Chaya Sura

Catalog entry: Y 05 Current חיי שרה no. ⁨5⁩ תשס"ט (2008–09) Yiddish 42 min

Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.

Listen

  1. Download · Length 42 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that a Jew's emunah is a feeling of the heart inherited from the mother, so that even a Jew who denies Hashem is only rationalizing what he knows deep inside.

The Rav opens by contrasting a gentile, who can grasp emunah through logic, with a Jew, who feels it by instinct. He illustrates with the halacha of a burglar: a son may not kill his father who breaks in, because a father's heart feels for his son even when he does not know whose house it is. From there he distinguishes chochmah, fixed facts that all agree on, from binah, the understanding of the heart, which Chazal say was given more to women; the seder's three matzos and four cups reflect this. Jewishness follows the mother because emunah is a feeling, and he shows from Hebrew grammar that the root of emunah yields the word for mother. He then describes how people rationalize out of pride, from the fox and the grapes, Eisav and a bochur blaming his rebbe, and concludes that a Jewish apikores really believes but denies out of desire, illustrated by a letter written after the Six Day War.

Topics: The Pintele Yid: The Inner Point of Every Jew · Foundations of Emunah · Simple Emunah, Above Reason

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Emunah as instinct: the father and the burglar

    The Rav opens by saying a Jew feels emunah instinctively, unlike a gentile who reaches it through logic. He brings the halacha of a burglar who may be killed, and Rashi's case of a father breaking in to his son, and argues that even a father who does not know it is his son's house feels it in his heart, as even wild animals do for their young.

  2. 4:51 Chochmah and binah, matzos and cups

    The Rav explains that Jews are Hashem's children and feel bound to Him with the heart, not only the mind. He contrasts chochmah, objective facts, with binah, the heart's understanding, reads 'aliba d'Abaye' as 'according to Abaye's heart', and brings the Gemara that women were given extra binah. The three matzos (grain, intellect) and four cups (wine, feeling) at the seder, matching the Avos and Imahos, show the two sides.

  3. 12:09 A wife's feeling and the Lechovitcher's cry

    The Rav brings the Avnei Nezer's explanation of why a woman may remarry on one witness's word: she feels whether her husband is alive. He then tells how Reb Mordechai of Lechovitch cried out that he no longer felt his Rebbe, Reb Shlomo of Karlin, until he was told the Rebbe had passed away.

  4. 15:32 Why Jewishness follows the mother: emunah and em

    The Rav asks why a child's Jewishness follows the mother when tribe and inheritance follow the father, and answers that emunah is a feeling, which comes from the mother. He supports this from a rule of Hebrew grammar: a three-letter verb ending in nun drops it as a noun (chanan to chen, shanan to shen, ganan to gan), so from aman, to believe, comes em, mother.

  5. 23:50 Ben Sira's fox and the sour grapes

    The Rav mentions the Gemara on outside books, among them Ben Sira's fables, which the gentiles adopted as Aesop's fables. He tells the fable of the fox who could not climb the fence to the grapes and declared them sour, and explains that like every proud person the fox cannot admit his own weakness.

  6. 28:12 Eisav, the hammer and the bochur: rationalization

    The Rav says that everything, even psychology, can be learned from Chumash and Rashi, and shows it with Eisav: seeing that his Canaanite wives displeased his parents, he concluded he lost the berachos because of his wives and married Yishmael's daughter. He adds the man who hits his thumb and blames the hammer and the bochur who blames his rebbe and classroom, calling this rationalization born of pride.

  7. 33:56 The Jewish apikores really believes

    The Rav explains that a Jewish apikores denies Hashem only because he wants to follow his desires, cites a philosopher's essay that there never was a true atheist, and tells of the miracles of the Six Day War and a woman who wrote to a newspaper asking it to stop reporting them so she could keep going to the beach on Shabbos. He concludes that every Jew believes.

The shiur, written up

Emunah as instinct: the father and the burglar

0:22

The Rav opens by saying that a gentile can grasp emunah through logic, but a Jew feels it by instinct. He brings the Torah's halacha (Shemos 22:1) that a burglar who tunnels in may be killed, since he is presumed ready to kill an owner who resists. a

2:11

Rashi, following the Gemara (Sanhedrin 72b), excludes a father breaking in to his son, since a father would not kill his son. Even if the father does not know the house is his son's, the Rav says, his heart knows; this instinct exists even in wild animals, who risk their lives for their young. b,c

Chochmah and binah, matzos and cups

4:51

So too, Jews are Hashem's children, 'banim atem' (Devarim 14:1), bound to Him by a rope; a Jew knows there is a Ribono shel Olam not only because his mind dictates it but because his heart does. e

