Vayichi

Catalog entry: Y 05 Current ויחי no. ⁨12⁩ תשס"ט (2008–09) Yiddish 39 min

Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.

Listen

  1. Download · Length 39 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that Jewish emunah rests on the national revelation at Sinai and its unbroken tradition, and that our generation, the 'heel' of the body of Klal Yisroel, has emunah without feeling, yet its small avodah is especially precious to Hashem.

The Rav opens with the Rambam and the Kuzari: Jewish faith rests on the whole people standing at Sinai, something no other religion claims, and so the Torah will never be exchanged. Emunah, he says, is not grasped with the intellect, just as a picture is not heard and music is not seen. He then reads the Yismach Moshe's answer to a man troubled by doubts: a tradition received from six hundred thousand eyewitnesses cannot be a lie, since no parent could tell his child about an event nobody saw. Next comes the Bnei Yissaschar's question how the Rambam could write the Moreh Nevuchim if philosophical inquiry is forbidden, answered with the story of the Yismach Moshe and the Rambam's yiras shamayim. Finally the Rav describes every generation, and all of history, as one body of Adam haRishon; ours is the heel, without feeling, yet our small avodah is precious, like the parrot in the Ba'al Shem Tov's parable.

Topics: Foundations of Emunah · Avodah of the Last Generation · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek · Matan Torah at Har Sinai

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Emunah built on Sinai, not on the intellect

    Recalling the Rambam and the Kuzari, the Rav explains that Jewish faith rests on a revelation the whole nation witnessed, unlike other religions, and cites the Rambam's principle that the Torah will never be exchanged. He lists ways to emunah and argues, with the parable of a picture and a symphony, that Hashem is not grasped by the intellect.

  2. 5:09 The Yismach Moshe's answer to doubts

    The Rav reads the Yismach Moshe's reply to a man plagued by doubts in emunah: the proof is not philosophy but the tradition received from six hundred thousand who saw, which no one could have invented and handed to his children. He adds that even other nations accept the miracles of Egypt, and lists the public miracles of the desert and of Eretz Yisroel.

  3. 13:03 The Bnei Yissaschar's question on the Moreh Nevuchim

    The Rav brings the Bnei Yissaschar's question: philosophical inquiry weighs both sides, so for a moment one entertains denial; how then could the Rambam write the Moreh Nevuchim? He answers that the Rambam was holy, and tells how the Yismach Moshe asked in Heaven for the Rambam's yiras shamayim and could not bear it.

  4. 16:54 The Rambam's katnus and answer before question

    The Rav relates the Ba'al Shem Tov's comment that what the Yismach Moshe received was only the Rambam's mochin dekatnus, explains gadlus and katnus in tefillah, and concludes that the Rambam felt Hashem even while writing questions, writing for those who had strayed. From the order of Ein Kelokeinu he shows that a Jew must begin with the answer of emunah before asking.

  5. 20:40 Each generation as the body of Adam haRishon

    Bringing the Tanya and a Midrash, the Rav explains that all souls hung from Adam haRishon, from head to toenails, so that each generation is a complete Adam haRishon: the head are the great Torah scholars, the heart the masters of tefillah, the hands the givers of tzedakah. Each person has the choice to use his gift for Hashem or for worldly things, illustrated with Reb Elchonon Wasserman and a wealthy man who gave to colleges.

  6. 27:33 Our generation is the heel without feeling

    The Rav extends the image to all generations: the generation of the desert with Moshe Rabbeinu is the head, the generation of David and Shlomo the throat, and the last generation, ikvesa demeshicha, the heel. The heel has no feeling and stays dark even in the summer sun; so emunah today is present but unfelt, like a tooth pulled after a dentist's injection, unlike the Elul and tefillah of earlier generations.

  7. 35:17 The precious avodah of a low generation

    The Rav contrasts Reb Avraham of Ciechanow's joy at putting on tefillin with our small satisfaction, yet says our avodah is more precious in Heaven than that of earlier generations: holding back from interrupting learning or from idle talk is mesiras nefesh for us. He closes with the Ba'al Shem Tov's parable of the king who delights more in a talking parrot than in his wise ministers.

The shiur, written up

Emunah built on Sinai, not on the intellect

0:03

Recalling the Rambam and the Kuzari, the Rav explains that Jews believe because the whole nation stood at Sinai and every Jew heard Hashem speak. No other religion claims this; theirs began with individuals whom a people believed, and they are built on the Torah. On this rests the Rambam's principle that the Torah will never be exchanged. a,b

2:58

Emunah can come from being a child of the Avos or from looking at the world, but the Rav says Hashem is not grasped by the intellect: a picture is not heard and music is not seen. Another faculty is needed, close to nevuah and ruach hakodesh.

