bachurim vayechi
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current ויחי no. 9 תשע"ג (2012–13) Yiddish 35 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
Through stories of tzaddikim, the Rav shows the bachurim how great people went out of their way never to trouble or pain another Jew, even at a cost to themselves or to a mitzvah.
The Rav tells the bachurim that this time he wants to speak about middos, and to do it through stories of tzaddikim. He tells how Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld asked each Yom Tov visitor whether he had been at the Kosel, so that a guest sitting with him would not feel slighted, and how he moved back to the Old City before his passing so that the Jews at his levayah would not have to walk far. He gave the Rosh Hashanah musaf to the son of the late chazzan for the widow's sake. The Chofetz Chaim skipped the na'anuim on the town's only esrog so as not to pain those who had none. Rav Moshe Kliers declared a broken eruv kosher to protect the honor of the Sefardi chacham, and Rav Chaim Ozer weighed a servant's trouble and kept a guest company in the sukkah. After taking leave of the bachurim for several weeks, the Rav ends with the Chofetz Chaim's rebuke of talmidim who laughed at a broken-hearted woman, and Rav Elchonon Wasserman's seriousness.
Topics: Bein Adam LaChaveiro · Stories of Tzaddikim · Middos Tovos · Chazal and Gedolei Yisroel
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Middos through stories; the visitors and the Kosel
The Rav says he will speak about middos through stories of tzaddikim. He tells how Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld asked each Yom Tov visitor whether he had been at the Kosel, so that the Lubliner Rav sitting with him would not feel slighted.
-
3:53 Returning to the Old City before his passing Story
Rav Yosef Chaim, sent by his doctors to the airier New City, moved back to the crowded Old City a few weeks before his passing. He explained that his burial would be on Har HaZeisim, and he did not want everyone to walk a long way from the New City.
-
7:38 The mourner who led musaf on Rosh Hashanah Story
When the baal musaf died days before Rosh Hashanah, Rav Yosef Chaim delayed the choice and then sent the deceased's son to the amud. Asked about the Shulchan Aruch's rule on a mourner leading the davening, he said the widow in the ezras nashim would otherwise suffer, and the Rav calls this the thinking of a tzaddik.
-
11:27 The Chofetz Chaim's esrog without na'anuim Story
During the First World War there was one esrog in Radin, brought for the Chofetz Chaim, and everyone made the brachah on it. At Hallel he did not shake it, explaining that the others could fulfil the mitzvah of taking it but could not do na'anuim, and he would not cause them pain.
-
14:49 The eruv in Teveria and the chacham's honor Story
In Teveria the Sefardi chacham oversaw the eruv. When it broke on Shabbos, Rav Moshe Kliers declared it kosher; after Shabbos the Gemara showed it was pasul. Asked privately, he explained that announcing it would have shamed the chacham and the honor of the Torah, which outweighs an issur derabbanan.
-
20:21 Rav Chaim Ozer: the servant and the guest in the sukkah Story
Rav Chaim Ozer hesitated to take a spacious summer apartment until the servant agreed, since its kitchen was far from the dining room. Later, ill and exempt from sukkah, he sent a poor guest to eat in the sukkah and came down to sit with him, citing Avraham Avinu's hachnasas orchim.
-
27:46 Taking leave of the bachurim
The Rav tells the bachurim that his doctors are urging him to spend several weeks in Miami for his health, so they will not meet for about four weeks. He says he will miss the davening here and asks that he return with better health.
-
31:26 Not laughing at a heavy heart Story
A simple woman told the Chofetz Chaim she could not pray at her parents' graves because they were alive; the talmidim laughed and he rebuked them sharply. The Rav adds that Rav Elchonon Wasserman, following Chazal on laughter in this world, was never seen smiling except once, and closes with a l'chaim.
