יש כמה מדריגות במדריגת אמת. הדרכה וי"ד שלא להיות עצוב כשבאים אצלו מחשבות רעות ועצה איך להתחזק כנגדם.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' י"ג no. 30 Pocket Guide p. 44 Yiddish 42 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that truth has many levels, so the beinoni's prayer is true by his own measure, and that a beinoni should not be saddened by bad thoughts but fight them through the hidden love every Jew has for Hashem.
Continuing Tanya chapter 13, the Rav explains why a beinoni's love in prayer is not called 'avodas emes' compared to tzaddikim: truth is lasting, as 'sfas emes tikon la'ad', and a fervor that gives way to desire after davening shows it lacked truth. Yet truth has levels. Yaakov, the attribute of truth, is the middle bar running through all the boards of the Mishkan, each board a level of Jews, so what is falsehood for a higher person is truth for a lower one. He brings the Yismach Moshe's answer to the Rema: every Jew has his own reading of the Torah by his level. Moving to chapter 14, he teaches that a beinoni must not feel bad about bad thoughts; he should rejoice at the chance to fulfil 'lo sasuru', strengthen himself with the hidden love that makes even simple Jews give their lives, and fight every sin.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Thought and the Power of Speech
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why the beinoni's prayer is not called truth listed in the guide
Continuing Tanya chapter 13, the Rav explains that the beinoni subdues evil only during prayer, and that relative to tzaddikim this is not 'avodas emes'. Truth, he explains from 'sfas emes tikon la'ad', is lasting, while falsehood and the pleasures of this world are momentary and leave a person empty.
-
4:34 Yaakov, the middle bar of the Mishkan listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Yaakov, the attribute of tiferes, is the middle bar that runs from end to end through the boards of the Mishkan, each board being a level among Jews. He reads the names Yisrael and Yaakov as spanning head to heel, and brings the Yerushalmi that the boards had a fixed order, marked by writing, which may not be changed.
-
8:29 Each level has its own truth listed in the guide
Since Yaakov's attribute of truth passes through every board, the Rav concludes that each Jew has his own level of truth. For a tzaddik, desire returning after prayer shows the prayer was falsehood; for a beinoni, being cleaved to Hashem during prayer alone is the truth of his level, as the Tanya says.
-
11:59 Every Jew's own reading of the Torah listed in the guide
From 'darosh darash', the middle of the Torah in the week's parsha, the Rav learns that every Jew has his own interpretation of the Torah by his level. He illustrates it with the Rema that one who is 'mafleg bachasidus' may give his life even for other mitzvos, and the Yismach Moshe's answer to how this fits 'vachai bahem'.
-
18:32 Two readings of 'sfas emes tikon la'ad' listed in the guide
The Rav applies this to the passuk 'sfas emes tikon la'ad': for the great tzaddik it means truth that never fades, while for the beinoni it means truth that is stored away until his next prayer. He reads the Tanya's words that the attribute of truth is Yaakov's, the middle bar and a 'heritage without bounds', reaching every level, and illustrates with how a twelve-hour learning day is judged differently for the Chofetz Chaim and for a young bochur.
-
23:39 Chapter 14: the beinoni and free choice listed in the guide
Having finished the Tanya's foundations, the Rav begins chapter 14: the beinoni never acts on the yetzer hara's words though he hears them, and he should not feel bad that bad thoughts come after davening, since this is how he was created. Being repulsed by evil is not always in a person's power, but his thought, speech and action always are.
-
28:35 Rejoicing at the mitzvah of 'lo sasuru' listed in the guide
The Rav teaches that the first bad thought is not in a person's control and he need not feel bad about it; on the contrary, he should rejoice, since pushing it out fulfils 'lo sasuru acharei levavchem', one of the greatest mitzvos, which breaks the sitra achra. He then reads the Tanya's declaration that one does not want to be separated from Hashem but to cleave to Him with thought, speech and action.
-
32:49 The hidden love and the spirit of folly listed in the guide
The Rav explains the hidden love, mentioned here for the first time in the Tanya: every Jew, even a wicked one, has it, and at a time of decree to serve idols simple Jews gave their lives. He asks why such a Jew commits other sins, and answers with the Tanya that a spirit of folly makes him think other sins do not cut him off, so the beinoni resolves to fight the yetzer hara over every sin.
-
38:16 Love with delight, and the beinoni's work listed in the guide
The Rav explains that truly despising evil comes only from 'ahavah betaanugim', which the tzaddik has constantly and the beinoni only at moments, especially on Shabbos and Yom Tov, a gift like 'avodas matanah'. When it is absent, desire for this world fills the void; this answers the question of Iyov 'You created tzaddikim', and the beinoni's work is never to obey the yetzer hara.
The shiur, written up
Why the beinoni's prayer is not called truth
Yaakov, the middle bar of the Mishkan
The Tanya then calls the beinoni's service true by his own measure. To explain, the Rav brings Yaakov Avinu, the middle bar that runs 'from end to end' through the boards of the Mishkan, each board a level among Jews. All of Klal Yisrael is in Yaakov, from the highest Jew to the lowest, who has only the point of a Jew. d
Each level has its own truth
Every Jew's own reading of the Torah
The Rav notes that 'darosh darash' in the week's parsha is the middle of the Torah, its seed. From there begin its six hundred thousand interpretations, matching the root souls, and every Jew has his own interpretation according to his level. i
Two readings of 'sfas emes tikon la'ad'
So too, the Rav explains, 'sfas emes tikon la'ad' reads differently by level. For the great tzaddik, desire after davening shows the prayer lacked truth. For the beinoni it means truth packed away until his next prayer, when with true preparation he can again keep the yetzer hara from disturbing him. b
Chapter 14: the beinoni and free choice
Rejoicing at the mitzvah of 'lo sasuru'
The first bad thought, the Rav teaches, is not in his control. Rather than feel bad, he should rejoice: pushing it away fulfils 'lo sasuru acharei levavchem', which the Gemara explains as heresy and immoral thoughts. Driving out a thought of idolatry, which the first commandment forbids, breaks the sitra achra. r,t,u
The hidden love and the spirit of folly
Here, the Rav notes, the Tanya first mentions the hidden love. Every Jew has it, even a wicked one, and in a time of decree it would make him give his life rather than serve idols; throughout history simple Jews were killed rather than do so.
