מלחמה לה' בעמלק - קליפה של ליצנות
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע בשלח no. 6 Pocket Guide p. 9 תש"נ (1989–90) Yiddish 38 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that the power of Amalek is leitzanus, the joke that denies reality, and that the war against Amalek in every generation is the war against mockery of Torah.
The Rav opens with the war against Amalek in every generation and Chazal's image of Amalek jumping into the boiling bath and cooling it, and asks why Purim is celebrated with laughter and what the 'mockery' of Egypt in parshas Bo means. He shows the destructive power of leitzanus: one joke wipes out a hundred mussar talks, as in the story his rebbe told of a student who answered a drasha on the Livyasan with 'I don't like fish.' Analyzing laughter through the spleen, which Sefer Yetzirah assigns to Adar, he explains that a joke is the opposite of sechel and denies reality. Pharaoh survived the plagues by joking, so Hashem mocked Egypt measure for measure; Amalek, the jester, cooled the bath with a joke. Today Amalek jokes about the rebbe, the bachur and the Gemara, cutting the chain of mesorah, and Gog uMagog will fight Hashem with jokes. The Rav calls on bnei Torah to reject leitzanus.
Topics: Doubts in Emunah and Amalek
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Amalek who cooled the boiling bath listed in the guide
The Rav opens with the parsha's closing words on the war against Amalek in every generation and brings Chazal's mashal on 'asher korcha' of Amalek jumping into a boiling bath. He asks why Purim is celebrated with laughter and what the 'mockery' of Egypt in parshas Bo means.
-
3:57 The destructive power of leitzanus listed in the guide
The Rav explains that a letz, unlike other sinners whom Gehinnom cleanses, does not merit to greet the Shechinah, because leitzanus destroys like nothing else. One joke wipes out a hundred mussar talks, as in the story his rebbe Reb Shraga Feivel told of a student who answered a drasha about the Livyasan with 'I don't like fish.'
-
9:07 The spleen, Adar and what a joke is listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Gemara that the spleen laughs and Sefer Yetzirah, which assigns the spleen to the month of Adar. He then analyzes a joke: it is the opposite of sechel, and the more absurd it is, the more it awakens the spleen, as onions stir the eyes and pepper the nose.
-
14:11 Laughter denies reality listed in the guide
The Rav asks why simple people laugh at a sick or insane person instead of pitying him, and answers that what is opposite to sechel triggers laughter. He explains that a sense of humor helps a person endure troubles because it takes him out of reality into a world of fantasy; laughter denies the truth.
-
18:56 Pharaoh's jokes and Amalek the jester listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Pharaoh withstood the plagues by making jokes about them, so Hashem's 'hisalalti' was mockery measure for measure. Amalek too was a jester: by jumping into the bath he made Israel's awesomeness a joke, and so on Purim, in Adar, the month of the spleen, we mock avodah zarah, the one leitzanus Chazal permit.
-
25:07 Amalek today: mocking the rebbe and the Gemara listed in the guide
From 'vayachalosh Yehoshua' the Rav shows that Amalek was only weakened and remains, entering even the yeshiva. A joke about the rebbe cuts the rope of mesorah reaching back to Moshe at Sinai; then come jokes about the good bachur and about the words of the Gemara, a poison that takes much mussar to remove.
-
32:59 Gog uMagog's war and the call to bnei Torah listed in the guide
The Rav reads Tehillim 2 as the war of Gog uMagog, fought against Hashem with jokes because nothing else can push away emes, and Hashem answers with laughter. He ends by calling on bnei Torah to see themselves as Yehoshua's soldiers against Amalek: to reject leitzanus and be serious about Torah and mitzvos.
The shiur, written up
Amalek who cooled the boiling bath
The Rav opens with the parsha's closing words (Shemos 17:16): Hashem's war with Amalek continues in every generation. On 'asher korcha' (Devarim 25:18) he brings Rashi's mashal of a boiling bath nobody dared enter, until one man jumped in, burned himself, but cooled it for others. He then asks why the Yom Tov of Amalek's defeat is celebrated with jokes, unlike any other, and what Hashem's mockery of Egypt in Shemos 10:2 means. a,b,c,d
The destructive power of leitzanus
A sinner, the Rav explains, is cleansed in Gehinnom and can then greet the Shechinah, but Chazal (Sotah 42a) say the letz cannot, because no force destroys like leitzanus. A rebbe may give a hundred mussar talks; one joke, everyone laughs, and all of it is neutralized. f
His rebbe, Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, told of a drasha about the tzaddikim eating the Livyasan in Gan Eden. A student raised his hand: 'Rebbi, I don't like fish.' He refuted nothing; the joke alone destroyed the talk.
The spleen, Adar and what a joke is
The Rav brings the Gemara (Berachos 61b) that the spleen laughs, and Sefer Yetzirah, the sefer of Avraham Avinu, which assigns each month an organ: Adar's is the spleen. g,h
He then analyzes a joke. It is the opposite of sechel: what makes people laugh is its absurdity, and the further from logic, the better the joke. Just as onions bring tears and pepper makes one sneeze, a joke in the air stirs the spleen to laugh.