The shiur, written up
Middos through stories; the visitors and the Kosel
The Rav says that this time he wants to speak to the bachurim about middos, through stories of how tzaddikim served Hashem. He begins with Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, who on Yom Tov received Jews coming from the New City. Once, with the Lubliner Rav sitting beside him, he asked every visitor whether he had already been at the Kosel. Later he explained that he did not want his guest to feel slighted, so he showed that people come for the Kosel and stop by him on the way.
Returning to the Old City
Because the Old City was crowded and airless, Rav Yosef Chaim's doctors had him move to the New City. A few weeks before his passing he insisted on returning. He explained that his end was near, and since burial is on Har HaZeisim beside the Old City, from the New City everyone would have to walk a long way. The Rav calls this the thought of a tzaddik: not to trouble Jews even when it is harder for himself, while another person thinks only of his own needs.
The mourner who led musaf
A few days before Rosh Hashanah the baal musaf died, and when asked for a replacement Rav Yosef Chaim said there was still time. At musaf he called the son of the deceased to the amud. Asked about the Shulchan Aruch's rule that a mourner should not lead the davening, he said the widow, whose husband had led musaf for decades, would sit in the ezras nashim and suffer to see a stranger in his place. The Rav stresses that the tzaddik's thought was not to cause the widow pain. a
The only esrog in Radin
During the First World War one esrog reached Radin, brought for the Chofetz Chaim, and the whole town made the brachah on it. At Hallel he did no na'anuim. He explained that everyone could fulfil the mitzvah of taking it, but no one else could shake it, and he would not cause them pain by doing what they could not.
The eruv in Teveria
In Teveria the Sefardi chacham oversaw the eruv, and the Ashkenazim had Rav Moshe Kliers. When the eruv broke, Rav Moshe Kliers was asked on Shabbos and said it was kosher. After Shabbos he learned the Gemara with the chacham, and it became clear the eruv had been pasul; the chacham was deeply distressed.
Asked privately why he had said kosher, Rav Moshe Kliers answered that the chacham is a talmid chacham and a yerei Shamayim. Had he declared the eruv pasul, everyone would know the chacham had erred, a blemish in the honor of the Torah, which outweighs carrying with a pasul eruv, an issur derabbanan.
Rav Chaim Ozer: the servant and the guest
Rav Chaim Ozer Grodzensky went away in the summer for his health, and the rebbetzin wanted a spacious, airy apartment. He hesitated, and first asked the servant whether she was satisfied. She said the kitchen was far from the dining room, but the apartment was worth it, and only then did he agree. His concern, the Rav explains, was not to burden her.
Another year, ill on Sukkos and living several floors up, Rav Chaim Ozer was exempt from the sukkah as a mitztaer. A poor Jew came, and he was sent to eat in the sukkah downstairs. In the middle of the meal Rav Chaim Ozer came down and sat with him. He explained that illness exempted him from sukkah but not from hachnasas orchim, as Avraham Avinu sat waiting for guests while in pain from his milah, and a guest should not eat alone. d
Taking leave of the bachurim
The Rav tells the bachurim that his doctors, including his cardiologist, are urging him to spend a few weeks in Miami, where it is warmer and the days are longer. They will not meet for about four weeks. He says he will miss the davening here, and asks that he return with better health to be with them again.
Not laughing at a heavy heart
A simple woman told the Chofetz Chaim that usually one who needs a yeshuah prays at his parents' graves, but her parents were alive. The talmidim laughed, and he rebuked them sharply: a woman with a heavy heart comes with her troubles, and they laugh? The Rav adds that Rav Elchonon Wasserman, following Chazal on laughter in this world, was never seen smiling except once, when a foolish man joked at a gathering of rabbonim. e
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:11 The Rav says he is speaking to the bachurim about middos this time, through stories of how tzaddikim served Hashem.
- 5:16 Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld returned to the Old City before his passing against his doctors' advice, so that Jews would not have to walk far to his burial on Har HaZeisim.
