תיקון המדות הנוגע למעשה - דוגמאות וסיפורים
Catalog entry: זמנים ספירה no. 7 Pocket Guide p. 29 תש"נ (1989–90) Yiddish 1 hr 31 min
Listen
About this shiur
Through many examples and stories of gedolim, the Rav shows how careful one must be with another person's feelings and dignity, and ties the low state of middos to churban, past and present.
The Rav opens with the churban that came through sinas chinam, and with the Maharal's reading that Kamtza, who did nothing, was blamed as the friend of the one who made the machlokes. From the passuk that Hashem judges 'every hidden thing' he moves to hidden wrongs between people: disgusting habits in front of others, staring at a blemish, embarrassing questions, unclear letters, names that shame a child. A nisayon can come at any moment, as in the story of R' Yosef tested by a poor guest. He shows how halachah itself avoids shaming the poor and the unlearned, and tells many stories of the Chasam Sofer, R' Akiva Eiger, R' Yisrael Salanter, R' Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld and others. He says great rabbanim attributed the churban in Europe to low middos, warns of the danger facing Klal Yisrael today, and calls for teshuvah as Shavuos approaches.
Topics: Bein Adam LaChaveiro · Middos Tovos · Stories of Tzaddikim · Chazal and Gedolei Yisroel
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Sinas chinam and the friend of Bar Kamtza listed in the guide
The Rav explains that every punishment reveals the sin behind it, so the churban shows it came from sinas chinam. He asks why the Gemara blames Kamtza, who did nothing, and brings the Maharal: Kamtza was the friend of the man who made the machlokes.
-
3:08 Hidden wrongs between people listed in the guide
From the passuk that Hashem judges every hidden thing, the Rav lists wrongs people do not see as sins: disgusting habits in front of others, staring at a blemish, asking one's rebbi an unprepared question in public, and writing letters and addresses unclearly.
-
8:06 Names that shame a child; the Bas Ayin's Hadas listed in the guide
The Rav warns against giving a child a name he will be ashamed of among his friends, and tells of the Bas Ayin in Tzfas who insisted a girl be named Hadas rather than Hadassah, which seventeen years later made her shidduch possible.
-
15:58 Small things make the eved Hashem listed in the guide
The Rav speaks of davening a long Shemoneh Esrei where one does not block others, of listening attentively when someone speaks, and says the eved Hashem is recognized in a hundred small things. He brings R' Sholom of Belz on the 'frummer' and says a person can be tested at any moment, even while leading his child to the chuppah.
-
21:29 R' Yosef and the hungry guest Story listed in the guide
The Rav tells of R' Yosef, a tzaddik who took in the guests nobody wanted, who was tested by the Satan disguised as a starving poor man, and passed. He adds the story of Dovid HaMelech and Nasan HaNavi: a person never knows when his test comes.
-
25:30 Doing a favor completely listed in the guide
The Rav says a person with good middos marks his house number clearly and says a phone number slowly. He tells of a young Belzer Rebbe who as a child told the exact time, and of R' Elchonon Wasserman, who asked a driver to take him all the way to the house: a chessed should be done completely.
-
28:59 Halachah that protects the poor from shame listed in the guide
The Rav says the Shechinah stands with the poor man, and shows from a tamei korban Pesach burned with Mikdash wood, from the baal korei, from singing at a hakafah of yichus, and from the borrowed clothes of Tu B'Av that Chazal built practices to avoid shaming. He gives the rule of 'what is hateful to you, do not do to your friend'.
-
33:17 Appeasing, private tzedakah, and Levi listed in the guide
The Rav says one who shamed a friend must appease him, even by letter, and that tzedakah to a person of good family should be given privately. He brings the Gemara that Levi was kept outside the heavenly beis medrash for not attending R' Afes's shiurim and causing him distress.
-
36:43 The Chasam Sofer's delayed teshuvah Story listed in the guide
The Rav tells the story behind a teshuvah of the Chasam Sofer about reburying R' Mordechai Banet in Nikolsburg. The answer was held back six months because R' Mordechai Banet appeared in a dream: he had to remain buried there for six months, for not defending a girl who was shamed by a broken shidduch.
