanzer Rav answered about the red uniforms of the Hungarian soldiers. Coming out, the Sanzer Rav said he had great siyata dishmaya to know what to answer: they had not been talking about carts or uniforms but about great secrets of the Torah.

    In the story: the Sanzer Rav, the Ruzhiner, R' Shlomo Eliezer

  2. 27:01 Answering an objector with a baseball game

    The Rav tells that a man complained to him about loud davening, asking why one cannot daven quietly. The Rav answered him that at a professional baseball game, when the batter hits a home run, the whole crowd screams. When we come before Ribono shel Olam in davening, he said, that is our home run, and so we shout.

  3. 31:41 R' Aharon of Karlin before the beis din

    R' Aharon of Karlin, a talmid of the Maggid, lived in Karlin and had a minyan that davened loudly, which angered people. A beis din summoned him; its head was a great talmid chacham and a misnaged. R' Aharon came in and greeted him familiarly as 'Avrahaml', which angered him. The rest of their exchange is too garbled in the recording to retell.

    In the story: R' Aharon of Karlin, the Maggid of Mezritch

Insights

  1. 12:58 The Rav reads the Ba'al HaTanya's demand that all say each word together in light of the Ba'al Shem Tov's teaching that each word is a heichal: saying the same word at once puts the whole tzibbur in one heichal.
  2. 10:05 Lashon hakodesh is not only the language of the Torah; according to the Rav one can speak 'in lashon hakodesh' even in Yiddish, as tzaddikim speak words that carry hidden depths.
  3. 12:26 A foreign thought in the middle of davening, such as what shoes to buy for Yom Tov, pushes a person out of the heichal of the word he is saying.
  4. 25:40 Loud communal davening works like the angels, who receive from one another: even a person who walks in without enthusiasm gets an 'injection' from the tzibbur and begins to daven well.
  5. 28:28 The Rav contrasts the crowd that shouts over a home run with those who resent shouting in davening, the privilege of standing before Ribono shel Olam.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 1:16 The Rav wants bachurim to get used to davening aloud and with geshmak, gathered around the chazan.
  2. 15:04 He says one should daven together with the tzibbur, and neither stand silent nor engage in idle talk during davening.
  3. 16:14 He tells the bachurim to remember, when they are older, that the one at the amud must be someone who can bring the tzibbur to daven.
  4. 30:01 He says one should have a good eye and not begrudge another who is better or davens better.
  5. 34:50 He says to daven somewhat loudly together with the tzibbur and its nusach, but someone without a good voice should not shout in a way that disturbs others.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Rabbi Aharon of Karlin (Rabbi Aharon HaGadol), Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Chasam Sofer, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), the Maggid of Mezritch, the Ramban, Yosef HaTzaddik

Terms היכל, חזרת הש"ץ, לשון הקודש, סודות התורה, פסוקי דזמרה, שבת שירה

Report an error on this page