המוחין מולידות המדות' מחלוקת אם מהמוחין באים למדות או להיפך. החכמה והבינה עוסקים באהבה ויראה והדעת מקשרם למדות.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' ג no. ⁨12⁩ Pocket Guide p. 42 Yiddish 42 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 42 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

On Tanya chapter three, the Rav explains how chochmah and binah, the 'father and mother' of the mind, give birth to love and fear of Hashem through long, steady contemplation of His greatness, and why this was the Ba'al HaTanya's distinctive path.

The Rav reads Tanya chapter three: the first flash of an idea is chochmah, its development in length and breadth is binah, and they are called father and mother because their children are the middos, love and fear. This, he says, was the Ba'al HaTanya's distinctive view against most of the Maggid's other students, who worked with the public from the middos; both are true, and the dispute was over which path to teach the masses. With the mashal of a carpenter, he explains that a person was given a thinking soul in order to use it, and he describes the endless creation, worlds above worlds and angels above angels, whose contemplation brings first fear and then love. He shows this order in the brachos of Krias Shema, distinguishes fear of His exaltedness from fear of punishment, explains the language of longing through Shechem's hidden spark of Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon, and concludes that only contemplation bound with da'as yields lasting love and fear.

Topics: Ahavas Hashem and Dveikus · Yiras Shamayim · The Sefiros

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Chochmah and binah as father and mother listed in the guide

    The Rav reads Tanya chapter three: the first flash of an idea is chochmah, its development is binah, and they are father and mother whose children are love and fear. He explains that the Ba'al HaTanya held avodah must come through contemplating G-dliness with chochmah, binah and da'as, which then gives birth to the middos.

  2. 4:02 The dispute among the Maggid's students listed in the guide

    The Rav describes the difference of opinion between the Ba'al HaTanya and most of the Maggid's students, who began with the middos: both are true, and the question was how to teach the masses. He compares it to Yosef and his brothers, and to the dispute with Rabbi Mottel of Chernobyl over whether the Rebbe lifts the chassidim or they must lift themselves.

  3. 8:43 The thinking soul and the endless creation

    With the mashal of a carpenter who makes a table because he is a carpenter, the Rav explains that a person was created with an intellect in order to use it. He then describes what contemplation reaches: a creation without end, the higher hidden worlds, and Hashem who fills and surrounds all worlds beyond even that.

  4. 15:50 Planets and angels: first fear, then love

    The Rav describes the earth's orbit as a galgal that is nothing beside larger ones, and above them the souls and angels, each as nothing before the one above, up to the Kisei HaKavod. Such contemplation brings fear of Hashem and then love; he insists avodah must begin with fear, as Rosh Hashanah comes before Sukkos.

  5. 19:44 The order in the brachos of Krias Shema

    The Rav shows the Tanya's order in the brachos of Krias Shema: Yotzer speaks of the luminaries and the angels and brings yirah, Ahavah Rabbah brings love, and then come Shema and Vehaya, the acceptance of the yoke of Heaven and of the mitzvos. He asks for whom Chazal instituted Yotzer if it is said in forty-five seconds without thought.

  6. 23:25 Fear of His exaltedness, not of punishment

    Returning to the Tanya's words, the Rav explains that contemplation gives birth to fear of Hashem's exaltedness, unlike fear of punishment, which serves for reward. He compares it to the awe one feels before a great tzaddik, and explains the Tanya's word for shame through the Gemara that reads 'His fear upon your faces' as bushah.

  7. 26:27 Shechem's longing and the spark of Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon

    After fear comes a burning love, and the Rav notes that the Tanya's words of longing are those of the pesukim about Shechem and Dinah. Following the Midrash and the Ohr HaChaim, he explains that a hidden spark of Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon in Shechem longed for its own kind, and so a Jew, a part of G-d, must long for Hashem; he adds that Rabbi Chanina was a gabbai tzedakah, a root of chesed.

  8. 33:17 Love from Abba, fear from Imma, and da'as listed in the guide

    The Rav concludes that from chochmah, Abba, comes love, and from binah, Imma, comes fear, the two sides of right and left. He explains kelos hanefesh and the soul's thirst for Hashem from the element of fire, and that da'as means binding: the Ba'al HaTanya demands contemplation that is strong and sustained for long hours, not a moment.

  9. 38:13 Long davening and love that lasts

    The Rav recalls a talmid chacham in the Stoliner shul in Williamsburg who davened at length with contemplation and tears. Without da'as, he explains, love and fear are 'shav', not imaginary but without permanence; even passing life is worth something, yet the Ba'al HaTanya demands lasting life.

