זמן של שישו אתה כל המתאבלים עליה
Catalog entry: זמנים ט"ו באב no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 33 תש"מ (1979–80) Yiddish 42 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Tu b'Av is a festival of the future: Jews rejoice that they merited to mourn the Beis HaMikdash and never stopped hoping, and its full meaning will be revealed only when Moshiach comes.
The Rav notes that Pesach, head of the festivals, sets the weekday of each festival through the atbash sign, yet the seventh day of Pesach sets nothing, though Tu b'Av always falls on its weekday. He answers that the signs mark only what has already happened; Tu b'Av belongs to the future, to the 'day that is entirely Shabbos'. This is why the Gemara gives six reasons for Tu b'Av, none sufficient: the seventh will be known when Hashem makes a dance for the tzaddikim. He explains Tu b'Av as rejoicing that Jews merited to mourn, a sign of life, shown by the slain of Beitar who did not decay. Tu b'Av opens the days of teshuvah: each Jew resolves to be good, 'borrowing' from what he will become. Like David's watchmen awaiting morning, Jews keep hoping after every disappointment, a depth only a pointing finger can convey.
Topics: Tu B'Av and the Weeks of Nechamah · Awaiting Moshiach · The Beis HaMikdash and Its Churban
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Untranscribed opening (Unclear audio)
-
7:43 Why the seventh of Pesach sets no day listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Pesach, king of the festivals, sets the weekdays of the festivals by the atbash sign, and asks why the seventh day of Pesach, though Tu b'Av falls on its weekday, is not part of the sign. He answers that the sign marks only festivals already given; Tu b'Av belongs to the future, and its hint will be made when Moshiach comes.
-
11:07 Six reasons, and the missing seventh listed in the guide
The Rav compares the Gemara's six reasons for Tu b'Av to a child who gives six excuses for coming late, since no one reason suffices. Each reason is true yet too small for the greatest festival; the seventh reason will be known when Hashem makes a dance for the tzaddikim and each will point with his finger.
-
14:25 Rejoicing that we mourned; the slain of Beitar listed in the guide
The Rav explains Tu b'Av as the joy over having mourned the Beis HaMikdash for 1,912 years, a sign of the Jewish life force, 'rejoice with her all who mourn her'. He brings the slain of Beitar, who fought for Bar Koziva and whom the enemies wished to leave to rot, yet they did not decay: the hope for Moshiach is alive and does not decay.
-
19:40 A festival of the future; start of teshuvah listed in the guide
The Rav ties Tu b'Av to the seventh day of Pesach, which points to the future redemption, and explains that it celebrates what will be. Tu b'Av opens the days of teshuvah: each Jew makes an accounting, adds Torah at night and takes on new resolutions, as a rav would say over farfel that what was until now is lost. Every Jew has his own redemption when he does teshuvah.
-
23:14 Borrowed white garments and endless hope listed in the guide
The Rav explains that mitzvos are garments, like the soiled garments removed from Yehoshua the Kohen Gadol, and that on Tu b'Av a Jew 'borrows' white garments from the good he will become, bringing the Kotzker's remark about borrowing a father. He describes the disappointment when Moshiach did not come on Tisha b'Av, and brings 'watchmen for the morning': a Jew keeps hoping and rises from mourning to rejoice.
-
26:48 What only a finger can explain listed in the guide
The Rav says all the disappointments will be sweetened into the great joy of the future Tu b'Av, the dance of the tzaddikim. Some ideas cannot be put into words and can only be pointed at with a finger; so too the depth of a Jewish heart that still hopes after 1,912 years, 'behold this is our G-d, we hoped for Him'. He closes with a blessing for the redemption.
-
30:27 Untranscribed end of the recording (Unclear audio)
The shiur, written up
Why the seventh of Pesach sets no day
The Rav explains that Pesach, king of the festivals, fixes the weekday of each festival through the atbash sign. He asks why the seventh day of Pesach, its main day, fixes nothing, though Tu b'Av always falls on its weekday. He answers that the signs cover only festivals Jews already have; Tu b'Av belongs to the future, and its hint will be made when Moshiach comes. b
Six reasons, and the missing seventh
The Gemara gives six reasons for Tu b'Av. The Rav compares this to a child who gives six excuses for coming late: if one were good, one would suffice. Each reason is true, yet too small for the greatest festival. The seventh will be known when Hashem makes a dance for the tzaddikim and each points with his finger. d,e
Rejoicing that we mourned
A festival of the future
The seventh of Pesach points to the future redemption, so Tu b'Av celebrates what will be. It also opens the days of teshuvah: each Jew resolves to improve, to learn before sleeping and daven with the tzibbur, as a rav would say over his Shabbos farfel that what was until now is 'farfallen', lost.
