אלו שעברו על חלב עכו"ם' חמץ בפסח' ונדה לא ימסרו נפשם על קידוש ה'. כל עבירה היא ע"ז ממש.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' כ no. ⁨42⁩ Pocket Guide p. 45 Yiddish 41 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 41 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains why sins tied to idolatry, like chametz on Pesach and niddah, weaken a Jew's readiness to give his life for Hashem, and begins Tanya chapter 20, which shows that every sin is rooted in idolatry and that Hashem remains exactly as He was before creation.

The Rav reviews the previous chapter: even a simple Jew will give his life rather than bow to an idol, because idolatry tears him from his root. He then cites the hagahos of the Tzemach Tzedek, as he heard it: one who eats chametz on Pesach, drinks chalav akum, or is not careful with niddah may lose that readiness, since these sins are bound up with idolatry, and he uses this to explain a puzzling Tosafos about a tzaddik who drank wine a gentile had touched. He contrasts the soldier's trained self-sacrifice with the inner instinct of even the lowest Jews. Turning to Tanya chapter 20, he explains that Anochi and Lo yihyeh contain the whole Torah, that every sin is rooted in idolatry, and that everything is drawn to its source, a sense sins numb. He then explains Hashem's absolute oneness, unchanged by creation, through the parable of speech and thought within the soul.

Topics: Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · Mesiras Nefesh · Foundations of Emunah

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Self-sacrifice and the three exceptions listed in the guide

    The Rav recalls that every Jew will give his life rather than bow to an idol, since idolatry is above reason and tears him from his root. He brings, as he heard it, the hagahos of the Tzemach Tzedek: one who eats chametz on Pesach, drinks chalav akum or is lax with niddah may not have this strength, because these sins are tied to idolatry.

  2. 4:27 A puzzling Tosafos; Jewish versus trained self-sacrifice listed in the guide

    The Rav tells a story from Tosafos in Avodah Zarah about a tzaddik who drank wine a gentile had touched to annoy him, and who later gave his life al kiddush Hashem, and says the Tzemach Tzedek's words explain it. He then contrasts soldiers and others who are trained to die for a cause with Jews, even the lowest, whose hidden love would not let them be torn from Hashem.

  3. 9:46 Every sin is rooted in idolatry listed in the guide

    The Rav outlines the coming chapters: being ready to die for idolatry while stumbling in other sins is foolishness, because every sin is rooted in idolatry. If a Jew understood this, he would overcome his nature for every sin as he does for idolatry.

  4. 13:04 Anochi and Lo yihyeh include the whole Torah listed in the guide

    The Rav begins Tanya chapter 20: the first two commandments, heard from Hashem Himself, include the whole Torah, the positive mitzvos stemming from emunah and the prohibitions from idolatry. To explain this, the Tanya first speaks of Hashem's oneness, and the Rav explains 'all believe that He is alone' with the Rosh Hashanah piyut, where Hashem searches the hidden places of the heart.

  5. 16:58 Drawn to the source; the ox knows its owner

    The Rav explains that everything is drawn to its source, as hunger and thirst draw a person to what he lacks, so all creation is drawn to Hashem. Through the ox that knows its owner, the donkey of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair and the Canaanite slave who may eat terumah, he shows how a person's soul extends into his possessions, and explains that sins numb a Jew's sense of Hashem like an anesthetic.

  6. 25:41 Alone as before creation: yachid umeyuchad

    Reading the Tanya, the Rav explains that Hashem is alone after creation exactly as before, with no change. Physical things occupy a place and exclude another, and every thing can be divided, so nothing created is truly one; Hashem's 'echad' is a oneness without limit, and before Him all the worlds are as nothing.

  7. 33:20 The parable of speech, thought and the soul

    The Rav explains the Tanya's parable: one word is nothing compared to the power of speech, still less to thought, and less still to the essence of the soul. He shows that a person thinks in a language, but the first stirring, like hunger or a desire, comes from the soul itself before any letters, as with an animal that wants food without planning.

The shiur, written up

Self-sacrifice and the three exceptions

0:38

The Rav recalls that even a simple Jew will give his life rather than bow to an idol, even outwardly and without believing in it, because he feels it tears him from Hashem, his root, and idolatry is above reason.

