Vayera
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current וירא no. 4 תשס"ט (2008–09) Yiddish 36 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that at his milah Avraham Avinu was remade by Hashem into a new creation who believes in the Ribono shel Olam by nature, and that this emunah passes to his children by inheritance, the way animals inherit instinctive knowledge.
The Rav announces that this year he will speak about emunah, the foundation of all the mitzvos. The Rambam counts 'Anochi Hashem Elokecha' as the mitzvah of emunah, connected to Avraham, the first believer, whose emunah was simple, without chochmah. The Ramban holds that emunah is not one of the 613 but their foundation, like the foundation of a house, and the Rav argues the Ramban seems right, since every mitzvah is phrased as a command while 'Anochi' is a statement. To defend the Rambam he builds a long introduction: bodily features and middos are inherited, learned knowledge is not, yet animals such as the bee, the beaver and the spider are born with knowledge. Avraham was a new creation: at his milah Hashem gave him the letter heh and made him a being who believes instinctively, and he was first made barren to cut him off from Terach. Every Jew inherits this emunah, which raises a question about Jews who deny it, left for next week.
Topics: Foundations of Emunah · Avraham Avinu · Bris Milah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The mitzvah of emunah and Avraham
After a garbled opening, the Rav says that this year he will speak about emunah, the foundation of all the mitzvos. He brings 'Anochi Hashem' as the mitzvah of emunah according to the Rambam and ties it to Avraham Avinu, whose emunah was simple, without chochmah, like that of our grandmothers.
-
4:06 Rambam and Ramban: is emunah a mitzvah?
The Rav presents the Ramban's view that emunah is not one of the 613 mitzvos but their foundation, like the foundation of a house. He argues that the Ramban seems right: every mitzvah is phrased as a command, while 'Anochi Hashem' is a statement, like a doctor introducing himself.
-
11:22 What a child inherits from his parents
To answer for the Rambam the Rav begins a long introduction: features of the body, such as skin color, and traits of the soul, such as a quick temper, are inherited. Knowledge, such as knowing Bava Metzia by heart, is not inherited; it is acquired through toil in learning.
-
15:31 Inborn knowledge: bee, beaver and spider
The Rav shows that there is knowledge that is inherited: the bee builds its precise honeycomb, the beaver builds a dam, and the spider spins its species' web, though none was ever taught. He concludes that such knowledge is part of the creature's very being and passes on by inheritance.
-
22:04 Avraham Avinu as a new creation
The Rav says two things were created after the creation of the world: fire on motzaei Shabbos, and Avraham Avinu, a new creation whose novelty is his knowledge of Hashem. Others are punished for not believing because they could know through contemplating the world but do not want to; Avraham was remade at his milah to believe by nature, and the Rav begins to explain the small heh of 'behibaram' as the letter of birth.
-
28:06 The heh of birth and Avraham's new name
The Rav explains that the world was completed when Avraham received the heh at his bris. He shows the heh as the letter of birth from Rachel, whose name lacks a heh, from a segulah of a silver heh, and from 'hei lachem zera', and brings the verses in davening about Avraham's new name and his faithful heart: the new thing in him, emunah, passes to his children.
-
32:03 Cut off from Terach; a question for next week
The Rav explains that Avraham was created barren to sever him from the generations of Terach, so that a new people believing in Hashem would begin from him, and he brings Rashi on why Terach's death is written before Avraham leaves. He ends with a strong question: if every Jew inherits emunah, how can there be Jews who deny Hashem? The answer is left for next week.
The shiur, written up
The mitzvah of emunah and Avraham
The Rav announces that this year he will speak about emunah, the foundation of all the mitzvos. The Rambam, he says, counts 'Anochi Hashem' (Shemos 20:2), the first of the Ten Commandments, as the mitzvah of emunah. It is bound up with Avraham Avinu, of whom it says 'vehe'emin baShem' (Bereishis 15:6): a simple emunah, like that of our grandmothers who never went to school. Learning Torah raises a person's emunah higher and higher, yet emunah itself stands even higher. a,c
Is emunah a mitzvah?
The Ramban disagrees: emunah is not one of the 613 mitzvos that the Gemara (Makkos 23b) says were given to Moshe at Sinai. It is not less than a mitzvah but greater: it is their foundation. One cannot live in the foundation of a house, yet without it there is no house. The whole Torah stands on emunah, as the Gemara (Makkos 24a) says that Chavakuk set all the mitzvos on one: 'the tzaddik lives by his emunah'. d,e
The Rav argues that, to a bachur's understanding, the Ramban seems right. Every mitzvah is written as a command: 'Zachor es yom haShabbos' (Shemos 20:8), make a fence for your roof (Devarim 22:8), do not eat what is forbidden (Devarim 14:3). 'Anochi Hashem' commands nothing; it is a statement, like a doctor who walks in and introduces himself. Since mitzvah comes from the word tzivui, command, how can the Rambam call it a mitzvah? g,h,i
What a child inherits
To answer, the Rav builds a long introduction. A child is born with features of his parents: dark skin, a long nose, and also traits of the soul, such as a quick temper, so one must work on one's middos. But knowledge is not inherited: a father who knows Bava Metzia by heart does not have a child born knowing it; the child must toil over the Gemara himself.