Borrowed white garments and endless hope
What only a finger can explain
All the disappointments, the Rav says, will be sweetened into the great joy of the future dance. Some ideas cannot be put into words, only pointed at with a finger, like a Jewish heart still hoping after 1,912 years. Then all will say 'behold this is our G-d, we hoped for Him', and hope again. f
Sources
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 8:44 The atbash sign gives no day for the seventh of Pesach because Tu b'Av, which falls on its weekday, belongs to the future, and a sign cannot be made for what has not yet happened.
- 13:23 The Gemara's six reasons for Tu b'Av are each true but each insufficient, which itself shows that the real reason is still hidden until Moshiach comes.
- 15:01 On Tu b'Av Jews rejoice that they merited to mourn the Beis HaMikdash, a sign that they are alive and still hope for its rebuilding.
- 20:59 Tu b'Av is the first of the days of teshuvah, when each Jew resolves to improve and, like borrowed white garments, draws now on the good he will become.
- 26:11 A Jew never despairs: after every disappointed hope for Moshiach he hopes again, and this is the joy that will be revealed in the future.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 8:44 Why does the seventh day of Pesach, the main day of Pesach, determine no festival in the atbash sign, though Tu b'Av falls on its weekday?
Answer: 10:07 The signs mark only festivals Jews already have; Tu b'Av belongs to the future, and its hint will be made when Moshiach comes.
-
Question: 11:14 Why does the Gemara give six different reasons for Tu b'Av?
Answer: 13:23 Because none is enough for the greatest festival; the seventh, true reason will be known only when Moshiach comes.
Stories
-
17:19 The slain of Beitar did not decay
After the destruction, Jews did not give up and gathered around Bar Koziva, thinking he was Moshiach; even Rabbi Akiva thought so, until it became clear he was not. The wicked enemies wanted those who had fought for him to lie unburied and rot, to show that the hope of the Jewish people had rotted away. Instead the slain did not decay, which the Rav ties to the blessing 'Hatov' that they did not decay and 'Hameitiv' that they were given to burial.
In the story: Bar Kochba (Ben Koziva), Rabbi Akiva
-
22:03 A rav and the Shabbos farfel
A rav used to eat farfel every Shabbos, as is the Jewish custom. Over it he would say: Ribono shel Olam, what was until now is 'farfallen', lost; from now on it will be good.
-
24:05 The Kotzker on borrowing a father
A chassid of Kotzk visited a Galician tzaddik who would cry out 'Oy Tatte' in his prayer. When he returned to Kotzk and told of it, the Kotzker said that one could answer: I am borrowing a father.
In the story: the Kotzker Rebbe
Insights
- 10:07 Tu b'Av has no place in the atbash calendar sign because a sign can only be made for something that has already happened, while Tu b'Av is a festival of what will be.
- 11:22 Like a child who gives six excuses, the Gemara's very listing of six reasons, none sufficient alone, reveals that the true reason for Tu b'Av is still unknown.
- 18:51 The slain of Beitar who did not decay show that the hope for Moshiach, even when attached to a false Moshiach, is a living force, and a living thing does not decay.
- 23:57 The borrowed white garments of Tu b'Av hint that a Jew may borrow now from the good person he will become.
- 27:42 The pointing finger of the future dance of the tzaddikim conveys what words cannot: the depth of a Jewish heart that keeps hoping after so many disappointments.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 21:28 The Rav says that on Tu b'Av each Jew should make an accounting and strengthen himself in serving Hashem, adding Torah study at night.
- 22:29 He lists concrete resolutions: learning before sleep, not oversleeping, getting up for davening, learning before davening and davening with the tzibbur.
- 25:02 He says that on Tu b'Av one must decide within himself: I will be good.
- 26:11 The Rav says a Jew never gives up hope; if his prayer is not answered he hopes again.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Bar Kochba (Ben Koziva), Rabbi Akiva, Rashi, the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), Yehoshua the Kohen Gadol
Terms את"ב"ש, חמשה עשר באב, יום שכולו שבת, לעתיד לבוא, מחול, שביעי של פסח