-
41:11 A sharp bochur and a soul seeking tikkun Story listed in the guide
Through R' Shlomo Bloch the Rav tells of a great rosh yeshiva whose children died, because as a bochur he had shamed a visiting rav in public. Then he tells of a soul that came to R' Moshe of Savran: it had repented for everything except shaming a chassan who erred in Tehillim before his father-in-law.
-
47:14 R' Akiva Eiger guards others' honor Story listed in the guide
The Rav tells three stories of R' Akiva Eiger: he kept silent at shared sheva brachos so as not to outshine another chassan, spilled his own wine at the Seder when a guest spilled his, and left a kushya of R' Mordechai Banet unanswered in public so as not to embarrass the town's rav. He then warns young people against nicknames.
-
53:44 R' Yisrael Salanter and the shamed shoemaker listed in the guide
The Rav tells how R' Yisrael Salanter gave up a rosh yeshiva position rather than overshadow the other rosh yeshiva, and how he said the rabbanim of Vilna would be held accountable when a rich man shamed a shoemaker at his daughter's chuppah. He then says he heard from great rabbanim that the churban in Europe came because middos had sunk so low.
-
58:39 The Imrei Emes' warning and today's danger
The Rav brings the Imrei Emes' drashah at the Knessia Gedolah on 'Vayischazeik Dovid', understood only after the churban of Hitler, and the Gemara that the world trembled until the Torah was given. He describes the danger to Eretz Yisrael today and tells how his father-in-law's kehillah in Vienna argued over petty matters while Hitler threatened.
-
1:05:12 Not relying on America; teshuvah before Shavuos
The Rav says Jews cannot rely on America, now that it no longer needs Israel against Russia, and warns that rising racism and antisemitism resemble how things began in Germany. The only answer is teshuvah, tefillah and tzedakah; Sivan is a time of teshuvah, as Klal Yisrael came to Sinai in teshuvah, and one must accept the yoke of Torah.
-
1:09:58 R' Yisrael Salanter: the maid and his last night Story listed in the guide
The Rav tells how R' Yisrael Salanter agreed to eat at a wealthy host only if the Shabbos meal took an hour and a half, to spare the tired widow who served. Then he tells of his last night, when he spent his final moments calming his roommate's fear of being alone with a dead body.
-
1:16:00 A kept secret and a kerosene cholent Story listed in the guide
The Rav tells how R' Yitzchak Elchanan refused even a hundred rubles to reveal who a collection was for, and the donor then confided that he too had lost his fortune. Then R' Avigdor Halberstam, brother of the Divrei Chaim, ate a whole pot of cholent cooked with kerosene so the hostess would not be shamed.
-
1:21:05 R' Shmuel Salant, the shofar, and the brazen Story listed in the guide
The Rav tells how R' Shmuel Salant rebuked students who laughed at an old woman's question, and how he told a baal tokea that he failed because he felt pride at another's failure. He tells of the Chofetz Chaim expelling a bochur who was insolent to his host, explaining from the Mishnah that the brazen never do teshuvah, and of the Satmar Rav expelling a bochur who refused to collect money.
-
1:26:47 R' Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld's sensitivity Story listed in the guide
The Rav tells how R' Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld spared the Lubliner Rav's feelings when visitors came only to him, gave the Mussaf to the late chazzan's son to comfort the widow, and asked to return to the Old City before his passing so the people carrying him would not have far to go.
The shiur, written up
Sinas chinam and the friend of Bar Kamtza
The Rav explains that every punishment reveals the sin behind it, so the churban of the Beis HaMikdash shows that it came through sinas chinam, as in the episode of Kamtza and Bar Kamtza. He asks why the Gemara blames Kamtza, who did nothing. The Maharal answers that a baal machlokes always has friends who back him, and Kamtza was the friend of the one who made the machlokes. a
Hidden wrongs between people
From the passuk in Koheles that Hashem brings into judgment 'every hidden thing', and the Gemara on it, the Rav speaks of wrongs people do not count as sins: disgusting habits in front of others, or staring at someone's blemish when he is sensitive to it. Chazal weighed even when to ask one's rebbi a question, as the Gemara tells that Rav asked Rebbi about another masechta. b,c,d
Names that shame a child
The Rav says parents were warned not to give a child a name he will be ashamed of among his friends. Jews took French names in France and German names in Germany, but today a child can be mocked for such a name, especially a girl. Some advise names from Tanach, yet the Rav notes that this too can cause problems in shidduchim, and he tells a story to show it.