6:50

The Rav distinguishes chochmah, facts like one plus one is two that nobody can dispute, from binah, the heart's understanding, which differs with each person's nature. So 'aliba d'Abaye' means according to Abaye's heart, from the root of his soul. The Gemara (Niddah 45b) learns from 'vayiven' (Bereishis 2:22) that women were given extra binah, and their feelings are stronger. g,f

9:46

Grain brings intellect, as the Gemara (Berachos 40a) says, while wine brings out feeling. So at the seder the three matzos match the Avos and the four cups the Imahos, like the three- and four-headed shin of the tefillin. This feeling of being Hashem's children is the inheritance of Avraham Avinu. h

A wife's feeling and the Lechovitcher's cry

12:09

The Rav notes that although matters require two witnesses, a woman may remarry on one witness's word that her husband died. The Avnei Nezer explains that she feels whether he is alive, so her believing the witness is itself a sign. i

13:16

Likewise Reb Mordechai of Lechovitch cried out that he no longer felt his Rebbe, Reb Shlomo of Karlin; told that the Rebbe had passed away, he calmed down, now understanding why.

Why Jewishness follows the mother: emunah and em

15:53

The Rav asks why the child of a Jewish mother is Jewish and the child of a gentile mother is not, when tribe and inheritance follow the father (Bamidbar 1:2). He answers that emunah is a feeling, and feeling comes from the mother. j

18:37

He supports this from grammar, using the distinction Rashi often draws between verb and noun: a three-letter verb ending in nun drops it as a noun. From chanan comes chen; from shanan, the sharpness of 'veshinantam' (Devarim 6:7), which the Gemara (Kiddushin 30a) explains as answering Torah questions at once, comes shen, a tooth; from ganan, to protect, comes gan, a fenced garden. n,k,l

22:21

And from aman, to believe, as in 'vehe'emin' (Bereishis 15:6), comes em, mother. A gentile knows there is a Ribono shel Olam; a Jew feels it, which is something else entirely. m

Ben Sira's fox and the sour grapes

23:54

The Rav mentions the Gemara (Sanhedrin 100b) on outside books, among them Ben Sira, whose fox fables the gentiles adopted as Aesop's fables. In one, a fox saw delicious grapes behind a high fence, struggled three days and nights to climb over, and finally declared them sour. o

26:54

The fox, the Rav explains, is like every proud person who must be right: rather than admit his weakness, he says the grapes are no good.

Eisav, the hammer and the bochur

28:24

Everything, even psychology, can be learned from Chumash and Rashi, as a melamed seeking psychology books was told. Eisav's wives grieved Yitzchak and Rivkah (Bereishis 26:35), Rivkah could not bear Yaakov marrying such a wife (Bereishis 27:46), and Eisav then married Yishmael's daughter (Bereishis 28:6-9). p,q,r

31:10

The Rav reads this as Eisav deciding he lost the berachos because of his wife, never imagining the fault was his. So a man who hits his thumb blames the hammer, and a struggling bochur blames the boring rebbe and the stuffy classroom. Psychology calls this rationalization and denial; it stems from pride.

The Jewish apikores really believes

34:12

A Jewish apikores, the Rav says, descends from Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov; he claims not to believe because he wants to follow desires the Torah forbids. He tells of a man who slipped on a banana peel crying 'Oh G-d!', and cites a philosopher's essay, 'There never was a true atheist': deep in his heart the denier knows there is a Ribono shel Olam.

37:41

Before the Six Day War newspapers wrote it was the end of Israel, yet the Jews won wondrously, and secular papers reported miracles for months, such as a second bomb bursting a rooftop water tank that put out the first bomb's fire. A woman asked a paper to stop, since if a Ribono shel Olam makes miracles she could not drive to the beach on Shabbos. That, the Rav concludes, is the Jewish apikores: he believes.

Sources

Torah

  1. a Shemos 22:1 text index In the write-up: 0:22
  2. e Devarim 14:1 text index In the write-up: 4:51
  3. f Bereishis 2:22 text index In the write-up: 6:50
  4. j apparently Bamidbar 1:2 index In the write-up: 15:53
  5. k Devarim 6:7 text index In the write-up: 18:37
  6. m apparently Bereishis 15:6 index In the write-up: 22:21
  7. p Bereishis 26:35 text index In the write-up: 28:24
  8. q Bereishis 27:46 text index In the write-up: 28:24
  9. r Bereishis 28:6-9 text index In the write-up: 28:24

Talmud Bavli

  1. c apparently Sanhedrin 72b index In the write-up: 2:11
  2. g Niddah 45b text index In the write-up: 6:50
  3. h Berachos 40a text index In the write-up: 9:46
  4. l Kiddushin 30a text index In the write-up: 18:37
  5. o apparently Sanhedrin 100b index In the write-up: 23:54

Rishonim

  1. b apparently Rashi on Shemos 22:2 index In the write-up: 2:11
  2. n Rashi (place not identified) index In the write-up: 18:37

