קטרת ושיר השירים. (טעם שהצדוקים התעקשו להקטיר הקטרת מחוץ לקודש הקדשים)
Catalog entry: זמנים יום הכיפורים no. 4 Pocket Guide p. 16 תש"ע (2009–10) Yiddish 31 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that the Tzedukim wanted the ketores prepared outside the Kodesh HaKodashim because they saw Hashem only as a King, while on Yom Kippur Klal Yisroel stands before Him as a kallah before her chosson, the same love expressed in the fragrance of Shir HaShirim.
The Rav opens with the Gemara and Yerushalmi on the Tzedukim, who held that the Kohen Gadol should prepare the ketores outside and bring it into the Kodesh HaKodashim ready, since one does not prepare things in a king's presence; he asks why the Torah rejected this seemingly correct reasoning. He contrasts Rosh Hashanah, the judgment of the whole world where Hashem sits as King, with Yom Kippur, when Klal Yisroel is alone with Him like a wife with her husband, who is not embarrassed to cook in front of him. The Tzedukim, deniers of the Oral Torah, did not accept that Klal Yisroel is the kallah and the Chachamim the akeres habayis. The ketores, a matter of fragrance, is the avodah of chosson and kallah, as is Shir HaShirim, which opens and closes with fragrance. Smell was not damaged by the sin of the Etz HaDaas and is the sense of Moshiach. He ends with Rosh Hashanah as fear that comes from love.
Topics: Yom Kippur · Korbanos and Avodas HaMikdash · Shir HaShirim · Hashem's Love for Klal Yisroel
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why the Tzedukim prepared the ketores outside listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Gemara and the Yerushalmi that the Tzedukim wanted the ketores prepared outside and brought into the Kodesh HaKodashim ready, as one does for a king, and the Gemara's account of the Tzeduki Kohen Gadol who did so and died. He asks why the Torah rejected this seemingly correct reasoning.
-
4:09 Yom Kippur: the queen at home with the King listed in the guide
The Rav contrasts Rosh Hashanah, the judgment of the whole world, with Yom Kippur, which belongs to Klal Yisroel alone. He compares the Chachamim to the akeres habayis who runs the household, and explains that when the King and queen are alone they are husband and wife, so preparing the ketores in His presence is no disrespect; this is the yichud of the Kodesh HaKodashim, where no one else may be present.
-
9:48 Who speaks to whom: Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur listed in the guide
On Rosh Hashanah the King sits on His throne and the people speak to Him, as kings are addressed through an intermediary; on Yom Kippur, in the Shemoneh Esrei, Hashem speaks to Klal Yisroel with love, like a husband to his wife. The Tzedukim, deniers of the Oral Torah, saw Hashem only as King, and the Rav adds that with Moshiach this closeness will be all year.
-
14:34 Ketores, fragrance and the avodah of chosson and kallah listed in the guide
The Rav calls the ketores the main avodah of Yom Kippur, an avodah of fragrance belonging to Moshiach, who will judge by smell. The Tzeduki denied that Hashem and Klal Yisroel are chosson and kallah, the theme of Shir HaShirim; the ketores is the most beloved avodah, done inside. He adds that Avraham's tent is written with a heh, as he first pitched Sarah's tent.
-
17:51 Shir HaShirim, fragrance and the undamaged sense listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Shir HaShirim expresses the closeness of Hashem as chosson and Klal Yisroel as kallah, and that its fragrances from beginning to end make it the same matter as the ketores. Smell alone was not damaged by the sin of the Etz HaDaas and is the sense of Moshiach; the Tzeduki who denied this love was punished through his nose.
-
24:33 Neilah, Rosh Hashanah joy and fear from love
Today too, on Yom Kippur all Jews enter the Kodesh HaKodashim, and Neilah locks them in with Hashem. Rosh Hashanah is a time of love and joy, yet in kedushah love and fear go together; the Rav gives the mashal of a mother holding her child and a story of the Kozhnitzer Maggid's joy on Rosh Hashanah, and closes asking that Jews daven for a yeshuah and merit to daven with fear, love and joy.
