ביאור מדרש נפלא - עשה מצוה זו שבשבילה תיכנס לארץ (שייכות לפרשת כי תצא)
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע כי תבוא no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 13 תשמ"א (1980–81) Yiddish 1 hr 15 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains the Midrash that bikkurim is the mitzvah through which one enters the Land: a gift to a talmid chacham counts as bikkurim, and bonding with the talmid chacham, whom one must ask about the Torah's shiurim, is what truly brings a Jew into Eretz Yisrael.
The Rav opens with the Midrash calling bikkurim the mitzvah for whose sake Israel will enter the Land, and asks how this can be, since bikkurim applied only after the Land was conquered and settled. Following the Chasam Sofer, he explains that a gift to a talmid chacham is like bikkurim, because both are called 'reishis', the first and primary thing for whose sake the world was made. He then raises further questions: why bikkurim rather than terumah, why the bas kol blesses specifically bikkurim, why it must go to 'the kohen in those days', and why only from the seven species. After several introductions on the seven species as the source of the Torah's shiurim, on the need for a rebbe, on the hidden border around Eretz Yisrael, and on the kohen as teacher, he answers that bikkurim exists so that the kohen will learn and teach the yearly shiurim. He applies this to Elul and closes with Ki Seitzei and the tochachah of Ki Savo.
Topics: Kavod HaTorah and Talmidei Chachamim · Kedushas Eretz Yisroel · Hiskashrus to Tzaddikim and Emunas Chachamim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The Midrash and the question listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Midrash that bikkurim is the mitzvah for whose sake Israel will enter the Land, and the question of the meforshim: bikkurim applied only after the Land was conquered and settled. He adds the Gemara that a gift to a talmid chacham is like bikkurim, and asks why bikkurim of all gifts.
-
3:24 The leaves and the fruits listed in the guide
Following the Chasam Sofer, the Rav tells the mashal of the leaves of the vine and the palm who complain that they are older than the grapes and dates yet serve them as baskets; the owner answers that he planted the tree for the fruit. The nations make the same claim against Israel.
-
7:05 Reishis: the talmid chacham and bikkurim listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the world was created in thought in Tishrei and in deed in Nisan, and the Torah opens with Bereishis to show that the thought comes first: Israel, the Torah and the talmid chacham are 'reishis'. Since bikkurim too is reishis, a gift to a talmid chacham is like bikkurim, and before the Land was settled this was the mitzvah through which Israel merited it.
-
13:01 Four questions on bikkurim listed in the guide
The Rav asks why bikkurim rather than terumah, which is holier; why the bas kol after viduy maaser blesses specifically bikkurim; why bikkurim must go to 'the kohen in those days', with the Ramban's question; why the declaration and the story of leaving Mitzrayim belong to bikkurim; and why bikkurim come only from the seven species.
-
21:55 The seven species and the shiurim listed in the guide
As a first introduction, the Rav brings the Gemara that the verse of the seven species teaches the Torah's shiurim, and lists the measures learned from each species. He asks why the Torah gave measures that remain unclear, comparing it to a builder told to use an unknown measure, and notes the disputes over shiurim today.
-
27:16 No Jew can stand without a rebbe listed in the guide
The Rav lays down the rule that a Jew must attach himself to a talmid chacham and a good chevra. Even Shlomo HaMelech, while his rebbe Shimi ben Gera lived, did not marry Pharaoh's daughter; afterwards he stumbled. He brings that cleaving to talmidei chachamim is cleaving to Hashem, and that the whole Torah is built on shiurim.
-
32:32 Unclear shiurim send one to the talmid chacham listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Hashem gave so many shiurim and left them unknown so that a Jew would have to go to the talmid chacham at every step, and that in Heaven they rule like the talmid chacham. He gives examples from daily life and reads 'a land whose stones are iron' as referring to the talmidei chachamim of Eretz Yisrael.
-
35:57 In Eretz Yisrael yet not in it listed in the guide
As a second introduction, the Rav brings the Tzemach Hashem LiTzvi, who asks how the nations could defile the holy place, and answers that a strip of foreign land is spread under their feet, so that they are never truly in Eretz Yisrael. He compares it to Shabbos: a person who does not keep it stands in the day but has a partition between him and Shabbos.
-
39:39 The kohen as teacher and posek listed in the guide
As a third introduction, the Rav explains that the kohen has two roles: the avodah in the Beis HaMikdash and teaching Torah, as in 'they shall teach Your laws to Yaakov'. This is why the passuk of the zaken mamrei speaks of 'the kohen who stands to serve', and why the lips of the kohen guard knowledge; he notes how many poskim and teachers in his beis medrash are kohanim and levi'im.
