כמו שהטוב הכי גדול היא קיום המצוה' כן להיפוך' הדבר הכי גרוע היא עבירה. איכות עוה"ז יותר רע מטוב' חוץ אצל צדיק.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' כ"ד no. 46 Pocket Guide p. 45 Yiddish 42 min
Listen
About this shiur
Learning Tanya chapter 24, the Rav explains why a sin is worse than the kelipos and the lowest creatures, why this world is mostly evil and bitter except for the true servants of Hashem, and why a Jew who would die rather than serve idols still sins: a spirit of folly hides his hidden love.
The Rav reviews the previous lesson: through a mitzvah a person is united with Hashem more than the highest worlds, while through a sin he is worse than the sitra achra, which still submits to Hashem; following the Ba'al Shem Tov, every sin carries a spark of idolatry. He then reads the Tanya's words that this world is the dregs of the kelipos, and shows from nature, from people and from each person's own reckoning that evil dominates here. Only rare tzaddikim truly taste the sweetness of Torah; he illustrates this with the Beis Aharon of Karlin, the Ba'al Shem Tov's parable of the cherries, and the tale of the king who sought a happy man's shirt. Returning to the text, he explains that the Tanya now answers how serving Hashem can be 'very near': a person sins only through a spirit of folly, which hides the love that would make him give his life rather than serve idols. Even wild animals obey Hashem, and they cannot harm one who keeps his tzelem Elokim.
Topics: Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · Kedushah and Kelipah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 A mitzvah unites, a sin is worse than the sitra achra listed in the guide
The Rav reviews the previous lesson: through Torah and mitzvos a person is united with Hashem more than the highest worlds, while one who sins is the only creature that rebels against Hashem's will, worse than the sitra achra. He brings the Ba'al Shem Tov that thinking Hashem sees and lets the sin pass is a spark of kefirah.
-
3:48 This world, the dregs where evil prevails listed in the guide
The Rav reads the Tanya that this world is the dregs of the kelipos, explains the difference between ordinary waste and pure dregs, and shows that evil, absent above and a minority in the lower worlds, dominates here. He illustrates it from animals, from people, and from each person's reckoning of his own life.
-
8:16 Tzaddikim taste the sweetness of Torah listed in the guide
The Rav says the exceptions are tzaddikim who feel the pleasure of Torah that Dovid HaMelech describes, while most people are not zocheh to it. He tells how the Beis Aharon of Karlin compared a poritz's extravagant summer sleigh ride to his own delight in Nishmas, and brings the Ba'al Shem Tov's parable of the free cherry: a taste is given as a sample, then one must pay with toil.
-
15:06 The great and wealthy are not content listed in the guide
The Rav argues that this world is full of bitterness even for those who seem to have everything: world leaders, Napoleon who barely slept, the wealthy described in Likutei Moharan, and the statistics of suicide among the prominent. Only the Jew with bitachon who serves Hashem is content.
-
20:45 The king and the happy man's shirt Story
The Rav tells a story he heard as a boy: a melancholy king was told to sleep one night in a contented man's shirt, but the only truly happy man his messengers found was a laughing beggar who owned no shirt at all. Wealth and power, he concludes, bring no contentment.
-
24:06 Serving with truth, and the Tanya's opening question listed in the guide
The Rav says that one who serves Hashem with truth feels sweetness in a blatt Gemara, Tehillim, Shabbos and every mitzvah, but one should not expect the world itself to offer contentment. Returning to the text, he explains that the Tanya now begins answering its opening question from the title page: how can serving Hashem be 'very near'?
-
27:31 The sotah, the spirit of folly and the hidden love listed in the guide
The Rav brings Chazal that no one sins unless a spirit of folly enters him, learned from the sotah. Every Jew, even a sinner, has a hidden love that would make him give his life rather than serve idols; he illustrates it with an angry father who snatches his child from a speeding car. So why does the sotah sin, when it is easier to resist adultery than to be killed?
-
34:08 A sin is worse than the lowest creatures listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the spirit of folly covers the soul up to chochmah but not chochmah itself, so idolatry awakens mesirus nefesh; in truth even a light sin is idolatry and makes the sinner worse than impure creatures. He brings the Gemara that a gnat preceded the wicked, and explains that wild animals, though they have no choice, do Hashem's will, and that no animal may rule over a man.
