An Explanation of טומאת יולדת and מצוות מילה
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) תזריע מצורע no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 59 תשס"ב (2001–02) English 54 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains why a woman becomes tamei after giving birth, as the emptying of a great kedushah, and why Eliyahu HaNavi's coming to the bris on the eighth day cuts her tumah short after a boy.
The Rav opens with Shabbos Rosh Chodesh Iyar, where the end of the week and the beginning of the month meet, and tells the story of Avner, the Ramban's student who went astray, to show that a Jew keeps his beginning and his end and can never be lost. He describes Sefirah as seven weeks of purifying the seven middos, part of a pattern of seven days of preparation and an eighth of purity that runs through the parshiyos. He then asks why a mother becomes tamei after giving birth, and why the Torah mentions milah there. Using the Ohr HaChaim's explanation of why a Jewish body is metamei b'ohel, he answers that the kedushah of the child who learned Torah in the womb has left her. To explain why a boy brings only seven days, he brings Eliyahu HaNavi, who comes to every bris and whose purity reaches the mother. He closes with Rosh Chodesh, Iyar as a time of renewal, and the call to fix one's middos and guard against lashon hara, which keeps Klal Yisrael out of Yerushalayim.
Topics: Tumah, Taharah and Mikveh · Eliyahu HaNavi at the Bris · Sefiras HaOmer · Bris Milah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Shabbos Rosh Chodesh: beginning and end
The Rav speaks of the double parsha and of Rosh Chodesh Iyar as a capsule of the whole month and a time of renewal, like the moon reborn. When Rosh Chodesh falls on Shabbos the kedushah of the end and of the beginning join, while Amalek has only a beginning.
-
4:51 Avner, the Ramban's student Story
The Rav tells the story from the mussar sefarim of Avner, a student of the Ramban who became an apikores and an officer of the king, summoned the Ramban on Yom Kippur, and was shown his name in the third letters of a passuk in Ha'azinu.
-
11:09 Why a Jew can never be lost
The Rav asks why Avner was hinted in the middle letters, when only the first and last letters of a word contain the whole word. He answers that a Jewish soul is never lost forever: Avner lost only his middle and kept his beginning and his end, unlike Amalek.
-
15:30 Sefirah: seven to purify, the eighth to be pure listed in the guide
The Rav explains Sefirah as cleansing the seven middos (chesed, gevurah, tiferes), seven times seven, before Matan Torah. He shows the same pattern of seven and the eighth in Shemini, in the yoledes, in the metzora, and in shemittah and yovel.
-
22:56 Two questions on the yoledes listed in the guide
The Rav asks why the passuk about a mother's tumah mentions milah on the eighth day, and why she becomes tamei at all after bringing a Jewish child into the world, a child who learned the whole Torah from a malach in the womb.
-
27:02 The Ohr HaChaim's honey can listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Ohr HaChaim, who asks why a Jewish body is metamei b'ohel and a non-Jew's is not, and answers with the mashal of flies swarming an emptied honey can: tumah feeds on the residue of kedushah. The Rav applies this to the mother who carried a 'beis medrash' within her.
-
31:55 Eliyahu at the bris cuts the tumah short listed in the guide
The Rav asks why a boy, whose kedushah in the womb is greater, brings seven days of tumah and a girl fourteen. Showing that a close relative shares both the din of an avel and the simchah of a bris, he answers that Eliyahu HaNavi, connected to the eighth and free of tumah, comes to the bris and his purity interrupts the mother's tumah.
-
40:00 Shavuos as the eighth, Rosh Chodesh and Iyar
The Rav returns to Sefirah as days of taharah leading to Shavuos, the eighth, like yovel after seven times seven. He explains Rosh Chodesh as the moon's renewed union with the sun, a special Yom Tov for women, connected to Rachel and Dovid HaMelech, and Iyar as the month of renewal in ruchniyus and in nature.
-
46:42 Middos, lashon hara and the return to Yerushalayim
The Rav ties Tazria-Metzora to Sefirah as days of fixing middos between man and his fellow, recalls the students of Rabbi Akiva, and warns against lashon hara, which makes a metzora and drove Klal Yisrael out of Yerushalayim. He brings the Gemara of Moshiach as a metzora at the gates of Rome and ends that the real battle is fought in the batei medrash.
The shiur, written up
Shabbos Rosh Chodesh: beginning and end
The Rav notes the special kedushah of two parshiyos read together, and that this Shabbos is Rosh Chodesh Iyar. Rosh Chodesh is a capsule of the whole month, as Rosh Hashanah is of the year, and a time of renewal, like the moon that disappears and is born anew.
