האומות מכירים וכופרים מטעם של rationalization

Catalog entry: אמונה א' no. ⁨11⁩ Pocket Guide p. 39 Yiddish 28 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 28 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains from the Rambam that our belief in the Torah rests on the mesorah of Har Sinai, so no later prophet can change it, and that the nations, who know this, deny it through rationalization born of jealousy.

The Rav recalls that the mesorah of Klal Yisroel is true because a whole nation heard Hashem at Har Sinai, and that a prophet is believed only because the Torah commands it, like two witnesses. With the Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah he shows that a prophet with signs who contradicts Moshe is not heeded, as witnesses who say it is night are not believed by one who sees daylight. The Torah cannot be added to or changed, so the claims of the nations about a new law collapse; Bilaam himself said Hashem does not change His mind. Why do they hold on? Rationalization and jealousy of the chosen people. The Rav applies this to Rashi's question about the first mitzvah, to Moshe as father of all prophets, and to the world's preoccupation with Jews and Yerushalayim. A story of a dying heretic who recanted shows that rationalization falls away at the end. He closes that mesorah is the halachic basis of emunah.

Topics: Torah Min HaShamayim and the Mesorah · Yisroel and the Nations

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The mesorah of Sinai and belief in a prophet

    The Rav recalls that the mesorah is true because the whole nation heard Hashem at Sinai and passed it down. He explains from the Rambam that a later prophet is believed only by decree of the Torah, like two witnesses, which is not true knowledge.

  2. 3:05 No prophet can change the Torah

    The Rav reads the Rambam that a prophet who performs wonders to contradict Moshe is not heeded, comparing him to witnesses who claim it is night in daylight. He continues with the Rambam that the Torah can never be changed, rejecting the claims that Hashem gave a new law or moved Shabbos to Sunday or Friday.

  3. 10:02 Bilaam's words and the nations' jealousy listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the passuk said by Bilaam, that Hashem is not a man who changes His mind, and shows that the nations' whole structure collapses on the Torah they themselves accept. He explains that they hold on through rationalization, driven by jealousy of the chosen people, as the Ohr HaChaim writes on Yosef's brothers.

  4. 13:47 Why HaChodesh is the first mitzvah

    The Rav asks on Rashi's opening why 'HaChodesh hazeh lachem' is called the first mitzvah when earlier mitzvos were given. Following the Rambam, he answers that an individual prophet like Avraham cannot be believed with certainty; we keep even milah only because Moshe wrote it, so HaChodesh is the first mitzvah received from Moshe, who is father of the prophets before and after him.

  5. 19:32 Mesorah as halacha; the world revolves around Jews listed in the guide

    The Rav notes that the Rambam's Yad HaChazakah is a book of halacha, not philosophy, and its basis for emunah is the mesorah of Sinai. The nations are jealous and know the truth subconsciously: everything revolves around the Jews, Eretz Yisroel and Yerushalayim, yet they deceive themselves, as the Kotzker said.

  6. 23:30 The heretic who recanted; mesorah as the strongest way Story listed in the guide

    The Rav retells a story of a leading heretic in Eretz Yisroel who on his deathbed told his students that the Torah is true, and explains that at death rationalization falls away. He then sums up the ways to emunah discussed so far and closes that mesorah is the halachic and strongest way, tied to yetzias Mitzrayim and Matan Torah.

The shiur, written up

The mesorah of Sinai and belief in a prophet

0:24

The Rav recalls that the mesorah of Klal Yisroel cannot be denied: a whole nation heard Hashem speak from the fire, all of them became prophets, and they passed it down from generation to generation. A later prophet, by contrast, is believed only because Hashem commanded it, just as the Torah commands us to follow two witnesses, though they could lie. That is a decree, not true knowledge, which Klal Yisroel has only through Har Sinai. a

No prophet can change the Torah

3:05

From here the Rav reads the Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah chapter 8: a prophet who performs great wonders to contradict Moshe is not heeded, even if his signs can only be explained as sorcery, like the sorcery the Gemara in Shabbos says was smuggled out of Egypt. Moshe's prophecy does not rest on signs; we heard it ourselves. It is like witnesses who tell a court that it is night when the court sees daylight. b,c

6:30

He continues with chapter 9: the Torah can never be added to or reduced, as the passuk forbids, and it is 'not in Heaven' to be brought down again. So when someone claims that Hashem changed His mind and gave a new testament, or moved Shabbos to Sunday or Friday, it cannot be. d,e,g

Bilaam's words and the nations' jealousy

10:16

The Rav points out that the passuk 'Hashem is not a man that He should lie or change His mind' was said by Bilaam, a gentile. The nations accept the Torah of Moshe, which says all this, so their whole structure collapses. They hold on through rationalization, since they cannot keep the Torah, and above all through jealousy of the chosen people, as the Ohr HaChaim writes on Yosef's brothers. h,k

Why HaChodesh is the first mitzvah

14:08

The Rav applies this to Rashi's opening, that the Torah could have begun with HaChodesh hazeh lachem, the first mitzvah Yisroel were commanded. Why the first, when milah and other mitzvos came earlier? According to the Rambam it is simple: an individual who says Hashem spoke to him can be followed only with a question mark. m

16:18

Even Avraham Avinu with milah was a single individual. We keep milah because Moshe wrote it in the Torah, so HaChodesh is the first mitzvah received from Moshe himself. This explains the Rambam's words that Moshe is father to the prophets before him and after him. q

Mesorah as halacha; the world revolves around Jews

20:13

The Rav notes that while philosophy books bring proofs, the Rambam's Yad HaChazakah is a book of halacha, and its basis is the mesorah from Sinai. The nations are jealous of this and know the truth subconsciously: everything revolves around the Jews, Eretz Yisroel and Yerushalayim, for which nations have always fought. Yet they deceive themselves, as the Kotzker said, and pure logic would bring a person to serve Hashem.