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. d Chasam Sofer (place not identified) 2:34 index
  2. i Avnei Nezer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 12:09

Key points

  1. 0:22 A gentile can understand emunah with logic, but a Jew feels it instinctively in his heart.
  2. 6:50 Chochmah is fixed knowledge all must accept, while binah is the heart's understanding, which differs from person to person according to his nature.
  3. 17:00 A child's Jewishness follows the mother because emunah is a feeling, and feeling comes from the mother.
  4. 26:54 A person's pride drives him to justify himself and blame anything but himself, which psychology calls rationalization and denial.
  5. 34:12 A Jewish apikores truly believes; he denies only because he wants to follow his desires.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 2:59 Why may a son not kill his father who breaks in, even if the father does not know it is his son's home?

    Answer: 3:48 Because a father's heart knows; there is an instinctive feeling binding a father to his son even without knowledge.

  2. Question: 16:18 Why does a child's Jewishness follow the mother, when tribe and inheritance follow the father?

    Answer: 17:00 Because emunah is a feeling, and feeling comes from the mother.

  3. Question: 12:09 How may a woman remarry on the word of a single witness?

    Answer: 12:45 The Avnei Nezer explains that she feels whether her husband is alive, so if she believes the witness that is a sign.

  4. Question: 34:09 Why would a Jew descended from Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov say he does not believe?

    Answer: 34:21 Because he wants to follow his desires where the Torah forbids them, so he declares the Torah untrue.

Stories

  1. 13:16 The Lechovitcher no longer feels his Rebbe

    Reb Mordechai of Lechovitch was a talmid of Reb Shlomo of Karlin. When Reb Shlomo passed away, people were afraid to tell the Lechovitcher. He began crying out that he did not feel the Rebbe, until they had to tell him the Rebbe had died. Then he calmed down, saying he now understood why he no longer felt him.

    In the story: Reb Mordechai of Lechovitch, Reb Shlomo of Karlin

  2. 24:54 The fox and the grapes

    In Ben Sira's fables, which the gentiles later took over as Aesop's fables, a fox came to a vineyard and saw beautiful grapes, but there was a high fence. For three days and three nights he struggled to climb over it. In the end he said the grapes were sour.

    In the story: Ben Sira, Aesop

  3. 28:12 The melamed who wanted psychology books

    A successful melamed came asking to learn books of psychology so he would understand a child's way of thinking and become a better melamed. He was answered: why not learn Chumash and Rashi? Everything can be learned from the Torah.

  4. 34:42 The atheist and the banana peel

    A man climbing a staircase slipped on a banana peel at the top and tumbled down the stairs, crying out 'Oh G-d!'. He was asked why he was calling out to G-d.

  5. 36:19 The Six Day War and the woman's letter

    Before the Six Day War the Jews in Eretz Yisroel faced terrible danger: a small army surrounded by huge Arab forces that vowed to push them into the sea, and newspapers wrote it was the end of Israel. In six days the Jews won wondrously, and for months even secular papers reported miracles, such as a bomb setting a house on fire and a second bomb bursting the water tank on the roof, which put out the fire. A woman wrote to a newspaper asking it to stop writing about the miracles: Shabbos was her day to drive to the beach, and if there is a Ribono shel Olam who makes miracles she could not keep doing so.

Insights

  1. 8:25 The Rav reads the Gemara's 'aliba d'Abaye', 'according to Abaye', literally as 'according to Abaye's heart': a sage holds his view because his heart, from the root of his soul, tells him so.
  2. 22:30 From the grammar rule that a verb ending in nun drops it as a noun, the Rav derives that from aman, to believe, comes em, mother: emunah comes from the mother.
  3. 5:49 The seder's three matzos, from grain that brings intellect, stand for the Avos, and its four cups of wine, which bring out feeling, stand for the Imahos, like the three-headed and four-headed shin on the two sides of the tefillin.
  4. 3:14 A father who breaks in to his son's house without knowing it is his son's still would not harm him, because his heart knows; so too a Jew's bond to Hashem works beneath conscious knowledge.
  5. 31:10 Eisav concluded that he lost the berachos because of his wives, never imagining the fault was his own, the same rationalization as the fox and the grapes.
  6. 12:29 According to the Avnei Nezer as the Rav brings it, a woman may rely on a single witness about her husband's death because she feels whether he is alive; her believing the witness is itself the sign.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 10:20 The Rav says that at the seder one should speak about the Exodus with feeling and enthusiasm.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Abaye, Aesop, Avraham Avinu, Ben Sira, Esav, Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin, Rashi, Rivka Imeinu, the Avnei Nezer of Sochatchov, the Chasam Sofer, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu

Terms אמונה, אפיקורס, גאוה, הרגש, חב"ד, רבונו של עולם, תאוה

Report an error on this page