דיבורים המעוררים את הלב
Catalog entry: זמנים אלול no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 15 תשל"ה (1974–75) Yiddish 57 min
Listen
About this shiur
For Elul, the Rav teaches that releasing others as in shmitah brings Hashem's release of our debts, and warns that letzanus, the scoffing that undoes emunah, shut Pharaoh off from reality and shuts a person out of tefillah.
The Rav opens with Elul as the forty days of favor when Moshe went up for the second luchos, and says the teshuvah of that time left its mark on the season for all generations. From the parsha of shmitah he explains that shmitah means letting go: what a person does below, Hashem does above, so one who releases what others owe him causes Hashem to release his own debt. This happens each Tishrei and, in small, every Shabbos, and is why one makes peace with others before Rosh Hashanah and accepts love of one's fellow before davening. Strengthening each other is the call of the time, and its great enemy is letzanus. With Rabbi Tzadok he shows that letzanus is the opposite of emunah and shuts a person out of the palaces of tefillah. Pharaoh, a scoffer, used jokes to escape the reality of the plagues, and was punished measure for measure. He closes with Rosh Hashanah as a day of emes and with Hashem's love for Klal Yisrael.
Topics: Chodesh Elul · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek · Bein Adam LaChaveiro · Shemitah and Yovel
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Elul, the days of favor and the second luchos listed in the guide
The Rav describes the forty days of favor when Moshe went up for the second luchos and the broken spirit of the people after the egel, and says their teshuvah left a mark on these days for all generations. He adds that the second luchos were given to baalei teshuvah and were greater than the first.
-
3:46 Shmitah and the beloved seventh listed in the guide
From the parsha of shmitah the Rav explains that shmitah means letting go, and that every mitzvah a person does below Hashem does correspondingly above. He brings that every seventh is beloved, Shabbos among days and Tishrei among months, and notes that the shmitah cycle of years begins from Tishrei.
-
8:50 Releasing others' debts before Rosh Hashanah listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Hashem gave the mitzvah of releasing debts so that by letting go of what others owe us we arouse Him to let go of our own debt, and that this happens every Tishrei and every Shabbos, a small Rosh Hashanah. He brings the Gemara that the Satan has no power on Yom Kippur, and speaks of being mochel others and accepting love of one's fellow before davening in Elul.
-
13:19 Letzanus, the opposite of emunah listed in the guide
The Rav calls for strengthening one another in serving Hashem and warns that letzanus cools a person's Yiddishkeit. With Rabbi Tzadok he explains that emunah, the first of the Ten Commandments, is the root and entrance of all good, while letzanus is the root of all bad, and that Heaven helps the scoffer in his scoffing.
-
17:11 Scoffers shut out of the palaces of tefillah listed in the guide
The Rav describes how a bochur who davens with warmth is mocked, and calls letzanus the kelipah of Amalek. He brings the Gemara that scoffers do not receive the Shechinah, and Rabbi Tzadok's explanation that a scoffer is not let into the palaces of tefillah, comparing it to the guards placed at Gan Eden and to the Ba'al Shem Tov's teaching that a person is where his thoughts are, with a story of the Ba'al Shem Tov.
-
23:10 Pharaoh the scoffer listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Midrash that calls Pharaoh a letz and asks where Pharaoh's scoffing is seen, and why a logical man kept withstanding plague after plague. He answers that jokes are an escape from reality, and illustrates how one joke silences a hundred rebukes with a story of a child who ended a derashah about the Leviasan.
-
32:42 Pharaoh's punishment, measure for measure listed in the guide
The Rav brings the passuk 'that I made sport of Egypt' with Rashi's explanation, and says Pharaoh's punishment was measure for measure: Hashem made a joke of the one who made jokes. He then describes how Yosef gathered the world's money into Egypt, the envy of the nations, and how it all went out with Yosef's family.
-
37:35 Rosh Hashanah as a day of emes listed in the guide
Much of this stretch is lost in the recording. In what survives, the Rav calls the theme the preparation for Rosh Hashanah, points to the conclusion of the Rosh Hashanah brachah, which speaks of emes, and says that since the Torah binds every Jew, each one must make a cheshbon for himself.
