טעם שאפי' פושעים מולידים נשמות גדולות. חכמה למעלה מהשגה. פילפולי התורה מבינים אבל גזירות אינם מבינים. חכמה מקור הבינה. יארצייט המגיד ממזריטש זצוקללה”ה שהוא מקור החסידות.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא ב' י”ח no. 5 Pocket Guide p. 46 Yiddish 36 min
Listen
About this shiur
Learning Tanya chapter 18, the Rav explains why great souls are often born to simple Jews, why the darkest times bring the light of Moshiach as Chanukah does, and why chochmah, the source of binah, is beyond understanding.
The Rav reads Tanya chapter 18: even the lowest Jew has in his inwardness the highest level, and great souls are born even to simple people, as the Sefer HaGilgulim says. He explains that the hidden inheritance of the Avos surfaces in later generations, and that Hashem hides great souls among simple or sinful parents to outwit the Satan, as seen in the lineage of David HaMelech and a Midrash about Esav and David. He connects this to Chanukah, which falls in Teves, the hardest month and the longest night, and reveals a spark of the light of Moshiach, as will happen in the darkness of ikvesa dimeshicha. Today's trials are great, but like a stone dropped from high that sinks deep, today's souls fell from high places. Returning to Tanya, he explains through a river's hidden spring and an inventor who cannot explain gravity that chochmah is the source of binah and cannot be grasped. He closes with the yahrzeit of the Maggid of Mezritch.
Topics: Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · The Hidden Roots of Moshiach · Levels and Root of the Soul
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why simple people have great children listed in the guide
The Rav reads Tanya chapter 18, that even the lowest soul holds within it the highest level and that great souls are born to simple people. He explains that the hidden inheritance of the Avos surfaces in later generations, like a talent for niggun that skips a generation.
-
4:43 Outwitting the Satan: the line of David listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Hashem uses this to trick the Satan, as seen in the lineage of David HaMelech. He brings a Midrash that the Satan hoped for a share through Esav and later through David, who was also 'admoni', and compares it to an owner who hides his diamonds where a thief will not look.
-
10:02 Chanukah in the darkest night listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Midrash that Teves belongs to Esav and is the hardest month, and that its long night is the time the sitra achra rules. Chanukah comes precisely then and its lights reveal a spark of the light of Moshiach, just as Moshiach will be revealed in the darkness of ikvesa dimeshicha.
-
17:12 The stone that falls from high listed in the guide
The Rav describes the great trials of today's generation and asks whether it is lacking for being so low. With the mashal of a stone dropped into mud from a roof, he explains that today's souls fell from high and can raise sparks earlier generations could not, which is why great souls are sometimes born to simple fathers.
-
21:55 Chochmah, the hidden source of binah listed in the guide
The Rav learns the Tanya's words that chochmah is the source of intellect and above understanding. He illustrates it with a river fed by a hidden spring, the pasuk of the river going out of Eden, an inventor who can explain his machine but not why things fall, and a pilpul whose starting point cannot itself be explained. He breaks off to continue after Chanukah, and closes by noting the yahrzeit of the Maggid, the source of all of Chassidus, with lechaim and a niggun.
The shiur, written up
Why simple people have great children
The Rav reads Tanya chapter 18: even the lowest soul, wrapped in much physicality, holds in its inwardness the same level as the greatest tzaddik, and great souls come even to simple people, as the Sefer HaGilgulim says. He asks how very simple Jews come to have children who are tzaddikim and gedolei hador. a,b
He answers that the inheritance of Avraham Avinu lies hidden in every Jew and surfaces only in later generations, just as a talent for niggun may skip a son and reappear in the grandson.
Outwitting the Satan
Hashem uses this to outwit the Satan, who stands against Moshiach, and it is seen especially in the line of David HaMelech. The Rav brings a Midrash: the Satan demanded a share in Avraham's seed and hoped for Esav, of whom it says he came out first and red; but Yaakov took the bechorah and the brachah. d,e
When David was born 'admoni im yefe einayim', the Satan rejoiced at the same word. But the Gemara explains that David killed only Hashem's enemies with the 'eyes', the Sanhedrin's consent. So Hashem hides great souls where the Satan will not look, like an owner hiding diamonds from a thief. f,g
Chanukah in the darkest night
This, the Rav says, is the idea of Chanukah. A Midrash divides the months between Yaakov and Esav, and Teves, Esav's, is the hardest of all. Night is when the sitra achra rules, as the pasuk says that in it all the beasts of the forest creep; even a fever rises at night. The longest night falls in Teves, and the Chanukah miracle came on that night. h,i
Bringing Rabbi Pinchas of Koretz, cited by the Bnei Yissaschar, and the Maharal, he explains that lighting Chanukah candles reveals the light of Moshiach, and so a Jew feels great dveikus at them. So too Moshiach will be revealed in ikvesa dimeshicha, the lowest 'heel' of history, where we stand now. k
The stone that falls from high
Today's trials, the Rav says, are greater than any earlier generation's: once the world was modest, while today the street, television and internet reach into Jewish homes. Is such a low generation then lacking? A stone dropped into mud sinks a little, but dropped from a roof it sinks deep.
