הנשמות חלק אלקי ממעל ממש' 'בנים' אתם לה' אלוקיכם; קשיא: איך יש מדריגות בנשמות אם כלם אלקות.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' ב no. 6 Pocket Guide p. 41 Yiddish 45 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains why every Jewish soul is 'truly a part of G-d above' and a child of Hashem drawn from His wisdom, and then takes up the question of how there can be levels among souls, answering with the image of one body from head to heel that runs through the generations down to our own, the heel before Moshiach.
The Rav learns the opening of Tanya chapter two: the second soul of a Jew is truly a part of G-d. From the verse that Hashem breathed into Adam the breath of life, and the saying that one who breathes, breathes from within himself, he shows that this breath carries Hashem's innermost being, which is why the shofar is blown with a cry beyond words. The daily blessing 'You breathed it into me' shows this holds for every Jew. The soul rose in Hashem's thought, and Jews are called His children: as a child is drawn from the father's brain, every soul is drawn from Hashem's wisdom. Since Hashem is Himself the knowledge, as the Rambam writes, the human brain, made for this world, cannot grasp it; the soul and ruach hakodesh can, and the rest is received and believed. He then asks how levels among souls are possible, and explains that one body has a head and a heel, and so do the world and the generations, down to our own heel generation, where truth is lacking.
Topics: Levels and Root of the Soul · The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · Hashem's Love for Klal Yisroel
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Breathed from within: the soul and the shofar listed in the guide
The Rav opens Tanya chapter two, that the second soul of a Jew is truly a part of G-d, and explains the verse of Hashem breathing the breath of life into Adam: one who breathes, breathes from within, so the soul carries Hashem's innermost being. He connects this to Rosh Hashanah, when this breath is blown back through the shofar with a cry beyond words.
-
5:16 Every Jew says 'You breathed it into me' listed in the guide
The Rav asks how we know the breath of Hashem is in every Jew and not only in Adam, and answers from the daily blessing instituted by the Men of the Great Assembly, 'You breathed it into me'. He shows that breath is the inner life of a person, as the signs of life in the Shulchan Aruch, a feather or a cold mirror at the nose, test for breath.
-
8:51 Risen in thought: Jews as Hashem's children listed in the guide
The Rav explains Chazal's words that Israel rose in Hashem's thought and the verses calling Jews Hashem's children. A child is drawn from the father's brain, and so every Jewish soul is drawn from Hashem's thought and wisdom.
-
12:36 He is the knowledge and the knower listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Rambam that Hashem is the knowledge and the knower: a person's knowledge comes from outside and is separate from him, while Hashem's knowledge is Himself. Following the Tanya, he says this cannot be grasped by a human mind, as the verse asks whether one can find out G-d.
-
16:01 The brain was made for this world listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the brain, like the hands, feet and lungs, is a part of the body made for this world, and it interprets what the five senses take in, as with the eye that sees upside down. Just as a painting cannot be heard however strong the ears, the brain cannot grasp G-dliness.
-
23:01 The soul perceives what the mind cannot listed in the guide
The Rav says there is a sense that perceives G-dliness: a Jew with ruach hakodesh perceives through his soul, not his mind, since sins have not cut him off from it. The mind grasps Hashem's oneness with His wisdom only through emunah; it was received from those with ruach hakodesh that every soul comes from Hashem's wisdom, like a child from the father's brain, and one who does not understand must believe.
-
27:12 The question: how can souls differ? listed in the guide
The Rav raises the Tanya's question: there are countless levels of souls, from the Avos and Moshe Rabbeinu down to our generations. If greater souls came from wisdom and lesser ones from lower powers it would be understood, but if all come from wisdom and are equally children, why are they not equal? He announces that he will step aside to explain another matter in order to reach the answer.
-
30:34 From head to heel: body, world and generations listed in the guide
The Rav explains that one person's body has levels, from the head with its wisdom down to the heel, and the world too has limbs: Yerushalayim is its heart. So too the generations, from those that are the head down to the heels, and within each generation. He shows that the heel hardly feels a needle because it is farthest from the head, the source of all feeling.
