מבשרי אחזה אלוקי

Catalog entry: אמונה א' no. ⁨5⁩ Pocket Guide p. 39 Yiddish 28 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 28 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that Hashem cannot be grasped by philosophy, since human intellect is not a sense made for G-dliness, yet a person can recognize that there is a Creator by looking at the wonders of his own body, as in 'from my flesh I see G-d'.

The Rav distinguishes two paths to emunah: the inherited, instinctive faith of Jews as believers descended from believers, and chakirah, philosophical inquiry, the path of the Rambam in his Moreh Nevuchim. He describes the dispute over philosophy, with the sages of Ashkenaz, especially the Rosh, forbidding it, and notes that philosophy is a foreign import found nowhere in Chumash, Shas or Midrash; the Acharonim, the Vilna Gaon among them, distanced themselves from it entirely. Philosophy fails, he explains, because the intellect is no more made to perceive Hashem than the ear is made to see a picture. The faculty for G-dliness is ruach hakodesh, present in every Jew through his neshamah but insulated by aveiros. Still, from the creations one can recognize that there is a Creator: 'from my flesh I see G-d'. He describes the eye, heart, blood vessels, lungs and digestion, an anatomy book, and a watch that could never assemble itself.

Topics: Creation and Its Wonders · Foundations of Emunah · Simple Emunah, Above Reason

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Two paths to emunah: feeling and inquiry

    The Rav recalls that Jews are believers descended from believers, holding emunah as an instinctive inheritance from the Avos. He then presents the second path, chakirah, logical inquiry, and describes the Rambam's Moreh Nevuchim as its chief example, approaching Hashem, Torah from Heaven and reward and punishment through reason.

  2. 3:17 The dispute over philosophy

    The Rav describes how Rishonim attacked the Rambam's approach, how the sages of Ashkenaz, especially the Rosh, forbade philosophy and even made a cherem, while the Sefardi sages valued it. He stresses that philosophy is found nowhere in Chumash, Shas or Midrash, that the Acharonim, including the Vilna Gaon, rejected it entirely, and that Hashem cannot be 'figured out' like a mathematical problem.

  3. 7:13 Five senses, intellect and ruach hakodesh

    The Rav explains that our five senses connect us to our surroundings but none is made for G-dliness, and the intellect is likewise the wrong faculty, like trying to hear a picture. The sense for G-dliness is ruach hakodesh, present in every Jew through his neshamah; aveiros insulate a person from it like insulation on a live wire.

  4. 14:01 From my flesh I see G-d: the eye listed in the guide

    The Rav says the Acharonim warned against philosophy today, yet through Hashem's creations, though not His essence, one can understand that there is a Creator. Citing Iyov's 'from my flesh I see G-d', he describes the eye in detail: the retina, lens and pupil that adjusts to light, the eyelashes and tears that protect and clean it, its self-healing, and two eyes working together for depth.

  5. 20:08 The heart, blood, lungs and digestion listed in the guide

    The Rav describes the heart, a plain piece of muscle that beats for a lifetime and speeds up and slows down by itself, the fifty thousand miles of blood vessels that carry food and oxygen and remove waste, the lungs that adjust automatically, and the digestive system beginning with the teeth, asking whether all this came about by itself.

  6. 24:24 The anatomy book and the watch listed in the guide

    The Rav adds the sense of taste and saliva, then tells of an anatomy book he found in an apartment in Eretz Yisrael, with wonders on every page such as why the spine is curved. He closes with the parable of a watch whose parts could never assemble themselves in a shaking machine, concluding that even a non-Jew should recognize the Creator simply by looking at his own body.

The shiur, written up

Two paths to emunah: feeling and inquiry

0:00

The Rav recalls that Jews, believers descended from believers, inherit emunah from the Avos, especially Avraham Avinu, so that a Jew believes instinctively, through feeling. A second path is chakirah, logical inquiry, which reaches the conclusion that there is one Creator, that the Torah is from Heaven and that there is reward and punishment. Its chief exponent was the Rambam in his Moreh Nevuchim. a,b

The dispute over philosophy

3:17

Rishonim fought the Rambam over this, even burning his books. The sages of Ashkenaz, especially the Rosh, forbade philosophy and made a cherem, while the Sefardi sages valued it. The Rav stresses that philosophy is a foreign import: nowhere in Chumash, Shas or Midrash is there an argument proving Hashem's existence by logic. The Acharonim rejected it entirely; the Vilna Gaon called it accursed philosophy. Their claim is that Hashem cannot be 'figured out' like a mathematical problem.

Five senses, intellect and ruach hakodesh

7:15

To explain why, the Rav notes that a person has only five senses, a small number, and through them he knows his surroundings; none of them is made for G-dliness. If someone said he heard a picture in a museum, one would tell him a thousand times sharper hearing would not help, for it is the wrong faculty. The intellect is likewise the wrong faculty for knowing Hashem.