A Yerushalmi Jew told him that his grandfather was a chassid of the Bas Ayin, whose shul in Tzfas still bears a plaque about the earthquake, when the half of the shul where he stood with his people did not fall. When a girl was named in his presence and the gabbai called out Hadassah, the Bas Ayin insisted on Hadas. Seventeen years later her mother-in-law turned out to be named Hadassah, which would have prevented the shidduch.
The Rav says he gives no ruling against Jewish customs, but notes that the Chazon Ish was concerned for a child's embarrassment.
Small things make the eved Hashem
The Rav says one who davens a long Shemoneh Esrei should stand where he will not trap others, since one may not pass in front of a person davening. When someone speaks to a person, he should listen with attention and not brush him off. An eved Hashem is recognized not in the big things everyone does, like shofar or fasting, but in a hundred small ones.
He brings R' Sholom of Belz, who said one must be an erlicher Yid, not a 'frummer'; one who brushes off a broken-hearted man before Ne'ilah is a frummer, while listening to him is a chessed. A test can come at any moment, even while leading one's child to the chuppah.
R' Yosef and the hungry guest
The Rav tells of R' Yosef, a tzaddik who took in the guests nobody wanted. When Heaven decreed to give him a son with a great soul, the Satan received permission to test him and came as a smelly poor man in the middle of his long davening. R' Yosef cut his davening short, fed him again and again, and when the guest demanded challah and fish, went out and asked the town to bring some. The Satan withdrew, and R' Yosef merited his great son.
Doing a favor completely
The Rav says a person with good middos marks his house number clearly and says a phone number slowly, so others are not troubled. He tells of a young Belzer tzaddik who, as a child of three, told a visitor the exact time and said the clock taught him that a favor must be done completely. R' Elchonon Wasserman likewise asked a man who gave him a ride to take him right to the house, explaining that a chessed should be done whole.
Halachah that protects the poor from shame
When a poor man comes, the Rav says, one must remember that the Shechinah stands at his right. Chazal were careful about people's feelings: a korban Pesach that became tamei was burned with wood of the Mikdash, and nobody could bring his own, so as not to shame those who could not buy wood. g,h
Appeasing, private tzedakah, and Levi
One who shamed a friend must appease him, the Rav says, even by letter, and tzedakah to a person of good family should be given privately. He brings the Gemara that Shmuel saw Levi kept outside the heavenly beis medrash, because he had not gone to the shiurim of R' Afes and caused him distress. k
The Chasam Sofer's delayed teshuvah
The Rav tells the story behind a teshuvah of the Chasam Sofer. R' Mordechai Banet, rav of Nikolsburg, passed away in a small town and was buried there, and Nikolsburg asked whether he could be reburied in their city. The Chasam Sofer permitted it, but sent his answer only six months later. l
His family explained: R' Mordechai Banet came to him in a dream. As a young rav there he had not done enough to stop a chassan from breaking a shidduch, and the girl was badly shamed; so he had to lie there six months.
A sharp bochur and a soul seeking tikkun
R' Shlomo Bloch, a talmid of the Chofetz Chaim, told of a great, sharp rosh yeshiva whose children died. As a fiery bochur of seventeen he had challenged a visiting rav's pilpul with kushyos, rejected the answers, and in the heated exchange shamed him in front of everyone. The Rav says that young people especially must be careful in bein adam lachaveiro.
He then tells of a soul that came to R' Moshe of Savran for a tikkun. It had been a true tzaddik and had done teshuvah for everything but one thing: when a father-in-law boasted of his chassan, the chassan erred in Tehillim, and this man pointed it out, so the chassan turned red with shame. For this he was not let in, since Heaven is exacting in matters between people.
R' Akiva Eiger guards others' honor
At sheva brachos shared with another chassan, R' Akiva Eiger kept silent while the other said Torah, and only after he left said a wondrous pilpul; he had not wanted to shame him. At his Seder, when a poor guest spilled wine over the fine tablecloth, he at once spilled his own cup so the guest would not feel hurt.
In Nikolsburg, when R' Mordechai Banet asked a kushya in the middle of his drashah, R' Akiva Eiger left it unanswered. Privately he said he could have answered, but did not want to embarrass the rav of the town. The Rav adds a warning against nicknames among young people, which shame a person.