-
36:14 The heel before Moshiach and the descent after the Avos
The Rav brings the Gemara in Sotah that the last generation before Moshiach is called its heels, and says the Arizal already headed the heel souls while the Ba'al HaTanya called his generations the heels of Moshiach. He shows the same descent at the beginning of Klal Yisrael: the Avos, then the tribes, then the seventy souls who went down to Egypt, and with Yaakov Avinu's passing the heels began.
-
40:12 Our generation: the heel, where truth is missing
The Rav says that with Moshe Rabbeinu and the generation of Matan Torah the order began again from the heads, and descended down to our generation, the very bottom of the heel, which feels nothing and stands in darkness. He brings the Gemara that chutzpah grows before Moshiach and truth is missing, and shows it in Krias Shema, whose last word corresponds to the lowest limb and where the word emes is not written in the passage.
The shiur, written up
Breathed from within: the soul and the shofar
The Rav opens Tanya chapter two: the second soul of a Jew is truly a part of G-d above. The Tanya brings the verse that Hashem breathed into Adam the breath of life, and the saying that one who breathes, breathes from within himself. Only at the soul does the Torah use this language, so man holds an inwardness that comes from Hashem Himself. a,b,c
This, the Rav says, is why the shofar is blown on Rosh Hashanah: the breath we received is beyond words, so we blow it back with a cry we ourselves cannot put into words.
Every Jew says 'You breathed it into me'
Risen in thought: Jews as Hashem's children
Chazal say that Israel rose in Hashem's thought, and the verses call Jews His children: 'My firstborn son, Israel', 'You are children to Hashem your G-d'. The Rav explains that a child's life begins in the father's brain and travels down the spinal cord; the child is an extension of that brain. So every Jewish soul is drawn from Hashem's thought and wisdom. f,h,i
He is the knowledge and the knower
Here the Tanya brings the Rambam: Hashem is the knowledge and the knower. The Rav explains that a person's knowledge is acquired from outside and lies in his brain as in a vessel, separate from him; Hashem's knowledge is Himself. A person cannot grasp this, as the verse in Iyov asks whether one can find out G-d. j,k
The brain was made for this world
Why can't the mind grasp it? The brain, the Rav explains, is part of a body made for this world. Hands were not made to touch the Heavenly Throne, feet walk the street, lungs breathe this world's air, and a fish's world needs no lungs. The brain is the tool that connects a person to this world.
It interprets the five senses: the eye registers a picture upside down, and the brain makes him see it upright. Each thing needs its own sense. Nobody sees a symphony or hears a painting, and not because the ears are weak; a thousand times stronger, they still would not hear it. So too the brain was not made to understand G-dliness. k
The soul perceives what the mind cannot
There is a sense for G-dliness: a Jew with ruach hakodesh perceives it through his soul, not his mind, as long as his sins have not cut him off from it. Through the soul he knows what will be tomorrow and what happens in heaven. l
With the mind, the Rav says, one grasps that Hashem is the wisdom only through emunah, since 'My thoughts are not your thoughts'. It was received from those with ruach hakodesh that every soul comes from Hashem's wisdom, as a child from the father's brain; one who does not understand must believe. m
The question: how can souls differ?
The Tanya then notes the countless levels of souls, from the Avos and Moshe Rabbeinu to our generations. The Rav sharpens the question: if great souls came from wisdom and lesser ones from lower powers, like a man's middos below his wisdom, it would be understood. But if all are children from wisdom, they should be equal, as all of a man's children are his children. He announces a digression to reach the answer. n
From head to heel
Levels exist within one person: the head with wisdom, understanding and knowledge, then the limbs, down to the heel, all one structure. The world too has limbs: Yerushalayim is its heart, and there are its eyes and arms, 'from the corner of the earth'. So too the generations, from the head down to the heels, and within each generation: heads, eyes, those who work for others, and those who do things without feeling. o,p
A needle in the head hurts; in the sole of the foot one hardly feels it, because the heel is farthest from the head, the source of all feeling.
