Z Chanukah
Catalog entry: זמנים זאת חנוכה no. 19 תשע"ד (2013–14) Yiddish 54 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the folder and file name.
Listen
About this shiur
Through a piece of Sfas Emes, the Rav explains that Chanukah opens the source of miracles, a level above nature, so that everything in these days comes through miracles, and he urges using the last day of Chanukah to draw on it.
After a word on the seudos of Chanukah, the Rav turns to a piece of Sfas Emes. It asks why the blessing is 'she'asa nissim' if it refers to the miracle of the oil, and answers that the lighting is not chiefly for that miracle: Chanukah comes from a level above the seven days of nature, the source of miracles, which descends into time during these eight days. As during Sefirah everything relates to the day's sefirah, on Chanukah everything carries miracles; this is why even the first day, with enough oil, has a blessing. The Rav applies this to the last day of Chanukah and to the present need of Jews for miracles, tells of Rabbi Shlomo Kluger and of Ruzhin on the worth of Chanukah, and closes with Chanukah as a time of pekidas akaros, also for one barren in Torah and tefillah.
Topics: Miracles and Nature · Zos Chanukah · The Miracle of Chanukah and the Greeks
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Opening niggun (Singing)
-
4:38 The seudos of Chanukah
The Rav says the seudos of Chanukah carry some mitzvah because Jews made them, rejoicing that they were moser nefesh for Torah and mitzvos, and he turns to a piece of Sfas Emes. Most of this stretch's audio is untranscribed.
-
12:20 Why 'she'asa nissim': the source of miracles
Following the Sfas Emes, the Rav asks why the blessing is 'she'asa nissim' if it is for the miracle of the oil, and answers that the lighting is not chiefly for that miracle: Chanukah comes from the level above nature, the order of miracles above the seven days of creation, whose gates open in these days.
-
16:24 Everything on Chanukah carries miracles
The Rav explains that the eight days join the world of miracles to time. As in Sefirah everything relates to the day's sefirah, on Chanukah, which is hod, everything, even the kugel and the candles, comes from the source of miracles; so the blessing is on the miracles present today, and even the first day, when the oil sufficed, has one.
-
20:33 The last day and the need for miracles listed in the guide
On the last day of Chanukah the Rav says one must strive to connect to the source of miracles, since Hashem has brought Jews, in Eretz Yisroel and elsewhere, to a state where they need miracles. He draws on the Hallel's complaint 'why should the nations say', and notes that tomorrow one can still say Hallel and Al Hanissim.
-
23:58 Rabbi Shlomo Kluger, Ruzhin and the dreidel Story
The Rav tells of a question put to Rabbi Shlomo Kluger by a prisoner let out for a short time, and of his answer favoring Hallel with the tzibbur over lighting. He cites the Ruzhiner that a simple Jew can accomplish on Chanukah what a tzaddik accomplishes with his tefillos, and tells of young men playing dreidel and the saying that what one wins on Chanukah cannot be lost.
-
27:17 Pekidas akaros and closing tefillah
After a long niggun, the Rav says Chanukah is a time of pekidas akaros like Rosh Hashanah, and, citing a Midrash, that barrenness includes one who sees no fruit in his Torah or tefillah. He urges using tomorrow's Hallel and Al Hanissim to ask that Jews be remembered with salvation and that barren Zion be remembered, with the ingathering of the exiles. The recording ends with a long untranscribed stretch.
The shiur, written up
The seudos of Chanukah
The Rav begins with the seudos made on Chanukah. They carry something of a mitzvah, he says, because Jews themselves made them: Jews rejoice that they were moser nefesh for Torah and mitzvos, and to this day they rejoice when they make such a seudah on their own, to give honor to Chanukah. Like the other festive meals, it is something Jews created out of their own devotion. From here he turns to a piece of Sfas Emes. a
Why 'she'asa nissim'
The Sfas Emes considers the blessing 'she'asa nissim'. The Gemara says there was a miracle each night, yet if the blessing were on the miracle of the oil, it would have to name that miracle; instead it speaks of miracles in general, without saying which. a,b
The answer is that the lighting is not chiefly for that miracle. Chanukah comes from a level above nature, the place from which miracles come, and that level comes down into nature. Hashem set the order of nature in the seven days of creation; above it stands a separate order of miracles, and in these days its gates open.
Everything on Chanukah carries miracles
Each of the eight days, the Rav explains, brings down a spark of miracles, joining the world of miracles to time itself. He compares it to Sefirah, where, as the seforim say, everything a person feels and says relates to that day's sefirah. Chanukah is hod, the aspect of miracle, and so a time of thanksgiving.
When Chanukah comes, the source of miracles opens and all its flow comes from there: in the kugel, the gefilte fish, the wine and the burning candles there are miracles. The blessing, then, says that today there are miracles. This also answers why it is said on the first day, when there was oil enough: even then a spark of miracles came down, and the light burned from the source of miracles.
