The Ramban and his student Avner

About: the Ramban Avner

The story

Retold here from 7 tellings; details differ from one to another. Hear it in the shiur.

The Ramban had a student named Avner who went off the derech and became a general in the king's army. One Yom Kippur he summoned the Ramban, ate a pig in front of him, and argued with him. Avner said he had left because of the Ramban's teaching that Haazinu contains every Jew's history, and asked where he was in it. After praying by the wall, the Ramban showed him the passuk 'amarti af'eihem ashbisa me'enosh zichram', whose third letters spell Avner. Shaken, Avner decided to do teshuvah, set off in a rowboat without oars, and was never heard of again.

Where he tells it

In order of year where it is known; the undated ones last.

The shiurim in which the story is told
Shiur Occasion Year Language At
פרשה של אמונה. עשי"ת - זמן לנקות חציצות האמונה 1 האזינו תשל"ב (1971–72) Yiddish 2:21
“מה טעם פתח בבראשית!” ווי געשמאק אז מען פאנגט אן פון בראשית! 2 בראשית תשל"ז (1976–77) Yiddish 38:03
פרשה שכולל הכל - מכוון כנגד עשי"ת שכולל הכל 2 האזינו תשל"ז (1976–77) Yiddish 12:54
An Explanation of טומאת יולדת and מצוות מילה 3 תזריע מצורע תשס"ב (2001–02) English 5:42
Emunah - A Hereditary Instinct from the Avos 3 EMUNAH #1 (English) not known English 5:51
Recognizing Hashem Through the Wonders of the Torah 7 EMUNAH #1 (English) not known English 8:17
The Multitudes at הר סיני - An Iron Proof of the Truth of the תורה 10 EMUNAH #1 (English) not known English 3:28