-
44:18 Bikkurim: to learn the yearly shiurim listed in the guide
The Rav brings a teshuvah of the Chasam Sofer: how can shiurim be fixed by the fruits of Eretz Yisrael when they once were huge? The answer is that they grow with Israel's merits and must be measured each year. From this the Rav concludes that bikkurim of the seven species come to the kohen so that he can fix the shiurim, which answers why only the seven species and why the bas kol says 'repeat it next year'.
-
49:28 The kohen of your days and entering the Land listed in the guide
The Rav answers the Ramban: since the purpose of bikkurim is to learn, one must go to the kohen of one's own days. Without attachment to a talmid chacham a Jew falls, as even Shlomo did; with it he becomes an ehrliche Jew and truly enters Eretz Yisrael. This is why he declares 'I have come to the Land' and tells of leaving Mitzrayim, the land of the nations.
-
52:59 Elul, the Eretz Yisrael of time listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Eretz Yisrael is the 'reishis' of place as Rosh Hashanah is the reishis of time; with the Meshech Chochmah he says that in Eretz Yisrael it is Rosh Hashanah all year. The forty days from Rosh Chodesh Elul to Yom Kippur are the Eretz Yisrael of the year, and one can be in them without being in them.
-
56:20 Coming to the kohen today listed in the guide
The Rav applies the Midrash: to have a share in Rosh Hashanah one must come to the 'kohen', ask how to do teshuvah, how to daven and how to become better. The kohen today can be a rebbe, friends, or the author of a sefer, whose soul is in his words. The kohen's hand under the owner's hand shows that the guide lifts a person up, and one must learn Parshas Ki Savo.
-
59:33 Ki Seitzei: tikkun, geulah and the ben sorer
The Rav briefly reviews Parshas Ki Seitzei as a parsha of tikkun and geulah, mentioning the yefas toar, tzitzis and Amalek. He dwells on the ben sorer umoreh: the Gemara says there never was one, yet one Tanna says he sat on his grave. The Rav explains that no Jew is ever beyond hope; the one that Tanna saw later became a tzaddik.
-
1:08:04 The tochachah as hidden blessing
The Rav explains that the curses of Ki Savo are covered blessings, as the sefarim say, and that what looks bad in a Jew is not truly bad. Rashi on 'hashkifah' shows that even a harsh look turns to blessing through matnos aniyim. Elul is the time to reveal the good hidden in a Jew and to turn judgment into mercy; he closes with a brachah for a good year.
The shiur, written up
The Midrash and the question
The Rav opens with the Midrash: perform this mitzvah, bikkurim, for its sake you will enter the Land. The meforshim ask how, since bikkurim applied only after the Land was conquered and settled. He adds the Gemara that bringing a gift to a talmid chacham is like bringing bikkurim, learned from the bread of bikkurim brought to Elisha, and asks why bikkurim, of all the gifts to the kohen. a,b,c
The leaves and the fruits
Following the Chasam Sofer, the Rav tells a mashal. The leaves of the vine and the palm complain that they are older than the grapes and dates, yet serve as baskets to hold them. The owner answers that he planted the tree for the fruit; the leaves only came first to protect it. The nations make the same claim against Israel: they are older, so why must they serve? d
Reishis: the talmid chacham and bikkurim
The Rav brings the dispute of Rabbi Eliezer and Rabbi Yehoshua whether the world was created in Tishrei or in Nisan, and the resolution that it was created in thought in Tishrei and in deed in Nisan. The Torah opens with Bereishis, which points to thought, to show that what is first in thought is primary, though created later. f,g
Israel and the Torah are called 'reishis', and so is the talmid chacham. Since bikkurim too is reishis, a gift to a talmid chacham is like bikkurim. Before the Land was settled, this was how the mitzvah was kept, and through it Israel merited to enter the Land; this, says the Chasam Sofer, is the Midrash. i,c,d
Four questions on bikkurim
The Rav finds the answer incomplete. Terumah and other gifts are also called reishis, and terumah is holier, so why is the gift compared specifically to bikkurim? Further, after viduy maaser, which covers all the gifts, Rashi says a bas kol blesses: 'you brought bikkurim today, repeat it next year'. Why mention bikkurim alone? j,k
Rashi explains 'the kohen in those days' as the kohen of your time, and the Ramban asks, as with a judge, what difference it makes for bikkurim which kohen receives them. The Rav also asks why the declaration 'I have told today that I came to the Land' and the passage of 'Arami oved avi' belong to bikkurim. l,m,n,o,p
The seven species and the shiurim
The first introduction: beyond the order of brachos, the Gemara says the whole verse of the seven species comes to teach shiurim, and the Rav lists them: wheat for the measure of bread, barley for a bone, the vine for a nazir, figs for carrying on Shabbos, olives for the kezayis, dates for Yom Kippur. This is the praise of the Land, that its fruits teach the halachos. r,s,t
He then asks why Hashem gave measures that remain unknown, like a builder told to use a measure he never heard of, and notes how far apart the opinions on shiurim are today.