Avner, the Ramban's student
The Rav tells a story found in the Yesod Yosef and the Kav HaYashar. Avner, a student of the Ramban, became an apikores and a high officer of the king. On Yom Kippur he summoned the Ramban, ate a forbidden creature before him, and argued with him over how many lashes he deserved. b,c
Asked why he had strayed, Avner said he could not believe the Ramban's teaching that every Jew is hinted in Ha'azinu. The Ramban showed him his name in the third letters of a passuk there, which says that their memory will be erased from mankind. Avner did teshuvah, set out to sea in a boat without oars, and was never heard from again. d
Why a Jew can never be lost
The Rav asks why Avner is hinted specifically in the middle letters. Chazal expound the first letters of words because the first letter contains the whole word, and so does the last, as Shabbos contains the whole week; the middle letter does not.
He answers that a Jewish neshamah can never be lost forever; if not in this life, it returns in another gilgul. Unlike Amalek, Avner kept his reishis and his acharis, connected through the Avos, and lost only his middle.
Sefirah: seven to purify, the eighth to be pure
The Rav brings the Ribono shel Olam prayer said after Sefirah: its purpose is to cleanse and sanctify ourselves before Kabbalas HaTorah. Each person has seven middos to purify. Chesed is love of what is good, gevurah is fear in its place, and tiferes, the week beginning that night, is harmony and beauty that makes a Kiddush Hashem. e
Seven middos within seven make seven times seven, leading to the fiftieth day. The same pattern fills the parshiyos: Shavuos has seven days of tashlumin, as the Gemara says; the Kohanim served on the eighth after the days of miluim; the yoledes and the metzora become tahor on the eighth; and yovel follows seven shemittos. f,g
Two questions on the yoledes
The Rav asks two questions on the parsha. Why does the passuk about the mother's tumah turn to milah on the eighth day? And why should she become tamei at all? She brought a Jewish child into the world, bringing Moshiach nearer, as the Gemara says that he comes when all the neshamos are emptied out of the Guf. The Gemara also says a malach teaches the child the whole Torah in the womb, so she was a walking place of Torah. g,h,i
The Ohr HaChaim's honey can
The Ohr HaChaim in Parshas Chukas asks why a Jew's body is metamei b'ohel and a non-Jew's is not. He answers with a mashal: flies swarm more to an emptied honey can than to an emptied garbage can. When the neshamah leaves a Jew's body, a residue of kedushah remains, and tumah, which has no substance of its own, swarms to feed on it. j
The Rav applies this to the mother, who carried a beis medrash within her. At birth that kedushah empties out, and tumah clings to what is left. A non-Jewish mother is not tamei, since no such kedushah left her.
Eliyahu at the bris cuts the tumah short
The Rav then asks: a boy learns Torah in the womb with an obligation a girl does not have, so his kedushah is greater. Why then is the mother tamei seven days for a boy and fourteen for a girl? It should be the opposite. k
To keep his answer, he explains that close relatives are bound in their neshamos. The midas hadin of a death reaches the seven close relatives, which is why they are aveilim. So too a simchah: at a bris on a postponed Tisha B'Av the father, mohel and sandek may eat, and the mother too, though milah is not her mitzvah, because she shares her child's simchah. l
Eliyahu HaNavi, whose neshamah did not eat from the Eitz HaDaas, belongs to the eighth, the level of Moshiach, and wherever he comes tumah is pushed away. He comes to every bris on the eighth day, and as a close relative the mother receives his purity, which cuts her tumah short. This is why the passuk mentions milah.
Shavuos as the eighth, Rosh Chodesh and Iyar
The Rav returns to Sefirah: seven weeks of taharah to cleave to Hashem and receive the Torah anew. Shavuos is the eighth, like yovel after seven times seven, when the shofar frees the slaves and everyone returns to his field; on Shavuos Rus is read, with Dovid, who is Moshiach.
Rosh Chodesh celebrates the renewed union of sun and moon, Hashem and Knesses Yisrael, after the earth came between them. It is therefore a Yom Tov especially for women, who avoid certain melachos then; it is connected to Rachel and to Dovid HaMelech. Iyar above all is a month of renewal, seen in nature as the trees blossom.
Middos, lashon hara and the return to Yerushalayim
Sefirah, the Rav says, is for middos between man and his fellow; the students of Rabbi Akiva died then for lacking them. He urges being considerate and generous and avoiding lashon hara, which the Gemara says makes a person a metzora. A metzora is sent even out of Yerushalayim, and the Gemara says the Beis HaMikdash was destroyed through lashon hara, so Klal Yisrael was sent out like a metzora. m,n
The Gemara in Sanhedrin tells that Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi found Moshiach at the gates of Rome as a metzora, bearing Klal Yisrael's sins, unable to build the Beis HaMikdash and gather them, as the Rambam describes. In Iyar each Jew should make a cheshbon hanefesh about his middos. The real battle, the Rav ends, is in the batei medrash: learning, davening, tzedakah and good middos. o,p
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
- f Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 19:43
- h Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 23:23
- i Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 23:23
- l Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 33:55
- m Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 47:05
- n Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 47:05
- o Sanhedrin 98a text index In the write-up: 50:18
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 3:56 Shabbos Rosh Chodesh joins the kedushah of the end (Shabbos) with the kedushah of the beginning (Rosh Chodesh), while Amalek has only a beginning and no end.
