שיר המעלות ממעמקים קראתיך ה'
Catalog entry: תפילה no. 38 Pocket Guide p. 50 Yiddish 45 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains the kapitel Shir Hamaalos Mimaamakim as a cry from the hidden depth of the Jewish soul, which sin never reaches, and as the song of a Jew who keeps waiting for the geulah through every disappointment.
The Rav opens with Hirsch's view that this kapitel is the climax of the Shir Hamaalos: Hashem frees Jews even from their sins. Citing the Bnei Yissaschar that teshuvah does not help for the nations, he explains that Jews are children of Hashem, and the point of G-dliness in a Jew's heart is never touched by sin. He supports this from the Rambam on 'until he says I want', and from the thirty-nine lashes. He then reads the kapitel verse by verse: tachanunim as a request for an undeserved gift, forgiveness created before the world, the Jew's direct access to Hashem without intermediaries, and how forgiveness removes the barrier that blocks fear of Heaven. On 'kivisi Hashem' he speaks of daily disappointments in avodah and in the hope for Moshiach, the dates of the ketz that passed, the frum Jews whose machlokes delays the geulah, and the call to keep hoping.
Topics: Teshuvah · The Pintele Yid: The Inner Point of Every Jew · Awaiting Moshiach · The Time of the Geulah and the Ketz · Tehillim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why Hashem frees Jews from sin listed in the guide
The Rav brings Hirsch's view that this kapitel is the climax of the Shir Hamaalos, since Hashem frees Jews even from their sins, and asks why. From the Bnei Yissaschar he shows that teshuvah does not help the nations, and explains that Jews are children of Hashem, carrying a point of G-dliness that sin does not touch.
-
5:00 The inner will and the depths listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Rambam on forcing a person until he says 'I want', explaining that every Jew inwardly wants Hashem's will. He speaks of the hidden part of the Torah that the Arizal permitted to reveal, and of the thirty-nine lashes that do not reach the highest level of the soul, then reads 'mimaamakim' as calling from that depth.
-
11:13 Tachanunim: asking for an undeserved gift listed in the guide
On 'Hashem shim'ah bekoli', the Rav brings Rashi that tachanunim means asking for an undeserved gift, and the Midrash of the treasure of matnas chinam shown to Moshe Rabbeinu, which opens only to one who knows nothing is due to him. On 'im avonos tishmor' he notes that even the greatest tzaddikim had a flaw.
-
16:23 Forgiveness before the world; no intermediary listed in the guide
The Rav explains that since man is prone to sin from Adam on, forgiveness was created before the world. On 'ki imcha haselichah' he contrasts the intermediaries needed before a king, and the confession of the gentiles, with a Jew who comes straight to Hashem as a child, and reads Kayin's 'gadol avoni minso'.
-
20:08 Forgiveness so that You be feared listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Berditchever's words that Hashem is full of mercy greater than man's sins, and explains 'lema'an tivareh': without forgiveness a sinner would despair and give himself over to this world. He then explains that sins are a barrier that keeps a person from feeling Hashem, and forgiveness removes it so he can fear Hashem.
-
25:07 Kivisi Hashem: hope after disappointment listed in the guide
On 'kivisi Hashem' the Rav describes the great day when the whole world will recognize Hashem, and the daily and weekly disappointments of a Jew who resolves to serve Hashem and falls again. He tells how the Sassover Rebbe would resolve each morning to begin anew, and reads 'mishomrim laboker' as waiting for the personal and general geulah.
-
30:05 Waiting for Moshiach; be'itah and achishenah listed in the guide
The Rav tells how the Yismach Moshe waited for Moshiach every moment, including the story of his son's arrival. He then brings the Gemara on 'be'itah achishenah' and the Gemara in Avodah Zarah about a certain year, explaining that the Tannaim's times were times of achishenah, and that at such a time the Satan accuses and brings troubles.
-
35:30 Dates of the ketz and the spoiled geulah listed in the guide
The Rav goes through dates that were foretold for the geulah and brought great troubles instead, and says the geulah was spoiled not by the irreligious but by machlokes and lashon hara among frum Jews. He brings the Arizal's date for the great day of judgment, calls for preparing and self-correction, and ends with 'kivisi Hashem': after each disappointment one keeps waiting for the morning.
