Vayeshev
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current וישב no. 9 תשס"ט (2008–09) Yiddish 43 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Jewish emunah rests on the revelation at Har Sinai, witnessed by an entire nation and handed down unchanged, and that the nations' denial of it and their hatred of the Jews come from jealousy of the chosen people, as with Yosef's brothers.
The Rav opens with the mesirus nefesh of whole Jewish communities, which goes beyond the trained loyalty of a gentile soldier: Jews carry emunah in the heart. Unlike other faiths, each founded by one individual, Jews believe what an entire nation saw at Har Sinai. Through Rashi's question why the Torah did not begin with 'Hachodesh hazeh lachem', he shows that millions witnessed the revelation, comparing it to undeniable history such as George Washington or Julius Caesar. Every Jew became a prophet, the Sefer Torah was written before eyewitnesses, and every copy is identical. Following the Rambam, belief in Moshe rests on Sinai, so the first mitzvah he taught begins the Torah; and the Torah is eternal, so a prophet who changes it is false. Small differences arose in galus and between the tribes' middos, yet the foundations are shared. The nations deny this from jealousy of the chosen people, as Yosef's brothers did.
Topics: Foundations of Emunah · Matan Torah at Har Sinai · Torah Min HaShamayim and the Mesorah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Jewish mesirus nefesh for emunah
The Rav contrasts a gentile soldier, trained from childhood to die for his country, with Jews who gave their lives rather than convert, even whole communities during the Crusades. He explains that Jews have emunah in the heart, an inheritance from the Avos.
-
6:17 Faiths founded by one man
The Rav explains that every other faith was started by one individual: the founder of Christianity, who made religion easy by permitting forbidden things, and Muhammad, who claimed G-d had changed the Torah. Jews, he says, do not believe one man but what a whole nation received.
-
10:19 Rashi's question and a nation at Sinai listed in the guide
The Rav brings Rashi's question why the Torah did not begin with 'Hachodesh hazeh lachem', and starts building the answer: millions stood at Har Sinai, heard Hashem and became prophets. A whole people cannot pass on a lie to its children, just as no one can deny George Washington, Julius Caesar or Alexander the Great.
-
15:47 The Sefer Torah written before witnesses listed in the guide
The Rav explains that every Jew at Sinai was a prophet, and at the end of forty years Moshe wrote the Sefer Torah before people who had seen everything in it; every Jew wrote his own, so all are identical to this day. He brings 'panim b'fanim' and 'ki sh'al na', and notes that Christians and Muslims admit Matan Torah but claim Hashem changed His mind.
-
20:39 Why we believe Moshe Rabbeinu listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah: Jews believe Moshe because at Sinai they heard Hashem appoint him to teach them the rest of the Torah, after they asked that Moshe speak to them. Therefore, he concludes, the Torah should have begun with 'Hachodesh', the first mitzvah Moshe taught, which answers Rashi's question.
-
24:34 The Torah is eternal listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Rambam that the Torah stands forever, with the pesukim against adding or subtracting, 'the revealed things are ours forever' and 'it is not in heaven'. A prophet cannot change a halachah, so one who says a mitzvah was only for a time, like moving Shabbos to Sunday or Friday, is a false prophet.
-
28:50 One Torah, small differences
The Rav explains that the same Torah passed down through the generations; in galus some details were forgotten and disputes arose, but the foundations are shared by all Jews. Disputes are 'eilu v'eilu': middas chesed and middas din both come from Hashem, each tribe had its own judges, as with Beis Hillel and Beis Shammai, and the tefillin of Rashi and Rabbeinu Tam.
-
34:40 Why the nations deny and hate listed in the guide
The Rav asks why the nations, who admit Matan Torah, claim it was changed, and why they hate Jews even today when neither they nor many Jews keep their religion. He answers that they cannot bear that the Jews are the chosen people, and brings this week's sedra: Yosef's brothers saw their father loved him more and hated him from jealousy.