No Jew can stand without a rebbe
Unclear shiurim send one to the talmid chacham
Since the shiurim are unknown, a Jew must keep going to the talmid chacham, and in Heaven they rule as the talmid chacham rules. At each step of life a new question arises, and he must ask again. This, the Rav says, is why the shiurim are so unclear, and why 'a land whose stones are iron' refers to the firm talmidei chachamim of Eretz Yisrael. u
In Eretz Yisrael yet not in it
The second introduction is from the Tzemach Hashem LiTzvi, who wonders how the nations could defile the holy place. He answers that a strip of foreign land is spread beneath them, so that even living in Eretz Yisrael they are not in it. The Rav compares it to Shabbos: one who does not keep it stands in the day, but a partition separates him from Shabbos. y
The kohen as teacher and posek
The third introduction asks why the passuk of the zaken mamrei speaks of 'the kohen who stands to serve'. The Rav explains that the kohen has two roles: teaching, as 'they shall teach Your laws to Yaakov', and the avodah. A posek who is a kohen carries a special bracha, for the lips of the kohen guard knowledge. z,aa,ab
He notes that in his beis medrash eight of the poskim and teachers turned out to be kohanim or levi'im, a sign of this gift.
Bikkurim: to learn the yearly shiurim
The kohen of your days
This answers the Ramban: if the purpose is to learn, one must go to the kohen of one's own time. A Jew who learns and davens alone, without a talmid chacham, will fall, as even Shlomo did. Attached to the talmid chacham, he becomes an ehrliche Jew and is truly in Eretz Yisrael, so he can say 'I have come to the Land' and tell of leaving Mitzrayim, the land of the nations. m,o
Elul, the Eretz Yisrael of time
Eretz Yisrael is reishis of place, as Rosh Hashanah is reishis of time; the Meshech Chochmah says that in the Land it is Rosh Hashanah all year. The forty days from Rosh Chodesh Elul to Yom Kippur are the Eretz Yisrael of the year, and even a Jew in America enters it then, yet one can be in them without being in them. ad
Coming to the kohen today
To have a share in Rosh Hashanah, the Rav says, one must come to the 'kohen' and ask how to do teshuvah, how to daven warmly, how to do chessed. Today's kohen may be a rebbe, friends, or the author of a sefer whose soul lives in his words. The kohen's hand beneath the owner's shows that the guide lifts him up.
Ki Seitzei and the ben sorer umoreh
The Rav briefly reviews Parshas Ki Seitzei as a parsha of tikkun and geulah, touching on tzitzis, with the Maharal on its eight strings and the time of Moshiach.
The tochachah as hidden blessing
The Rav turns to Ki Savo. The sefarim say that the curses of the tochachah are blessings covered over, and what looks bad in a Jew is not truly bad. Rashi teaches that every 'hashkafah' in the Torah is for bad except one, turned to blessing by matnos aniyim. af,ag
Elul is the time to reveal the good hidden in every Jew and to turn judgment into mercy, as the shofar does on Rosh Hashanah. One should learn the parsha with its meforshim, see how bad things are truly good, and show Hashem the good within. He closes with a brachah for a good year.
Sources
Torah
- j Devarim 26:16 text index In the write-up: 13:28
- o Devarim 26:3 text index In the write-up: 17:32, 49:51
- p Devarim 26:5 text index In the write-up: 17:32
- r Devarim 8:8 text index In the write-up: 22:01
- z Devarim 17:12 text index In the write-up: 39:39
- aa Devarim 33:10 text index In the write-up: 39:39
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
- c Kesubos 105b text index In the write-up: 0:25, 9:36
- f Rosh Hashanah 10b text index In the write-up: 7:19
- n Rosh Hashanah 25b text index In the write-up: 17:32
- q apparently Menachos 84b index In the write-up: 20:47
- s apparently Berachos 41a index In the write-up: 22:01
- t Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 22:01
- u apparently Taanis 4a index In the write-up: 32:43
- v Berachos 8a text index In the write-up: 27:25
- w Kesubos 111b text index In the write-up: 30:54
- ae Sanhedrin 71a text index In the write-up: 1:03:31, 1:06:33
Midrash
- a Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 0:25
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- e Rashi on Bereishis 1:1 3:07 text index
- g apparently Tosafos, Rosh Hashanah 27a index In the write-up: 7:19
- i Rashi on Bereishis 1:1 text index In the write-up: 9:36
- k Rashi on Devarim 26:16 text index In the write-up: 13:28, 46:17
- l Rashi on Devarim 26:3 text index In the write-up: 17:32
- m apparently Ramban on Devarim 26:3 index In the write-up: 17:32, 49:51
- ag apparently Rashi on Devarim 26:15 index In the write-up: 1:09:03
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 10:00 Bringing a gift to a talmid chacham counts as bringing bikkurim, because both the talmid chacham and bikkurim are called 'reishis'.