The last day and the need for miracles
On the last day of Chanukah, the Rav says, one must exert oneself to connect to the source of miracles. Hashem has now brought Jews to a state where they need miracles: in Eretz Yisroel one asks how they live and where their bread comes from. Yet the Torah is eternal and the Jewish people are eternal.
Rabbi Shlomo Kluger, Ruzhin and the dreidel
The Rav tells of a prisoner, to be let out for a short time, who asked Rabbi Shlomo Kluger whether to go at night to light Chanukah candles or in the morning to daven and say Hallel with a minyan. He answered to go to shul and say Hallel with the tzibbur, which shows the worth of that Hallel.
The Ruzhiner said that what a tzaddik accomplishes with his tefillos, a simple Jew can accomplish on Chanukah. The Rav adds a story of young men playing dreidel who lost a few coins, and the remark that what one wins on Chanukah can no longer be lost.
Pekidas akaros and the closing tefillah
After a long niggun, the Rav says the seforim call Chanukah a time of pekidas akaros, the remembering of the barren, like Rosh Hashanah, and he mentions the Bnei Yissaschar. At such a time one can daven and give blessings for the barren. e
Barrenness, he explains citing a Midrash, is not only a woman without children. One whose davening does not go, or who sees no fruit in his Torah, is also barren, and Chanukah is the time for him to ask for success in tefillah and Torah. f
He closes by urging that tomorrow morning, in Al Hanissim, at Mincha and in bentching, one use each moment of Chanukah to ask the Ribono shel Olam that Jews be remembered with salvation, that barren Zion be remembered, and that the exiles be gathered in joy together.
Sources
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- f Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 36:58
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 14:14 Chanukah comes from a level above nature, the place from which miracles come, and that level descends into the world in these days.
- 15:03 Above the order of nature set in the seven days of creation there is an order of miracles, and on Chanukah it is joined to time.
- 14:02 The blessing 'she'asa nissim' is said not on the miracle of the oil but on the opening of the source of miracles in these days.
- 18:29 Everything on Chanukah, from the food to the candles, carries miracles, and even the first night's light burned from the source of miracles.
- 20:33 The Rav says that on the last day of Chanukah one must work to connect to the source of miracles, since Jews today need miracles.
- 36:58 Chanukah is a time of pekidas akaros, and this includes one who is 'barren' in Torah or in tefillah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 13:05 If the blessing is for the miracle of the oil, why does it say 'she'asa nissim' in general instead of naming the miracle?
Answer: 13:58 The lighting is not chiefly for the oil miracle; the blessing is on the source of miracles that opens on Chanukah.
-
Question: 19:35 Why is a blessing on miracles said on the first day, when there was enough oil and no miracle?
Answer: 19:55 Even on the first day a spark of miracles came down, and the light burned from the source of miracles.
Stories
-
24:00 The prisoner's question to Rabbi Shlomo Kluger
Someone held in prison was to be let out for a short time and asked Rabbi Shlomo Kluger whether to go in at night and light Chanukah candles, or to go in the morning, daven and say Hallel with a minyan. Rabbi Shlomo Kluger answered that he should not use it for lighting but go in the morning to shul and say Hallel with the tzibbur. The Rav brings it to show the great worth of Hallel.
In the story: Rabbi Shlomo Kluger
-
26:11 The dreidel and what is won on Chanukah
In a story connected with Ruzhin, someone came in and saw several young men playing with the dreidel, and one of them had lost a few coins. He said that what one wins on Chanukah can no longer be lost.
Insights
- 19:05 The blessing 'she'asa nissim' is not thanks for the oil alone; it acknowledges that the source of miracles is open now, so everything happening today comes through miracles.
- 15:03 Chanukah's eight days reach beyond the seven days of creation that set the order of nature; they draw down the separate order of miracles into time.
- 17:29 Just as during Sefirah everything a person feels and says relates to that day's sefirah, on Chanukah even the kugel, the gefilte fish and the wine hold miracles.
- 18:06 Chanukah is hod, the aspect of miracle, and therefore a time of hoda'ah, thanksgiving.
- 19:35 Even on the first night, when the oil was naturally enough, the light burned from the source of miracles, which is why a blessing on miracles is said that night too.
- 36:58 Barrenness is not only a woman without children: one whose davening does not go and who sees no fruit in his Torah is also 'barren', and Chanukah, a time of pekidas akaros, is when he can ask for help.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 20:33 The Rav says one must exert oneself on the last day of Chanukah to connect to the source of miracles.
- 37:37 He says one who feels barren in Torah or tefillah can use Chanukah to ask for success in davening and in learning.
- 38:10 He urges using tomorrow's Hallel and Al Hanissim to ask Hashem that Jews be remembered with salvation.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Rabbi Shlomo Kluger, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Maharal of Prague, the Sfas Emes
Terms הוד, טבע, מסירות נפש, על הניסים, עקרה, פקידת עקרות, רבונו של עולם