The Yismach Moshe's answer to doubts

5:22

The Rav reads the Yismach Moshe's reply to a man who believed yet was troubled by doubts and asked for a clear proof. The Yismach Moshe answers that the proof comes not through philosophy but through the way of the Torah, whose ways are pleasant, namely the tradition received from those who saw with their own eyes. c,d

7:57

Such a tradition cannot be a lie: if a vast crowd agreed to tell their children of a Sinai nobody saw, the children would ask each other and discover the lie at once. The Rav notes that the Yismach Moshe uses the Torah's figure of six hundred thousand men, though with women and children there were millions. e

10:05

Even Christians and Muslims accept the miracles of Egypt. The Rav lists the Red Sea, the pillar of fire, the well and the man, and brings the passuk in Devarim asking whether any nation ever heard G-d speaking from the fire. Later came the splitting of the Yarden, the sun standing still, the walls of Yericho and Korach swallowed, all seen by everyone. f

The Bnei Yissaschar's question on the Moreh Nevuchim

13:28

The Bnei Yissaschar asks: one may not engage in chakirah, for a philosopher weighs the arguments on both sides, and while he considers that perhaps there is no Creator he is a heretic. How then could the Rambam write the Moreh Nevuchim? g,h

15:43

He answers that the Rambam was holy, and the Rav tells how the Yismach Moshe asked in Heaven for the Rambam's yiras shamayim, was seized with trembling, and begged that it be taken away.

The Rambam's katnus and answer before question

16:54

The Ba'al Shem Tov said this was only the Rambam's mochin dekatnus. Everyone, the Rav explains, has times of gadlus, when tefillah burns, and of katnus; if even the Rambam's katnus was too much, his gadlus was beyond bearing. He felt Hashem so tangibly that denial never occurred to him while writing questions, and he wrote for philosophers of his time who had strayed.

19:49

Thus Ein Kelokeinu first declares 'there is none like our G-d' and only then asks 'who is like our G-d': a Jew begins with emunah and may then ask.

Each generation as the body of Adam haRishon

20:58

The Rav brings the Tanya that Klal Yisroel in every generation has a full body's limbs, and a Midrash that all souls hung from Adam haRishon, from his head down to his heel and toenails. So each generation is a whole Adam haRishon: the head are the great Torah scholars, the heart the masters of tefillah, the hands the givers of tzedakah. j,k,l

24:02

Each has a choice: a head can grow great in Torah or in science, a heart can compose a song like Yedid Nefesh or empty tunes, a hand can give to Torah institutions or to colleges. Reb Elchonon Wasserman, collecting in America, was offered chai by a wealthy man who gave to colleges, and he contrasted that chai with the college gifts. m

Our generation is the heel

27:56

All history from the start to Moshiach is also one body: the generation that received the Torah, with Moshe Rabbeinu, is the head; that of David and Shlomo, who built the Beis Hamikdash, the throat; the last generation, ikvesa demeshicha, the heel. That, the Rav says, is why emunah and Yiddishkeit are so weak today: a needle prick hurts in the fingers but is hardly felt on the heel.

30:08

Earlier generations felt tefillah; the Rav recalls a tradition that Ahavah Rabbah once took four hours. In the summer sun at noon everything is lit except the heel on the ground, and in the same way Elul once made Jews tremble, while our Ne'ilah lacks that sense of Hashem's closeness.

34:24

Pulling a tooth is among the worst pains, yet after the dentist's needle it is not felt. So it is with our Yiddishkeit: the emunah is there, but it is not felt.

The precious avodah of a low generation

35:35

Reb Avraham of Ciechanow felt more joy reaching for his tefillin than one who won ten thousand rubles; we feel only some satisfaction. Yet the Rav says our avodah is more precious in Heaven, because we are so small: holding back from interrupting learning or from idle talk at lunch is mesiras nefesh for us.

37:34

He closes with the Ba'al Shem Tov's parable of a king who delights more in a parrot saying 'good-bye' than in his wise men's counsel, since a parrot speaking is a wonder. So too our mitzvos are a wonder to Hashem.

Sources

Torah

  1. e Shemos 12:37 text index In the write-up: 7:57
  2. f Devarim 4:32-33 text index In the write-up: 10:05
  3. l apparently Devarim 15:8 index In the write-up: 20:58

Kesuvim

  1. d Mishlei 3:17 text index In the write-up: 5:22
  2. n Tehillim 16:8 33:33 text index

Midrash

  1. k Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 20:58

Rishonim

  1. a Kuzari (place not identified) index In the write-up: 0:03
  2. h Moreh Nevuchim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 13:28

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. c Yismach Moshe (place not identified) index In the write-up: 5:22
  2. g Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 13:28
  3. i Mesilas Yesharim (place not identified) 18:55 index
  4. j Tanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 20:58

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. b apparently Ninth principle index In the write-up: 0:03
  2. m Yedid Nefesh (place not identified) index In the write-up: 24:02

Key points

  1. 0:28 Jewish emunah rests on the revelation at Sinai witnessed by the entire nation, which no other religion claims and which cannot be denied.
  2. 3:31 Hashem cannot be grasped with the intellect; another faculty is needed, just as the eye cannot hear music and the ear cannot see a picture.
  3. 7:25 Following the Yismach Moshe, a tradition from six hundred thousand eyewitnesses passed from parent to child cannot be a fabrication.
  4. 21:10 Every generation, and all of Jewish history together, forms one body of Adam haRishon, and each person has the choice to serve Hashem in the way of his place in it.
  5. 28:43 Ours is the generation of the heel, whose emunah is present but not felt, and therefore its small acts of avodah are especially precious to Hashem.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 5:22 How can a person troubled by doubts know that the Torah is true?