The shiur, written up

Chochmah and binah as father and mother

1:01

The Rav reads Tanya chapter three: the first flash of an idea is chochmah; once it gains length and breadth it is binah. They are called father and mother because their children are the middos, love and fear of Hashem. This, he explains, was the Ba'al HaTanya's view: one must work at understanding G-dliness, think it over and bind oneself to it with da'as, and that gives birth to the middos. a

The dispute among the Maggid's students

4:09

Most of the Maggid's other students, the Rav says, held that one need not rely so much on chochmah, binah and da'as and should begin with the middos. Both are true, as 'these and these are the words of the living G-d'; the question was how to teach the masses. A sefer he cites on Vayeshev compares it to Yosef and his brothers: a few strong people in a concentrated way, or many people with each receiving a little. The same divide stood between the Ba'al HaTanya and Rabbi Mottel of Chernobyl, over whether the Rebbe lifts the chassidim or they must lift themselves. b

The thinking soul and the endless creation

9:04

To explain why a person should engage in such thought, the Rav gives a mashal: a carpenter makes a table because he is a carpenter. So too, Hashem created man with a thinking soul, and when he puts that intellect to work and contemplates, a product comes out.

11:15

What does he contemplate? Hashem's greatness: He fills all worlds and surrounds all worlds. The Rav describes a creation without end; one could fly in a spaceship at the speed of light and never reach its end, because it has none, and beyond that is still Hashem. Nor does 'fills all worlds' mean only the planets and stars. Above them are the spiritual worlds, called olamos because they are hidden, and Hashem is beyond all of them.

Planets and angels: first fear, then love

16:09

The earth's orbit, a galgal, is like nothing beside the galgal of a greater planet, which is like a fly's eye beside others. Above them are souls and angels, each like nothing before the one above, up to the Kisei HaKavod. Such thought brings fear of Hashem and then love. The Rav insists it must begin with fear; love that comes first has something wrong with it, just as Sukkos follows Rosh Hashanah.

The order in the brachos of Krias Shema

20:27

This, the Rav says, is the order of the brachos of Krias Shema. Yotzer speaks of the luminaries and of the angels, so one is moved by Hashem's greatness and fear comes. He asks for whom Chazal instituted it if one says it in forty-five seconds without knowing what he said. Ahavah Rabbah follows, a bracha of love, and then Shema and Vehaya, accepting the yoke of Heaven and of the mitzvos. c,d,e

Fear of His exaltedness

24:11

Contemplation gives birth to fear of Hashem's exaltedness, not fear of punishment, which is like serving for reward. One who comes before a great tzaddik is gripped by fear without thinking of punishment. The Tanya speaks of shame, the Rav notes, because the Gemara reads 'His fear upon your faces' as bushah. a,f

Shechem's longing and Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon

26:30

After fear the heart burns with love and longing for Hashem. The Rav points out that the Tanya's words of longing are those the pesukim use for Shechem's desire for Dinah, and the Midrash notes that from Shechem one learns how to love Hashem. a,g,h

28:21

Why Shechem? Following the Ohr HaChaim, a hidden spark of Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon was in him, and when he saw Dinah it flared up, since every kind is drawn to its kind. If that spark longed so, a Jew, a part of G-d above, must long for Hashem. Rabbi Chanina was a devoted gabbai tzedakah, a spark of chesed, which is love. i

Love from Abba, fear from Imma, and da'as

33:31

From chochmah, Abba, comes love; from binah, Imma, comes fear: the right and the left. Kelos hanefesh means the soul longs to leave its place and cleave to Hashem, as David HaMelech says his soul thirsts for G-d. This thirst, the Rav explains, comes from the soul's element of fire, as the Arizal teaches. j,k

36:39

Da'as means binding, from 'Adam knew Chavah'. The Ba'al HaTanya demands contemplation that is strong and steady, sitting for long hours, not a moment. m

Love that lasts

38:35

The Rav recalls a great talmid chacham in the Stoliner shul in Williamsburg who davened at length with contemplation and tears. Without such da'as, he explains, love and fear are not imaginary but 'shav': real, yet without permanence. Even fleeting life counts for something, yet the Ba'al HaTanya demands lasting life.

Sources

Torah

  1. d apparently Devarim 6:4 index In the write-up: 20:27
  2. e apparently Devarim 11:13 index In the write-up: 20:27
  3. g apparently Bereishis 34:3-8 index In the write-up: 26:30
  4. m Bereishis 4:1 text index In the write-up: 36:39

Kesuvim

  1. k apparently Tehillim 42:3 index In the write-up: 33:31
  2. l apparently Tehillim 84:3 34:45 index

Talmud Bavli

  1. b apparently Eruvin 13b index In the write-up: 4:09
  2. f apparently Nedarim 20a index In the write-up: 24:11
  3. n Gemara (place not identified) 41:23 index

Midrash

  1. h Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 26:30

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a Tanya ch. 3 text index In the write-up: 1:01, 24:11, 26:30
  2. i apparently Ohr HaChaim, Bereishis 34:21 index In the write-up: 28:21