The heel before Moshiach
The Gemara in Sotah calls the generation before Moshiach its heels. The Arizal headed the heel souls; the Ba'al HaTanya called his generations the heels, and it has gone deeper. The same descent began Klal Yisrael: the Avos, then the tribes, then the seventy souls who went to Egypt. With Yaakov Avinu's passing, as Rashi notes, the eyes and hearts were closed and the heel began. q,s
Our generation, where truth is missing
With Moshe Rabbeinu and the generation of Matan Torah, the heads of all generations, the order began again, 'when the heads of the people gathered'. It descended to our generation, the very bottom of the heel, which feels nothing and stands in darkness. The Gemara says chutzpah grows before Moshiach and truth is missing. t,q
The Rav shows this in Krias Shema, whose words correspond to the limbs: its last word, corresponding to the lowest limb, should be emes, yet emes is not written in the passage. At the heel, truth is not seen.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 0:26 The verse that Hashem 'breathed into his nostrils the breath of life' shows that the soul comes from Hashem's innermost being, since one who breathes breathes from within himself.
- 5:28 The daily blessing 'You breathed it into me' shows that this breath of Hashem is in every Jew, not only in Adam.
- 10:20 Jews are called children of Hashem because, as a child is drawn from the father's brain, every Jewish soul is drawn from Hashem's thought and wisdom.
- 14:35 The human brain was created to understand this world, so it cannot grasp Hashem, who is Himself the knowledge and the knower; this is grasped only by the soul.
- 27:20 The Rav asks how there can be greater and lesser souls if all of them come from Hashem's wisdom, just as all of a man's children are equally his children.
- 31:23 Like the limbs of one body from head to heel, there are levels in the world and in the generations, and our generation is the heel before Moshiach, which hardly feels.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:16 How do we know that the breath of Hashem is in every Jew today and not only in Adam?
Answer: 5:47 From the blessing every Jew says each day, 'You breathed it into me', in the same language used for Adam.
-
Question: 15:14 How can Hashem be both the knowledge and the knower?
Answer: 15:20 A human mind cannot grasp it, because the brain was made to understand this world; one understands it through emunah, not comprehension.
-
Question: 27:20 If every Jewish soul comes from Hashem's wisdom and all are His children, why are there greater and lesser souls?
Answer: 31:11 The Rav begins to answer with the image of one body: a single person has levels from the head to the heel, and so do the world and the generations.
-
Question: 35:18 Why does the heel hardly feel anything?
Answer: 35:47 Because it is farthest from the head, the source of all feeling, which travels down through the spinal cord.
Insights
- 3:55 The shofar of Rosh Hashanah returns to Hashem the very breath He breathed into man: since that breath is beyond words, it is given back with a sound that has no words.
- 5:28 To show that every Jew, not only Adam, has the breath of Hashem, the Ba'al HaTanya brings not a verse but the blessing every Jew says each day, 'You breathed it into me'.
- 22:09 The mind cannot grasp G-dliness not because it is weak but because it is the wrong sense, as no ear, however strong, can hear a painting.
- 23:23 A Jew perceives G-dliness through his soul, not his mind, and sin is what insulates him from that soul.
- 35:45 The heel feels least because it is farthest from the head, the source of all feeling; so the last generation before Moshiach, the heel, hardly feels anything in Yiddishkeit.
- 44:20 The last word of Krias Shema corresponds to the lowest limb, and there the word emes is not written in the passage: at the bottom of the heel, truth is not seen.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 25:59 The Rav says that if one does not understand that every soul comes from Hashem's wisdom, one must believe it, since it was received this way.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Anshei Knesses HaGedolah, Moshe Rabbeinu, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu
Terms ויפח באפיו נשמת חיים, חלק אלוק ממעל, מוח האב, נפש השנית, עקבתא דמשיחא, פנימיות, רוח הקודש, רמ"ח אברים, שופר