Love with delight, and the beinoni's work
Sources
Torah
- d Shemos 26:28 text index In the write-up: 5:04
- e Shemos 26:30 text index In the write-up: 7:15
- i Vayikra 10:16 text index In the write-up: 12:07
- m Vayikra 18:5 text index In the write-up: 14:57
- o Bereishis 28:14 text index In the write-up: 20:26
- r Bamidbar 15:39 text index In the write-up: 29:21
- u Shemos 20:3 text index In the write-up: 29:21
- z Bamidbar 18:7 text index In the write-up: 38:40
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Acharonim and Chassidus
- a apparently Tanya ch. 13 index In the write-up: 0:40
- h apparently Tanya ch. 13 index In the write-up: 10:38
- k apparently Shulchan Aruch Yoreh De'ah 157:1 index In the write-up: 14:57
- l Yismach Moshe (place not identified) index In the write-up: 14:57, 16:16
- n apparently Tanya ch. 13 index In the write-up: 20:26
- p apparently Tanya ch. 14 index In the write-up: 23:39
- s Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) 28:56 index
- w apparently Tanya ch. 14 index In the write-up: 36:27
Key points
- 2:22 Truth is what endures: a tzaddik's fervor in prayer that gives way to desire for this world afterward shows that it lacked truth.
- 9:00 Truth has levels: what would be falsehood for a higher person is true service for a lower one, according to his level.
- 14:49 Every Jew has his own reading of the Torah according to his level, as the Yismach Moshe answers the question on the Rema.
- 25:46 A beinoni should not feel bad when bad thoughts come to him even after good preparation for davening; this is how he was created and his mission in the world.
- 29:37 When a bad thought comes he should rejoice, since pushing it away fulfils the mitzvah of 'lo sasuru' and breaks the sitra achra.
- 32:56 Every Jew, even the worst, has a hidden love for Hashem that would make him give his life rather than serve idols; he sins only because a spirit of folly makes him forget it.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:14 If the tzaddik truly cleaved to Hashem in prayer, why does desire for this world come back afterward?
Answer: 2:30 Truth is lasting, as 'sfas emes tikon la'ad'; if the desire returns, it is a sign that the prayer lacked truth.
-
Question: 15:43 How can the Rema say that one who is 'mafleg bachasidus' may give his life for any mitzvah, when the Torah says 'vachai bahem'?
Answer: 16:16 The Yismach Moshe answers that every Jew has his own reading by his level: for a great servant of Hashem, 'life' means the soul's life in Torah, which is lost by transgressing.
-
Question: 25:52 Why, after all his preparation for davening, do bad thoughts come to the beinoni afterward?
Answer: 26:10 This is how he was created and his mission in the world; he need not feel bad about it.
-
Question: 36:27 If even a simple Jew has a hidden love that would make him give his life, why does he commit other sins?
Answer: 36:39 A spirit of folly enters him and makes him think that other sins do not cut him off from his Judaism, so he forgets his hidden love.
Insights
- 3:21 The Rav defines truth by permanence: worldly pleasure is like a 'chalal', one slain, empty of content, and leaves a void, while joy in a Yom Tov, a mitzvah or a blatt Gemara remains even afterward.
- 5:51 Yisrael begins with the letters that make it 'li rosh', a head, and Yaakov is 'akev', the heel, with the small yud as its point; so Yaakov binds all Jews from the highest to the lowest, who has nothing but the point of a Jew.
- 7:58 Because each board of the Mishkan is a level of Jews and Yaakov's attribute of truth passes through all of them, the same service can be falsehood for a higher person and truth for a lower one.
- 16:55 Following the Yismach Moshe, for a great servant of Hashem 'vachai bahem' means the life of the soul in Torah, so for him losing a mitzvah is death, and he may give his life for it.
- 19:26 For the beinoni, 'sfas emes tikon la'ad' means a truth that is packed away and waits for the next prayer, when with true preparation he can again keep the yetzer hara from disturbing him.
- 29:50 Without a bad thought the beinoni could not fulfil 'lo sasuru', so its coming is a chance for one of the Torah's greatest mitzvos, and pushing out a thought of idolatry breaks the root of the sitra achra.
- 39:07 The beinoni has 'ahavah betaanugim' only at moments, so when it is absent the desire for this world fills the place, since there is no vacuum.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 25:46 The Rav says the beinoni should not feel bad when bad thoughts come to him after davening.
- 29:37 He says that when a bad thought comes one should rather rejoice at the chance to fulfil 'lo sasuru'.
- 28:08 He explains that when the first thought comes, a person can drive it away by turning his mind to words of Torah.
- 38:02 He says the beinoni's work is always to strive not to obey the yetzer hara, and to fight it over every sin.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Iyov, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Eliezer (ben Hurkenos), the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chofetz Chaim, the Rambam, the Rema, the Yismach Moshe, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms אהבה בתענוגים, אהבה מסותרת, אמת, בינוני, יצר הרע, מסירות נפש, נחלה, עבודה זרה, עבודת מתנה, צדיק גמור, רוח שטות