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. c apparently Shacharis, brachos of Krias Shema (Yotzer Or, Ahavah Rabbah) index In the write-up: 20:27

Other

  1. j Etz Chaim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 33:31

Key points

  1. 1:01 Chochmah is the first point of an idea and binah its development; they are called father and mother because they give birth to the middos, love and fear of Hashem.
  2. 2:04 The Ba'al HaTanya held that avodah must start with contemplating G-dliness through chochmah, binah and da'as, while most of the Maggid's other students began with the middos.
  3. 12:14 Contemplating Hashem's greatness, a creation with no end and worlds and angels each as nothing before the one above it, brings a person first to fear of Hashem and then to love.
  4. 24:11 The yirah born of contemplation is fear of His exaltedness, awe before His greatness, not fear of punishment.
  5. 36:45 Da'as means binding: only strong, sustained contemplation bound to the mind gives love and fear permanence; otherwise they are 'shav', real but passing.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 1:37 Why are chochmah and binah called father and mother?

    Answer: 1:42 Because their children are the middos, love and fear of Hashem, which they give birth to.

  2. Question: 14:09 Why are the higher realms called olamos, worlds?

    Answer: 14:09 Because they are hidden (ne'lam), beyond what the human mind is equipped to grasp.

  3. Question: 18:51 Why must avodah begin with fear and not with love?

    Answer: 18:54 If it begins with love, something is wrong with it; first comes fear, then love, as Rosh Hashanah and the Ten Days come before Sukkos.

  4. Question: 21:06 For whom did Chazal institute birchas Yotzer, if one says it in forty-five seconds without knowing what he said?

    Answer: 20:57 It is a bracha of contemplating Hashem's greatness, meant to bring a person to fear as the angels fear Him.

  5. Question: 29:42 Why did Shechem have such a great desire for Dinah?

    Answer: 29:01 The spark of holiness of Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon within him longed for holiness, since every kind is drawn to its own kind.

  6. Question: 40:09 What does the Tanya mean by calling love and fear without da'as 'shav'?

    Answer: 40:14 Not that they are imaginary; they are real love and fear, but they have no permanence and pass away.

Stories

  1. 38:20 A long davening in the Stoliner shul

    The Rav recalls a Jew, a great talmid chacham, who davened in the Stoliner shul in Williamsburg where the Rav himself davened. He would sit down to daven with contemplation and with relish, until tears ran from both his eyes. Others would go home, eat, rest a little and learn, and come back to shul, while he was still davening. The Rav brings him as an example of contemplation with persistence and with all one's strength.

Insights

  1. 5:15 The Rav presents the dispute between the Ba'al HaTanya and the other students of the Maggid not as a question of truth, since both views are true, but of which path to teach the masses: the Ba'al HaTanya demanded that ordinary people learn chochmah of G-dliness, while the others may have done so themselves but worked differently with the public.
  2. 5:51 He likens this to the dispute between Yosef and his brothers: whether to work with a few strong, great people in a concentrated way or with many, where each receives only a little.
  3. 7:27 The same divide, he says, separated the Ba'al HaTanya from Rabbi Mottel of Chernobyl: whether the Rebbe lifts up the chassidim, who bind themselves to him, or whether the chassidim must lift themselves.
  4. 20:27 The Rav finds the Tanya's path in the order of the brachos of Krias Shema: Yotzer contemplates the luminaries and the angels and brings fear, Ahavah Rabbah brings love, and only then come Shema and Vehaya, accepting the yoke of Heaven and of the mitzvos.
  5. 27:55 Shechem's intense words of desire for Dinah came from a hidden spark of Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon within him that longed for its own kind; from this the Rav learns that a Jew, a part of G-d above, must long for Hashem in the same way.
  6. 32:14 He adds that the love-language came specifically through Shechem because Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon was a devoted gabbai tzedakah, a spark of chesed, and chesed is love.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 37:03 The Rav says that contemplation of Hashem's greatness should not be for a moment or two, but sitting for long hours and thinking about it with all one's powers of thought.
  2. 20:57 He says birchas Yotzer is meant to be a bracha of contemplating Hashem's greatness, not something said in forty-five seconds without knowing what one said.
  3. 18:36 According to the Rav, avodah must begin with fear of Hashem, and only after it comes love.
  4. 30:56 He says that a Jew, being a part of G-d above, must arouse in himself a longing for Hashem.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Dinah, Dovid HaMelech, Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon, Rabbi Mordechai (Mottel) of Chernobyl, Shechem ben Chamor, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Maggid of Mezritch, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, Yosef HaTzaddik

Terms אימא עילאה, ארבע יסודות, בושה, בינה, גלגול, דעת, התבוננות, התקשרות, חכמה, יראת הרוממות, כסא הכבוד, ממלא כל עלמין, ניצוצות, רבונו של עולם

Report an error on this page