R' Yisrael Salanter and the shamed shoemaker
R' Yisrael Salanter gave up a rosh yeshiva position when he saw the students drawn to him more than to the other rosh yeshiva. He also said the rabbanim of Vilna would answer for not teaching middos, when a rich man at a shoemaker's daughter's chuppah asked him how much it would cost to fix his shoe.
The Rav says he heard from great rabbanim that the churban in Europe came because middos had sunk so low: people shamed others, and there was jealousy, hatred and petty machlokes.
The Imrei Emes' warning and today's danger
The Rav saw the Imrei Emes speak at the Knessia Gedolah on 'Vayischazeik Dovid': when Dovid's wives and children were taken, he strengthened himself. The Imrei Emes said Klal Yisrael must strengthen itself, that more would be returned than was taken, and that above all there must be no sinas chinam. Nobody understood until the churban of Hitler. m
He brings the Gemara in Shabbos that the world trembled until Klal Yisrael accepted the Torah. Today, he says, the danger in Eretz Yisrael is great, with chemical and other weapons; believers stay because Hashem watches the land, while others hide their heads like the ostrich. n
His father-in-law was on the board of the kehillah in Vienna, which met over petty matters such as positions and who would be president while Hitler threatened all of Europe.
Not relying on America; teshuvah before Shavuos
The Rav says Jews cannot rely on America, which no longer needs Israel against Russia, and warns that rising racism and antisemitism resemble how things began in Germany. The only answer is teshuvah, tefillah and tzedakah.
R' Yisrael Salanter: the maid and his last night
A wealthy host boasted to R' Yisrael Salanter of his long Shabbos meals, but R' Yisrael came only on condition that the meal last no more than an hour and a half. Asked why, he called in the maid, a poor widow, and apologized for the rushing; she said that after working since early Friday she could hardly stand through a meal of many hours.
At the end of his life, among strangers, he spent his last night calming his roommate's fear of being alone with a dead body. The Rav says a person's last moment reflects his whole life.
A kept secret and a kerosene cholent
R' Yitzchak Elchanan collected for a rich man who had lost his fortune, and refused to reveal his name even when a donor offered a hundred rubles. The donor then told him privately that he too had lost everything, and now saw that his secret would be kept.
R' Avigdor Halberstam, brother of the Divrei Chaim, honored with serving the cholent, kept taking it for himself until the pot was empty. The hostess later found it smelled of kerosene she had used by mistake; he ate it so she would not be shamed.
R' Shmuel Salant, the shofar, and the brazen
When students laughed at an old woman whose cat had snatched unsalted meat, R' Shmuel Salant answered her seriously and rebuked them: laughed at, she would not come to ask again. He told a baal tokea that he failed because he felt pride when the first could not blow.
The Chofetz Chaim sent away a bochur insolent to his host and would not let him repent in the yeshiva. The Rav explains the Mishnah 'the brazen go to Gehinnom': every sinner may do teshuvah, but the brazen never does. The Satmar Rav likewise sent away a bochur who refused to collect money. p
R' Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld's sensitivity
When the Lubliner Rav sat with R' Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld on Yom Tov, he asked each visitor whether he came from the Kosel, so the guest would not be pained that people came only to him. He gave Mussaf to the late chazzan's son, to comfort the widow rather than make her weep at a stranger's voice. Before his passing he asked to return to the Old City, so his bearers would not have far to go.
Sources
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
- a Gittin 55b text index In the write-up: 1:19
- c apparently Chagigah 5a index In the write-up: 3:11
- d apparently Shabbos 3b index In the write-up: 3:11
- h apparently Pesachim 82a index In the write-up: 29:10
- j apparently Shabbos 31a index In the write-up: 31:01
- k apparently Berachos 18b index In the write-up: 33:20
- n apparently Shabbos 88a index In the write-up: 1:00:17
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 1:19 Every punishment reveals its sin: the Beis HaMikdash was destroyed through sinas chinam, and even the friend of a baal machlokes shares the blame.
- 3:18 Hashem judges even 'hidden' wrongs that people do not count as sins, such as behaving disgustingly in front of others or causing someone embarrassment.
- 17:39 What distinguishes an eved Hashem is not the big mitzvos everyone keeps but a hundred small things, above all in how he treats people.
