עונשים -על הנאה גשמיות' לעם הארץ שמבטל תורה' לתלמיד חכם המבטל תורה; לימוד חכמת חיצוניות יותר חמור מדברים בטלים.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' ח no. ⁨24⁩ Pocket Guide p. 43 Yiddish 46 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 46 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Continuing Tanya chapter 8, the Rav explains the lasting imprint of physical pleasure and idle talk, the special severity of bitul Torah for one who can learn, and why secular wisdom studied for its own sake is worse than idle talk, permitted only as a means for the sake of Heaven.

The Rav continues Tanya chapter 8. Forbidden food comes from the three impure kelipos, and even a rabbinic prohibition rests on the food itself. Kosher food eaten for pleasure falls temporarily into kelipas noga; even if later elevated, an imprint remains in the body, like a stain that survives washing, and only chibut hakever removes it, unless one, like Rebbi, never enjoyed this world. Idle talk of an am ha'aretz is kelipas noga, cleansed by kaf hakela; a talmid chacham who could learn commits bitul Torah, with its own severe punishment, beyond the cold Gehinom for neglected positive mitzvos. Secular wisdom is worse than idle talk: idle talk comes from the middos, as animals chatter, while wisdom comes from chabad that fell into kelipah at the breaking of the vessels. It is allowed only as a means, for parnassah or serving Hashem, with honest calculations and never through studies bound up with heresy and sin.

Topics: The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · Torah Lishmah and Hasmadah · Kedushah and Kelipah · Thought and the Power of Speech

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Forbidden food and the impure kelipos

    The Rav reads Tanya on forbidden food, which cannot be elevated, and mentions the Tzemach Tzedek's notes on rabbinic prohibitions, explaining that even a rabbinic prohibition rests on the food itself. He contrasts the desire for forbidden things, from the gentile 'demons' of the impure kelipos, with the desire for kosher things, which can be elevated.

  2. 4:02 The imprint of permitted pleasure listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that kosher food eaten for pleasure enters kelipas noga and leaves an imprint in the body even after teshuvah, like a stain that survives washing, removed only by chibut hakever. He brings Rebbi, who raised his ten fingers and said he had not enjoyed this world, though he was very wealthy, as Rashi in Toldos shows.

  3. 9:32 Idle talk: the am ha'aretz and the talmid chacham listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that the idle talk of an am ha'aretz who cannot learn is not itself a sin, but is kelipas noga and needs cleansing by kaf hakela. A talmid chacham who could learn commits bitul Torah, and the Rav explains the fire Gehinom for active sins, the snow Gehinom for neglected positive mitzvos, and a special punishment for bitul Torah.

  4. 16:34 Secular wisdom counts as idle talk listed in the guide

    The Rav reads Tanya that the wisdom of the nations is included in idle talk regarding bitul Torah, and is worse. Mathematics or physics studied when one could learn is idle talk compared to Torah. He brings Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya to show that the wisdom of the nations rises and falls opposite the sages of Torah.

  5. 20:35 Earlier generations' depth, today's details

    In a digression the Rav observes that recent generations developed pilpul and new chiddushim, while the earlier Rishonim had deeper knowledge; likewise the nations' earlier wise men pursued wisdom for its own sake, while today's science is details and machinery. A doctor once knew a patient's state from his face and pulse; today it is tests and electronics.

  6. 24:20 Idle talk from the middos, wisdom from chabad listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that empty chatter comes from the middos, as animals bark and sing, while wisdom comes from chabad, and kelipah too has chabad. So one who studies secular wisdom to be a scientist when he could learn does greater damage than one who tells jokes, since the impurity reaches the soul's chabad. He then rereads the Tanya's words on this.

  7. 30:41 The breaking of the vessels listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the beginning of Tanya chapter 3: the seven middos have good and evil, while chabad is only good. He explains, calling it an awesome matter, that at the breaking of the vessels chochmah fell into the kelipos, which is why the nations have wisdom, and why engaging in it gives the kelipah a hold on something from a very high place.