- 13:07 A Jewish soul can never be lost forever; even Avner, who strayed, was hinted only in the middle letters of the words, keeping his beginning and his end.
- 16:23 Sefirah is a time of purifying the seven middos, and the parshiyos of these weeks repeat the pattern of seven days of preparation and purity on the eighth.
- 30:45 A mother becomes tamei after birth because the great kedushah of the child she carried has left her, just as the Ohr HaChaim explains why a Jewish body is metamei b'ohel.
- 38:41 After a boy the tumah lasts only seven days because Eliyahu HaNavi comes to the bris on the eighth day, and his purity reaches the mother as a close relative.
- 47:03 Iyar, the month of Tazria-Metzora, is a time to repair one's middos between man and his fellow and to guard against lashon hara, which turned Klal Yisrael into a metzora sent out of Yerushalayim.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 12:08 If only the first and last letters of a word contain the whole word, why is Avner hinted in the third, middle letters?
Answer: 13:07 Because a Jewish soul is never lost forever: Avner lost only his middle, and kept his beginning and his end.
-
Question: 23:23 Why does the passuk about a mother's tumah after birth mention milah?
Answer: 38:42 Because Eliyahu HaNavi comes to the bris on the eighth day, and his purity ends the mother's tumah.
-
Question: 25:04 Why should a mother become tamei after bringing a Jewish child into the world?
Answer: 30:45 The kedushah of the child, who learned Torah in her womb, has left her, and tumah clings to the residue of kedushah.
-
Question: 27:12 Why is the body of a Jew metamei b'ohel and the body of a non-Jew not?
Answer: 27:46 Like flies drawn to an emptied honey can, tumah swarms to the residue of kedushah left when the neshamah departs; a non-Jew's body has no such kedushah.
-
Question: 32:49 If the tumah comes from the kedushah that left her, why is it seven days after a boy, whose kedushah is greater, and fourteen after a girl?
Answer: 38:41 Really it should be at least fourteen, but after a boy Eliyahu HaNavi comes to the bris and his purity reaches the mother, a close relative, and interrupts her tumah.
-
Question: 36:00 Why may the mother eat at a bris on a postponed Tisha B'Av, when the mitzvah of milah is not hers?
Answer: 36:12 As a close relative with a shaychus neshamah to the child, she shares in the simchah of the bris.
Stories
-
5:42 Avner and the Ramban on Yom Kippur
Avner, a student of the Ramban, became an apikores and rose to be a high officer of the king. On Yom Kippur he summoned the Ramban, ate a forbidden creature in front of him and asked how many lashes he had earned, arguing with his rebbi over the count. When the Ramban asked why he had left the derech, Avner said it was the Ramban's teaching that every Jew is hinted in Ha'azinu, which he could not believe. The Ramban showed him that the third letters of the words of a passuk in Ha'azinu spell his name, and that the passuk says his memory will be erased from mankind. Avner did teshuvah, and after Yom Kippur set out to sea in a boat without oars and was never heard of again.
In the story: the Ramban, Avner
Insights
- 4:07 Shabbos holds the kedushah of acharis and Rosh Chodesh the kedushah of reishis, so a Shabbos Rosh Chodesh joins both, which Klal Yisrael has and Amalek, with a beginning but no end, lacks.
- 11:19 Avner was hinted in the middle letters because the first and last letters contain the whole word: a Jew who strays loses only his middle, while his beginning and end, his connection to the Avos, remain.
- 26:35 A mother carrying a child is like a walking beis medrash, since the child learns Torah from a malach in the womb; her tumah after birth is the emptying of that kedushah.
- 37:32 Eliyahu HaNavi, whose neshamah did not eat from the Eitz HaDaas, is connected to the eighth, the level of Moshiach, and wherever he comes tumah is pushed away; this is why the passuk of the yoledes mentions milah.
- 35:38 Like the father, mohel and sandek, the mother may eat at a bris on a postponed Tisha B'Av because her shaychus neshamah with the child shares in his simchah, and the same closeness lets Eliyahu's purity reach her.
- 49:35 Because of lashon hara Klal Yisrael became like a metzora sent out of Yerushalayim, and Moshiach himself sits as a metzora who cannot bring them back until the sin is repaired.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 17:23 The Rav says the weeks of Sefirah are for purifying and refining one's seven middos.
- 48:03 The Rav urges care with lashon hara and good middos toward others: being considerate, generous and understanding.
- 50:12 The Rav says that in Iyar, the month of Tazria-Metzora, every Jew should make a cheshbon hanefesh about his middos and resolve not to speak lashon hara.
- 52:34 The Rav says the battle over Eretz Yisrael is fought in the batei medrash: by learning, davening, giving tzedakah and having good middos as a Jew should.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Amalek, Avner, Dovid HaMelech, Eliyahu HaNavi, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi, Rachel Imeinu, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Rambam, the Ramban
Terms אבילות, אחרית הימים, אפיקורס, התחדשות, יובל, לשון הרע, מילה, מצורע, ספירת העומר, ראש חודש, ראשית, רבונו של עולם