-
38:13 Announcements and mazel tov (Brachah)
The shiur, written up
Jewish mesirus nefesh for emunah
The Rav returns to a foundation of Yiddishkeit: a Jew's emunah, an inheritance from the Avos. Gentiles also die for their beliefs, he notes, but a gentile soldier dies for his country because from childhood he was taught daily in school to pledge allegiance to his motherland.
Jews were different. Even Jews who were lax in many aveiros gave their lives rather than convert, and not only individuals but whole communities and cities, as in the time of the Crusades. This, the Rav explains, is because Jews have emunah in the heart, not only what was taught and drilled into them.
Faiths founded by one man
Every other faith, the Rav explains, was begun by one individual. The founder of Christianity, of whom the Gemara speaks, knew sorcery and made religion easy by permitting treif food and other aveiros. Muhammad likewise said one should believe in the G-d of the Jews, but that He had changed the Torah. Jews, by contrast, do not believe one man; they believe what an entire nation received. c
Rashi's question and a nation at Sinai
The Rav brings Rashi's question at the beginning of Bereishis: the Torah should have begun with 'Hachodesh hazeh lachem', the first mitzvah given to the Jews. What does that mean, he asks, when milah and gid hanasheh appear earlier? a,b
To build the answer he describes Har Sinai: millions, six hundred thousand men besides women and children, heard Hashem and each became a prophet, and they told their children. A whole people cannot pass on a lie, since the children would ask why they had not seen it. Just so, no one can deny George Washington, Julius Caesar or Alexander the Great, events seen by multitudes.
The Sefer Torah written before witnesses
At the end of forty years in the wilderness, the Rav continues, Moshe wrote the Sefer Torah, and every Jew is commanded to write one. Those who had stood at Sinai saw that everything in it, from yetzias Mitzrayim to the mann, was true. Since one wrong letter invalidates a Sefer Torah, every scroll today is an exact copy. f
Why we believe Moshe Rabbeinu
The Rav asks with the Rambam why Jews believe Moshe, when they heard only the Aseres HaDibros themselves. The answer: they saw with their own eyes. Hashem wanted to give the whole Torah to everyone, but the people said, 'You speak with us', and they heard Hashem appoint Moshe to teach them the rest. g,h
The Torah is eternal
The Rambam continues that it is explicit in the Torah that it stands forever: one may not add to it or take from it, the revealed things are 'ours and our children's forever', and it is not in heaven. A prophet may foretell events but cannot change a halachah. One who says a mitzvah was only temporary, like making Shabbos Sunday or Friday, denies Moshe's prophecy and is a false prophet. i,j,k,l
One Torah, small differences
The same exact Torah passed from generation to generation. In bitter galus, the Rav explains, when Jews could not learn freely, certain details were forgotten and disputes arose, yet the foundations, the taryag mitzvos and their details, are the same among all Jews.
Of a machlokes in the Gemara one says 'eilu v'eilu', both are true. Middas chesed and middas din both come from Hashem, and each tribe received the Torah by its middah, so each needed its own judges. Thus, as the Zohar says, Beis Hillel, from chesed, are usually lenient and Beis Shammai stringent. Likewise Rashi and Rabbeinu Tam each ruled like a different custom about the order of the parshiyos in tefillin, but the four parshiyos themselves are never disputed. m,n,o
Why the nations deny and hate
Why then do the nations say Hashem changed His mind? Because to keep the Torah they would have to admit that the Jews are the chosen people, which they cannot bear. Deep down they know the truth, and so they hate the Jews.
Sources
Torah
- b Shemos 12:2 text index In the write-up: 10:19, 23:16
- d Devarim 5:4 text index In the write-up: 18:41
- e Devarim 4:32-33 text index In the write-up: 18:41
- f apparently Devarim 31:19 index In the write-up: 16:13
- h apparently Shemos 20:16 index In the write-up: 20:42
- j Devarim 13:1 text index In the write-up: 25:04
- k Devarim 29:28 text index In the write-up: 25:04
- l apparently Devarim 30:12 index In the write-up: 25:04
- o apparently Devarim 16:18 index In the write-up: 30:35
- q apparently Devarim 14:2 35:46 index
- r Bereishis 37:4 text index In the write-up: 36:43
- s Bereishis 37:11 text index In the write-up: 36:43
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Key points
- 4:04 Jews, even whole cities and communities, gave their lives rather than convert, because emunah is in their heart and not only taught and drilled into them.