The shiur, written up
Why Hashem frees Jews from sin
The Rav opens with Hirsch's view that this kapitel is the climax of the Shir Hamaalos. The earlier ones tell how Hashem saves Jews from their troubles and from exile; here He frees them even from their sins, which is why the kapitel is said during the Ten Days of Repentance. The Rav then asks why Hashem frees Jews from sin at all. a
The inner will and the depths
The Rav brings the Rambam's question on the Gemara that a man who owes a korban is beaten until he says 'I want': how is that wanting? The Rambam answers that every Jew inwardly wants Hashem's will. The yetzer hara covers it, and the beating breaks the yetzer, so the point in the heart surfaces and he means what he says. h,i
This idea belongs to the hidden part of the Torah, which most Rishonim did not receive and which the Arizal said may now be revealed. The Rav connects the Sages' giving thirty-nine lashes rather than forty to a level of the soul that sin never reached. That innermost place is the 'maamakim', the depths, from which the Psalmist asks for forgiveness. m,b
Tachanunim: asking for an undeserved gift
On 'Hashem, hear my voice', the Rav brings Rashi that tachanunim means asking for an undeserved gift. He tells the Midrash that Moshe Rabbeinu was shown treasuries for Torah, tefillah and mitzvos, and the greatest was the treasury of undeserved gifts. Only one who truly knows nothing is due him receives from it, as a father gives to a child simply because he is his father. n,o,p
Forgiveness before the world; no intermediary
Since Adam Harishon sinned at the very start, man is prone to sin, so forgiveness was created with the world; the Gemara counts teshuvah among what preceded it. On 'ki imcha haselichah' the Rav contrasts the ministers one needs before a king, and the gentiles' confession to a priest, with a Jew who comes straight to Hashem like a child. Kayin's 'my sin is too great to bear' he reads as: You bear the whole world, and not my sin? t,v,w
Forgiveness so that You be feared
The Rav brings the Berditchever: Hashem is full of mercy and he is full of sin, but how great can his sin be beside Hashem's mercy? Forgiveness exists 'so that You be feared': without it a sinner would count himself lost and grab this world. With it he returns, and after Yom Kippur takes care to stay clean. v
Fear of Heaven is simple logic, yet people lack it, because sins form a barrier that keeps one from feeling Hashem. Forgiveness removes it; the heart becomes pure and one fears Hashem.
Kivisi Hashem: hope after disappointment
On 'kivisi Hashem', the Rav says Jews wait for the day when the whole world will know Hashem. So too a person resolves each morning, and each Shabbos, to serve Hashem properly, and finds a disappointment at the end. The Sassover would say each morning that today he would truly be an ehrliche Yid. 'Like watchmen for the morning': one waits for the personal and the general geulah, and when it does not come, hopes for the next morning. y,ab
Waiting for Moshiach; be'itah and achishenah
Great tzaddikim waited for the geulah every moment. The Yismach Moshe told his gabbai each night to wake him if Moshiach came. Once, in the mikveh, he heard that someone had come and ran home undried; shown that it was his son Rabbi Elazar Nisan, he wept, for he had thought it was Moshiach.
The Gemara reads 'be'itah achishenah': if Jews are worthy, Hashem hastens it; if not, it comes in its time. The Tannaim calculated times from Daniel, and the Gemara in Avodah Zarah names a year, yet these passed, for they were times of achishenah. At such a time, the Rav explains, the Satan accuses that Jews are unworthy and brings troubles. ac,ad,ae,af
Dates of the ketz and the spoiled geulah
A time was foretold for 5408, and instead came Chmielnicki's decrees. The Malbim, in his commentary on Daniel, set 5674, and that year the World War began. Another time was 5700, when Hitler entered Poland and the worst troubles since the Churban began, in which a third of Klal Yisrael was killed. A time from the Arizal also passed, since such times were of achishenah and were spoiled. ag
The year 5708 brought only a Jewish state, which the Rav calls a broken gate of geulah. The irreligious did not spoil it; they know nothing and are like captured children. Machlokes and lashon hara among frum Jews about gedolim and other Rebbes spoiled it.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
- b Tehillim 130:1 text index In the write-up: 8:09
- d Tehillim 47:9 2:46 text index
- n Tehillim 130:2 text index In the write-up: 11:25
- q Tehillim 130:3 text index In the write-up: 15:07
- s Tehillim 90:2 16:56 text index
- v Tehillim 130:4 text index In the write-up: 16:29, 20:15
- y Tehillim 130:5 text index In the write-up: 25:36, 41:50
- ab Tehillim 130:6 text index In the write-up: 25:36
- af Daniel (place not identified) index In the write-up: 32:33
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
- e apparently Kiddushin 32b 3:02 index
- h apparently Arachin 21a index In the write-up: 5:04
- k Gemara Chagigah (place not identified) 7:46 index
- m apparently Makkos 22b index In the write-up: 8:09
- t apparently Pesachim 54a index In the write-up: 16:29
- ad Sanhedrin 98a text index In the write-up: 32:33
- ae apparently Avodah Zarah 9b index In the write-up: 32:33
Midrash
- p Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 11:25
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 0:30 This kapitel is the climax of the Shir Hamaalos: beyond saving Jews from physical troubles, Hashem frees them from their sins.