2:09

He then brings what he heard is in the hagahos of the Tzemach Tzedek: one who eats chametz on Pesach, drinks chalav akum, or is not careful with niddah may lack this strength. Each is tied to idolatry: the Torah sets the prohibition of molten gods beside the festival of matzos, and the Mishnah in Shabbos compares idolatry's impurity to that of a niddah. b,c,d

A puzzling Tosafos; Jewish self-sacrifice

5:48

The Rav brings a Tosafos in Avodah Zarah: a gentile put his hand into a talmid chacham's vat of wine to annoy him, and the tzaddik drank from it at once to show it was permitted. Tosafos adds that this tzaddik later gave his life al kiddush Hashem, and the Rav says the Tzemach Tzedek's words explain why: had he transgressed in that matter, he would not have had the strength for it. e,b

7:36

Recalling the hidden love from the previous chapter, he notes that gentiles also die for a cause, like soldiers drilled day after day to die for the king. Among Jews, even the lowest who had abandoned the Torah gave their lives by the hundreds of thousands out of an inner instinct. a

Every sin is rooted in idolatry

10:26

The coming chapters, the Rav says, explain that being ready to die for idolatry while stumbling in other sins is foolishness, since every sin is rooted in idolatry. A Jew who understood this would overcome even his love of life for any sin; he fails only because he does not understand.

Anochi and Lo yihyeh include the whole Torah

13:14

Tanya chapter 20 opens with the first two commandments, which Chazal say were heard from Hashem Himself and which include the whole Torah: every positive mitzvah stems from emunah, and every prohibition is rooted in idolatry, emunah's opposite. f,g

15:41

To explain this the Tanya first speaks of Hashem's oneness, saying all believe He is alone. The Rav links this to the Rosh Hashanah piyut: though some seem not to believe, Hashem searches the hidden places of the heart, where everyone believes. f,h

Drawn to the source

17:00

The Rav explains that everything is drawn to its source: hunger and thirst draw a person to the food and water he lacks. Since everything comes from Hashem, everything is instinctively drawn to Him, Jews above all, who have emunah as an inheritance. So the prophet says that the ox knows its owner and the donkey its master's trough. i

19:10

A person's soul extends into his possessions. The donkey of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair, his acquisition, would not eat untithed food, and a Canaanite slave may eat terumah, as the verse says, because he is the kohen's acquisition. j,l

23:47

The donkey knows its master only through the trough, while the ox knows him directly. If Jews have this sense, why do they not know? Sins numb it, as a dentist's injection numbs the nerves, until Israel knows less than the ox and the donkey. i

Alone as before creation

25:45

The Tanya says Hashem is alone after creation exactly as before, with no change. The Rav explains that physical things occupy a place that nothing else can share, so it seems a created world must displace Him; but that is only our perception, for His glory fills the earth. f

29:05

Nothing created is truly one: any stick can be cut in two, and taking a place implies something outside it. So in creation one is the smallest number. With Hashem, whom we declare One in the Shema, 'echad' is the greatest number, a oneness without limit, and before Him all the worlds are as nothing. m

Speech, thought and the soul

33:25

The Tanya's parable: a single word is nothing compared to the person, nor even to his power of speech, still less to his thought, from which speech draws its life, and less still to the essence of the soul with its ten powers. f

36:11

Thought, the Rav explains, comes in letters, a language, usually one's mother tongue; an American-born yeshiva student who learned Yiddish still thinks in English. Yet the first stirring, like hunger, comes from the soul itself without language, and only then does thought plan how to get food. An animal feels the desire but has no letters of thought; likewise, the Tanya says, a desire arises in the heart before the mind thinks about it. f

Sources

Torah

  1. c Shemos 34:17-18 text index In the write-up: 2:09
  2. l Vayikra 22:11 text index In the write-up: 19:10
  3. m Devarim 6:4 text index In the write-up: 29:05

Nevi'im

  1. i Yeshayah 1:3 text index In the write-up: 17:00, 23:47

Mishnah

  1. d apparently Mishnah Shabbos 9:1 index In the write-up: 2:09

Talmud Bavli

  1. g apparently Makkos 24a index In the write-up: 13:14
  2. j apparently Chullin 7a-b index In the write-up: 19:10

