ב - ה' מנ"א תשל"ח - אמונה בתורת הסוד וביאור שנטמן האר"י הק' בימים אלו.
Catalog entry: זמנים מסיבת לחיים בקעמפ תורה ודעת דרשה אחר שריפה במחנה תורה ודעת (קעמפ) no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 32 תשל"ח (1977–78) Yiddish 38 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that in a long galus Jews are judged by their emunah alone, and that the hidden light of the Nine Days, the days of the Arizal's passing, calls for believing in the secrets of the Torah even without understanding them.
The Rav contrasts two nearly identical verses in Tehillim about Hashem coming to judge the world: if Moshiach comes early, Jews are judged by the measure of Torah; if galus drags on past kitz after kitz, they are judged by their emunah. Like watchmen waiting for morning, Jews keep hoping, and so Chavakuk based all the mitzvos on 'a tzaddik lives by his emunah'. On the Arizal's day of passing, he says the Arizal's words cannot be understood without ruach hakodesh, so at his tziyun one can only sing his zemiros. The Arizal and Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai share one soul and passed away in days of mourning, whose light is too great for now and appears as darkness. Rabbi Shimon revealed open and hidden Torah, so his day is a joy; the Arizal's stays hidden. The Rav ends by urging everyone to believe his emunah is whole.
Topics: Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Awaiting Moshiach · The Hidden Light · Pshat, Remez, Drush and Sod · Chazal and Gedolei Yisroel
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Waiting for the morning: emunah in a long galus
The Rav points to two similar verses about Hashem coming to judge the world, and says Moshiach can come early or after a long wait. Like watchmen waiting for morning, Jews keep hoping after every kitz that passed, and this is why Chavakuk based all the mitzvos on emunah for a fallen generation.
-
16:39 Judged by uprightness or by emunah
The Rav explains that a navi's name carries his message, and Chavakuk's is clinging to emunah. Had Moshiach come in earlier generations, each Jew would have been judged by his Torah and avodah; now, after the kitzim passed, the verse says the nations will be judged by their emunah.
-
19:58 The Arizal's day: singing at his tziyun listed in the guide
The Rav notes that today is the Arizal's yahrzeit and that his secrets cannot be understood without ruach hakodesh. He tells how at the Arizal's tziyun in Tzfas, unable to say over his teaching, he sang his zemiros, and explains that the Arizal and Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai are one soul who both passed away in days of mourning.
-
23:42 Hidden light, hidden secrets, and complete emunah listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the days of sefirah and the Nine Days hold a light kept for the future, too great for us now, so it appears as darkness; Rabbi Shimon revealed both nigleh and nistar, so his day is a joy, while the Arizal revealed only secrets, so his day stays hidden. Returning to the verse, he calls on everyone to strengthen his emunah, believe in the secrets hidden in the Torah, and believe that his own emunah is whole.
The shiur, written up
Waiting for the morning: emunah in a long galus
The Rav says Moshiach can come quickly, or only after a long wait; tzaddikim gave kitzim, and they passed. He brings the verse in Tehillim of watchmen waiting for morning: this is the quality of Klal Yisrael. When morning comes and it is still cloudy and dark, a Jew waits again for another morning, hoping and believing even when disappointed. c
Judged by uprightness or by emunah
The Rav explains that a navi's whole being is his message, and it lies in his name: Chavakuk was named from 'you will embrace a son', and his message is holding on to emunah through so many disappointments. Had Moshiach come in earlier generations of great Torah and mesiras nefesh, each Jew would have been judged on his avodah. g
The Arizal's day: singing at his tziyun
Turning to the Arizal, whose day of passing it is, the Rav says that understanding his words requires ruach hakodesh. Revealed Torah every Jew grasps somewhat, but the Arizal revealed the secrets of the Torah, which are beyond us.
He recalls that at the Arizal's tziyun in Tzfas he wondered what to say over, as one says a mishnah at a Tanna's grave. He thought of singing the Arizal's zemiros: he longs to know the secrets but cannot, yet he can sing. The Rav adds that the Arizal and Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai share one soul, and both passed away in days of mourning: sefirah and the Nine Days. m
Hidden light, hidden secrets, and complete emunah
The Rav explains that some days are very high but we are not yet worthy of them. Like the hidden light Hashem stored for the tzaddikim in the future, these days belong to the days of Moshiach, so they are wrapped in darkness. j
Darkness is not essentially dark: it is light we cannot receive, as the eyes go dark looking at the sun. Hence Hashem 'forms light and creates darkness', and creating is higher than forming. The days of mourning that will turn to joy are thus the greatest days, hidden for now. k,l
The difference: Rabbi Shimon revealed both revealed and hidden Torah, so on his day there is joy, as the hidden emerges through the revealed. The Arizal left only secrets, and the light of the Nine Days is so high that its joy cannot yet be revealed; so one gathers, says lechayim and sings zemiros.