- 6:48 Other religions were begun by a single person, while the Jewish faith rests on what a whole nation received at Har Sinai.
- 12:17 An event seen by millions and passed on by a whole people cannot be falsified, just as no one can deny George Washington or Julius Caesar.
- 20:55 Following the Rambam, Jews believe Moshe Rabbeinu because they themselves heard at Sinai Hashem appoint him to teach them the Torah.
- 25:12 The Torah is eternal; no prophet may add to it or take from it, and one who claims Hashem changed a mitzvah is a false prophet.
- 29:48 The foundations of the Torah are the same among all Jews; only small details differ, through forgetting in galus or the tribes' different middos.
- 36:16 The nations hate the Jews out of jealousy, because deep down they know the Jews are the chosen people, as Yosef's brothers were jealous of him.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 10:24 Rashi: why does the Torah begin with Bereishis and not with 'Hachodesh hazeh lachem', the first mitzvah given to Jews?
Answer: 23:07 The Rav builds toward the answer that Hachodesh was the first mitzvah Moshe taught after Hashem appointed him at Sinai before the whole people, the basis of belief in all the mitzvos.
-
Question: 20:55 Why do Jews believe Moshe Rabbeinu, when they heard only the Aseres HaDibros themselves?
Answer: 21:38 Because, as the Rambam writes, they saw with their own eyes and heard Hashem appoint Moshe to teach them the rest of the Torah.
-
Question: 34:51 Why do the nations, who admit Matan Torah, claim that Hashem changed the Torah?
Answer: 35:09 Because accepting it would mean admitting that the Jews are the chosen people, which they cannot bear; deep down they know the truth.
-
Question: 36:28 Why do the nations hate Jews today, when they no longer believe in their own faith and many Jews do not keep the Torah?
Answer: 37:26 Out of jealousy, because they know the Jews are the chosen people, as Yosef's brothers hated him because their father loved him more.
-
Question: 29:31 If the whole Torah came down unchanged, why are there disputes among Jews?
Answer: 30:09 In galus some details were forgotten, and differing views reflect middas chesed and middas din, both true ('eilu v'eilu'); the foundations remain the same for all.
Insights
- 2:30 A gentile's readiness to die for his country is the product of daily drilling from childhood, while the Jew's readiness to die for his emunah comes from emunah in the heart, inherited from the Avos.
- 10:43 Rashi's question why the Torah did not begin with 'Hachodesh' is tied to the foundation of emunah: Hachodesh was the first mitzvah Moshe taught on the strength of the appointment the people heard at Sinai.
- 23:22 Even mitzvos with a tradition from Avraham, like milah, or from Yaakov, like gid hanasheh, are binding not because of that individual but because Moshe was commanded at Sinai to teach them.
- 16:41 The halachic rule that one wrong letter invalidates a Sefer Torah, together with the mitzvah for every Jew to write one, kept every Sefer Torah an exact copy for thousands of years.
- 31:08 Differences in halachah between tribes reflect middas chesed and middas din, both from Hashem; this is why each tribe needed its own judges, and why Beis Hillel tends to leniency and Beis Shammai to stringency.
- 35:06 The claim of other faiths that Hashem changed His mind comes not from reason but from their inability to accept that the Jews are the chosen people.
- 36:43 Today's hatred of the Jews cannot be explained by religious difference, since the nations themselves no longer keep their faith; its secret is in Vayeshev: jealousy of the beloved son.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Alexander the Great, Avraham Avinu, Beis Hillel, Beis Shammai, George Washington, Julius Caesar, Mohammed, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbeinu Tam, Rashi, Shimon HaTzaddik, the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms בית שמאי, החודש הזה לכם, מדת הדין, מדת החסד, מסירות נפש, מתן תורה, נביא שקר, עם הנבחר, רבונו של עולם, שבטים, תרי"ג מצוות