-
46:44 Elul and Hashem's love for Klal Yisrael listed in the guide
In a poorly recorded closing, the Rav says that just as Moshe began in Elul to bring the luchos down from heaven, a Jew must now purify his heart and bind himself to Hashem, mentions 'one thing I ask of Hashem', and speaks of the great love between Hashem and a Jew, for which a person gives everything he has. He ends with wishes for a good Elul and a good Rosh Hashanah.
The shiur, written up
Elul, the days of favor and the second luchos
The Rav opens with the forty days of favor, when Moshe went up for the second luchos and the people waited, broken after the sin of the egel. The teshuvah they did then, he says, left a mark on these days for all generations. Chazal say Moshe left no corner of heaven untouched, repairing the root of every Jewish soul. And the second luchos, given to baalei teshuvah, were greater than the first.
Shmitah and the beloved seventh
Turning to the parsha of shmitah, 'at the end of seven years', the Rav explains that the word shmitah means letting go, and the Torah calls it 'shmitah to Hashem'. A Midrash teaches that what a person does in this world, Hashem does in heaven; this is why He gave mitzvos, each one an act that brings about its counterpart above. a,b,c
Releasing others' debts before Rosh Hashanah
From here the Rav explains the mitzvah of releasing debts. Hashem wants to forgive us our debt, so He commanded that we release what others owe us; by letting go below we arouse the release above. This happens each Tishrei and every Shabbos, a small Rosh Hashanah.
He brings the Gemara that the Satan has power on every day of the year except Yom Kippur. In Elul, therefore, one is mochel others before Rosh Hashanah, as the Shulchan Aruch says. He adds that the davening of this time should begin by accepting the mitzvah of loving one's fellow as oneself. e,f,g
Letzanus, the opposite of emunah
Now, says the Rav, everyone must strengthen others in serving Hashem, and the great danger is letzanus, scoffing, which cools Yiddishkeit. Rabbi Tzadok writes in Tzidkas HaTzaddik that the root of all good is emunah, which is why the Ten Commandments open with 'I am Hashem your G-d'; emunah is the entrance to serving Hashem. h,i
Scoffers shut out of tefillah
Rabbi Tzadok adds that just as a person arouses Heaven with mitzvos, so with scoffing: Heaven supplies him with good jokes. A bochur who davens with warmth is mocked, and one joke can empty him out. This, the Rav says, is the kelipah of Amalek, whom the Midrash calls a scoffer. h,l
The Gemara says scoffers do not receive the Shechinah. Rabbi Tzadok explains that a scoffer is not let into davening: each part of tefillah is a palace, and he is turned away, as guards were placed at Gan Eden after Adam sinned. m,h,n
A person is where his thoughts are, as the Ba'al Shem Tov taught. The Besht once greeted a man after davening; he had been in Danzig with his merchandise. The scoffer loses all connection to davening and learning.
Pharaoh the scoffer
The Midrash applies to Pharaoh the passuk that calls the arrogant man a scoffer. The Rav says he searched the Chumash and the Midrash and found no joke of Pharaoh's. Why, then, is he called a letz? o
He asks a further question. Pharaoh was warned and saw each plague arrive as Moshe foretold, yet withstood them with an almost superhuman strength. A logical man who lives by calculation would have given in after one plague or two, since it was ruining his country.
The answer is his letzanus. A joke is an escape, the opposite of reality. Plagues are suffering, but a joke takes a person away from his situation, so he never faces it and never submits to Moshe.
A scoffer never answers with logic. The Rav tells of a teacher who described to young students the good prepared for tzaddikim, the Leviasan among it; a child raised his hand and said he does not like fish, and the derashah was over. One scoffing remark pushes away a hundred rebukes; this, the Rav says, is the destruction. p
Pharaoh's punishment, measure for measure
What was Pharaoh's punishment? The Rav brings the passuk that a Jew should tell his children 'that I made sport of Egypt', and Rashi's explanation that Hashem mocked Egypt. Measure for measure: Hashem let Pharaoh make good jokes, then made a joke of him. q,r
The Rav then describes how Yosef gathered the money of the whole world into Egypt, making it the richest land and the envy of its neighbors, until all that wealth went out with Yosef's family.
Rosh Hashanah as a day of emes
Much of this part of the recording is lost. In what survives, the Rav calls this the preparation for Rosh Hashanah and asks what the seal of its brachah is: it speaks of emes, and Rosh Hashanah is emes, the opposite of scoffing's escape from reality. s
Since the Torah obligates every Jew, the Rav says, each one must make a cheshbon for himself.