10:52

There is a sense for G-dliness, ruach hakodesh, and every Jew has it because his neshamah is a portion of G-d above. Sometimes even a simple, upright Jew feels it when an idea suddenly clarifies a sugya. But aveiros separate a person from it, like insulation on a live wire. c,d

From my flesh I see G-d: the eye

14:11

Therefore, the Rav says, the Acharonim warned against philosophy today. Yet through Hashem's creations, though not His essence, one can understand that there is a Creator. One need not survey all of creation: as Iyov said, 'from my flesh I see G-d'. e

16:10

He describes the eye, which specialists study for years: the retina receives the image upside down and the brain turns it upright; the pupil widens in the dark and narrows in light by itself; eyelashes block dust and tears wash the eye without pressing a button; it heals itself, and two eyes together give depth. Can one say the eye made itself?

The heart, blood, lungs and digestion

20:24

The heart, a plain piece of muscle without wires or screws, beats for seventy or eighty years without tiring, and speeds up during exertion and calms afterwards by itself. Fifty thousand miles of vessels carry food and oxygen and remove waste. The lungs adjust automatically, and digestion begins with the teeth. f

The anatomy book and the watch

25:43

The Rav tells of an anatomy book he found in an apartment in Eretz Yisrael, with wonders on every page, such as why the spine is curved: a straight one would crack from impact. Shaking a watch's twenty parts in a machine for a full day will never produce a watch. Even a non-Jew, he concludes, can see the Creator simply by looking at his own body.

Sources

Nevi'im

  1. d apparently Yeshayahu 59:2 index In the write-up: 10:52

Kesuvim

  1. e Iyov 19:26 text index In the write-up: 14:11
  2. f Tehillim 90:10 text index In the write-up: 20:24

Talmud Bavli

  1. a apparently Shabbos 97a index In the write-up: 0:00

Rishonim

  1. b Moreh Nevuchim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 0:00

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. c apparently Tanya ch. 2 index In the write-up: 10:52

Key points

  1. 0:00 There are two paths to emunah: the inherited, felt faith of Jews as believers descended from believers, and chakirah, philosophical inquiry, as the Rambam did in Moreh Nevuchim.
  2. 3:57 Philosophy is a foreign import: no argument proving Hashem's existence by logic is found in Chumash, Shas or Midrash, and the Rishonim of Ashkenaz and later the Acharonim distanced themselves from it.
  3. 6:39 The intellect cannot grasp Hashem, just as no amount of hearing can hear a picture; the faculty for G-dliness is ruach hakodesh.
  4. 12:13 Every Jew has ruach hakodesh because of his neshamah, but aveiros insulate the body from the neshamah like insulation on a live wire.
  5. 14:28 Through the creations, though not in His essence, one can understand that there is a Ribono shel Olam, and a person need only look at his own body: 'from my flesh I see G-d'.
  6. 18:51 The eye, heart, blood vessels, lungs and digestive system each adjust and repair themselves automatically, and one cannot say they made themselves, just as shaking watch parts will never produce a watch.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 6:39 Why can Hashem not be understood through philosophy?

    Answer: 9:04 Because human faculties, the five senses and the intellect alike, are not made to perceive G-dliness, just as the ear cannot hear a picture; the sense for G-dliness is ruach hakodesh.

  2. Question: 12:32 If every Jew has ruach hakodesh, why does not every Jew perceive G-dliness?

    Answer: 12:52 Because aveiros separate a person from his neshamah like insulation on a live wire, so he has no contact with it.

  3. Question: 26:11 Why is the spine curved and not straight?

    Answer: 26:22 A straight spine would crack from impact; a curved one is flexible and absorbs the blow.

Stories

  1. 25:22 The anatomy book in Eretz Yisrael

    The Rav relates that in an apartment he rented in Eretz Yisrael, the landlord had a son who studied medicine, and there he found a medical book on anatomy describing the shape of the body and its organs. The book had over three hundred pages, and on every page there were wonders, perhaps twenty to a page. One example: why is the spine curved and not straight? Because a straight spine would crack from impact, while a curved one is flexible and absorbs the blow.

    told in 1 other shiur →

Insights

  1. 1:51 Philosophy is not a Jewish article: no Gemara or Midrash anywhere tries to establish the foundations of emunah through logical arguments, and the Rav takes this absence itself as a sign that it is a foreign import.
  2. 9:50 Trying to grasp Hashem with the intellect is like trying to hear a picture: even hearing a million times sharper would not help, because it is the wrong faculty altogether, not a weak one.
  3. 11:17 The sudden flash that makes a whole sugya clear to a simple, upright Jew is a small appearance of the ruach hakodesh that every Jew has through his neshamah.
  4. 12:40 Aveiros act like the insulation on an electric wire: the current of the neshamah is still there, but the person has no contact with it.
  5. 14:59 One need not survey the whole creation to see the Creator; a person's own body, with its self-adjusting and self-repairing systems, is enough, which is the meaning the Rav gives to 'from my flesh I see G-d'.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 14:11 The Rav says that, as the Acharonim warned, one should no longer occupy oneself with philosophy; earlier tzaddikim could, but today one cannot.
  2. 14:54 The Rav says a person should take himself and contemplate what an eye is, and from his own body come to see the Creator.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Iyov, the Rambam, the Rosh, the Vilna Gaon

Terms אלקות ממש, חלק אלוק ממעל, חקירה, מאמינים בני מאמינים, נפלאות, רבונו של עולם, רוח הקודש, שכר ועונש, תורה מן השמים

Report an error on this page