- 29:40 Halachah and Jewish custom were built to avoid shaming those who have less, as with the wood for a tamei korban Pesach, the baal korei and the borrowed clothes of Tu B'Av.
- 35:28 Heaven is exacting about the feelings of others: the stories of Levi, R' Mordechai Banet and the soul that came to R' Moshe of Savran show punishment for causing distress or shame.
- 57:46 The Rav reports hearing from great rabbanim that the churban in Europe came because middos had fallen so low, and he warns of the danger facing Klal Yisrael today.
- 1:07:42 With Shavuos approaching, he calls for teshuvah and for accepting the yoke of Torah, mitzvos and fear of Heaven, turning only to the Ribono shel Olam.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:27 Why does the Gemara blame the churban on Kamtza, who was the friend and did nothing?
Answer: 2:39 The Maharal explains that a baal machlokes always has friends who back him; as the friend of the one who made the machlokes, Kamtza was his accomplice.
-
Question: 38:20 Why did the Chasam Sofer delay his teshuvah about R' Mordechai Banet for six months?
Answer: 39:07 R' Mordechai Banet appeared in a dream and said he had to stay buried there six months for not defending a shamed girl.
-
Question: 51:53 Why did R' Akiva Eiger leave R' Mordechai Banet's kushya unanswered?
Answer: 52:05 He could answer, but did not want to embarrass the rav of the town in public.
-
Question: 1:11:25 Why did R' Yisrael Salanter insist the Shabbos meal take only an hour and a half?
Answer: 1:11:42 To spare the widowed maid, who worked from early Friday and could not stand through a meal of many hours.
-
Question: 1:25:05 Why did the Chofetz Chaim not let the insolent bochur stay and do teshuvah?
Answer: 1:25:13 From the Mishnah 'the brazen go to Gehinnom': every sinner can do teshuvah, but the brazen never does.
-
Question: 1:28:46 Why did R' Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld give Mussaf to the late chazzan's son?
Answer: 1:29:04 The widow would weep hearing a stranger in her husband's place, but her own son would comfort her, and that is a greater honor for the congregation.
Stories
-
10:43 The Bas Ayin and the name Hadas
The Rav tells, from a Yerushalmi Jew whose grandfather was a chassid of the Bas Ayin, that the Bas Ayin's shul in Tzfas still bears a plaque recalling how half of it stood in an earthquake when he gathered the people around him. When a girl was named at the Torah in his presence, the gabbai called her Hadassah; the Bas Ayin stopped him and insisted on Hadas. Seventeen years later she became a kallah, and her mother-in-law was named Hadassah, so with that name the shidduch could not have been made.
In the story: the Bas Ayin
-
21:47 R' Yosef tested by a hungry guest
R' Yosef was a tzaddik who always took the poor guests nobody else would take. When it was decreed in Heaven to give him a son with a great soul, the Satan asked permission to test him, and came as a smelly poor man in the middle of his long davening, saying he was hungry. R' Yosef cut his davening short and took him home, fed him again and again, and when the guest demanded fish and challah he went out and called on the people of the town to bring some. The Satan withdrew, and R' Yosef merited a son who became a great tzaddik.
In the story: R' Yosef
-
37:04 R' Mordechai Banet's six months
R' Mordechai Banet, rav of Nikolsburg, passed away in a small town and was buried there, and Nikolsburg asked the Chasam Sofer whether he could be reburied in their city. The Chasam Sofer wrote a teshuvah but held it back; that night R' Mordechai Banet appeared to him in a dream. As a young rav in that town he had not done enough to stop a chassan from breaking a shidduch with a girl, who was badly shamed, so he had to lie there six months. After six months the Chasam Sofer sent his teshuvah permitting the move.
In the story: R' Mordechai Banet, the Chasam Sofer
-
41:18 The bochur who shamed a visiting rav
R' Shlomo Bloch, a talmid of the Chofetz Chaim, told of a great, sharp rosh yeshiva whose children died. As a seventeen-year-old bochur with a fiery temperament, he had challenged a visiting rav's pilpul with kushyos, refused to accept the answers, and in the heated exchange shamed him in front of everyone. R' Shlomo Bloch said this was the cause.
