עיקר האמונה - אמונה פשוטה

Catalog entry: אמונה א' no. ⁨12⁩ Pocket Guide p. 39 Yiddish 27 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 27 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Through the Spanish expulsion and the Ohr HaChaim of Rabbi Yosef Yaavetz, the Rav shows that what keeps a Jew in his faith is not philosophy but simple emunah received by mesorah, the faith on which Chavakuk founded all the mitzvos.

The Rav recalls that Jewish faith rests on mesorah, passed from parents and teachers back to Har Sinai, and that simple faith, not proofs, is what holds. He brings Rabbi Yosef Yaavetz, who lived through the expulsion from Spain, which fell on Tisha B'Av, a day of calamities from the spies through Beitar. Yaavetz asks why the decree came, and notes that the philosophers who had proven Hashem's truth by logic converted outwardly, while simple people left Spain with mesirus nefesh. The Rav then describes the controversy over the Rambam's works, the burning of the Gemara in Paris, and, in a tangent, how copying errors in the Gemara were corrected. Rabbeinu Yonah saw the burning as a punishment and did teshuvah, producing Shaarei Teshuvah. Chavakuk founded all mitzvos on emunah. Finally the Rav notes that each person, and each period of a great man's life such as the Chazon Ish's, has its own focus.

Topics: Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Foundations of Emunah

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Faith by mesorah, and the decree of Spain listed in the guide

    The Rav recalls that emunah rests on mesorah from Har Sinai and that simple faith, not proofs, is what endures. He introduces Rabbi Yosef Yaavetz and his Ohr HaChaim, written in the time of the Spanish expulsion, and describes the decree to convert or leave Spain with nothing, and the Inquisition.

  2. 5:02 Tisha B'Av, the expulsion, and the Yaavetz's lesson listed in the guide

    The Rav tells how the expulsion fell on Tisha B'Av, a day of calamities from the spies through Beitar, and how the exiles left to music and wandered destitute. He brings the Yaavetz's reckoning of why it happened, and his observation that the philosophers converted while simple Jews held firm, concluding that only simple emunah, received by mesorah from Yetzias Mitzrayim and Har Sinai, keeps a Jew.

  3. 12:49 The Rambam controversy and the burning in Paris

    The Rav describes the opposition of the Ashkenazi gedolim to the Rambam's path of chakirah, the burning of his works in Paris, and the later decree that burned wagonloads of handwritten Gemaras. He explains that copying by hand caused errors, which is why Tosafos sometimes dispute Rashi's girsa, and how the Baalei Tosafos corrected the text.

  4. 16:04 Printing and the correct girsa of the Gemara

    In a digression the Rav explains how the gedolim, chiefly the Bach, corrected the printed Gemara, why remaining differences of girsa between Rashi and Tosafos are both true, and why masechtos that were rarely learned, such as Nedarim, Nazir and Kodashim, still have many errors noted by the Shitah Mekubetzes.

  5. 19:41 Rabbeinu Yonah's teshuvah and Chavakuk's one mitzvah listed in the guide

    The Rav tells that after the Gemaras were burned in Paris, Rabbeinu Yonah, who had encouraged burning the Rambam's works, saw it as a heavenly punishment and did teshuvah, which brought about Shaarei Teshuvah. He then brings the Gemara in Makkos that Chavakuk founded all the mitzvos on one, emunah, explaining that smaller generations cannot exert themselves equally in everything.

  6. 23:53 Each person's own focus; the Chazon Ish

    The Rav observes that every person puts more strength into certain areas, Torah, tefillah or tzedakah, and that great people change their focus over their lives. He describes the Chazon Ish, hidden and learning in Vilna, and later in Bnei Brak spending hours daily on people's needs and on yeshivos, and asks where such differences come from, leaving the answer for the next shiur.

The shiur, written up

Faith by mesorah, and the decree of Spain

0:06

The Rav recalls that the foundations of faith learned in the Rambam rest on mesorah: Jews received their emunah from parents and teachers, generation after generation, back to Har Sinai. This is why the Torah commands making known to one's children the day of standing before Hashem at Chorev, and it is simple faith, not proofs, that holds. a

2:15

He introduces Rabbi Yosef Yaavetz, who wrote the small sefer Ohr HaChaim in the time of the Spanish expulsion, when the king and queen ordered every Jew to convert or leave with nothing but his clothes. b