-
38:55 Tzelem Elokim: the wolves and Daniel listed in the guide
An animal kills a man only when he appears to it like a beast, having lost his tzelem Elokim. The Rav tells the Skulener Rebbe's family story of wolves that sniffed a wagon of holy children and left them unharmed, mentions Daniel in the lions' den, and concludes that the sinner rebels against Hashem more than the worst creatures, out of folly.
The shiur, written up
A mitzvah unites, a sin is worse than the sitra achra
The Rav reviews the previous lesson. When a person learns Torah and does mitzvos, which are Hashem's will and wisdom, he is united with Hashem more than the highest worlds. A sinner, though, is the only creature that rebels against that will; even the sitra achra knows Hashem rules and submits to Him, so the sinner is worse.
Following the Ba'al Shem Tov, he adds that sinning as if Hashem sees and lets it pass holds a spark of kefirah, even when one forgets it.
This world, the dregs where evil prevails
The Tanya, citing the Etz Chaim, calls this world the dregs of the kelipos. Ordinary waste, the Rav explains, still holds a little food; these dregs are pure waste. Above there is no evil, as in Tehillim 5:5, and in the lower worlds good prevails, but here evil dominates. a,b,c
He shows it: more insects than animals, more impure animals than pure, more goyim than Jews, more sinners than tzaddikim, and anyone who reckons his life finds more pain than pleasure.
Tzaddikim taste the sweetness of Torah
Tzaddikim are the exception: one who toils in Torah for its own sake tastes a pleasure beyond anything, as Dovid HaMelech testifies in Tehillim 19. Most learners are not zocheh to it. The Beis Aharon of Karlin, told of a poritz who spread sugar over a field to ride a sleigh in summer, asked how that could compare to his delight in Nishmas on Shabbos morning. d
The Ba'al Shem Tov compared a moment of sweetness to a cherry a fruit seller gives free to taste; the next one costs money. So Hashem gives a sample to awaken a person, and then he must pay with toil until he earns it. Only rare individuals pay the full price.
The great and wealthy are not content
The king and the happy man's shirt
The Rav tells a story he heard as a boy. A melancholy king was told to sleep one night in a contented man's shirt. His messengers found no rich or powerful man truly content, until a laughing beggar, asked for his shirt, said he had none.
Serving with truth, and the Tanya's opening question
The sotah, the spirit of folly and the hidden love
The Tanya answers with Chazal in Sotah 3a: no one sins unless a spirit of folly enters him, learned from the verse of the sotah. Every Jew, even a sinner, has a hidden love, explained in earlier chapters, that would make him give his life rather than serve idols, as whole communities did in the Crusades. k,l,n
The Rav compares it to an angry father beating his child who, when a car speeds toward the child, snatches him away: love hidden under anger surfaces when life is at stake. Why, then, does the sotah sin, when resisting is easier than being killed?
A sin is worse than the lowest creatures
The spirit of folly, the Rav explains, covers the soul only up to chochmah, so idolatry still awakens the hidden love. In truth even a light sin is idolatry and makes one worse than impure creatures, as Chazal say in Sanhedrin 38a that a gnat preceded the wicked. Wild animals have no choice, yet do Hashem's will; even each blade of grass has an angel that tells it to grow. o
Tzelem Elokim: the wolves and Daniel
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 0:54 Through a mitzvah a person is bound to Hashem more than the highest worlds, while a sin cuts him off and makes him worse than the sitra achra, which still submits to Hashem.
- 5:51 In the upper worlds there is no evil, in the lower worlds good is the majority, but in this world evil dominates over good.
- 9:31 Only rare tzaddikim truly feel the sweetness of Torah and mitzvos; most people's lives hold more pain than pleasure.
- 18:50 Wealth, power and status do not bring contentment; only one who serves Hashem with truth and trusts in Him is truly content.
- 28:14 Every Jew has a hidden love for Hashem that would make him give his life rather than serve idols; he sins only because a spirit of folly keeps him from seeing that every sin is also idolatry.
- 37:22 Even the wildest animals carry out Hashem's will, so the sinner is worse than them; and an animal cannot harm one who keeps his tzelem Elokim.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 26:17 How can the Tanya, based on the verse 'the matter is very near to you', say that serving Hashem is easy?
Answer: 27:03 From here on the Tanya answers: a person sins only through a spirit of folly, while his hidden love would keep him from any sin if he understood that every sin is idolatry.
