הקב"ה ודיבורו אחד ממש. אלא לגבי נבראים יש צמצומים.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' כ"א no. 43 Pocket Guide p. 45 Yiddish 33 min
Listen
About this shiur
Learning Tanya chapter 21, the Rav explains that Hashem's speech is not separate from Him as human speech is; it is one with His essence, and the tzimtzumim and concealments exist only from the side of the creations who receive.
The Rav places chapter 21 within a five-chapter unit showing that any sin, even the smallest, cuts a Jew off from Hashem like idolatry, since Anochi and Lo yihyeh are the roots of all the mitzvos; the Ba'al Shem Tov, he notes, said this in one word. He then explains that human speech is communication that separates from the speaker and is felt, which the Ba'al haTanya could sense and which a tape recorder now shows, and he tells the story of the Ba'al haTanya and the king in prison. Hashem's speech, by contrast, is not separate from Him; it is called speech only as a mashal, as Dovid compared himself to a desert bird only in his loneliness. Like a person's desire in the heart before it becomes thought, Hashem's speech is one with His essence, and nothing changed through creation. Only from the side of the recipients are there tzimtzumim and hester panim; for Him darkness is like light, and like the kamtza whose shell is part of itself, His garments are Himself.
Topics: Tzimtzum, the Worlds and the Merkavah · Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · Foundations of Emunah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Every sin as idolatry: the Ba'al Shem Tov's word
The Rav places the chapter within a five-chapter unit explaining that any sin cuts one off from Hashem like idolatry, since Anochi and Lo yihyeh are the roots of all positive and negative mitzvos. He says these are deep chapters he will go through quickly, and notes that the Ba'al Shem Tov said all this in one word on 'and you will turn away and serve other gods'.
-
4:12 Human speech and Hashem's speech listed in the guide
The Rav explains that human speech is the communication that carries one person's thought over to another, as 'yadber amim' means leading over, and it separates from the speaker. Hashem's speech is not separate from Him; it is called speech only as a mashal. He contrasts the Rishonim's answer that a Sanhedrin is fixed but its ruling goes out as separate, which cannot apply to Hashem.
-
8:26 Speech is felt: the Ba'al haTanya in prison Story
Reading the opening of chapter 21, the Rav explains that the Ba'al haTanya, with his fine senses, could feel the speech that leaves a person, which a tape recorder shows today. He tells how the king came in disguise to the Ba'al haTanya in prison and tested him on the time and on the number of coins from the table to the ceiling.
-
12:55 Why it is called speech: a mashal listed in the guide
The Rav explains that nothing is separate from Hashem, since His glory fills the earth, and His speech is not like ours just as His thoughts are not ours. He asks why it is called speech at all and answers that it is a mashal for revelation, like Dovid's comparison to a desert bird, and that the ten utterances and all of Tanach are His speech. He then shows that human speech expresses thought, and thought itself comes from a deeper root.
-
18:31 Desire before thought: speech one with His essence listed in the guide
The Rav explains that every thought is stirred by a desire in the heart, as when a person wants to eat, before it becomes letters of thought. For a person, speech is a power of a power; for Hashem, speech is His very essence, united with Him as the desire is united with a person's self, and there is no change in Him through creation.
-
22:29 Two points of view: Creator and recipients listed in the guide
The Rav says the Nefesh HaChaim discusses this at length: no place is empty of Hashem, yet a person relates to his things as real. There are two perspectives: from the Creator's side only His glory fills the earth, while from the recipients' side we live in a world of imagination. He asks how anything can exist after creation if before it there was only Hashem, and answers that for Him it is all the same.
-
26:19 Tzimtzumim only for the receivers; the kamtza listed in the guide
Rereading the text, the Rav explains that the many tzimtzumim and the hester panim exist so the creations can receive the light without being nullified, but before Hashem darkness is like light. With the mashal of the kamtza whose shell is part of itself, and the halachah that one's own hand is not a head covering while another's hand is, he shows that Hashem's garments are His own essence. He closes by saying he will stop here and review.