- 11:53 Before bikkurim could be brought to Yerushalayim, the mitzvah was fulfilled by bringing gifts to a talmid chacham, and through it Israel merited to enter the Land.
- 23:05 The seven species are the source of the Torah's shiurim, and the Torah left the shiurim unclear so that Jews would always have to go and ask a talmid chacham.
- 45:24 Since the fruits of Eretz Yisrael grow larger or smaller with the merits of the people, the kohen in Yerushalayim, receiving bikkurim from every region, could fix the shiurim anew each year.
- 38:33 One can live in Eretz Yisrael and not be in it, just as one can stand in the day of Shabbos without having a share in it; attachment to a talmid chacham is what brings a Jew truly into the Land.
- 55:43 Elul is the 'Eretz Yisrael of time', and to enter it one must come to the 'kohen' of today, a rebbe, a friend or a sefer, and ask how to do teshuvah and serve Hashem.
- 1:09:30 The curses of the tochachah are hidden blessings; Elul is the time to reveal the good hidden in every Jew.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:44 How can bikkurim be the mitzvah for whose sake Israel enters the Land, when bikkurim applied only after conquest and settlement?
Answer: 11:53 Before the Land was settled one fulfilled it by bringing gifts to a talmid chacham, which counts as bikkurim, and through that Israel merited the Land.
-
Question: 2:22 Why is a gift to a talmid chacham compared specifically to bikkurim and not to other gifts to the kohen?
Answer: 10:00 Both bikkurim and the talmid chacham are called 'reishis'.
-
Question: 21:14 Why may bikkurim be brought only from the seven species?
Answer: 46:23 The seven species are the source of the shiurim, and the kohen received them in order to fix the shiurim each year.
-
Question: 16:45 Why does the bas kol after viduy maaser bless specifically bikkurim, 'repeat it next year'?
Answer: 48:26 Because bikkurim must come every year to learn that year's shiurim, unlike the other gifts that may wait three years.
-
Question: 17:42 What difference does it make to which kohen bikkurim are brought, that the passuk says 'the kohen in those days'?
Answer: 49:15 The whole purpose of bikkurim is for the kohen to rule and teach, so one must go to the living teacher of one's own time.
-
Question: 1:04:28 If a ben sorer umoreh never existed, how could a Tanna say he sat on his grave?
Answer: 1:05:18 There never was a Jew beyond hope; the one he saw met the conditions but was not executed, and later became a tzaddik.
Stories
-
43:17 Counting the kohanim in the beis medrash
The Rav relates that in the beis medrash they went around the poskim and maggidei shiur one by one, noting who is a kohen and who is a levi. They found that eight of them were kohanim or levi'im. He brings it as a sign of the special gift of teaching given to the tribe of Levi.
Insights
- 5:41 The leaves grow first but the tree was planted for the fruit; so too the world was created in thought in Tishrei but in deed in Nisan, and the Torah opens with Bereishis to show that what is first in thought, Israel and the talmid chacham, is the primary thing.
- 31:32 The Torah deliberately left its shiurim unclear so that a Jew would never be able to manage alone and would always need to ask a talmid chacham.
- 46:32 The purpose of bringing bikkurim to the kohen was to learn halachah: from the seven species brought from every region, the kohen could fix that year's shiurim, which changed with Israel's merits.
- 36:45 A gentile in Eretz Yisrael walks on a strip of foreign land; likewise a Jew can live in the Land, or stand in Shabbos or in Elul, without being in it, unless he connects to it.
- 49:51 Since the purpose is learning, the kohen of one's own days is essential; today the 'kohen' to whom one brings bikkurim can be a rebbe, a friend, or the author of a sefer.
- 1:05:18 The ben sorer umoreh teaches that no Jew is ever lost: the one that Tanna saw later became such a tzaddik that people sat at his grave.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 30:01 The Rav says a Jew must have a rebbe and a good chevra of friends; otherwise he can sink.
- 56:40 The Rav says that in Elul one should go to the 'kohen' and ask how to do teshuvah, how to daven with feeling and how to have a good heart toward other Jews.
- 1:14:19 The Rav urges learning Parshas Ki Savo with the meforshim, to see how what looks bad is truly good and to reveal the good within oneself.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Elisha HaNavi, Rabbi Eliezer (ben Hurkenos), Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, Rashi, Shimi ben Gera, Shlomo HaMelech, the Chasam Sofer, the Ramban, Yiftach
Terms ביכורים, יציאת מצרים, ירושה, ראשית, רבונו של עולם, שבעת המינים, תלמיד חכם