לבנה בשלימותה - התגלות השכינה

Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת ט"ו באב no. ⁨5⁩ Pocket Guide p. 33 תשס"ט (2008–09) Yiddish 32 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 32 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that the dor hamidbar knew on Tu b'Av that the decree had ended because only then could they sense the moon, the middas malchus and yiras shamayim, which had been hidden since the sin of the meraglim.

The Rav opens with the Gemara's reason for the yom tov of Tu b'Av: every Tisha b'Av in the desert part of the generation died in graves they dug, and in the fortieth year they kept lying down night after night until the full moon of the fifteenth told them the decree was over. He asks how they could have doubted the date on the fourteenth, when the moon is almost full. He tells how the Radziner Rebbe brought his techeiles to the Sfas Emes, who said he did not smell techeiles. Through the Ramchal's question on the berachah of Yotzer and the Divrei Yoel on Rabbeinu Tam, he develops an upper and a lower sun and moon. The moon is malchus and yiras shamayim, which is the sense of smell; after the meraglim it was hidden, and on Tu b'Av, the start of the awakening toward Rosh Hashanah, they sensed it again.

Topics: Tu B'Av and the Weeks of Nechamah · Yiras Shamayim

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Why Tu b'Av is a yom tov listed in the guide

    After opening singing, the Rav brings the Gemara's reason for Tu b'Av: each Tisha b'Av in the desert part of the generation died in graves they had dug, and in the fortieth year they lay down night after night until the full moon of the fifteenth showed them the decree was over.

  2. 4:45 A question, and the Radziner's techeiles Story

    The Rav asks how they could have thought they miscounted on the fourteenth, when the moon is nearly full. He then tells how the Radziner Rebbe found the chilazon, made techeiles and argued for it, and how the Sfas Emes held it to his nose and said he did not smell techeiles.

  3. 8:10 The upper sun and the lower sun

    The Rav brings the Ramchal's question on the berachah of Yotzer, which speaks of opening the gates of the east each day, and his answer that the influence of an upper sun comes down each dawn into the visible sun. He adds the Divrei Yoel, who answers the Baal HaTanya's objection to Rabbeinu Tam's 72 minutes with the upper sun.

  4. 12:00 The moon, malchus and the sense of smell listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that the moon is malchus and yiras shamayim, which is smell, so the Sfas Emes meant the techeiles lacked yiras shamayim, as there will be no techeiles until Moshiach. The moon is hidden on Rosh Hashanah until Jews crown Hashem with the shofar, and after the meraglim the 'smelled' moon was hidden altogether.

  5. 15:55 Sensing the moon on Tu b'Av listed in the guide

    The Rav answers his question: they thought a merit was holding off the decree day after day, as with the sotah, until on Tu b'Av they sensed the moon and malchus. Tu b'Av is when the awakening toward Rosh Hashanah and teshuvah begins, and it brings lights of geulah.

  6. 19:23 Singing (Singing)

The shiur, written up

Why Tu b'Av is a yom tov

3:08

The Rav brings the Gemara's reason for the yom tov of Tu b'Av. Every Tisha b'Av in the desert the generation lay down in graves they had dug, and part of them died. In the fortieth year all rose, so they feared they had miscounted and lay down again each night until the fifteenth, when the full moon showed them the decree was over. a

A question, and the Radziner's techeiles

4:48

The Rav calls this Gemara a wonder: on the fourteenth the moon is almost full, so how could they still think it was Tisha b'Av? a

5:57

He then tells of the Radziner Rebbe, a genius also learned in chemistry, who found the chilazon, made techeiles and argued for it with proofs. When he brought it to the Sfas Emes, the Sfas Emes held it to his nose and said he did not smell techeiles.

The upper sun and the lower sun

8:14

The Ramchal asks why the berachah of Yotzer speaks of opening the gates of the east each day, when nobody thought the sky splits open. He answers that there is an upper sun and moon; each dawn the upper sun's influence comes down through the tzimtzumim into the visible sun, giving it its power. b

11:04

With this the Divrei Yoel answers the Baal HaTanya, who wrote in his siddur that the senses contradict Rabbeinu Tam's 72 minutes: those minutes follow the upper sun. d,e

The moon, malchus and the sense of smell

12:00

The moon is middas malchus, yiras shamayim, and yiras shamayim is the sense of smell, as Yeshayahu 11:3 says of Moshiach, who is compared to the moon in Tehillim 89:38. So the moon is called yareach, from rei'ach. This explains the Sfas Emes: one might prove the dye is techeiles, but it lacks the yiras shamayim of the upper moon, and so there will be no techeiles until Moshiach. f,g

14:32

On Rosh Hashanah the moon is hidden, as Tehillim 81:4 says, until Jews arouse malchus with the shofar of Tehillim 98:6. After the meraglim there was hester panim: the physical moon remained, but the moon one 'smells' was gone. h,i

Sensing the moon on Tu b'Av

16:14

So they thought a merit was holding off the decree day by day, as the Mishnah in Sotah describes. On the fifteenth they sensed the moon and malchus. The Rav explains that then the awakening toward Rosh Hashanah and teshuvah begins, and Tu b'Av brings lights of geulah. j

Sources

Nevi'im

  1. f Yeshayahu 11:3 text index In the write-up: 12:00

Kesuvim

  1. g Tehillim 89:38 text index In the write-up: 12:00
  2. h Tehillim 81:4 text index In the write-up: 14:32
  3. i Tehillim 98:6 text index In the write-up: 14:32