Talmud Yerushalmi

  1. k Yerushalmi (place not identified) 21:39 index

Rishonim

  1. e Tosafos, Avodah Zarah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 5:48

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya ch. 19 index In the write-up: 7:36
  2. f apparently Tanya ch. 20 index In the write-up: 13:14, 15:41, 25:45, 33:25, 36:11

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. h Vechol Ma'aminim (Rosh Hashanah piyut) (place not identified) index In the write-up: 15:41
  2. n Ani Ma'amin (place not identified) 30:02 index

Other

  1. b Hagahos of the Tzemach Tzedek (place not identified) index In the write-up: 2:09, 5:48

Key points

  1. 1:02 A Jew will give his life rather than even outwardly bow to an idol, because he senses that idolatry tears him from Hashem, his root, and this is above reason.
  2. 2:23 Sins connected to idolatry, such as chametz on Pesach, chalav akum and niddah, can take away a Jew's readiness for mesiras nefesh.
  3. 10:44 Every sin is truly rooted in idolatry, so a Jew should be as ready to overcome his nature for any sin as for idolatry; he fails only because he does not understand this.
  4. 13:27 Anochi and Lo yihyeh lecha include the whole Torah: every positive mitzvah stems from emunah and every prohibition from idolatry, its opposite.
  5. 17:00 Everything is instinctively drawn to its source, so all creation and above all Jews are drawn to Hashem; sins dull this sense like an anesthetic.
  6. 25:45 Hashem is One exactly as before creation; creation brings no change in Him, since everything is as nothing before Him.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 10:22 If every sin is rooted in idolatry, why does a Jew who would die rather than serve idols still stumble in other sins?

    Answer: 10:40 Because he does not understand that each sin cuts him off from Hashem just as idolatry does; it is foolishness, and the coming chapters explain it.

  2. Question: 24:30 If all creation, and Jews especially, instinctively know Hashem as the ox knows its owner, why does a Jew not sense it?

    Answer: 24:40 The sins a person commits numb this sense, as a dentist's injection numbs the nerves, so that he feels nothing.

  3. Question: 22:07 Why may a Canaanite slave eat terumah while even David HaMelech may not?

    Answer: 22:54 Not because of his own status, but because he is the kohen's acquisition, and the owner's soul extends into what he owns.

Stories

  1. 5:48 The tzaddik who drank the wine

    As the Rav brings it from Tosafos, a talmid chacham had a whole vat of wine, and a gentile, wishing to annoy the Jew, put his hand into the wine. The tzaddik drank from the wine right away in front of the gentile, to show him that he had accomplished nothing and that the wine was permitted. This same tzaddik later lived through a time of persecution and gave his life al kiddush Hashem.

    told in 2 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 6:38 The Rav reads a puzzling Tosafos through the Tzemach Tzedek: the tzaddik who later gave his life al kiddush Hashem was a Jew who had not transgressed in this matter, since one who had would not have had the strength for mesiras nefesh.
  2. 8:20 Gentile self-sacrifice comes from daily drilling, like soldiers trained to die for the king, while Jews, even the lowest, have given their lives in hundreds of thousands out of an inner instinct that would not let them be torn from Hashem.
  3. 23:47 The donkey knows its master only through the feeding trough, whereas the ox knows its owner directly; a Jew who does not sense Hashem has numbed this instinct through sin, like a dentist's anesthetic.
  4. 19:10 A person's soul extends into his possessions; this explains why the donkey of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair would not eat untithed food and why a Canaanite slave may eat terumah.
  5. 30:43 Among created things one is the smallest number, since anything can be halved; with Hashem 'echad' is the greatest number, a oneness without limit after which there is no other.
  6. 36:08 A person thinks in a language, usually his mother tongue, yet the first stirring, like hunger, comes from the essence of the soul before any letters; an animal has the desire but no letters of thought.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Dovid HaMelech, Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Tzemach Tzedek

Terms אהבה מסותרת, חלב עכו"ם, מסירות נפש, עבודה זרה, קידוש השם, רבונו של עולם

Report an error on this page