Tisha B'Av, the expulsion, and the Yaavetz's lesson

5:29

The deadline was postponed three days and, without the king intending it, fell on Tisha B'Av, a day on which, as Chazal say, calamity is brought: the spies, both Batei Mikdash, and Beitar, where Ben Koziva was taken for Moshiach until his sin showed otherwise. The exiles marched out to music the sages ordered, so they would not weaken in emunah, and wandered destitute until many reached Sefardi lands. d

9:55

The Yaavetz asks why this came about and answers that Torah was not learned properly or for the sake of Heaven, and people turned to philosophy. He notes that the philosophers who had proven Hashem's truth by logic converted, while simple people left with mesirus nefesh. The Rav concludes that only simple emunah, received by mesorah from Yetzias Mitzrayim and Har Sinai, keeps a Jew, which is why the current sedros must be learned well.

The Rambam controversy and the burning in Paris

13:33

The Ashkenazi gedolim, Rashi and the Baalei Tosafos, opposed the Rambam's path of chakirah, and his works were burned in Paris. Later the French government burned about thirty wagons of handwritten Gemaras. Copying by hand bred errors, the Rav explains, which is why Tosafos at times dispute Rashi's girsa.

Printing and the correct girsa

16:04

In a digression the Rav explains that once printing came, gedolim led by the Bach in his glosses corrected the text. Disputes of girsa that remain are both true, 'eilu va'eilu'. Rarely learned masechtos such as Nedarim and Nazir still hold many errors, as the Shitah Mekubetzes shows. i,k,l

Rabbeinu Yonah's teshuvah and Chavakuk's one mitzvah

20:37

Rabbeinu Yonah, who had encouraged burning the Rambam's works, saw the burning of the Gemaras as a sign from Heaven and did teshuvah; from this came Shaarei Teshuvah. The Rav then brings the Gemara in Makkos that Chavakuk founded all the mitzvos on one, 'tzaddik be'emunaso yichyeh'. This does not free anyone from the other mitzvos; smaller generations simply cannot concentrate on them all. n,p,q

Each person's own focus; the Chazon Ish

24:21

Every person, the Rav says, puts more strength into certain areas, Torah, tefillah or tzedakah, and great people change over their lives. The Chazon Ish hid and learned in Vilna, yet in Bnei Brak spent hours daily on people's needs and on yeshivos. Where such differences come from, he leaves for the next shiur.

Sources

Torah

  1. a Devarim 4:9-10 text index In the write-up: 0:06
  2. e Bamidbar 24:17 6:42 text index
  3. g Devarim 18:13 11:36 text index
  4. h apparently Shemos 20:2 12:00 index
  5. j Devarim 31:21 16:44 text index

Nevi'im

  1. f Zechariah 8:19 7:42 text index
  2. q Chavakuk 2:4 text index In the write-up: 20:37

Talmud Bavli

  1. d apparently Taanis 29a index In the write-up: 5:29
  2. k apparently Eruvin 13b index In the write-up: 16:04
  3. p apparently Makkos 23b-24a index In the write-up: 20:37

Rishonim

  1. n Shaarei Teshuvah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 20:37
  2. o Rosh on Rosh Hashanah (place not identified) 21:46 index

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. b Ohr HaChaim (Rabbi Yosef Yaavetz) (place not identified) index In the write-up: 2:15
  2. c Maayan Ganim (Bnei Yissaschar) (place not identified) 2:33 index

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. m Kinnos of Tisha B'Av (place not identified) 19:55 index

Other

  1. i Hagahos HaBach (place not identified) index In the write-up: 16:04
  2. l Shitah Mekubetzes (place not identified) index In the write-up: 16:04

Key points

  1. 0:14 Jewish faith is built on mesorah, received from parents and teachers generation after generation back to Har Sinai, not on philosophical proofs.
  2. 10:36 In the Spanish expulsion the philosophers who had proven Hashem's truth outwardly converted, while simple Jews left with mesirus nefesh.
  3. 12:17 What holds a Jew to emunah is knowing that he comes from a people who have given their lives for Hashem since Avraham Avinu.
  4. 20:37 Rabbeinu Yonah saw the burning of the Gemara as a heavenly punishment for encouraging the burning of the Rambam's works, did teshuvah, and from this came Shaarei Teshuvah.
  5. 22:34 Chavakuk founded all the mitzvos on emunah because later generations can no longer exert themselves equally in every mitzvah.
  6. 24:00 Each person, even among the upright, puts more of his strength into particular areas, and great people change their focus over the course of their lives.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 9:48 Why did Hashem bring the great calamity of the Spanish expulsion?