- 3:36 Jews are children of Hashem, and the point of G-dliness in the depth of a Jew's heart is never reached by sin; this depth is the 'maamakim' from which the Jew calls.
- 17:50 A Jew comes to Hashem for forgiveness directly, like a child to his father, without the intermediaries needed before a human king.
- 23:43 Sins form a barrier between a person and Hashem that blocks fear of Heaven; forgiveness removes it, which is why forgiveness leads to fear of Hashem.
- 28:15 A Jew must keep hoping after each disappointment, in his own avodah and in waiting for the geulah, like watchmen waiting for the morning.
- 34:18 Times for the ketz passed without the geulah because they were times of 'achishenah', dependent on merit, and the geulah was spoiled.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:31 Why does Hashem free Jews from their sins, when for the nations teshuvah does not help?
Answer: 3:14 Jews are His children, a part of the Father, with a point of G-dliness that sin does not reach; a father forgoes his honor for a child.
-
Question: 5:38 How can a 'rotzeh ani' forced by beating count, if he does not want?
Answer: 5:48 Inwardly every Jew wants Hashem's will; the yetzer hara covers it, and the beating breaks the yetzer so the inner point surfaces and he truly means it.
-
Question: 13:31 Why can't everyone take from the treasure of undeserved gifts?
Answer: 13:35 Only one who truly knows that nothing is due to him, with a lowly spirit and broken heart, receives from it.
-
Question: 20:49 Why does forgiveness exist 'so that You be feared'?
Answer: 20:56 Without forgiveness a sinner would consider himself lost and abandon himself to this world; with it he returns and guards himself.
-
Question: 22:49 Fear of Heaven is so logical; why do people lack it?
Answer: 23:43 Sins form a barrier that insulates a person from feeling Hashem; forgiveness removes it.
-
Question: 33:48 Why did the times the Tannaim and tzaddikim set for Moshiach pass without the geulah?
Answer: 33:55 They were times of achishenah, which depend on merit; if Jews are not worthy the time passes, and the fixed time of be'itah is unknown.
Stories
-
28:44 The Sassover's daily new beginning
The Rav tells that Rabbi Moshe Leib of Sassov, or perhaps Rebbe Reb Elimelech, would rise each morning and say that until now he had not been good, but today he would be an ehrliche Yid. Yesterday he had said the same, but today he meant it truly. So he would say every day.
In the story: Rabbi Moshe Leib of Sassov, Rebbe Reb Elimelech
-
31:02 The Yismach Moshe thought Moshiach had come
The Yismach Moshe would instruct his gabbai every night that if Moshiach came he must not forget to wake him. He had a dear son, the tzaddik Rabbi Elazar Nisan, who was a rav in another town and was to come to him. While the Yismach Moshe was in the mikveh, the son arrived and the shamash called in to him that 'he has come'. The Yismach Moshe dressed quickly without drying himself and ran home, and when the gabbai pointed to his son he burst into great weeping, for he had thought they said Moshiach had come.
In the story: the Yismach Moshe, Rabbi Elazar Nisan
Insights
- 10:04 The 'depths' of the kapitel are the innermost point of the Jew, the place where he is a child of Hashem and where no sin ever reached; calling from there is what makes forgiveness possible.
- 9:21 The thirty-nine lashes instead of forty reflect that the highest of the levels of the soul is never touched by sin, so it is not struck.
- 14:07 The treasure of undeserved gifts flows from the Jew being Hashem's child: a father gives to a child not because he earned it but because a father must give.
- 20:56 Forgiveness leads to fear of Hashem in two ways: it keeps a sinner from despairing and abandoning himself, and it removes the barrier of sin so that he can feel Hashem's presence.
- 35:00 At a time destined for the geulah the Satan accuses that Jews are unworthy, and this is why such dates brought great troubles rather than redemption.
- 40:27 Not the irreligious, who are like children captured and know nothing, but machlokes and lashon hara among frum Jews spoiled the geulah.
What the Rav says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Avraham Avinu, Chmielnicki, Hevel, Kayin, Moshe Rabbeinu, Noach, Rabbi Chaim Vital, Rabbi Elazar Nisan, Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, Rabbi Moshe Leib of Sassov, Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch, Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech), the Arizal, the Malbim, the Rambam, the Ramban, the Yismach Moshe, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms בעתה אחישנה, חלק אלוק ממעל, חציצה, יראת שמים, ממוצע, מתנת חנם, נקודה הפנימית, קץ, רוצה אני, תחנון