יש יראה ואהבה ביחד רק בה'. אבות נתאחדו בה' יותר ממרכבה גשמית. לפי שהאבות היו בעצם אלקות לכן בניהם גם הם כן. אין מקיף אם אינו מחובר לפנימיות. ביאור קצרה בד' עולמות וי' ספירות.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא ב' י"ח no. ⁨3⁩ Pocket Guide p. 46 Yiddish 42 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 42 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

On Tanya chapter 18, the Rav explains why love and fear of Hashem can live together only with Hashem, how the avos became so united with Him that this bond passed to their children, and gives a short explanation of the four worlds and the ten sefiros.

The Rav reviews that every Jew inherits a hidden love from the avos: love is the trait of Avraham and of Beis Hillel, fear that of Yitzchak and of Beis Shammai. Positive mitzvos come from love and prohibitions from fear, which is why a positive mitzvah overrides a prohibition, as he shows from the Ramban on zachor and shamor and from the Gemara on tzitzis and shaatnez. He then asks how fear, the opposite of love, can be part of the same inheritance, and answers that only with Hashem can union and awe coexist. The avos were Hashem's merkavah, yet more united than a chariot with its rider; their bond became their very essence and so passed to their children, together with nefesh, ruach and neshamah, even where these remain hidden as a makif. Finally he explains the ten sefiros and four worlds through the mashal of vapor, steam, water and ice, and the human powers of the soul, ending with daas.

Topics: Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · The Sefiros · Tzimtzum, the Worlds and the Merkavah

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Love and fear as the traits of the avos listed in the guide

    The Rav reviews that every Jew has a hidden love inherited from the avos and asks what its root is. He links love to Avraham and Beis Hillel and fear to Yitzchak and Beis Shammai, and says positive mitzvos come from love and prohibitions from fear.

  2. 3:38 Why a positive mitzvah overrides a prohibition listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Ramban on zachor and shamor: a positive mitzvah overrides a prohibition because love is greater than fear. He contrasts another view that action is greater than refraining, and shows the Gemara's source from tzitzis of wool on a linen garment.

  3. 6:57 Love and fear together, and the avos as merkavah listed in the guide

    The Rav asks how fear, the opposite of love, can be part of the inherited love, and answers that only toward Hashem can union and awe coexist. He explains that the avos, as Hashem's merkavah, had no will of their own and drew nefesh, ruach and neshamah to their children, like a horse that does only what its rider wants.

  4. 11:29 The limit of a mashal: more than a chariot listed in the guide

    The Rav shows from Dovid HaMelech comparing himself to a desert bird that a mashal holds only in one detail. A chariot can be separated from its rider, but the avos were united completely with Hashem and became a level of Elokus, which is why they passed nefesh, ruach and neshamah to their children.

  5. 15:00 What is inherited: essence, and the hidden makif listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that only essential traits are inherited, and the avos' bond with Hashem became their essence. He describes when one receives nefesh, ruach and neshamah, and explains through a mashal of hair color that ruach and neshamah held hidden as a makif, connected to a person's inner self, can come out in his children.

  6. 20:42 The ten sefiros and tzimtzum listed in the guide

    The Rav begins explaining the ten sefiros: the first powers Hashem drew forth at creation, named for the brilliant sapphire stone. Man, made in Hashem's image, has their reflection as his midos, and the great light was contracted and clothed again and again so the lower worlds could bear it.

  7. 25:54 The mashal of vapor, steam, water and ice listed in the guide

    To explain hishtalshelus and tzimtzum the Rav gives the mashal of a boiling kettle: invisible vapor near the spout, then steam that has no substance, then water that takes no form, then ice that can be shaped and touched. It is all the same thing, only ever more physical.

  8. 31:44 The four worlds and the names of the sefiros listed in the guide

    The Rav applies the mashal: the light was contracted step by step into Atzilus, Beriah, Yetzirah and Asiyah, each world able to create what the one above could not, until physicality is possible. The four worlds match the four letters of Hashem's Name, and he lists the ten sefiros.

  9. 34:58 Chochmah, binah, daas and the midos in man listed in the guide

    The Rav explains the powers of the soul: chochmah as the flash of an idea, binah as building it out, the midos from chesed to malchus, and daas as the bridge that knows when to use each trait. A child can be clever yet not a ba'al daas until he becomes bar mitzvah.