-
Question: 29:37 Why does the sotah sin, when she would give her life rather than bow to an idol, and it is easier to refrain from adultery than to be killed?
Answer: 30:12 Because a spirit of folly from the kelipah covers her soul up to chochmah, so she does not realize that this sin too cuts her off from Hashem like idolatry, and her hidden love is not awakened.
-
Question: 38:41 If no animal may rule over a man, how does a wild animal ever kill a person?
Answer: 38:55 Only when the man appears to it like a beast, having lost his tzelem Elokim through sin.
Stories
-
11:15 The Beis Aharon of Karlin and the poritz's summer sleigh ride
A chassid came to Reb Aharon of Karlin, and when asked, told him that the poritz was doing well. The poritz had gone mad and wanted to ride a sleigh in the middle of summer, so his servants brought hundreds of sacks of sugar, spread it over a large field, and harnessed two horses to a sleigh. The Beis Aharon dismissed it: how could such a pleasure compare to the delight he has on Shabbos morning when he says Nishmas kol chai?
In the story: Reb Aharon of Karlin (the Beis Aharon)
-
21:19 The king who sought a contented man's shirt
The Rav heard as a boy of a king who fell into melancholy, and none of the great sages and doctors could cure him. One sage prescribed that the king sleep one night in the shirt of a contented man. The king's messengers searched the whole land, but every man of wealth, power and fortune turned out, on examination, not to be content. At last they found a beggar in rags, laughing and beaming on a warm day; when they asked for his shirt for the king, he laughed so hard he nearly burst, and said he had no shirt.
-
39:14 The wolves that spared the holy children
The Rav heard from the Skulener Rebbe, who heard it from his grandmother, a descendant of Reb Eizikel. She once travelled by wagon through a forest with her children to visit their grandfather, when the horses reared up and a whole pack of wolves arrived. The leader of the pack jumped onto the wagon, went among all the people and sniffed each one, then leapt off and gave a signal, and all the wolves went away. The Rav explains that they had no permission to harm them, because they were holy souls who kept their tzelem Elokim.
In the story: the Skulener Rebbe, Reb Eizikel
Insights
- 1:34 Even the sitra achra and the angel at the head of the forces of impurity know that Hashem rules and submit to Him; the sinner, the only creature that rebels against His will, is therefore lower than them.
- 3:11 Following the Ba'al Shem Tov, the Rav explains that sinning while knowing Hashem sees, as if He would let it pass, contains a spark of kefirah, even if one forgets it at the time.
- 4:58 Ordinary waste mixed with food still contains a little food, but the dregs of this world, its lusts and sins, are pure waste with no good at all.
- 12:59 A moment of sweetness in avodah is like a free sample Hashem gives to awaken a person; afterwards he must pay the full price with toil until he earns that sweetness himself.
- 30:56 A father in a rage at his child still snatches him from a speeding car, because his natural love, hidden under the anger, surfaces when the child's life is at stake; so too a Jew's hidden love surfaces when faced with idolatry.
- 34:08 The spirit of folly covers the soul only up to chochmah; idolatry touches chochmah itself, so there the hidden love wakes, while other sins slip past it.
- 38:55 Wild animals rule over a man only when he appears to them like a beast, having lost his tzelem Elokim through sin; one who keeps it cannot be harmed by them.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 25:08 The Rav says that one should not place hopes in this world, expecting it to offer pleasure and contentment.
- 24:19 According to the Rav, one who serves Hashem with truth comes to feel sweetness in a blatt Gemara, a chapter of Tehillim, Shabbos and every mitzvah.
- 14:23 The Rav says that after the first taste of sweetness one must toil in avodas Hashem and pay with effort until one earns it.
- 16:03 From Napoleon, who barely slept so as not to lose his kingdom, the Rav cites tzaddikim who learned not to sleep away Shabbos.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Daniel, Dovid HaMelech, Napoleon, Rabbi Yitzchak Eizik of Komarna (the Heichal HaBrachah), Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, Rebbe Nachman of Breslov, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Beis Aharon (Rabbi Aharon II of Karlin-Stolin), the Chozeh of Lublin, the Kozhnitzer Maggid (Rabbi Yisrael of Kozhnitz), the Skulener Rebbe
Terms אהבה מסותרת, כפירה, מסירות נפש, סטרא אחרא, עבודה זרה, פסולת, צלם אלקים, קליפה, רבונו של עולם, רוח שטות