The shiur, written up
Why the Tzedukim prepared the ketores outside
The Rav opens with the Gemara in Yoma and the Yerushalmi: the Tzedukim held that the Kohen Gadol should prepare the ketores, the incense, outside and bring it into the Kodesh HaKodashim ready. Their reason was respect for a king, whose meal is cooked in the kitchen and brought in, not prepared before him. a,c
Yom Kippur: the queen at home with the King
To answer, the Rav contrasts the two Yamim Noraim. Rosh Hashanah is the judgment of the whole world, when all creatures pass before Hashem, as the Mishnah says; Yom Kippur belongs to Klal Yisroel alone, a day of closeness when the Kohen Gadol enters the Kodesh HaKodashim. The Chachamim, by whose Oral Torah the whole conduct of the Torah runs, are like the akeres habayis who runs the house, its cooking and its order. d
Here the Tzedukim erred. One does not cook before a king, but a wife is not uncomfortable cooking while her husband sits nearby. Hashem is the King and Klal Yisroel the queen; before others they act as king and queen, but alone they are husband and wife. This is why no man may be in the Ohel Moed, and the Yerushalmi adds not even angels: it is the yichud of Klal Yisroel with Hashem alone. e,f
Who speaks to whom
On Rosh Hashanah the King sits on His throne while the people below sing and plead, and, as the Gemara in Megillah says of great kings, they are addressed through an intermediary; in its Shemoneh Esrei, Jews speak to Hashem. The novelty of Yom Kippur's Shemoneh Esrei is that Hashem speaks to Klal Yisroel with love, like a husband to his wife, in the verses of Yeshayahu about erasing their sins. g,h,i
The Tzedukim, deniers of the Oral Torah, did not accept the Chachamim as the akeres habayis, so for them Hashem was only a King. With Moshiach, the Rav says, this closeness will last all year.
Ketores and the avodah of chosson and kallah
The main avodah of Yom Kippur is the ketores, an avodah of fragrance, which belongs to Moshiach, of whom Yeshayahu says he will judge by smell. The Tzeduki denied that Klal Yisroel is the kallah and Hashem the chosson, the theme of all of Shir HaShirim. The ketores, Rashi brings in Parshas Korach, is the most beloved avodah, and it is done inside, as between chosson and kallah. j,k
Shir HaShirim and the undamaged sense
Shir HaShirim expresses the closeness of Hashem the chosson with Klal Yisroel the kallah, and is therefore the same matter as the ketores. It seems a short megillah, eight brief chapters a person says when he comes early to Mincha on Erev Shabbos, yet it is full of spices: it opens with the fragrance of oils, lists nard, cinnamon and every kind of spice, and ends on the mountains of spices. m,n,o,p
In the sin of the Etz HaDaas every sense was damaged except smell: the pesukim mention sight, taste, touch and hearing, but not smell. The seforim, among them the Bnei Yissaschar, explain that smell is the sense of Moshiach, without blemish. The ketores is a love no sin has damaged; the Tzeduki who denied it was therefore punished through his nose. q,r,s
Neilah, Rosh Hashanah joy and fear from love
Today too, on Yom Kippur all Jews enter the Kodesh HaKodashim; hence the name Neilah, locking oneself in with Hashem. Rosh Hashanah is a time of love and joy: the poskim, from the Rosh to the Shulchan Aruch, cite the passuk in Nechemiah to eat rich food, and Jews sing and dance, sure that Hashem will accept their tefillos. t,u
In tumah, which is separation, love and fear exclude each other; in kedushah they go together. Avraham, the root of love, was told at the Akeidah that he fears G-d. Rosh Hashanah's fear comes from love, like a mother gripping her child on the stairs. The Rav cites Reb Moshe of Kozhnitz, who as a child could not understand his father's joy on the Day of Judgment, and later understood it was joy with fear. He closes asking that Jews daven for a yeshuah and merit to daven with fear, love and joy. v
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:45 The Tzedukim held that the ketores must be prepared outside and brought into the Kodesh HaKodashim ready, because that is the proper conduct before a king.
- 4:28 Rosh Hashanah is the judgment of the whole world before Hashem as King, while Yom Kippur belongs to Klal Yisroel alone, the day of closeness when the Kohen Gadol enters the Kodesh HaKodashim.
- 7:45 Hashem is the King and Klal Yisroel the queen, but when they are alone they are husband and wife, and a wife is not uncomfortable preparing food in her husband's presence.