- 8:45 Rav Yosef Chaim had the son of the late baal musaf lead musaf on Rosh Hashanah, so that the widow would not suffer hearing a stranger in her husband's place.
- 12:58 The Chofetz Chaim did not shake the only esrog in town during Hallel, so as not to cause pain to everyone who could not do so.
- 17:17 Rav Moshe Kliers explained that he called a broken eruv kosher because the honor of the Torah, embodied in the Sefardi chacham, outweighed an issur derabbanan.
- 21:46 Rav Chaim Ozer considered the trouble of his household servant before taking a summer apartment, and, though exempt from sukkah, came down to keep a poor guest company because he was not exempt from hachnasas orchim.
- 32:39 The Chofetz Chaim sharply rebuked talmidim who laughed at a simple woman's words, saying one may not laugh at a person with a heavy heart.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:51 Why did Rav Yosef Chaim ask every visitor whether he had been at the Kosel?
Answer: 2:56 So that the Lubliner Rav sitting with him would see that people came for the Kosel and stopped by him only on the way, and not feel slighted.
-
Question: 5:57 Why did Rav Yosef Chaim leave the New City, against his doctors' advice, a few weeks before his passing?
Answer: 6:33 His burial would be on Har HaZeisim near the Old City, and he did not want everyone to have to walk a long way from the New City.
-
Question: 9:08 Why did Rav Yosef Chaim send a mourner to lead musaf on Rosh Hashanah, although the Shulchan Aruch says a mourner should not lead the davening?
Answer: 9:44 Because the widow would suffer seeing a stranger in her husband's place, and sparing her that pain came first.
-
Question: 13:10 Why did the Chofetz Chaim, who held the esrog, not do na'anuim at Hallel?
Answer: 13:27 Everyone could fulfil the mitzvah of taking it, but not the na'anuim in the middle of Hallel, and he would not cause the others pain.
-
Question: 18:37 Why did Rav Moshe Kliers say the broken eruv was kosher?
Answer: 18:50 To protect the honor of the Sefardi chacham, a talmid chacham, since a public error would harm the honor of the Torah, which outweighs an issur derabbanan.
-
Question: 26:18 Why did Rav Chaim Ozer, exempt from sukkah, come down to the sukkah?
Answer: 26:44 He was exempt from sukkah but not from hachnasas orchim, as Avraham Avinu waited for guests though in pain, and a guest should not eat alone.
Stories
-
1:55 Rav Yosef Chaim and the Kosel question
On Yom Tov, Jews from the New City would come to the Old City and visit Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld. Once the Lubliner Rav, a great man, was sitting with him, and Rav Yosef Chaim asked every visitor whether he had already been at the Kosel. Asked later why, he explained that the guest might feel hurt that everyone came to greet Rav Yosef Chaim, so he wanted to show that people come for the Kosel and stop by him on the way.
In the story: Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, the Lubliner Rav
-
4:39 Back to the Old City
The Old City was crowded and airless, so Rav Yosef Chaim's doctors had him move to the New City, which was still mostly empty fields. A few weeks before his passing, weak, he insisted on moving back. He explained that he knew his end was near, and since burial is on Har HaZeisim beside the Old City, from the New City everyone would have to walk a long way.
In the story: Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld
-
7:50 The son of the baal musaf
The baal musaf for the Yamim Noraim died a few days before Rosh Hashanah, and the gabbaim asked Rav Yosef Chaim who should replace him; he said there was still time. At musaf he called the son of the deceased, who had a good voice, to the amud. Asked how a mourner could lead the davening, he said the widow, whose husband had led musaf for decades, would sit in the ezras nashim and suffer seeing a stranger in his place.
In the story: Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld
-
11:40 The only esrog in Radin
During the First World War no esrogim could reach Radin, but one man brought a single esrog for the Chofetz Chaim. On Sukkos morning everyone in town made the brachah on it. At Hallel the Chofetz Chaim did no na'anuim, and when asked why, he explained that everyone could fulfil the mitzvah of taking it, but in the middle of Hallel the others could not shake it, and he would not cause them pain.