Elul and Hashem's love for Klal Yisrael
Sources
Torah
- a Devarim 15:1 text index In the write-up: 3:59
- b Devarim 15:2 text index In the write-up: 3:59
- g apparently Vayikra 19:18 index In the write-up: 10:45
- i apparently Shemos 20:2 index In the write-up: 13:19
- n apparently Bereishis 3:24 index In the write-up: 19:05
- q Shemos 10:2 text index In the write-up: 32:42
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 0:13 The forty days of Elul were days of favor, and the teshuvah Klal Yisrael did then left a lasting mark on the season for all generations.
- 4:24 Shmitah means letting go; when a person releases what others owe him, Hashem correspondingly releases the debt of his sins.
- 13:19 Elul calls for strengthening one another in serving Hashem, and letzanus is what most cools a person's Yiddishkeit.
- 14:46 Following Rabbi Tzadok, emunah is the root and entrance of all good and letzanus is the root of all bad and the entrance to the opposite.
- 19:33 A scoffer is pushed away from the palaces of tefillah and loses his connection to davening and learning.
- 24:49 Pharaoh withstood the plagues because, as a scoffer, he used jokes to escape reality, and Hashem punished him measure for measure by making sport of Egypt.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 8:23 Why does the count of shmitah years begin from Tishrei?
Answer: 8:13 Because every seventh is a time of forgiveness, and Rosh Hashanah is the start of the release in which Hashem lets go of our debts.
-
Question: 19:21 What does the Gemara mean that scoffers do not receive the presence of the Shechinah?
Answer: 19:30 Rabbi Tzadok explains that a scoffer is not let into davening; he is pushed away from the palaces of tefillah.
-
Question: 23:33 Where does one see that Pharaoh was a scoffer, and how could a logical man withstand plague after plague?
Answer: 27:06 His jokes let him escape the reality of the plagues, so he never had to submit to Moshe.
-
Question: 32:42 What was Pharaoh's punishment for his scoffing?
Answer: 33:34 Measure for measure: Hashem made sport of Egypt, as Rashi explains, making a joke of the one who made jokes.
Stories
-
21:36 The Ba'al Shem Tov greets a man after davening
The Ba'al Shem Tov once came over to a man after davening and greeted him with 'shalom aleichem'. The man asked why, since he had been there all along. The Ba'al Shem Tov answered that during davening the man had been in Danzig, where his thoughts about his merchandise were.
In the story: the Baal Shem Tov
-
31:19 The child who did not like fish
The Rav relates a story he was told about a teacher of young students who spoke to them about the good prepared for tzaddikim, including the great fish, the Leviasan, made ready for them. A child raised his hand and said that he does not like fish. That was the end of the derashah, the Rav says, since one cannot answer such a remark.
Insights
- 6:39 The Rav reads 'shmitah to Hashem' as a mirror: by letting go of the debts others owe us, we cause Hashem to let go of the debt our sins have created.
- 8:23 Because the shmitah of years is counted from Tishrei, Rosh Hashanah is itself a time of release, and every Shabbos, the seventh day, is a small Rosh Hashanah with the same power.
- 15:07 Letzanus is the exact opposite of emunah: emunah is the gate into serving Hashem, and letzanus is the gate out of it.
- 19:21 Following Rabbi Tzadok, the Gemara's statement that scoffers do not receive the Shechinah means that the scoffer is kept out of the palaces of tefillah, so that even while davening his mind wanders elsewhere.
- 24:49 Pharaoh's superhuman stubbornness through the plagues came from his humor: a joke lets a person escape reality, so he never has to face it.
- 33:34 Pharaoh's punishment, 'that I made sport of Egypt', was measure for measure: Hashem let him make good jokes and then made a joke of him.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 9:58 The Rav says that before Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur one must be mochel others, letting go of what they owe, so that Hashem will let go of one's own debt.
- 12:33 The Rav says that the davening of this time should begin by accepting the mitzvah of loving one's fellow as oneself.
- 13:19 The Rav says one must strengthen others in serving Hashem and never cool them off with scoffing.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Moshe Rabbeinu, Pharaoh, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Rashi, the Baal Shem Tov, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אהבת ישראל, אמונה, בעלי תשובה, ליצנות, מדה כנגד מדה, עת רצון, רבונו של עולם, שבירת הלוחות, שטן, שמיטה