  8. 33:56 Torah lishmah, secular wisdom only as a means listed in the guide

    The Rav explains the exception: one who studies secular wisdom for parnassah, to support his family in Torah and to learn, elevates it like eating for the sake of Heaven. Torah must be learned lishmah and never as a spade, as the Mishnah says, while secular wisdom must be learned as a spade, not for its own sake; a better-paying profession can leave more time to learn.

  9. 39:26 All wisdom is found in the Torah listed in the guide

    The Rav explains the reason of the Rambam and Ramban for studying these wisdoms: to serve Hashem, such as drawing people closer to Torah. He adds that they knew the wisdoms from the Torah itself, citing the Ramban's introduction to Chumash, and points to tzaddikim whom doctors consulted and Rebbes who wrote prescriptions without schooling, since one who learns lishmah knows everything.

  10. 42:54 Honest calculations and the two conditions listed in the guide

    The Rav warns that the intent must be honest: few who study medicine do so for chessed, and many calculations about parnassah are false. An aveirah cannot be done lishmah, so college, where one must study heresy and faces tests of immorality, has no heter even for parnassah. He concludes with two conditions: intent for the sake of Heaven and studies free of prohibitions.

The shiur, written up

Forbidden food and the impure kelipos

0:08

The Rav reads the Tanya's words that forbidden food cannot be elevated, even if one ate it for the sake of Heaven. He mentions the Tzemach Tzedek's notes, printed in Derech Mitzvosecha, and explains that in the Ba'al HaTanya's view even a rabbinic prohibition rests on the food itself, so it too comes from the impure kelipos. a,b

2:25

The desire for forbidden things, the Tanya says, comes from gentile 'demons'. The desire for kosher things is like a Jewish one, and it can still be elevated. a

The imprint of permitted pleasure

4:20

Kosher food eaten only for pleasure, the Rav explains, is drawn down into kelipas noga until the person uses its strength to serve Hashem. Even then an imprint remains, because the food has become blood and flesh. He compares it to a stain on a cloth: after washing, a mark remains, and it needs a stronger detergent. That detergent is chibut hakever, the beating in the grave. a

5:56

Only one who never enjoyed this world is spared, like Rebbi, who at his passing raised his ten fingers and said he had not enjoyed it even with his little finger. This is a great chiddush, since Rebbi was very rich, as Rashi in Toldos shows, and had every food even out of season. c,d

Idle talk: the am ha'aretz and the talmid chacham

10:40

Turning to idle talk, the Rav explains that the prohibition lies not in the words themselves but in failing to speak words of Torah. An am ha'aretz who cannot learn commits no sin when he talks idly. He may be judged for not having learned in his youth, though Hashem knows each person's circumstances. Still, his idle talk is kelipas noga, like food eaten not for Heaven, and must be cleansed through kaf hakela, where the soul is thrown back and forth.

13:35

A talmid chacham who could learn, however, commits bitul Torah. The Rav explains the two Gehinoms: one of fire for a sin done with warmth and energy, one of snow for the coldness and laziness of neglecting a positive mitzvah. Torah study equals all the mitzvos, so its neglect carries a special punishment beyond that cold Gehinom.

Secular wisdom counts as idle talk

16:34

The Tanya adds that the wisdom of the nations is included in idle talk regarding bitul Torah, as in Hilchos Talmud Torah, and is even worse. The Rav explains that one who spends time on mathematics or nuclear physics when he could learn is engaged in idle talk compared to Torah. a,e

19:23

Hashem made the forces of holiness and impurity to balance each other. Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, who debated the minim, told his students that when he is gone, they too will not be, for without sages of Torah there are no wise men of the nations. f

Earlier generations' depth, today's details

20:35

In a digression, the Rav observes that recent generations developed pilpul and new chiddushim, while the earlier Rishonim had deeper, more fundamental knowledge. Among the nations too, the earlier wise men pursued wisdom for its own sake, while today's discoveries are details. A doctor once knew a patient's condition from his face and pulse; today it is machinery and tests, a wisdom of details without depth.