The shiur, written up

Love and fear as the traits of the avos

0:26

The Rav recalls that every Jew has a hidden love inherited from the avos, and asks what its root is and how it passes down. Love is the trait of Avraham and of Beis Hillel, who usually rule leniently; fear is the trait of Yitzchak and of Beis Shammai, who are stringent. All positive mitzvos come from love, and all prohibitions from fear.

Why a positive mitzvah overrides a prohibition

3:38

This, he says, is why a positive mitzvah overrides a prohibition: love is greater than fear. He brings the Ramban on zachor and shamor, where the positive command and the prohibition were said together for this reason. Other commentators hold that an active deed is greater than refraining. The Gemara learns the rule from the verses placing tzitzis of wool on a linen garment beside the ban on shaatnez. b,d,e

Love and fear together, and the avos as merkavah

7:06

The Rav then asks how fear, the opposite of love, can be part of the same inherited love. He answers that there is no contradiction, but only toward Hashem: love of Him means union, fear means nullification before Him, and only with Hashem can both be together.

8:33

The avos, Chazal say, are the merkavah: they had no will of their own and so drew nefesh, ruach and neshamah, the parts of action, speech and thought, to their children. Like a horse that does only what its rider sends, they were fully nullified. g

More than a chariot

11:33

Yet a mashal holds only in one detail. When Dovid HaMelech, fleeing Shaul, likens himself to the lonely birds of the desert in Tehillim, he means only their loneliness, not beak or feathers. So too the merkavah: a chariot can be separated from its rider, but the avos became one with Hashem, a level of Elokus, and therefore bequeathed nefesh, ruach and neshamah to their children. h

What is inherited

15:08

The Rav explains that a trait one acquired, such as learning, is not inherited, but what is part of a person's essence, like a hand with its fingers, is. The avos' union with Hashem became part of them, so their children have a hidden love as an inheritance.

16:48

Nefesh comes at birth, ruach at bar mitzvah with mitzvos, neshamah around twenty with Torah; some Jews stay with nefesh alone. Still, ruach and neshamah surround such a person as a makif bound to his inner self, so he can have talmidei chachamim as children. As black-haired children of a blond mother may have a blond child, what was hidden in one generation appears in the next.

The ten sefiros and tzimtzum

21:54

Turning to the four worlds and ten sefiros, the Rav says that at creation Hashem first drew forth ten awesome powers of holiness. The word sefiros, he notes, comes from the sapphire, a blinding gem of the choshen. These are the Mishnah's ten utterances, and since man was made in Hashem's image, he has their reflection, called midos. l,m

25:12

The light of creation was so great that even angels would burn, so Hashem contracted it again and again and clothed it in garments; the lower it descends, the more physical it becomes.

Vapor, steam, water and ice

26:29

His mashal, good though not exact, is a boiling kettle. Near the spout is vapor, so fine it cannot be seen. Farther off it cools into steam, which has no substance: a hand passed quickly through feels nothing. Collected, it becomes water, which takes no shape; colder still it becomes ice, which can be cut, shaped and touched.

31:19

Vapor and ice are the same thing with a great difference between them; it has only become more physical.

The four worlds

32:25

So the highest world, Atzilus, near to Hashem, is too lofty to create; contracted, it becomes Beriah, which can create something from nothing; then Yetzirah, where angels are formed; then Asiyah, our world, where physicality is possible. The four worlds match the four letters of Hashem's Name, and the Rav lists the ten sefiros from keser to malchus.

Chochmah, binah, daas and the midos

35:06

Leaving the Kabbalah aside, the Rav explains the human powers. Chochmah, the father, is the flash of an idea on a hard Tosafos; binah, the mother, from the word binyan, works it out into a whole structure. Then come the midos: chesed, fear or gevurah, tiferes as their harmony, netzach as perseverance, hod as yielding, and malchus as the vessel that, nullified to Hashem, receives all lights.

40:33

Daas is the bridge between mind and midos: it knows when to love and when to hate, for Hashem's will, unlike an animal led by nature. A child may be cleverer than an adult yet is not a ba'al daas until thirteen, when he becomes obligated in mitzvos.