In the story: the Chofetz Chaim
-
15:20 The eruv in Teveria
Teveria had a Sefardi and an Ashkenazi kehillah; the Sefardi chacham oversaw the eruv, and the Ashkenazim had Rav Moshe Kliers. When the eruv broke, Rav Moshe Kliers was asked on Shabbos and said it was kosher. After Shabbos he learned the Gemara with the chacham, it became clear the eruv had been pasul, and the chacham was deeply distressed. Asked privately why he had said it was kosher, he answered that publicizing the chacham's error would have harmed the honor of the Torah, which outweighs carrying with a pasul eruv, an issur derabbanan.
In the story: Rav Moshe Kliers
-
20:48 Rav Chaim Ozer's summer apartment
Rav Chaim Ozer Grodzensky went away in the summer for his health, and the rebbetzin asked to take a spacious, airy apartment. He hesitated and first asked the servant, provided by the community, whether she was satisfied; she said the kitchen was far from the dining room but the apartment was worth it. Only then did he agree, since his concern had been not to trouble her.
In the story: Rav Chaim Ozer Grodzensky
-
24:00 Keeping the guest company in the sukkah
Rav Chaim Ozer was ill on Sukkos and lived several floors up, so he did not eat in the sukkah, being a mitztaer. A poor Jew came with nothing to eat, the rebbetzin invited him, and Rav Chaim Ozer told him to eat in the sukkah downstairs. In the middle of the meal Rav Chaim Ozer came down and sat with him. When the man protested, he said he was exempt from sukkah but not from hachnasas orchim, like Avraham Avinu, and that it is not pleasant to eat alone.
In the story: Rav Chaim Ozer Grodzensky, Avraham Avinu
-
31:28 The woman whose parents were alive
A simple woman came to the Chofetz Chaim with a trouble and received a brachah. She then lamented that usually one who needs a yeshuah goes to the graves of his parents, but her parents were still alive and she could not. The talmidim laughed, and the Chofetz Chaim rebuked them sharply: a woman with a heavy heart comes with her troubles, and they laugh?
In the story: the Chofetz Chaim
-
33:23 Rav Elchonon's single smile
Rav Elchonon Wasserman was never seen laughing or smiling, in line with Chazal's words about laughter in this world. Once, at a gathering of rabbonim, a foolish man came in and made a joke; no one laughed, but Rav Elchonon smiled, and that was the only time a smile was seen on his face.
In the story: Rav Elchonon Wasserman
Insights
- 2:25 Rav Yosef Chaim's question to every visitor about the Kosel was a way of protecting the honor of a guest: it showed that people came to Yerushalayim for the Kosel and only stopped by him on the way.
- 7:10 The Rav contrasts the tzaddik with an ordinary person: the tzaddik's thought, even in his own illness, is not to trouble other Jews, while another thinks only of what he himself needs.
- 10:46 In the musaf, na'anuim and eruv stories, a tzaddik sets aside a rule or a mitzvah derabbanan for another person's feelings or honor; the Rav presents each as the way a tzaddik weighs things.
- 26:44 Rav Chaim Ozer's answer distinguishes two obligations: illness exempted him from sukkah, but not from hachnasas orchim, just as Avraham Avinu sat waiting for guests while in pain after his milah.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 0:22 The Rav holds up the tzaddik's way of thinking, never to trouble another Jew even when it is harder for oneself, as the middah the bachurim should learn from these stories.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Rabbi Chaim Ozer Grodzinski, Rabbi Elchonon Wasserman, Rabbi Meir Shapiro (the Lubliner Rav), Rabbi Moshe Kliers, Rabbi Yechezkel of Shinova (the Divrei Yechezkel), Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, the Chofetz Chaim
Terms אתרוג, הכנסת אורחים, כותל המערבי, נענועים