Inborn knowledge in animals
Yet some knowledge is inherited, as seen in animals. The bee builds a honeycomb of tiny chambers with wonderful precision, though it never saw its mother, who laid the egg and left. A beaver raised by a person from birth, once put in a pond, builds a dam that the Rav says he himself could not build without years of engineering study.
Even in New York one sees the spider spin a web with exactly its mother's design, each species its own kind. Such knowledge is born with the creature; it is part of its very being and passes on by inheritance.
Avraham Avinu, a new creation
Two things were created after the creation of the world: fire on motzaei Shabbos, which is why we make 'borei me'orei ha'esh', and Avraham Avinu. He and his children see like everyone else; what is new in him is a knowledge the nations lack: he believes in the Ribono shel Olam. The Gemara calls him the first of the believers, and this knowledge passes to his children. k
Why, then, is a non-Jew punished for idolatry? Because by contemplating the world and his own body he can know with his intellect that there is a Creator, as Avraham did at three; he does not want to know, since knowing would obligate him. Avraham too came to it through intellect, but at the milah Hashem remade him to believe by nature. The Rav then turns to 'behibaram' (Bereishis 2:4), written with a small heh, the letter of birth. l
The heh of birth
Cut off from Terach
Avraham was first created barren, cutting the rope of generations from Terach, so that a new people believing in Hashem would begin from him. Rashi (Bereishis 11:32) explains why Terach's death is written before Avraham leaves him: Terach was no longer his father, and Yitzchak has no connection to Terach. s
Every Jew inherits this natural emunah, not through intellect. This raises a strong question: how can there be Jews who deny Hashem? The Rav says the question does not truly begin, and leaves the explanation for next week.
Sources
Torah
- a Shemos 20:2 text index In the write-up: 1:04
- c Bereishis 15:6 text index In the write-up: 1:04
- g Shemos 20:8 text index In the write-up: 7:10
- h apparently Devarim 22:8 index In the write-up: 7:10
- i apparently Devarim 14:3 index In the write-up: 7:10
- l Bereishis 2:4 text index In the write-up: 24:22
- p apparently Bereishis 29:29 index In the write-up: 28:15
- q apparently Bereishis 47:23 index In the write-up: 28:15
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Key points
- 3:55 The Rambam counts 'Anochi Hashem' as the mitzvah of emunah, while the Ramban holds emunah is not one of the 613 but the foundation on which all of them stand.
- 7:26 Every mitzvah in the Torah is written as a command, while 'Anochi Hashem' is a statement in which Hashem presents Himself, so the Rav says the Ramban appears to be right.
- 14:26 Bodily features and character traits pass from parents to children, but learned knowledge does not; animals, however, are born with knowledge of how to build a hive, a dam or a web.
- 26:22 At his milah Hashem remade Avraham Avinu into a new creation who believes in the Ribono shel Olam by nature, not only through his intellect.
- 24:06 This emunah passes by inheritance to all of Avraham's children, who are therefore believers the sons of believers.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 10:29 How can the Rambam count emunah as a mitzvah when 'Anochi Hashem' is not written as a command?
Answer: 11:24 The Rav does not resolve it directly; he begins a long introduction about inherited knowledge, leading to the emunah Avraham's children inherit.
-
Question: 19:14 Who taught the beaver to build a dam, or the spider to spin its web?
Answer: 20:56 No one: the knowledge is born with the creature as part of its soul and passes on by inheritance.
-
Question: 22:51 In what way is Avraham a new creation, if he and his children see like other people?
Answer: 23:05 He has a knowledge that the nations lack: he believes in the Ribono shel Olam.
-
Question: 24:16 Why is a non-Jew punished for idolatry if he was not born with the knowledge that there is a Ribono shel Olam?
Answer: 24:34 He can know it through his intellect by contemplating the wonders of the world and of his own body, as Avraham did at three; he does not want to know, because knowing would obligate him.
-
Question: 33:27 Why did Avraham leave his father Terach while Terach was still alive?
Answer: 33:52 Because Terach was no longer his father: Avraham was a new creation, the start of a new people.
Insights
- 9:11 The Rav argues from the form of the verse that the Ramban appears right: a mitzvah means a command, yet 'Anochi Hashem' is written as a statement, Hashem presenting Himself, not as an order to believe.
- 20:56 Instinctive knowledge in animals, which no one taught them and which belongs to their very being, serves as the model for the emunah a Jew is born with.
- 22:51 Avraham's novelty as a 'new creation' was not physical, since he and his children see like other people, but a knowledge of Hashem that the nations do not have.
- 26:54 The small heh of 'behibaram' is read as 'b'Avraham': the world was completed when Avraham received the heh, the letter of birth, at his bris.
- 32:11 Avraham was created barren so that his line from Terach would be cut, and the new power of birth given with the heh began a new people; this is why Yitzchak has no connection to Terach.
- 2:24 The Rav reads 'vehe'emin' as written without a yud, the letter of chochmah, to show that Avraham's emunah was natural and not built on intellect.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 14:42 Since a quick temper and other middos are passed down by inheritance, the Rav says one must work on one's middos and uproot the bad ones.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Bilhah, Cham, Chavakuk, Lavan, Rachel Imeinu, Rashi, Terach, the Baal HaTurim, the Rambam, the Ramban, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms אמונה, אנכי ה' אלקיך, ירושה, מאמינים בני מאמינים, עקרה, רבונו של עולם, תרי"ג מצוות