- 13:16 The Tzedukim denied the Oral Torah and did not accept that the Chachamim are the akeres habayis who run the house, so for them Hashem was only a King.
- 19:07 The ketores and Shir HaShirim are one matter: the love and closeness of chosson and kallah, which is why Shir HaShirim opens and closes with fragrance.
- 21:57 The sense of smell was not damaged by the sin of the Etz HaDaas; it is the sense of Moshiach, and the ketores is a love that no sin has damaged.
- 28:09 Rosh Hashanah calls for fear that comes from love, like a mother who holds her child tightly on the stairs because she loves him.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:15 If one does not prepare a meal in a king's presence, why did the Torah reject the Tzedukim and require the ketores to be prepared inside the Kodesh HaKodashim?
Answer: 8:27 On Yom Kippur Hashem and Klal Yisroel are alone like husband and wife, and a wife is not embarrassed to prepare food before her husband.
-
Question: 20:07 Why does Shir HaShirim open and close with fragrance?
Answer: 20:19 Because it is the same matter as the ketores: the love of chosson and kallah between Hashem and Klal Yisroel.
-
Question: 22:56 Why was the sense of smell, unlike the other senses, not damaged by the sin of the Etz HaDaas?
Answer: 23:06 The seforim, among them the Bnei Yissaschar, explain that smell is the sense of Moshiach, in which there is no blemish.
-
Question: 28:55 How can one rejoice on Rosh Hashanah, the Day of Judgment?
Answer: 27:36 In kedushah love and fear go together; the fear of Rosh Hashanah comes from love, so the joy is with fear, rejoicing with Hashem our Father.
Stories
-
2:44 The Tzeduki Kohen Gadol
The Rav cites the Gemara about a Tzeduki Kohen Gadol who prepared the ketores outside and only then brought it into the Kodesh HaKodashim. Within a short time he died, and worms came out of his nose. Later in the shiur the Rav connects this punishment to the sense of smell.
-
28:40 The Kozhnitzer Maggid's joy on Rosh Hashanah
The Rav cites a sefer of Reb Moshe of Kozhnitz, who as a child saw his father, the Kozhnitzer Maggid, rejoicing greatly on Rosh Hashanah. He did not understand how his father could rejoice so on the Day of Judgment. Later he understood that the joy came together with fear: his father was rejoicing with the Ribono shel Olam, our Father in Heaven.
In the story: Reb Moshe of Kozhnitz, the Kozhnitzer Maggid
Insights
- 3:51 The Rav concedes that the Tzedukim's reasoning about honoring a king seems correct, and locates their error not in the halachah but in their view of the relationship: before a King one prepares outside, but a wife cooks freely in her husband's presence.
- 6:17 He ties the Tzedukim's denial of the Oral Torah to the ketores: the Chachamim are the akeres habayis who run the house of Torah, and whoever denies them also denies that Klal Yisroel is Hashem's wife and sees Him only as a King.
- 10:56 In the Rosh Hashanah Shemoneh Esrei Klal Yisroel speaks to Hashem, as subjects to a king; the novelty of the Yom Kippur Shemoneh Esrei is that Hashem speaks to Klal Yisroel with affection, as a husband to his wife.
- 22:56 Because smell alone was not damaged in the sin of the Etz HaDaas, the ketores expresses a love untouched by any sin; fittingly, the Tzeduki who denied that love was punished in his nose.
- 19:33 Shir HaShirim, a short megillah said before Mincha on Erev Shabbos, is full of fragrances from its first verses to its last, which shows that it is the same matter as the ketores.
- 27:11 In kedushah, unlike tumah which is separation, love and fear can exist together; the fear of Rosh Hashanah is a fear born of love.
What the Rav says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Rabbi Moshe of Kozhnitz, Rashi, Sarah Imeinu, Shlomo HaMelech, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Kozhnitzer Maggid (Rabbi Yisrael of Kozhnitz)
Terms חוש הריח, חתן וכלה, כהן גדול, נעילה, עץ הדעת, עקרת הבית, קודש הקדשים, קטורת, רבונו של עולם, שיר השירים, שמונה עשרה, תורה שבעל פה