So today's souls fell from very high and can raise sparks earlier generations could not reach. Great souls are therefore sometimes born to simple fathers, though often holy fathers draw them down too.
Chochmah, the hidden source of binah
Returning to the Tanya, the Rav reads that chochmah is the source of intellect and above understanding. A river grows from springs that rise from the depths and join into streams, while its source stays hidden under the earth. So the pasuk says a river goes out of Eden to water the garden: Eden, the source, is beyond grasp. a,l
Binah is understanding a matter, and its source is called chochmah, which no one can understand. As a mashal he describes a cement truck with its turning drum. Its inventor can explain the motor, the gasoline and every part, but not why the cement falls into the wheelbarrow rather than rising like a balloon or fire. That is nature, called gravity; he did not invent it and cannot explain it.
That given point is chochmah, 'koach mah', on which binah builds, from the word binyan. Likewise in a pilpul on the Rambam everything can be explained except its first point, which stands like a gezeirah. So there is a power in a Jew that exists but cannot be understood: the Jewish neshamah, the inheritance of the Avos. The Rav reads on that the Ein Sof clothes itself in chochmah. a
He stops in the middle, saying the explanation will continue after Chanukah. He notes the yahrzeit of the Maggid, the source of all of Chassidus, whose students were all the chassidishe tzaddikim, and asks for lechaim and a niggun of the Maggid.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 0:10 Even the lowest Jew carries in his inwardness the highest levels, the inheritance of Avraham Avinu, which can surface in his children or grandchildren.
- 4:46 Hashem brings great souls through simple or sinful parents to outwit the Satan, who would never think to look there.
- 10:23 Chanukah comes at the lowest point of the year, in Teves and its longest night, and its lights reveal a spark of the light of Moshiach, just as Moshiach will be revealed in the lowest generation.
- 19:09 The souls of the generation before Moshiach fell from very high places and therefore sank deep, so they can raise sparks that earlier generations could not reach.
- 21:58 Chochmah is the source of binah and is beyond grasp: one can understand and explain what is built on the first point, but not the point itself.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:22 How do very simple people come to have children who are great tzaddikim?
Answer: 2:31 The inwardness of the simple Jew holds the greatest levels in hiding, and they come out in his children.
-
Question: 4:43 Why does Hashem bring great souls specifically through simple or sinful parents?
Answer: 5:47 To outwit the Satan, who opposes Moshiach and would never think that a great soul would be born there.
-
Question: 14:36 Why does a Jew feel great closeness when he looks at the Chanukah lights?
Answer: 14:47 Because in them a spark of the light of Moshiach is revealed.
-
Question: 18:26 Is the generation of ikvesa dimeshicha not lacking, since it is so low?
Answer: 18:59 Like a stone that sinks deeper the higher it falls from, its souls came from very high and can draw out lofty sparks.
-
Question: 26:53 Why does the cement fall down into the wheelbarrow and not go up?
Answer: 27:29 That is nature, called gravity; no one can explain it, and this given point is what is called chochmah.
Insights
- 3:42 Spiritual greatness can be inherited hidden, like a physical trait or a talent for niggun that skips a generation and reappears in the grandson.
- 7:31 Hashem hides great souls in unlikely homes the way an owner hides diamonds where a thief would never think to look, so that the Satan, who guards the line of Moshiach, is outwitted.
- 12:21 Chanukah, set in Teves, the month given to Esav and the year's longest night, parallels ikvesa dimeshicha, the 'heel' of history, where Moshiach is revealed precisely in the deepest darkness.
- 18:59 The lower a generation has sunk, the higher its souls fell from: like a stone dropped from a roof that sinks deeper into mud, today's souls can reach sparks earlier generations could not.
- 26:48 An inventor can explain every part of his machine but not why the cement falls rather than rising; that given starting point, which binah builds on but cannot explain, is what is called chochmah.
- 29:10 In a pilpul on the Rambam everything can be explained except its starting point, which stands like a gezeirah; so too there is a power in a Jew that exists but cannot be understood, the Jewish neshamah inherited from the Avos.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 20:49 The Rav says the task of today's generation is to go down into the mud and draw out holy sparks that earlier generations could not reach.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Esav, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Rabbi Pinchas of Koretz, the Maggid of Mezritch, the Maharal of Prague, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms אורו של משיח, בינה, חכמה, כח מה, ניצוצות, סטרא אחרא, עקבתא דמשיחא, פנימיות, שטן, תקופת טבת