חכמה - שורש אמונה שהוא למעלה מהשגה. פתי יאמין לכל דבר - לגבי ה' כלנו פתיים. רוב יהודים ימסרו נפשם לה' חוץ אם יש לו קשר לגוי.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא ב' י”ח no. 6 Pocket Guide p. 46 Yiddish 41 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains from Tanya chapter 18 that every Jew's emunah comes from chochmah, which is above understanding, so that most Jews will give their lives for Hashem, unless, as the Tzemach Tzedek notes, a connection to the goy has cut them off.
The Rav reads Tanya chapter 18: chochmah is the root of the intellect, a level that cannot be grasped, and the light of the Ein Sof is clothed in it. Since even the lowest Jewish soul contains chochmah, every Jew, even the unlearned, believes in Hashem, for emunah begins where understanding ends. He explains 'a simpleton believes everything' and says that before Hashem all are simpletons, as David HaMelech called himself a beast before Hashem and therefore always with Him. This natural bond, like an animal's devotion to its young, is why even sinners give their lives for kiddush Hashem, as the Toldos story and Jewish history show. Why only 'most'? The Tzemach Tzedek excludes one who eats chametz on Pesach or drinks chalav akum, because these bind a Jew to the goy. The Rav applies this at length to modern culture, media and the internet, and closes with the Torah and sefarim that keep a Jew bound to Hashem.
Topics: Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Mesiras Nefesh · Yisroel and the Nations
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Chochmah above understanding as the root of emunah listed in the guide
The Rav reads Tanya chapter 18 and explains that chochmah is the root of the intellect that cannot be grasped, where the light of the Ein Sof is clothed. Since every Jewish soul contains chochmah, and emunah is belief in what one does not understand, even women and the unlearned believe in Hashem.
-
3:59 A simpleton believes everything; before Hashem all are simpletons listed in the guide
The Rav explains the passuk in Mishlei that a simpleton believes everything while the clever one understands, and compares the Jew's inborn emunah to a hen that guards her eggs with no intellect, out of natural love. He concludes that before Hashem all are simpletons, as David HaMelech said he was like a beast before Hashem and therefore always with Him.
-
9:01 Even sinners give their lives: the story in the Toldos listed in the guide
The Rav reads that even the lowest Jews and sinners mostly give their lives for kiddush Hashem, because a Jew is bound to Hashem as a child to its parents. He tells the story brought in the Toldos, which chassidim attribute to Adel, the Ba'al Shem Tov's daughter, about a thief who let himself be burned rather than convert.
-
14:36 Mesirus nefesh in Jewish history, and why only 'most' listed in the guide
The Rav brings examples from Jewish history: the Crusades, the decrees of Tach v'Tat, and the expulsion from Spain, where whole communities died or left everything rather than convert. He then asks why the Tanya says only 'most', and why some in Spain did convert.
-
18:20 The Tzemach Tzedek: chametz and chalav akum listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Tzemach Tzedek's note that one who eats chametz on Pesach or drinks chalav akum is not among those who give their lives. He explains that chametz is linked to avodah zarah and that chalav akum means having no connection to the goy, which sells a Jew to the klipah called goy; being a goy includes the goy's dress, culture and way of thinking.
-
22:48 The goy's hatred as a protection; the Ba'al HaTanya and Napoleon listed in the guide
The Rav explains from Tehillim that Hashem turned the Egyptians' hearts to hate the Jews, and that throughout the galus the goyim's hatred and the ghettos kept Jews from mixing with them. He tells that the Ba'al HaTanya preferred Russian rule to Napoleon, who would give the Jews freedom, because that would be good materially but bad spiritually.
-
27:12 Infected with the goy in America today listed in the guide
The Rav describes how Jews in America today take on the goy's culture through radio, television, offices, food, literature and news, and contrasts this with Jewish foods that carry kedushah. He brings the pesukim about mixing with the nations and being separated from them, and the special siman in Shulchan Aruch, and returns to chalav akum as the reason a minority will not give their lives.
-
31:44 Tosfos on wine touched to cause a loss listed in the guide
The Rav brings a Tosfos in Avodah Zarah that wine a goy touched only to cause the Jew a loss is not yayin nesech, with the proof from a chassid who drank such wine and later gave his life for kiddush Hashem. He explains that by the Tanya's rule, his mesirus nefesh is a sign that the wine was not yayin nesech and the psak was true.
-
35:18 The goy in the home today, and the remedy of Torah listed in the guide
The Rav says that earlier non-observant Jews had no connection to the goy, but today the goy has entered everywhere, through books, newspapers, radio and the internet, and shapes the mind as Torah would. He brings the Bnei Yissaschar on lighting Chanukah candles inside, since the public domain has entered the home, and closes that Torah, sefarim and stories of tzaddikim keep a Jew bound to the chochmah of the Ein Sof and to emunah.