The shiur, written up
Every sin as idolatry
The Rav places this chapter within a five-chapter unit showing that any sin, even the smallest, cuts a person off from Hashem as idolatry does, only people do not know it. Since Anochi and Lo yihyeh are the roots of all the mitzvos, transgressing any mitzvah touches idolatry. The Ba'al Shem Tov, he notes, said this in one word on 'and you turn aside and serve other gods': one who turns from the Torah is already serving other gods. a,b
Human speech and Hashem's speech
Speech is felt: the Ba'al haTanya in prison
Reading the opening of chapter 21, the Rav explains that a person's speech is felt. The Ba'al haTanya, with his fine senses, could feel it; today a tape recorder shows it. c
He tells how the king came in disguise to the Ba'al haTanya in prison, who made the blessing on a king. Asked the time in a windowless cell, he answered exactly, explaining that the permutations of Hashem's Name rule every moment and he is never distracted from Hashem. When the king secretly raised the table by a coin before asking how many coins reach the ceiling, he answered one less. f
Why it is called speech
With Hashem nothing is separate, since His glory fills the earth and no place is empty of Him; His speech is unlike ours, as His thoughts are not ours. The Rav asks why it is called speech at all, and answers that it is a mashal: as speech reveals hidden thought to a listener, His bringing forth of light to the creations is called speech. g,h,i,c
Desire before thought
Every thought is stirred by a desire in the heart: a hungry person's heart sends a message to his mind, which then plans how to eat. For a person speech is a power of a power, but Hashem's speech is His very essence, united with Him as the desire is with a person's self, and creation brought no change in Him. c
Two points of view
The Rav says the Nefesh HaChaim discusses this at length. There are two views: from the Creator's side only His glory fills the earth; from the recipients' side we perceive separate things, living in a world of imagination Hashem made for us. Before creation there was only Hashem, and as 'You were before the world was created' shows, for Him nothing changed. l,g,m
Tzimtzumim only for the receivers
Rereading the text, the Rav explains that the many tzimtzumim and the hester panim exist only for the recipients, who could not bear the full light. To them Hashem's speech seems separate, like a person's, but before Him there is no concealment: darkness is like light. c,n
His garments do not separate from Him, like the kamtza, whose shell is the creature itself. Hashem and Elokim are one. In halachah, one's own hand is no head covering for davening, but another person's hand is; a garment of oneself is no garment. o,p
He closes by saying he will stop here, review, and not add more complicated matters.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 1:22 Chapters 20-24 of Tanya show that every sin, even the smallest, cuts a person off from Hashem like idolatry, because Anochi and Lo yihyeh are the roots of all the mitzvos.
- 4:57 Human speech is communication that leaves the speaker and becomes something separate from him; Hashem's speech is not separate from Him at all.
- 14:21 Hashem's word is called 'speech' only as a mashal: as human speech reveals hidden thought to a listener, His speech is the revelation of His light to the creations.
- 18:02 Like a person's desire in the heart before it becomes letters of thought, Hashem's speech is one with His essence, and creation changed nothing for Him.
- 27:20 The tzimtzumim and hester panim exist only from the side of the recipients, so that they can bear the light; for Hashem darkness is like light and His garments are Himself.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 7:22 How can a Sanhedrin rule by majority, when a fixed body counts as half and half?
Answer: 7:51 The Rishonim answer that the court itself is fixed, but the ruling that goes out from it is separate; the Rav adds that this cannot be said of Hashem.
-
Question: 14:14 If Hashem's speech is not like human speech and is not separate from Him, why is it called speech?
Answer: 14:27 It is a mashal: as human speech reveals to a listener what was hidden in the speaker's thought, Hashem's bringing forth of His light from concealment to the creations is called speech.
-
Question: 25:26 Before creation there was only Hashem; how can there be anything besides Him after creation?
Answer: 25:53 For Hashem there is no change between before and after creation; the world exists only from the side of the recipients.
Stories
-
9:36 The Ba'al haTanya and the king in prison
When the Ba'al haTanya was in prison, the king came to him in disguise; on his entering, the Ba'al haTanya made the blessing for a king, knowing it was the ruler. In a closed cell without windows, the king asked him what time it was, and he answered exactly. Asked how he knew, he said that Hashem created the world with the Name Havayah, whose permutations rule each hour, minute and second, and since he is never distracted from Hashem, he knows the time. The king then asked how many coins could be stacked from the table to the ceiling; after the answer, the king secretly had four coins placed under the table's legs, and when asked again, the Ba'al haTanya answered one less, since the table was now a coin higher.
In the story: the Ba'al haTanya
Insights
- 3:23 What the Ba'al haTanya explains over five chapters, the Ba'al Shem Tov said in one word: one who turns away from the Torah in anything is already, in that, serving other gods.
- 7:39 The Rishonim's distinction that a Sanhedrin is fixed while the ruling that goes out from it is separate cannot be used for Hashem: His word never becomes separate from Him, it remains His essence.
- 15:36 Just as Dovid's 'I am like a desert bird' compares him to the bird only in being alone, not in feathers or beak, 'vayedaber' compares Hashem's word to speech only in its being communication.
- 19:17 Even a person's thought is not the first stage: it is stirred by a desire in the heart, as hunger makes the mind plan a meal, and that root is united with the person's self; Hashem's speech is united with Him in this way.
- 30:19 A turtle's shell is a garment that is part of the turtle itself; so too the garments of Hashem are His own essence. The Rav shows the idea in halachah: one's own hand on his head is not a covering, since it is part of him, while another person's hand is.
- 23:54 There are two true perspectives: from the Creator's side only His glory fills the earth, while from the side of the recipients Hashem created for them a world of imagination in which they live.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Dovid HaMelech, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov
Terms דיבור, הסתר פנים, לבושים, עבודה זרה, עצמות, פועל דמיוני, צמצום