bachurim mishpatim

Catalog entry: Y 05 Current משפטים no. ⁨11⁩ תשע"ג (2012–13) Yiddish 36 min

Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.

Listen

  1. Download · Length 36 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Opening the Tanya for bachurim, the Rav explains why the sefer begins with the word 'Tanya', what the oath 'be a tzaddik and not a rasha' means and why it gives strength, and how the Raya Mehemna reads the four types of people in the Gemara.

The Rav begins the Tanya with the Gemara in Niddah that a soul is sworn before birth to be a tzaddik and not a rasha. He brings the Chabad tradition that the opening word 'Tanya' breaks a kelipah of that name, and that the introduction addresses every Jew in every generation. Citing the Satmar Rebbe, he calls Tanya the sefer for one who wants to want to be good, and reads its letters as the future-tense prefixes. He describes the sefer's order: questions, knowledge, then avodah. He derives shevuah from sheva, the seven forces of creation, so the oath strengthens a person against the yetzer hara, as with Eliezer, and reads 'mashbi'in' as 'mashpi'in'. He then raises the Tanya's question about seeing oneself as a rasha, brings the Gemara's four types with the Raya Mehemna's reading, and ends with beinonim, Rabbah and Iyov.

Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Sefer HaTanya

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Why the sefer opens with 'Tanya'

    The Rav notes that the beraisa in Niddah the Ba'al HaTanya quotes does not begin with 'Tanya', and brings the Chabad tradition that he added the word to break a kelipah of that name. He adds that what he will say comes from sefarim or from what he heard from his rebbe, Reb Feivel Mendlowitz.

  2. 3:28 A sefer for one who wants to become better

    The Rav explains that the introduction addresses every Jew in every generation who learns the sefer, brings the Satmar Rebbe's answer that one who wants to want should learn Tanya, and says the sefer answers every question in avodas Hashem. He then reads the four letters of 'Tanya' as the prefixes of the future tense.

  3. 8:22 The oath and the order of the Tanya

    The Rav explains the oath the soul takes, to be a tzaddik and not a rasha and to be like a rasha in its own eyes, and describes the Tanya's system: questions, then knowledge, then avodah. He says he will learn the first chapter with its questions closely and may summarize some later chapters.

  4. 13:10 Shevuah, sheva and shefa

    The Rav brings the Ramban that shevuah comes from sheva: an oath binds a person with all seven forces of creation, which is why one may swear to strengthen himself against the yetzer hara, as Avraham made Eliezer swear. He then reads 'mashbi'in' as 'mashpi'in', since pei and beis interchange and a pei in ksav ashuri holds a hidden beis.

  5. 20:27 How can one consider himself a rasha?

    The Rav raises the Tanya's question: one who sees himself as a rasha will become sad and cannot serve Hashem with simcha, yet one who is always joyful may come to lightheadedness. He explains that 'like a rasha' means not being sure of oneself, and introduces the Gemara in Berachos on four kinds of people.

  6. 24:01 The Raya Mehemna on the four types

    The Rav gives the simple meaning of tzaddik and rasha who fare well or badly, and then the Raya Mehemna in parshas Mishpatim: every person has a yetzer tov and a yetzer hara, and 'tzaddik vera lo' is a tzaddik who masters his evil, while 'rasha vetov lo' has a yetzer tov he does not obey.

  7. 28:24 Beinonim, Rabbah and Iyov

    The Rav brings the Gemara at the end of Berachos that tzaddikim are judged by the yetzer tov, reshaim by the yetzer hara and beinonim by both, Rabbah's saying that he is a beinoni and Abaye's reply. He then sets out the Tanya's questions: how Iyov could say Hashem created tzaddikim and reshaim when that is not decreed at birth, and how Rabbah, who never stopped learning, could err in calling himself a beinoni.