    Answer: 7:01 Not through philosophy, but through the tradition of six hundred thousand eyewitnesses, which could never have been invented and handed down.

  2. Question: 14:49 If philosophical inquiry means entertaining denial for a moment, how could the Rambam write the Moreh Nevuchim?

    Answer: 15:43 The Rambam was holy and felt Hashem even while asking, and he wrote for the philosophers of his time who had strayed.

  3. Question: 19:49 Why does Ein Kelokeinu say 'there is none like our G-d' before asking 'who is like our G-d'?

    Answer: 20:04 A Jew must begin with the answer of emunah; only afterwards may he ask questions.

  4. Question: 28:53 Why are emunah and Yiddishkeit so weak today?

    Answer: 28:58 Because our generation is the heel of the body, which has no feeling.

Stories

  1. 16:02 The Yismach Moshe and the Rambam's yiras shamayim

    The Yismach Moshe asked in Heaven to be granted the yiras shamayim of the Tannaim and was told it was too much for him; the same answer came when he asked for that of the Amoraim. He then asked for the Rambam's yiras shamayim, and this was granted. He was suddenly seized by such awe that he began to tremble and fall, and he begged that it be taken from him, and it was. The Ba'al Shem Tov later said that what he had received was only the Rambam's mochin dekatnus.

    In the story: Yismach Moshe, Rambam, the Ba'al Shem Tov

  2. 26:17 Reb Elchonon Wasserman and the wealthy man

    Reb Elchonon Wasserman came to America to collect money for his yeshiva. There was a very wealthy man who did not give to yeshivos but gave to colleges, and Reb Elchonon asked him for money. The man offered chai, eighteen dollars, which the Rav notes was a large sum in those days. Reb Elchonon answered him by contrasting the chai offered to the yeshiva with what the man gave to the college.

    In the story: Rabbi Elchonon Wasserman

  3. 35:35 Reb Avraham of Ciechanow and his tefillin

    Reb Avraham of Ciechanow told a friend that every morning, when he stretched out his hand to put on tefillin, he felt greater joy than someone who had won a lottery of ten thousand rubles.

    In the story: Rabbi Avraham of Ciechanow

  4. 37:34 The Ba'al Shem Tov's parable of the parrot

    The great ministers and wise men of a kingdom stand before the king and offer him wisdom and counsel. Someone brings the king a gift, a parrot, a bird that talks without knowing what it says. The king stands by its cage and delights when it says 'good-bye', more than at all the words of his wise men, because wisdom from a wise man is no wonder, but a parrot speaking is a wonder.

    In the story: the Ba'al Shem Tov

Insights

  1. 4:00 The Rav argues that seeking Hashem with the intellect is a category error, like claiming to listen to a painting or to see a symphony; Hashem is perceived through a different faculty, akin to nevuah and ruach hakodesh, which Klal Yisroel as a whole still has.
  2. 7:59 The proof from Sinai, as the Rav reads the Yismach Moshe, lies in transmission: a fabricated event would be exposed at once, since children would find that neither they nor their friends had seen it.
  3. 18:10 The Rambam could engage in inquiry without danger because he felt Hashem so tangibly that denial never occurred to him even while posing the questions; even his yiras shamayim in a state of katnus was too much for the Yismach Moshe.
  4. 19:49 In Ein Kelokeinu the declaration 'there is none like our G-d' comes before the question 'who is like our G-d', teaching that a Jew begins with the answer of emunah and only then may ask.
  5. 22:43 The Rav applies the image of Adam haRishon's body twice: within each generation, where the head, heart and hands are the Torah scholars, the masters of tefillah and the givers of tzedakah; and across all history, where the desert generation is the head and ours the heel.
  6. 28:53 The heel's lack of sensation explains why emunah feels weak today: like a tooth pulled after a numbing injection, the emunah is present but not felt.
  7. 36:17 Because the people of the last generation are so small, their avodah is more precious to Hashem, just as a king delights more in a parrot's few words than in the wisdom of his ministers.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 20:04 The Rav says a Jew must begin with emunah, as in Ein Kelokeinu, and only then may he ask questions.
  2. 19:18 The Rav says that one who guards his eyes, his thoughts and himself from impurity keeps a pure emunah.
  3. 31:57 The Rav says that in our dark generation one must hold on strongly to emunah.
  4. 36:41 The Rav says that holding back from interrupting one's learning or from idle talk at a meal is, for us, mesiras nefesh that is precious to Hashem.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Adam HaRishon, Dovid HaMelech, Korach, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Avraham of Ciechanow, Rabbi Elazar Azikri (the Chareidim), Rabbi Elchonon Wasserman, Shlomo HaMelech, the Baal Shem Tov, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Rambam, the Yismach Moshe

Terms אדם הראשון, אמונה, בחירה, הרגש, חקירה, יראת שמים, מוחין, מסירות נפש, מעמד הר סיני, ספק, עקבתא דמשיחא, רבונו של עולם

Report an error on this page