The shiur, written up
Chochmah above understanding as the root of emunah
The Rav reads Tanya chapter 18: chochmah is a power above grasp, the root from which the intellect begins. Binah understands, but chochmah itself is not understood, and so the light of the Ein Sof is clothed in it. Since even the lowest Jewish soul contains chochmah, and emunah means believing what one does not understand, all Jews, even women who do not learn and the unlearned, believe in Hashem. a
Before Hashem all are simpletons
The Rav brings the passuk in Mishlei that a simpleton believes everything while the clever man understands. Belief is inborn, like the hen that guards her eggs for weeks and fights for them with no intellect at all, because a parent's love is natural. So a Jew's bond with Hashem, even in the greatest talmid chacham, comes not from intellect but from chochmah. b
Even sinners give their lives
The Tanya continues that even the lowest Jews and sinners mostly give their lives for kiddush Hashem. As an animal gives its life for its young, the Rav explains, a Jew is bound to Hashem, his source. d
He tells what the Toldos brings; chassidim say the wise woman there was Adel, the Ba'al Shem Tov's daughter. A thief caught stealing from a church was told he would be burned unless he converted, and he let himself be burned. He had no fear of Heaven, yet at the root of his soul he could not tear himself away from Hashem. e
Mesirus nefesh in Jewish history
Jewish history shows this, the Rav says. In the Crusades whole communities let themselves be killed rather than convert, and so in Tach v'Tat; from Spain hundreds of thousands left with nothing, and hidden Jews who stayed were often caught and burned. Then he asks why the Tanya says only 'most', and why some in Spain did convert. d
The Tzemach Tzedek: chametz and chalav akum
He answers with the Tzemach Tzedek's note: one who eats chametz on Pesach or drinks chalav akum is an exception. Chametz is like avodah zarah, as Tosfos explains, and the Torah sets keeping the festival of matzos beside the ban on idols. Chalav akum means having no connection with the goy; one who drinks it is sold to the klipah called goy, which includes the goy's dress, culture and way of thinking. f,g
The goy's hatred as a protection
The Rav explains from Tehillim that Hashem turned the Egyptians' hearts to hate the Jews, and this hatred protected them, since a Jew could not mix with the goy. Through the galus the ghettos did the same. The Ba'al HaTanya opposed Napoleon, who would give Jews freedom, holding that it would help them materially but harm them spiritually. j
Infected with the goy in America
Today in America, the Rav says, Jews are infected with the goy through radio, television, offices and culture. Jewish food carries kedushah, yet a chassid in a shtreimel goes to a Chinese restaurant, and the news comes mixed with commercials that are poison for the soul. He brings the pesukim on mixing with the nations and being separated from them, and the siman in Shulchan Aruch, and concludes that one who drinks chalav akum would not give his life. k,l,m
Tosfos on the chassid's wine
The Rav brings a Tosfos in Avodah Zarah: wine a goy touched only to cause a loss is not yayin nesech, as shown by a chassid who drank such wine and later gave his life rather than convert. By the Tanya, he explains, one who drank yayin nesech would not do so, so his mesirus nefesh proves the psak true. n,d
The goy in the home, and the remedy of Torah
Earlier non-observant Jews, the Rav says, had no connection with the goy, but today the goy is everywhere. He warns about books, the internet, television, radio and ordinary newspapers: as much Torah shapes a mind into a talmid chacham's, goyish material shapes it into a goy's.
He brings the Bnei Yissaschar on lighting Chanukah candles inside, though the Gemara says outside: the public domain has entered the home, and today the internet brings every goy into the living room. A Jew gives his life on condition that he is not infected with the goy; Torah and sefarim keep him bound to the chochmah of the Ein Sof and to emunah. o,p
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
- a Tanya ch. 18 text index In the write-up: 0:33
- d Tanya ch. 18 text index In the write-up: 9:01, 15:26, 31:44
- e Toldos Yaakov Yosef (place not identified) index In the write-up: 10:40
- m Shulchan Aruch Yoreh De'ah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 27:14
- o Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 37:25
Key points
- 0:33 Chochmah is a level above understanding in which the light of the Ein Sof is clothed, and every Jewish soul, even the lowest, contains it.
- 2:56 Emunah means believing what one does not understand, so it comes from chochmah, and therefore even women who do not learn and the unlearned believe in Hashem.
- 7:37 Before Hashem every person is a simpleton, as David HaMelech said he was like a beast before Hashem, and through this he was always with Him.
- 9:12 Even the lowest Jews and sinners, for the most part, give their lives for kiddush Hashem, because a Jew is bound to his Source and cannot tear himself away.
- 18:24 The Tzemach Tzedek notes that one who eats chametz on Pesach or drinks chalav akum is an exception, because these carry a connection to the goy.
- 35:51 The Rav says that today the goy has entered Jewish homes through media and the internet, and this cuts a Jew off from the kedushah of Yisrael.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:36 Why do all Jews, even women who do not learn and the unlearned, believe in Hashem?