The shiur, written up

Why the sefer opens with 'Tanya'

0:22

The Rav notes that the beraisa in Niddah that the Ba'al HaTanya quotes, that a soul is sworn to be a tzaddik and not a rasha, does not begin with the word 'Tanya'; he added it. According to the Chabad tradition, there is a kelipah called 'Tanya' that keeps a person from being an ehrlicher Yid, and he opened with that word to break it. a,b

A sefer for one who wants to become better

4:32

In his introduction the Ba'al HaTanya writes that he cannot answer everyone's questions personally, so this sefer answers every question in avodas Hashem. Someone once asked the Satmar Rebbe how one can want to want to be good; he answered: learn Tanya. c

6:37

The Rav suggests that the four letters of 'Tanya' are the prefixes of the future tense. The past is past; the sefer speaks to one who wants to become.

The oath and the order of the Tanya

8:36

The soul coming down is sworn to be a tzaddik and not a rasha, and even if the whole world calls it a tzaddik, to be like a rasha in its own eyes. The Tanya opens with questions that are answered by about chapter eight. a

10:21

Unlike most chassidish sefarim on the parsha, the Tanya has a system: first questions, then chapters of knowledge, then avodah, which can be understood only with that knowledge.

Shevuah, sheva and shefa

13:23

Why an oath? The Rav brings the Ramban in parshas Matos that shevuah comes from sheva. Hashem created the world in seven days, and all the forces of creation lie in them, so an oath binds a person with the strength of all creation. d

14:47

This is why, as the Gemara says, one who fears the yetzer hara will overpower him may swear to do a mitzvah. So Avraham made Eliezer swear before the shidduch with Rivkah: Eliezer had hoped to become related to Avraham, and the oath strengthened him where his yetzer tov alone might not suffice. e,f

17:24

Pei and beis interchange, so 'mashbi'in' is 'mashpi'in': the oath is a flow of holiness from above, given so the soul can fulfill it. In ksav ashuri, he adds, a white beis is visible inside the pei.

How can one consider himself a rasha?

21:17

The Rav raises the Tanya's question: one who sees himself as a rasha will be sad and unable to serve Hashem with simcha, yet constant joy can lead to lightheadedness. He explains that 'like a rasha' means not being sure of oneself. He then introduces the Gemara in Berachos on four kinds of people. g,h,i

The Raya Mehemna on the four types

24:09

Simply, 'tzaddik vera lo' is a tzaddik who suffers poverty or illness, and 'rasha vetov lo' a rasha with wealth and health. i

25:24

The Raya Mehemna in parshas Mishpatim reads it differently. Every person has a yetzer tov and a yetzer hara; 'tzaddik vera lo' is a tzaddik whose evil is subordinate to him, and 'rasha vetov lo' has a yetzer tov he does not obey. j

Beinonim, Rabbah and Iyov

28:30

The Gemara at the end of Berachos says the yetzer tov judges tzaddikim, the yetzer hara reshaim, and both judge beinonim. Rabbah said he was a beinoni, and Abaye answered that he leaves no one room to live. k

31:15

The Tanya asks: how could Iyov say Hashem created tzaddikim and reshaim, when another Gemara says that before birth it is decreed whether one will be wise or rich, but not whether a tzaddik or a rasha, since that is his choice? l,m

33:34

And if a beinoni has half merits and half sins, how could Rabbah err about himself? The Gemara relates that even the malach hamaves could not overcome him because he never stopped learning. The shiur ends with these questions open. n

Sources

Torah

  1. f apparently Bereishis 24 index In the write-up: 14:47

Kesuvim

  1. h Tehillim 100:2 text index In the write-up: 21:17

Talmud Bavli

  1. a Niddah 30b text index In the write-up: 0:22, 8:36
  2. e apparently Nedarim 8a index In the write-up: 14:47
  3. i Berachos 7a text index In the write-up: 21:17, 24:09
  4. k Berachos 61b text index In the write-up: 28:30
  5. l apparently Bava Basra 16a index In the write-up: 31:15
  6. m apparently Niddah 16b index In the write-up: 31:15
  7. n apparently Bava Metzia 86a index In the write-up: 33:34

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. j apparently Zohar, Raya Mehemna, parshas Mishpatim index In the write-up: 25:24