Returning to the verse, he says that however long the galus and its troubles, Jews are judged by emunah. Each should strengthen himself and know that secrets are hidden in the Torah; when learning has no taste, it is still good. He reads 'I believe with complete faith' as believing that one's emunah is whole, for every Jew has a hidden point of faith in his heart. a,n
Sources
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 14:22 The quality of Klal Yisrael is to keep waiting for the morning of the geulah, like watchmen, even after many kitzim and disappointments.
- 15:43 Chavakuk based all the mitzvos on emunah because his prophecy was for a generation that had fallen so low that emunah is what it can hold on to.
- 17:36 When the galus is long, Hashem judges the Jewish people by their emunah, not by the great Torah and avodah of earlier generations.
- 20:12 The Arizal's teachings cannot be understood without ruach hakodesh; at his tziyun one can at least sing his zemiros.
- 23:50 Days of mourning such as the Nine Days hide a light so great that it appears as darkness, kept for the tzaddikim in the future.
- 26:04 Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai revealed both the revealed and hidden Torah, so his day is joyous; the Arizal revealed only the hidden, so his day stays concealed.
- 29:20 Every Jew has a hidden point in his heart that believes in Hashem, and he should believe that his emunah is whole even when doubts arise.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 15:34 Why did Chavakuk base all the mitzvos on emunah alone?
Answer: 15:50 Because his prophecy was for a time when the generation had fallen so far that it no longer has the strength of earlier generations, and emunah is what it can hold on to.
-
Question: 12:53 Why do two nearly identical verses speak of judging with uprightness and with emunah?
Answer: 18:55 One describes Moshiach coming early, when Jews are judged by the measure of Torah; the other, with 'he comes' twice, describes a long galus after failed kitzim, when they are judged by their emunah.
-
Question: 21:24 What can one say over at the Arizal's tziyun, when his words cannot be understood?
Answer: 21:33 One can at least sing his zemiros.
-
Question: 23:42 Why are the days of sefirah and the Nine Days wrapped in darkness?
Answer: 24:08 They hold the light kept for the days of Moshiach, which we are not yet worthy of; a light too great appears as darkness.
-
Question: 25:55 Why is Rabbi Shimon's day of passing a joy while the Arizal's remains hidden?
Answer: 26:04 Rabbi Shimon revealed both the revealed and the hidden Torah, so the hidden comes out through the revealed; the Arizal revealed only secrets, so the joy of his day is not yet fit to be revealed.
Stories
-
21:08 Singing at the Arizal's tziyun in Tzfas
The Rav recalls being at the tziyun of the Arizal in Tzfas. At the grave of a Tanna one usually says over a mishnah or a saying of his, but he asked himself what he could say over at the Arizal's tziyun. He thought of singing Bnei Heichala, and then of the Arizal's zemiros with the words about the soul's longing: he has a longing to know the secrets but does not know them, yet sing he can.
In the story: the Arizal
Insights
- 18:55 The Rav reads the difference between the two verses as two scenarios of the geulah: an early coming judged by the measure of Torah, and a delayed coming, after 'he comes, he comes' with nothing happening, judged by emunah alone.
- 16:52 Chavakuk's essence lies in his name, given with the words 'you will embrace a son': his message is embracing and holding on, and the emunah of 'a tzaddik lives by his emunah' is what the Jews hold on to through disappointments.
- 24:26 Darkness is not essentially dark: it is light too great to be received, as one is blinded by looking at the sun; this is why 'creating' is said of darkness, a higher level than 'forming' said of light.
- 26:08 The joy of Rabbi Shimon's day of passing comes from his power to reveal the hidden through the revealed; the Arizal taught no revealed Torah, so the joy hidden in the Nine Days of his passing is not yet fit to be revealed.
- 29:05 When learning has taste, that is the revelation of Rabbi Shimon; when it has none, one is like learning the Arizal's words, and one must still know that it is good.
- 29:24 The Rav reads 'I believe with complete faith' as also believing that one's own emunah is whole, even when questions trouble a person.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 15:07 The Rav says a Jew should keep waiting and hoping for the geulah with emunah, and strengthen his emunah in the coming of Moshiach.
- 28:34 He says each person should take from this gathering to strengthen himself in emunah.
- 28:43 He says one should know and believe that secrets are hidden in the Torah, even without knowing them.
- 29:12 He says that when one feels no taste in learning, one must still know that it is good.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Chavakuk, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, Rashi, the Arizal
Terms אבילות, אור הגנוז, אמונה, הילולא, חבלי משיח, ל"ג בעומר, סודות התורה, ספירת העומר, צדיק באמונתו יחיה, רוח הקודש, תשעת הימים