Idle talk from the middos, wisdom from chabad

24:44

Natural desires, the Rav explains, come from the middos, and so does empty chatter with no value: animals do the same, a dog barks and birds sing. Wisdom comes from chabad, and kelipah too has chabad, in its 'back side'.

25:59

So one who studies the sciences to become a scientist, when he could learn, does more damage than one who tells jokes. Jokes come only from the middos of kelipah, and people can sit and talk all day with nothing to show for it. Secular wisdom clothes the soul's chabad in kelipah, where impurity should never reach, so the defilement is greater.

29:06

Rereading the Tanya, he explains that idle talk clothes only the lower middos of the G-dly soul in kelipas noga; the soul's chabad is untouched, since even fools can speak nonsense. a

The breaking of the vessels

30:51

The Rav brings the beginning of Tanya chapter 3: the seven middos have good and evil, while chabad is only good. How, then, can the nations have wisdom? At the breaking of the vessels, which he calls an awesome matter, the vessels could not hold the lights and burst, and chochmah fell to the kelipos. Since this wisdom comes from so high a place, engaging in it gives the kelipah a hold where it should have none. g

Torah lishmah, secular wisdom only as a means

33:56

The exception is one who studies secular wisdom for the sake of Heaven: for parnassah, so he can support his family, raise them in Torah and learn himself. This elevates it, like eating for the sake of Heaven, but it must remain a means and not a goal.

35:23

The Rav draws the contrast: Torah must be learned lishmah, and as the Mishnah says, not used as a spade to gain a rabbinic post, honor or parnassah. Secular wisdom is the reverse: it may be learned only as a spade. Wanting to be a professor is goyish. A profession that pays more can leave more hours for learning. h

All wisdom is found in the Torah

39:27

One may also study to serve Hashem, for example to draw people closer to Torah; this, the Tanya says, was the reason of the Rambam and Ramban. Yet they knew the wisdoms from the Torah itself, as the Ramban writes in his introduction to Chumash. The Rav points to a tzaddik whom great doctors consulted and to Rebbes who wrote prescriptions without schooling: whoever learns lishmah knows everything. a,i

Honest calculations and the two conditions

43:09

The calculation must be honest. Some study medicine out of a desire to do chessed, but most want an honorable profession. Many parnassah calculations are false and bring no more time to learn.

44:29

An aveirah cannot be done lishmah. College requires studying heresy, from the three impure kelipos, and brings tests of immorality, so there is no heter even for parnassah; better to collect at doors. Secular study is permitted only on two conditions: intent for the sake of Heaven, and studies free of prohibitions.

Sources

Mishnah

  1. h Avos 4:5 text index In the write-up: 35:23

Talmud Bavli

  1. c Kesubos 104a text index In the write-up: 5:56
  2. f apparently Chagigah 5b index In the write-up: 19:23

Rishonim

  1. d apparently Rashi on Bereishis 25:23 index In the write-up: 5:56
  2. i apparently Ramban, introduction to Bereishis index In the write-up: 39:27

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya ch. 8 index In the write-up: 0:08, 2:25, 4:20, 16:34, 29:06, 39:27
  2. b Derech Mitzvosecha (place not identified) index In the write-up: 0:08
  3. e Hilchos Talmud Torah (Shulchan Aruch HaRav) (place not identified) index In the write-up: 16:34
  4. g apparently Tanya ch. 3 index In the write-up: 30:51

Key points

  1. 4:13 Kosher food eaten for pleasure falls into kelipas noga, and even after it is elevated an imprint remains in the body that only chibut hakever removes.
  2. 10:09 Idle talk of one who cannot learn is kelipas noga, while for a talmid chacham who could learn it is the sin of bitul Torah, with its own severe punishment.
  3. 19:08 Studying secular wisdom when one could learn Torah is worse than idle talk, because it clothes the soul's chabad in kelipah.
  4. 31:48 Secular wisdom reached the nations through the breaking of the vessels, when chochmah fell into the kelipos.
  5. 35:23 Torah must be learned for its own sake, while secular wisdom may be learned only as a means, for parnassah or to serve Hashem.
  6. 44:51 The permission has two conditions: the intent must be for the sake of Heaven, and the studies may not be bound up with prohibitions such as heresy.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 10:52 Why is the idle talk of an am ha'aretz not itself a sin, while that of a talmid chacham is?