Rishonim

  1. d apparently Ramban, parshas Matos (Bamidbar 30) index In the write-up: 13:23

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. b apparently Tanya ch. 1 index In the write-up: 0:22
  2. c apparently Tanya, Hakdamas HaMechaber index In the write-up: 4:32
  3. g apparently Tanya ch. 1 index In the write-up: 21:17

Key points

  1. 8:36 Before a soul comes down it is sworn to be a tzaddik and not a rasha, and even if the whole world calls it a tzaddik it should be in its own eyes like a rasha.
  2. 4:07 The Tanya is a sefer in avodas Hashem for someone who wants to become better, and the Rav says it answers every question one can ask in avodas Hashem.
  3. 10:49 The Tanya is built in order: questions in the first chapter, then about ten or fifteen chapters of knowledge, and only then guidance in avodah, which can be understood only with that knowledge.
  4. 13:57 An oath carries the power of all seven forces of creation and so strengthens a person against the yetzer hara.
  5. 26:24 According to the Raya Mehemna, a 'tzaddik who has bad' is a tzaddik whose evil is subordinate to him, and a 'rasha who has good' is one who has a yetzer tov but does not obey it.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 0:29 Why does the Ba'al HaTanya open with the word 'Tanya' when the beraisa he quotes does not say it?

    Answer: 1:10 According to the Chabad tradition, there is a kelipah called 'Tanya' that prevents a person from being an ehrlicher Yid, and he began with that word to break it with this sefer.

  2. Question: 13:23 Why is the soul's charge given as an oath, and what does a shevuah add?

    Answer: 13:57 A shevuah comes from sheva and carries the strength of all seven forces of creation, so it gives a person power against the yetzer hara.

  3. Question: 21:01 How can the soul be sworn to see itself as a rasha, when that leads to sadness and Hashem must be served with simcha?

    Answer: 21:30 He is not told to think he is a rasha, only to be like a rasha, meaning not to be sure of himself.

Stories

  1. 4:19 How can one want to want?

    The Rav recalls that someone asked the Satmar Rebbe how a person can come to want to want to be good. The Satmar Rebbe answered that for wanting one should learn the sefer Tanya, and by learning it one will want to be an ehrlicher Yid.

    In the story: the Satmar Rebbe

  2. 15:27 Avraham makes Eliezer swear

    Avraham sent Eliezer to make the shidduch with Rivkah. Eliezer had hoped to become related to Avraham through the match, and Avraham had refused him. Since the yetzer hara might creep in and Eliezer might not carry out the mission properly, Avraham made him swear, and the oath gave him the strength his yetzer tov alone might have lacked.

    In the story: Avraham Avinu, Eliezer, Rivkah

Insights

  1. 6:37 The Rav suggests that the four letters of 'Tanya' are the four prefixes of the Hebrew future tense, so the very name of the sefer speaks of wanting to become: what was until now is past, and from now on one wants to be good.
  2. 13:34 Shevuah comes from sheva: since all the forces of creation lie in the seven days, an oath binds a person with the strength of all of creation, and that is why it helps against the yetzer hara.
  3. 17:24 'Mashbi'in oso' can be read as 'mashpi'in': pei and beis interchange, and in ksav ashuri a pei holds a white beis inside it, so the oath is a flow of holiness sent down from heaven to enable the soul to fulfill it.
  4. 21:30 Being 'like a rasha' in one's own eyes does not mean thinking oneself a rasha; it means not being sure of oneself.
  5. 26:15 According to the Raya Mehemna, the 'bad' and 'good' in the Gemara's four types are not what happens to a person but the yetzer within him and who is master over whom.
  6. 10:21 Unlike most chassidish sefarim, which teach on the parsha without a set progression, the Tanya proceeds systematically from easy matters to higher ones, laying down knowledge before giving guidance in avodah.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 4:32 Citing the Satmar Rebbe, the Rav says that one who wants to want to be good should learn the sefer Tanya.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Abaye, Avraham Avinu, Eliezer, servant of Avraham, Iyov, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbah (bar Nachmani), Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, Rivka Imeinu, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Ramban, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum)

Terms בינוני, השפעה, יצר הרע, יצר טוב, עצבות, קלות ראש, קליפה, רעיא מהימנא, שבועה

Report an error on this page