Sources

Torah

  1. d Devarim 22:11-12 text index In the write-up: 3:38
  2. i apparently Vayikra 11:17-18 11:57 index
  3. k apparently Shemos 24:10 22:51 index
  4. m Bereishis 1:26 text index In the write-up: 21:54

Kesuvim

  1. f apparently Mishlei 31:13 6:09 index
  2. h Tehillim 102:7 text index In the write-up: 11:33
  3. j Tehillim 111:10 21:16 text index

Mishnah

  1. l Avos 5:1 text index In the write-up: 21:54

Talmud Bavli

  1. c Gemara (place not identified) 3:54 index
  2. e apparently Yevamos 4a index In the write-up: 3:38

Midrash

  1. g apparently Bereishis Rabbah 47:6 index In the write-up: 8:33

Rishonim

  1. b apparently Ramban, Shemos 20:8 index In the write-up: 3:38

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya ch. 18 0:00 index

Key points

  1. 1:43 Love is the trait of Avraham and Beis Hillel, fear the trait of Yitzchak and Beis Shammai; positive mitzvos stem from love and prohibitions from fear.
  2. 3:04 A positive mitzvah overrides a prohibition because love is greater than fear.
  3. 7:45 Love and fear can coexist without contradiction only toward Hashem: union with Him and nullification before Him go together.
  4. 8:41 The avos were completely nullified to Hashem, more united with Him than a chariot with its rider, and so they drew down nefesh, ruach and neshamah to their children.
  5. 15:08 Only a trait that is part of a person's essence is inherited; the avos' bond with Hashem became their essence, so their children inherit a hidden love.
  6. 25:25 The ten sefiros come down through the four worlds of Atzilus, Beriah, Yetzirah and Asiyah by ever greater tzimtzum, like vapor that becomes steam, water and ice, and in man they become the ten powers of the soul.
  7. 39:53 Daas is the bridge between the intellect and the midos: it knows when to use each trait.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 3:02 Why does a positive mitzvah override a prohibition?

    Answer: 3:11 According to the Ramban, because love, the root of positive mitzvos, is greater than fear; other commentators say because an act is greater than refraining.

  2. Question: 7:06 If the hidden love is an inheritance, how can fear, its opposite, also be included in it?

    Answer: 7:45 There is no contradiction, but only toward Hashem: union with Him and awe before Him go together.

  3. Question: 11:29 If the avos are compared to a chariot, which is separate from its rider, how could their bond with Hashem pass to their children?

    Answer: 14:26 The mashal holds only in the point of nullification; the avos were truly united with Hashem and became a level of Elokus, so it became part of their essence.

  4. Question: 18:06 How can a person who merited only nefesh have children with ruach and neshamah?

    Answer: 17:45 He too has ruach and neshamah, hidden as a makif connected to his inner self, and what is inherited can come out in the next generation, like a hidden hair color.

Insights

  1. 7:45 Toward a person, love and fear pull against each other; only toward Hashem do they coexist, because loving Him means union and fearing Him means nullification, and both belong together.
  2. 14:02 Calling the avos a merkavah is a mashal that holds in one point only: a chariot stays a separate thing from its rider, while the avos became one with Hashem, a level of Elokus itself.
  3. 15:08 Acquired knowledge is not inherited, but what is part of a person's essence is; the avos' bond with Hashem had become their essence, which is why Jews inherit a hidden love.
  4. 17:45 Ruach and neshamah that a person never revealed still surround him as a makif connected to his inner self, so, like a hair color that skips a generation, they can appear in his children.
  5. 31:30 Vapor and ice are the same substance with a vast difference between them; so too the worlds are one light, ever more contracted and physical.
  6. 40:48 A child may be cleverer than an adult and still lack daas, since daas is not intelligence but the power to govern the midos.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Beis Hillel, Beis Shammai, Dovid HaMelech, Shaul HaMelech, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Ramban, Yitzchak Avinu

Terms אהבה מסותרת, אצילות, בית שמאי, דעת, השתלשלות, מקיף, מרכבה, נפש רוח נשמה, ספירה, צמצום, רבונו של עולם, שעטנז

Report an error on this page