The heretic who recanted

23:35

The Rav tells of a leading heretic in Eretz Yisroel who, dying, told his students he had lived in error and the Torah is true; they asked how they could trust him now. An observant Jew never recants at death, but sinners often repent then, because rationalization falls away.

26:15

Summing up instinct, nature and philosophy, he concludes that mesorah is the halachic and strongest way to emunah, rooted in yetzias Mitzrayim and Matan Torah.

Sources

Torah

  1. a Devarim 4:33 text index In the write-up: 0:24
  2. e Devarim 13:1 text index In the write-up: 6:30
  3. f Devarim 29:28 8:23 text index
  4. g Devarim 30:12 text index In the write-up: 6:30
  5. h Bamidbar 23:19 text index In the write-up: 10:16
  6. i Shemos 6:7 12:22 text index
  7. j Devarim (place not identified) 12:43 index
  8. o Shemos 19:9 16:59 text index
  9. r Shemos 20:2 27:39 text index

Talmud Bavli

  1. c apparently Shabbos 104b index In the write-up: 3:05

Midrash

  1. n Midrash (place not identified) 15:58

Rishonim

  1. b apparently Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah ch. 8 index In the write-up: 3:05
  2. d apparently Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah ch. 9 index In the write-up: 6:30
  3. l apparently Rashi, Bereishis 33:4 13:42 index
  4. m Rashi, Bereishis 1:1 text index In the write-up: 14:08
  5. p apparently Hilchos Melachim 8:11 18:10 index

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. k apparently Ohr HaChaim, Bereishis 37:11 index In the write-up: 10:16

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. q apparently Thirteen Principles, principle 7 index In the write-up: 16:18

Key points

  1. 2:01 Belief in a prophet after Moshe is only a decree of the Torah, like believing two witnesses, while belief in Moshe rests on what the whole nation saw at Har Sinai.
  2. 4:04 A prophet who comes with wonders to contradict Moshe is not heeded, just as a court that sees daylight does not believe witnesses who say it is night.
  3. 6:30 The Torah cannot be added to, reduced or exchanged, so any claim that Hashem gave a new Torah is false by the very Torah its claimants accept.
  4. 11:52 The nations hold on to their claims through rationalization, driven above all by jealousy of the Jewish people as the chosen nation.
  5. 17:10 Even mitzvos given to Avraham and the Avos are kept only because Moshe wrote them in the Torah; Moshe is the father of the prophets before him and after him.
  6. 20:13 Mesorah, not philosophy, is the halachic basis of emunah, and it is the strongest of the ways to faith.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 4:45 Should a court believe witnesses who testify that it is night when the court sees it is day?

    Answer: 4:56 No; likewise a prophet who claims Hashem changed the Torah is not believed, because the whole nation heard it at Sinai.

  2. Question: 11:51 Why do the nations persist in their claims when the Torah they accept refutes them?

    Answer: 11:52 Through rationalization, since they cannot keep the Torah, and above all out of jealousy of the chosen people.

  3. Question: 14:18 Why does Rashi call HaChodesh the first mitzvah, when milah and other mitzvos were given earlier?

    Answer: 17:10 Because earlier mitzvos are kept only through Moshe's word, and HaChodesh is the first mitzvah received directly from Moshe.

  4. Question: 25:08 Why do sinners repent at death while an observant Jew never recants?

    Answer: 25:22 Because at death there is no longer any reason to rationalize, and the truth comes out.

Stories

  1. 23:35 The heretic who recanted on his deathbed

    The Rav tells of a leading Zionist heretic in Eretz Yisroel who taught that there is no need to believe in the Torah and had many students who came to hear his ideology. When he fell ill and was dying, he told his students that he had lived his whole life in error and that the Torah is true. His students answered that he had taught them heresy all along, so how could they know he was not lying now.

Insights

  1. 2:22 Belief in any prophet but Moshe is only a decree, like trusting two witnesses who could be lying; true knowledge of Hashem belongs to Klal Yisroel alone through what they saw at Sinai.
  2. 10:25 The verse 'Hashem is not a man that He should lie or change His mind' was said by Bilaam, a gentile, so the nations' own prophet testifies against the idea of a new testament.
  3. 15:06 Rashi's statement that HaChodesh is the first mitzvah Yisroel were commanded is simple according to the Rambam: it is the first mitzvah received from Moshe, the only prophet believed with certainty.
  4. 18:51 The Rambam's words that Moshe is 'father to the prophets before him' mean that even the Avos and Adam are believed only because Moshe recorded their mitzvos.
  5. 24:52 A Jew who kept the Torah all his life never recants at death, while sinners often repent then, because at death rationalization falls away and only the truth remains.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Adam HaRishon, Avraham Avinu, Bilaam, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rashi, the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik

Terms כישוף, מסורה, מעמד הר סיני, נביא שקר, נס, עם הנבחר, קנאה, רבונו של עולם, שבע מצוות בני נח

Report an error on this page