    Answer: 10:03 The Yaavetz answers that Torah was not learned as it should be, even those who learned did so for honor and not for the sake of Heaven, and people turned to chakirah and philosophy.

  2. Question: 15:23 Why do Tosafos sometimes dispute Rashi over the girsa of the Gemara?

    Answer: 15:29 Because Gemaras were copied by hand, a scribe's mistake would be passed on to every copy made from his, and the Baalei Tosafos clarified the true girsa.

  3. Question: 22:43 Does Chavakuk's founding all mitzvos on emunah mean the other mitzvos need not be kept?

    Answer: 22:47 No. Earlier generations were great enough to exert themselves in every mitzvah; later, smaller generations cannot concentrate on all of them, so one mitzvah must be the foundation.

Stories

  1. 3:30 The expulsion from Spain on Tisha B'Av

    The king and queen of Spain decreed that all Jews must either convert or leave, taking nothing but the clothes on their backs. The day set for leaving was postponed by three days and, without the king intending it, fell on Tisha B'Av. The Jews who left went out in a great procession with music, which the sages of the generation ordered so that they would leave with joy and not weaken in their faith. They wandered destitute; countries closed their doors, many ships sank, and eventually many settled in lands of Asia and Africa, which is why they are called Sefardim.

    In the story: King Ferdinand of Spain, Queen Isabella of Spain

    told in 2 other shiurim →

  2. 14:17 The burning of the Gemara in Paris

    Some time after the Rambam's works were burned in Paris, the French government decreed against learning Gemara and had all Gemaras gathered from the whole country. About thirty wagonloads of handwritten Gemaras were burned in the streets of Paris, leaving the country without Gemaras to learn from. A kinnah said on Tisha B'Av was composed as a lament over it. Rabbeinu Yonah, who had encouraged the burning of the Rambam's works, saw it as a sign from Heaven and did teshuvah.

    In the story: Rabbeinu Yonah, the Rambam

    told in 2 other shiurim →

  3. 25:20 The two periods of the Chazon Ish

    In Vilna the Chazon Ish kept himself completely hidden, known to very few, and only learned, without involvement in communal needs. After the Chofetz Chaim passed away he felt he had no one left to stay for and moved to Eretz Yisrael, settling in Bnei Brak. There he became an entirely different Chazon Ish: he spent hours every day on communal needs, hundreds came daily for brachos and with their troubles, and he had time for everyone, from the wisest to the most foolish. He was also involved in running and building yeshivos.

    In the story: the Chazon Ish, the Chofetz Chaim

Insights

  1. 10:31 The Rav reads the Yaavetz as showing empirically that philosophical proofs of faith fail under trial: those who had proven Hashem's truth by logic converted, while those without such proofs went into exile for their faith.
  2. 0:58 Because the whole of Jewish faith rests on Yetzias Mitzrayim and Matan Torah as transmitted to one's children, the Rav says it is especially important to learn the sedros now being read.
  3. 16:51 Even differences of girsa that remain between Rashi and Tosafos are, in the Rav's view, both true, like a dispute between Rabbi Eliezer and Rabbi Yehoshua, since Hashem allowed both readings to stand among the gedolim who learned them.
  4. 21:03 The Rav points out that Shaarei Teshuvah, one of the most important mussar works, came about as a direct result of Rabbeinu Yonah's teshuvah over his part in the burning of the Rambam's works.
  5. 22:43 The Rav explains Chavakuk's founding all mitzvos on emunah not as a release from the other mitzvos but as a response to shrinking generations, who can no longer concentrate on everything and must make one mitzvah the foundation.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 12:06 The Rav says it is especially important to learn well the sedros of Yetzias Mitzrayim and Matan Torah being read now, since all of Jewish faith is built on them.
  2. 0:46 The Rav says that a Jew should believe through simple faith received from his parents and teachers, not through proofs and philosophy.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Bar Kochba (Ben Koziva), Chavakuk, Dovid HaMelech, King Ferdinand of Spain, Queen Isabella of Spain, Rabbeinu Yonah, Rabbi Eliezer (ben Hurkenos), Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, Rabbi Yosef Yaavetz, Rashi, the Baalei Tosafos, the Bach, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chazon Ish, the Chofetz Chaim, the Rambam, the Rosh

Terms אמונה פשוטה, חקירה, מאמינים בני מאמינים, מסורה, מסירות נפש, צדיק באמונתו יחיה, רבונו של עולם, תשעה באב

Report an error on this page