In the story: R' Shlomo Bloch, the Chofetz Chaim
-
44:24 The soul that shamed a chassan
A soul came to R' Moshe of Savran seeking a tikkun. It had been a true tzaddik and had done teshuvah for its sins, except one: at a wedding where the father-in-law boasted of his chassan's learning, the chassan made a mistake saying Tehillim, and this man pointed it out so that the chassan turned red with shame before his father-in-law. For that he was not let in.
In the story: R' Moshe of Savran
-
47:18 R' Akiva Eiger at sheva brachos, at the Seder and in Nikolsburg
At sheva brachos shared with another chassan, R' Akiva Eiger said nothing while the other chassan said Torah, and only after he left did R' Akiva Eiger say a wondrous pilpul, explaining that he did not want to shame him. At his Seder, when a poor guest spilled wine over the beautiful tablecloth, R' Akiva Eiger at once spilled his own cup with his elbow so the guest would not feel hurt. In Nikolsburg, when R' Mordechai Banet asked a kushya in the middle of his drashah, he left it unanswered; privately he said he could have answered, but did not want to embarrass the town's rav.
In the story: R' Akiva Eiger, R' Mordechai Banet
-
53:45 R' Yisrael Salanter steps aside
R' Yisrael Salanter received a position as rosh yeshiva in a yeshiva where another great rosh yeshiva already gave shiurim. When he noticed the students were more drawn to him, he left the yeshiva, giving up his position rather than compete with and pain the other rosh yeshiva.
In the story: R' Yisrael Salanter
-
55:20 The shoemaker at his daughter's chuppah
A shoemaker who had worked his way up made his daughter's wedding in the hall where only the very rich held weddings. At the chuppah a wealthy man, displeased that a plain shoemaker was mixing with the rich, took off his shoe and asked the father how much it would cost to fix it, and the man was deeply hurt. R' Yisrael Salanter said the rabbanim of Vilna would give a din v'cheshbon for it, since they had not taught mussar and middos.
In the story: R' Yisrael Salanter
-
58:39 The Imrei Emes at the Knessia Gedolah
The Rav says he saw the Gerrer Rebbe, the Imrei Emes, give a drashah at the Knessia Gedolah on 'Vayischazeik Dovid': when Dovid's wives and children were taken captive, he strengthened himself in Hashem. The Imrei Emes said Klal Yisrael must strengthen itself, that more would be returned than was taken, and that the main thing is that there be no sinas chinam. Nobody understood the drashah until, a few years later, came the churban of Hitler.
In the story: the Imrei Emes
-
1:03:31 Petty meetings in Vienna
The Rav's father-in-law was a prominent member of the board of the kehillah in Vienna. He told that while Hitler was strong and wanted to swallow all of Europe, the board met and argued about petty things: positions, seats, honor and who would be president or vice president. In the end those who could fled to America or Eretz Yisrael, and what happened to the rest is known.
-
1:10:05 R' Yisrael Salanter and the widow who served
A wealthy, G-d-fearing host invited R' Yisrael Salanter for Shabbos and boasted of his long meal with zemiros and divrei Torah. R' Yisrael agreed on condition the meal take no more than an hour and a half, and it was done quickly. Asked why, he called in the maid, a poor widow, and apologized to her for the rushing; she said that every Shabbos she worked from early Friday and could hardly stand by the time the meal stretched on for hours. R' Yisrael told the host that now he understood why he had asked.
In the story: R' Yisrael Salanter
-
1:13:28 R' Yisrael Salanter's last night
At the end of his life R' Yisrael Salanter was in a place where he was not known, sharing a room with another Jew. When he fell ill and understood that his last hour had come, at night, he spent it explaining to his roommate that there is no reason to fear a dead body, that it harms nobody. Then he passed away, and the roommate remained with him the whole night until morning, when the chevra kadisha could be called.
In the story: R' Yisrael Salanter
-
1:16:00 R' Yitzchak Elchanan keeps a secret
R' Yitzchak Elchanan went collecting for a wealthy man who had lost his fortune. One rich man asked who it was for and offered twenty-five, then fifty, then a hundred rubles to know, but R' Yitzchak Elchanan refused to reveal it. Then the man asked to speak to him privately and told him that he too had lost everything, and had been afraid to tell him lest his secret come out; now he saw it would be kept.