Laughter denies reality
The Rav asks why simple people laugh at an insane man instead of pitying him, and answers that he says things opposite to sechel, which triggers laughter. Laughter denies reality. That is why humor helps a person through troubles: a joke carries him out of reality into a world of fantasy where the trouble does not exist. It sacrifices the truth.
Pharaoh's jokes and Amalek the jester
Amalek today: mocking the rebbe and the Gemara
The war is unfinished: Yehoshua only weakened Amalek (Shemos 17:13), and Amalek remains, entering Jewish hearts and even the yeshiva. The strength of the Jewish people is the mesorah from rebbe to talmid back to Moshe at Sinai (Avos 1:1). One joke about the rebbe cuts that rope; this, the Rav says, is the essence of Amalek. l,m
Next he mocks a good bachur, weakening him as an example with no argument at all, only leitzanus. Then he twists the Gemara's words into a joke. Anyone with yiras Shamayim kisses a sefer and sets it upright; the joke poisons that respect, and the listener will need much mussar, drashos and tefillah to remove the poison.
Gog uMagog's war and the call to bnei Torah
Dovid HaMelech describes the final war of Gog uMagog against Hashem and His Moshiach (Tehillim 2:1-2). How can one fight Hashem? Only with jokes: against emes, Hashem being the G-d of truth (Yirmiyahu 10:10), no logic prevails, only a joke's fantasy. Measure for measure, He who sits in heaven laughs (Tehillim 2:4). n,p,o
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Key points
- 5:31 Leitzanus is the most destructive force: a single joke can neutralize a hundred mussar talks.
- 11:55 A joke is the opposite of sechel: what makes people laugh is its absurdity, its departure from reality.
- 20:01 Pharaoh and Egypt withstood the plagues by turning them into jokes, and Hashem therefore made a mockery of Egypt measure for measure.
- 23:49 Amalek's whole power is jokes, and that is why on Purim, in Adar, we turn laughter against avodah zarah and the wicked.
- 25:44 Amalek still remains and enters even the yeshiva, mocking the rebbe, the good bachur and the Gemara, and thereby weakening the mesorah from Sinai.
- 33:12 The final war of Gog uMagog against Hashem will be fought with jokes, and Hashem answers it with laughter.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:52 Why is the Yom Tov of Amalek's defeat celebrated with laughter and jokes, unlike any other Yom Tov?
Answer: 23:49 Because Amalek's whole power is jokes, measure for measure we make a mockery of avodah zarah and the wicked in Adar, the month of the spleen.
-
Question: 3:57 What was the 'mockery' Hashem made of Egypt?
Answer: 19:51 Pharaoh had neutralized the plagues by making jokes about them, so Hashem answered measure for measure with mockery.
-
Question: 12:24 What makes people laugh at a joke?
Answer: 12:32 Its absurdity: a joke is the opposite of sechel, and the further it is from logic, the funnier it is.
-
Question: 15:12 Why do simple people laugh at an insane person instead of pitying him?
Answer: 15:47 Because he says things opposite to sechel, and what is opposite to sechel triggers laughter.
-
Question: 19:31 How could Pharaoh and the Egyptians endure the terrible plagues?
Answer: 20:01 With a sense of humor: they turned each plague into a joke and so denied the truth they saw before their eyes.
-
Question: 33:31 How can anyone wage war against Hashem, and how does Hashem fight back?
Answer: 33:42 Only with jokes, which weaken His authority; and Hashem answers measure for measure by laughing at them.
Stories
-
6:57 'I don't like fish'
The Rav's rebbe, Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, told of a drasha given to students in America about the reward of tzaddikim, who will be served the Livyasan in Gan Eden. As the students sat listening intently, one of them raised his hand and said, 'Rebbi, I don't like fish.' He did not refute anything; he simply made a joke, and with that the whole talk was destroyed.
In the story: Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz
Insights
- 17:14 Humor eases suffering precisely because it denies reality, carrying a person into a world of fantasy where the trouble does not exist; the same power is what makes it destructive.
- 20:01 Hashem's 'mockery' of Egypt was measure for measure: Pharaoh had resisted the plagues by joking about them, so Hashem turned Egypt into a joke.
- 22:26 Amalek's jump into the boiling bath was itself a joke: everyone laughed, the awe of Israel became humor, and so other nations lost their fear of attacking them.
- 11:26 Because Adar's organ is the spleen, the organ of laughter, the month of Amalek's defeat is when laughter is turned back against avodah zarah and the wicked.
- 28:05 A joke about the rebbe needs no argument at all, yet it cuts the rope of mesorah that stretches from rebbe to talmid back to Moshe at Sinai.
- 33:42 Against emes no logic can prevail; only the falsehood and fantasy of a joke can push it away, which is why the final war against Hashem is fought with jokes and Hashem answers with laughter.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 36:02 The Rav tells bnei Torah that they have a mission to fight leitzanus: not to listen to it, to reject it and to distance themselves from it.
- 37:29 He says one must be serious about Torah and mitzvos, and just as one would not let one's life be taken, one must not let a joke take away one's spiritual, eternal life.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Amalek, Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Moshe Rabbeinu, Pharaoh, Rashi, Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, Yehoshua bin Nun
Terms גוג ומגוג, ליצנות, מחיית עמלק, מסורה, נחשלים, ספר יצירה, עמלק