    Answer: 10:40 The prohibition is not in the idle words themselves but in not speaking words of Torah; one who cannot learn is not neglecting Torah, while one who can is guilty of bitul Torah.

  2. Question: 27:39 Why is studying secular wisdom worse than idle talk and jokes?

    Answer: 26:20 Idle talk comes from the middos of kelipah, but wisdom comes from the chabad of kelipah, so it defiles the soul's chabad, a higher place that idle talk does not touch.

  3. Question: 32:09 How can the nations possess true wisdom, which is from holiness?

    Answer: 31:54 At the breaking of the vessels the vessels could not hold the lights and burst, and chochmah fell to the place of the kelipos, where it remains until the end.

  4. Question: 40:49 How did the Rambam and Ramban, and later tzaddikim, know the secular wisdoms without schooling?

    Answer: 41:10 They knew them from the Torah itself; one who learns Torah lishmah knows everything.

Stories

  1. 5:56 Rebbi's ten fingers

    The Rav relates from the Gemara that when Rebbi was passing away, he raised his ten fingers and said to the Ribono shel Olam that he had not enjoyed this world even with his little finger. The Rav stresses that this is a great chiddush, because Rebbi was very rich and had all foods even out of season, which in those days had to be brought from afar at great expense.

    In the story: Rebbi (Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi)

    told in 1 other shiur →

  2. 19:52 Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya and the debates

    The Rav tells that Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya used to debate the minim. When he was passing away, his students asked who would now conduct the debates for them, and he answered that when he is gone, they too will no longer be.

    In the story: Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya

    told in 3 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 7:30 The imprint of permitted pleasure is like a stain that remains after washing: even teshuvah removes the kelipas noga, but the trace needs a stronger 'detergent', chibut hakever.
  2. 14:35 The two Gehinoms match two failures: fire for one who warmed himself to an active sin, snow for the coldness and laziness of neglecting a positive mitzvah.
  3. 24:59 Idle chatter is a drive of the middos that even animals share, barking and singing; secular wisdom is worse precisely because its impurity reaches the higher level of chabad.
  4. 35:23 Torah and secular wisdom are opposites: Torah must be learned lishmah and not as a spade, while secular wisdom may be learned only as a spade and never for its own sake.
  5. 19:23 The wisdom of the nations rises and falls opposite the sages of Torah, as zeh l'umas zeh; when the Torah's sages are gone, the nations' wise men also decline.
  6. 44:29 An aveirah cannot be done lishmah, so a good intention cannot permit studies that require learning heresy, which comes from the three impure kelipos rather than kelipas noga.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 35:17 The Rav says secular wisdom may be studied only as a means, for parnassah or to serve Hashem, and never for its own sake or to become a learned man.
  2. 43:50 The Rav says one who studies for parnassah must make honest calculations, since many such calculations are false and do not bring more time for learning.
  3. 44:41 The Rav says studies that require learning heresy or bring tests of immorality, as in college, have no heter even for parnassah; it is better to collect at doors than to earn a living that way.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Antoninus, Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi (Rebbi), Rashi, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Rambam, the Ramban, the Tzemach Tzedek

Terms אפיקורס, ביטול תורה, גיהנום, דברים בטלים, חב"ד, חיבוט הקבר, לשמה, עם הארץ, קליפת נוגה, שבירת הכלים, שלש קליפות הטמאות

Report an error on this page