In the story: R' Yitzchak Elchanan Spektor
-
1:19:20 The kerosene cholent
R' Avigdor Halberstam, brother of the Divrei Chaim, was a guest at a Shabbos table where, as was the custom in Hungary and Galicia, the eldest was honored with the pot of cholent to serve. He put cholent on his plate, then took more and more, until the pot was empty and nobody else got any. Later the hostess noticed that the cholent smelled of kerosene, which she had put in by mistake; he ate it all so she would not be shamed in front of the guests.
In the story: R' Avigdor Halberstam, the Divrei Chaim
-
1:21:05 R' Shmuel Salant and the old woman's question
An old, simple woman came to R' Shmuel Salant, rav of Yerushalayim, while he sat with his students: as she salted meat, a cat had jumped up and taken a large piece of unsalted meat. The students laughed. R' Shmuel Salant did not laugh; he looked into a sefer, answered her seriously, and afterwards rebuked the students, saying that if they laughed at her she would not come again to ask.
In the story: R' Shmuel Salant
-
1:26:47 R' Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld and the Lubliner Rav
Every Yom Tov nearly every Jew in Yerushalayim came to wish R' Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld a good Yom Tov. Once the Lubliner Rav, R' Eliyahu Klatzkin, was sitting with him, and R' Yosef Chaim asked each visitor whether he had been at the Kosel. His son asked why; he answered that so the Lubliner Rav would not be pained that people came to him and not to the guest, he made it appear that they came on their way from the Kosel.
In the story: R' Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, R' Eliyahu Klatzkin
Insights
- 2:39 The Rav reads the Maharal on Kamtza as a lesson that one who stands beside a baal machlokes as his friend and ally shares in the churban, even if he did nothing himself.
- 19:16 He explains R' Sholom of Belz's acrostic on the word 'frummer', and contrasts the 'frummer' who brushes off a broken-hearted person before Ne'ilah with the erlicher Yid who listens, since that is a chessed.
- 31:01 He sees the practices of the baal korei reading for everyone and of singing at a hakafah of yichus as built on the same principle as the borrowed clothes of Tu B'Av: one who can do more must still follow the custom, so as not to expose those who cannot.
- 1:13:16 From R' Yisrael Salanter's last night the Rav learns that a person's final moment reflects his whole life: the tzaddik spent it sparing another Jew from fear, which shows what his life was.
- 1:25:23 On the Mishnah 'the brazen go to Gehinnom', the Rav explains that every sinner can do teshuvah, but the brazen never does, so he has a one-way road; this is why the Chofetz Chaim would not keep the insolent bochur.
- 1:28:59 R' Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld weighed comforting a widow by letting her son lead Mussaf as a greater honor for the congregation than the rule about who should lead.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 15:58 The Rav says one who davens a long Shemoneh Esrei should stand where he will not trap others behind him.
- 7:26 He says to write letters, addresses and house numbers clearly, and to say a phone number slowly, so others are not troubled.
- 17:16 He says that when someone speaks to a person, he should give him attention and show interest rather than brush him off.
- 33:20 He says tzedakah for a person of good family should be given privately, and one who shamed a friend must appease him, even by letter.
- 1:08:26 He says that in the month of Sivan every Jew is obligated in teshuvah, and should accept the yoke of Torah, mitzvos and fear of Heaven rather than busy himself with foolishness and careers.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Bar Kamtza, Dovid HaMelech, Kamtza, Levi (son of Yaakov), Nasan HaNavi, Rabbi Afes, Rabbi Akiva Eiger, Rabbi Avigdor Halberstam, Rabbi Elchonon Wasserman, Rabbi Eliyahu Klatzkin, Rabbi Mordechai Banet, Rabbi Moshe of Savran, Rabbi Shlomo Bloch, Rabbi Shmuel Salant, Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi (Rebbi), Rabbi Yisrael Salanter, Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan Spektor, Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, Rav (the Amora), Rav Yosef, the Bas Ayin, the Chasam Sofer, the Chazon Ish, the Chofetz Chaim, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), the Imrei Emes (Rabbi Avraham Mordechai of Ger), the Maharal of Prague, the Sar Shalom of Belz (Rabbi Shalom of Belz), the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum)
Terms בין אדם לחבירו, נסיון, עזות דקדושה, קבלת עול מלכות שמים, שנאת חנם, תשובה