Answer: 3:19 Because every Jewish soul contains chochmah, which is above understanding, and emunah comes from there.
-
Question: 6:18 Why does a hen, which has no intellect, fight to protect her eggs and chicks?
Answer: 6:46 Because the love of a parent for its child is natural and not from intellect, and so is a Jew's bond to Hashem, which comes from chochmah.
-
Question: 13:01 How could a thief who transgressed so much and did not fear Hashem give his life rather than convert?
Answer: 14:02 Because his soul, from its root, was bound to Hashem, and a Jew cannot tear himself away from Him, even without knowing why.
-
Question: 17:24 Why does the Tanya say only 'most' give their lives, and why did some in Spain convert?
Answer: 18:33 The Tzemach Tzedek notes that one who eats chametz on Pesach or drinks chalav akum will not give his life, because he has been sold to the klipah called goy.
-
Question: 34:23 Why is the chassid's mesirus nefesh a proof that the wine was not yayin nesech?
Answer: 34:46 Because, as the Tanya implies, one who drank yayin nesech would not give his life; since he did, the wine was permitted and the psak was true.
Stories
-
10:45 The thief who would not convert
The Toldos brings that a wise woman said that the Jews did not lose by attaching themselves to Hashem, and Hashem did not lose with the Jews, as was seen with Feivel, a sinner who died for kiddush Hashem. Chassidim say the woman was Adel, the Ba'al Shem Tov's daughter, whom they called a piece of fire. The man was a thief who stole from a church and was caught; he was told he would be burned unless he converted, and he let himself be burned. The Rav explains that though he had transgressed much and did not fear Hashem, the connection to Hashem from the root of his soul was there.
In the story: Adel, daughter of the Baal Shem Tov, Feivel
-
25:13 The Ba'al HaTanya against Napoleon
The Rav tells that Napoleon stood for freedom and equality and gave the Jews freedom where he conquered, while the Russians made decrees against the Jews. The Ba'al HaTanya held that it was better to be under the Russians, since a Napoleon victory would be good for the Jews materially but bad spiritually, and he worked against Napoleon's power although other tzaddikim did not agree with him. Napoleon fell, and Russia continued its decrees, but the Jews did not mix with the goy.
In the story: the Ba'al HaTanya, Napoleon
-
33:37 The chassid who drank the wine
Tosfos brings that a goy who wanted to cause a chassid a loss stuck his finger into his wine. The chassid drank the wine to show that it was not forbidden. Later the same Jew was forced to convert, refused, and gave his life for kiddush Hashem, and Tosfos brings this as a proof for the ruling.
Insights
- 2:59 Since emunah means believing what one does not understand, it does not depend on intellect at all; it comes from chochmah, which is above intellect, so the greatest talmid chacham's emunah is no more a product of his mind than that of the simplest Jew.
- 8:23 The Rav reads David HaMelech's 'I was a beast before You' together with 'and I am always with You': because he knew he had no understanding before Hashem, he was always bound to Him through emunah.
- 6:02 A Jew's readiness to die for Hashem is like a hen's readiness to fight for her eggs: not reasoning but nature, because Hashem is the Jew's source as parents are the source of a child.
- 19:05 Chametz on Pesach and chalav akum are singled out because they tie a Jew to the goy; the Rav connects this to Pesach itself, whose mitzvos begin with separating from avodah zarah, and to the passuk that puts the ban on molten idols next to keeping the festival of matzos.
- 23:31 The goyim's hatred through the galus, beginning with Hashem turning the Egyptians' hearts, was itself a protection, because it kept Jews from mixing with them.
- 34:28 The Rav reads the Tosfos story in light of the Tanya: since one who drank yayin nesech would not give his life, the chassid's later mesirus nefesh proves that the wine was permitted.
- 38:15 Through the Bnei Yissaschar's explanation of lighting Chanukah candles inside, the Rav says the public domain has entered the Jewish home, and today the internet brings every goy in the world into the living room.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 36:03 The Rav says one must have no connection with anything goyish: reading material, books, the internet, television and even the radio.
- 36:25 The Rav says that one who wants the news should use kosher newspapers, since ordinary newspapers keep teaching ideas against daas Torah.
- 40:10 The Rav says that learning Torah, mussar and chassidish sefarim, and the stories of chassidish and Litvish tzaddikim, brings kedushah into a person and keeps him connected to Hashem.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adel, daughter of the Baal Shem Tov, Dovid HaMelech, King Ferdinand of Spain, Napoleon, Rabbi Yaakov Yosef of Polnoye (the Toldos), the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Tzemach Tzedek
Terms אין סוף, אמונה, בינה, חכמה, חלב עכו"ם, יין נסך, מסירות נפש, פושעי ישראל, קידוש השם, קל שבקלים, רבונו של עולם, רשות הרבים