Mishnah

  1. j apparently Mishnah Sotah 3:4 index In the write-up: 16:14

Talmud Bavli

  1. a apparently Taanis 30b index In the write-up: 3:08, 4:48
  2. k apparently Sotah 2a 17:11 index

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. c apparently Zohar III 10a 9:03 index

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. e Divrei Yoel (place not identified) index In the write-up: 11:04

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. b apparently Shacharis, berachah of Yotzer Or index In the write-up: 8:14
  2. d Siddur of the Baal HaTanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 11:04

Key points

  1. 3:08 In the fortieth year the dor hamidbar lay down in their graves night after night, and only the full moon of the fifteenth of Av showed them the decree was over, so they made a yom tov.
  2. 9:44 There is an upper sun and moon and a lower sun and moon; the visible sun's power to sustain the world comes down from the upper sun each dawn through the tzimtzumim.
  3. 12:00 The moon is middas malchus, which is yiras shamayim, and yiras shamayim is the sense of smell; therefore the moon is called yareach, from rei'ach, smell.
  4. 15:27 Since the sin of the meraglim there was hester panim: the physical moon was there, but the moon one can 'smell' was hidden.
  5. 16:43 Tu b'Av is when the awakening toward Rosh Hashanah begins, and on it the dor hamidbar sensed the moon, middas malchus, revealed again.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 4:48 How could the dor hamidbar think on the fourteenth of Av that they had miscounted, when the moon is then almost full?

    Answer: 15:41 Since the meraglim, the moon of malchus that one 'smells' was hidden; they saw the physical moon but sensed malchus only on Tu b'Av.

  2. Question: 8:14 The Ramchal asks: the berachah of Yotzer speaks of opening the gates of the east every day, yet nobody ever thought the sky splits open each morning.

    Answer: 9:44 There is an upper sun; each dawn its influence comes down through the tzimtzumim into the visible sun.

  3. Question: 11:04 The Baal HaTanya writes that the senses contradict Rabbeinu Tam's 72 minutes after sunset.

    Answer: 11:24 The Divrei Yoel answers that the 72 minutes are measured by the upper sun, whose power leaves 72 minutes after sunset.

  4. Question: 13:09 What does it mean that there will be no techeiles until Moshiach comes?

    Answer: 13:28 Physically one might prove a dye is techeiles, but it does not 'smell' of techeiles: the yiras shamayim of the upper moon, which hints at Moshiach, does not flow into it today.

  5. Question: 16:59 Why specifically on the fifteenth of Av could they sense the moon?

    Answer: 17:08 Because then the awakening of Rosh Hashanah already begins and the time of teshuvah is aroused, so malchus starts to be revealed.

Stories

  1. 2:51 The last Tisha b'Av in the desert

    Because of the decree on the dor hamidbar, every Tisha b'Av they dug graves and lay down in them at night, and each year a certain part of them died while the rest got up and waited for the next Tisha b'Av. In the fortieth year all of them got up, and they thought they might have miscounted, so they lay down again on the tenth, eleventh, twelfth, thirteenth and fourteenth. When the fifteenth came and the moon was full, they knew they had not erred and made a yom tov.

    told in 3 other shiurim →

  2. 5:57 The Radziner's techeiles and the Sfas Emes

    The Radziner Rebbe, a great genius who also knew the sciences and chemistry, set out to find techeiles. He went to places near the Kinneret where the chilazon can be found, found it and made techeiles, and went around to rabbanim and gaonim claiming it was the original techeiles, but almost nobody would accept it, and he argued with proofs from Shas and poskim and from the sciences. He came to the Sfas Emes for his agreement; the Sfas Emes put the techeiles to his nose and said he did not smell techeiles. The Radziner felt he could answer thousands of arguments, but had no answer to 'it does not smell of techeiles'.

    In the story: the Radziner Rebbe, the Sfas Emes

Insights

  1. 12:14 The Rav reads the moon's name yareach as coming from rei'ach, smell: the moon is malchus and yiras shamayim, and yiras shamayim is perceived through smell, as said of Moshiach.
  2. 13:02 He explains the Sfas Emes's 'I do not smell techeiles' through this: one might prove scientifically that a dye is techeiles, but it lacks the root of yiras shamayim from the upper moon, and that is why there will be no techeiles until Moshiach.
  3. 15:41 The dor hamidbar could see a nearly full physical moon on the fourteenth and still doubt, because since the meraglim the moon one 'smells', middas malchus, was hidden from them; on Tu b'Av they sensed it again.
  4. 9:25 The upper sun and lower sun resolve both the Ramchal's question on the daily 'opening of the gates of the east' and, in the Divrei Yoel, the objection that the senses contradict Rabbeinu Tam's 72 minutes.
  5. 14:32 The moon is hidden on Rosh Hashanah because malchus must be aroused from below, through the shofar and the acceptance of malchus shamayim; Tu b'Av, as the start of that awakening, is when the moon was revealed to the dor hamidbar.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Rabbeinu Tam, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Radziner Rebbe, the Ramchal (Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto), the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), the Sfas Emes

Terms דור המדבר, הסתר פנים, חוש הריח, חמשה עשר באב, יראת שמים, מלכות, מרגלים, צמצום, תכלת

Report an error on this page