An Explanation of The צרעת of גחזי and his (הפטרה( תיקון

Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) תזריע מצורע no. ⁨2⁩ Pocket Guide p. 58 תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 1 hr 9 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 9 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains why Gehazi and his sons could not be cured of their tzaraas, how their good tidings to the starving city were blocked, and why even Gehazi is not lost forever.

The Rav learns the end of the haftarah of Naaman, where Elisha refuses payment for the cure, and then the chapters of the four metzora'im outside besieged Shomron, whom the Gemara identifies as Gehazi and his sons. He asks how the Gemara knows this and why the Navi records their whole reasoning, from which the Gemara in Avodah Zarah learns the halacha of chayei sha'ah. Bringing the Me'or Einayim that whoever brings good tidings receives the aspect of Eliyahu HaNavi, and the Maharal that all healing comes from the eighth level above nature, he explains that the lepers hoped to be healed by announcing the good news. The king's irrational refusal, shown by his acceptance of a weak two-horse search, kept the curse in force. Yet no Jew is rejected forever: every year Jews learn Gehazi's halacha, raising him toward his tikkun, and Pesach, like Yovel, brings freedom to every Jew.

Topics: Eliyahu HaNavi · Netzach Yisroel · The Neviim and Their Times

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The haftarah and the healing of Naaman

    The Rav notes which haftarah is read this year and why, then gives the background of Naaman, the Aramean general whose tzaraas Elisha cured by having him immerse seven times in the Yarden.

  2. 4:17 Elisha refuses payment; Naaman's requests

    The Rav explains why Elisha refused Naaman's gift, as a kiddush Hashem and for fear of idolatrous money, and why Elisha allowed Naaman, a non-Jew keeping the seven mitzvos, to bow outwardly in his king's temple while a Jew may not.

  3. 8:43 Gehazi's curse and the four lepers listed in the guide

    The Rav tells how Gehazi lied to Naaman, took payment, and was cursed by Elisha that Naaman's tzaraas would cling to him and his children forever. He then introduces the four lepers outside besieged Shomron, whom the Gemara identifies as Gehazi and his sons, and asks how the Gemara knows this.

  4. 13:52 The lepers' reasoning and chayei sha'ah listed in the guide

    The Rav reads the lepers' reasoning to surrender to Aram rather than die of hunger, asks why the Navi records it at length, and brings the Gemara in Avodah Zarah that learns from it that a sick person may undergo a risky surgery despite losing chayei sha'ah.

  5. 19:46 Aram flees; the lepers bring the news

    The Rav describes how Aram fled at the sound of chariots, which Chazal say were held back from the hail in Mitzrayim, how the lepers first hoarded gold and clothing, showing Gehazi's greed again, and then decided that keeping quiet on a day of good tidings was wrong and told the gatekeepers.

  6. 24:17 The king's suspicion and the officer's end

    The Rav reads how King Yehoram suspected a trap, how five horses were proposed but he sent only two, and asks why. The search finds Aram gone, the people plunder the camp, food becomes cheap as Elisha foretold, and the officer who mocked the prophecy is trampled to death.

  7. 31:53 Good tidings and Eliyahu HaNavi

    The Rav brings the Me'or Einayim that whoever brings good tidings receives the aspect of Eliyahu HaNavi, who is in charge of good tidings. Through the Maharal he explains that Eliyahu, who never died, belongs to the eighth level above the seven days of creation, the source of all healing.

  8. 37:03 Why Gehazi was not healed; the king's refusal listed in the guide

    The Rav answers how the Gemara knows the lepers were Gehazi and his sons: anyone else would have been healed by Elisha. He explains that the lepers hoped to undo the curse by bringing good tidings, but the king irrationally refused to accept their news, so the curse remained.

  9. 43:25 Two horses and 'the house of the king' listed in the guide

    The Rav proves the king's irrationality: he refused to act on strong logic, yet opened the gates on the word of two riders, an insufficient search. He also explains why the lepers' report went to 'the house of the king' while the searchers told the king himself.

  10. 49:15 No Jew is lost forever listed in the guide

    The Rav raises the principle that no one is ever cast away from Klal Yisrael, brings the Pri Tzaddik that Gehazi was healed in the merit of his teshuvah and good tidings, and tells the Gemara's story of Rabbi Yehoshua ben Perachya and his rejected student, which criticizes both him and Elisha for pushing away with both hands.

  11. 57:25 Gehazi, teacher of Klal Yisrael listed in the guide

    The Rav shows that the halacha of entering a doubtful risk for healing, which overrides chayei sha'ah and therefore Shabbos, comes from Gehazi's words, so Gehazi became the teacher of all Klal Yisrael. Measure for measure, he who kept talmidim from Elisha now has all Jews as talmidim, and each year this raises him toward his tikkun.

  12. 1:04:40 The trampled officer, Pesach and every Jew's tikkun listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Rema MiPano that the elder trampled in the Azarah on Erev Pesach was a gilgul of the officer trampled in Shomron, and explains that had he lived until Pesach, a time of freedom like Yovel, he would have had his tikkun. He concludes that these haftaros before Pesach teach that every Jew will have his tikkun.

The shiur, written up

The haftarah and the healing of Naaman

0:01

The Rav opens the haftarah of Tazria and Metzora, which form one continuous unit. He mentions that customs differ about the haftarah of Shabbos HaGadol, and that according to the Ba'al HaTanya and the Gra the special haftarah is said only when Shabbos HaGadol falls on Erev Pesach.

1:22

Before reading from the fourteenth passuk, he gives the background: Naaman, a general of Aram, heard from a captive Jewish maid about Elisha. Told to immerse seven times in the Yarden, he scorned it, since cold water harms tzaraas, but his servants persuaded him, and his skin became like a small boy's. a

Elisha refuses payment; Naaman's requests

4:37

Naaman returns and begs Elisha to accept a gift, but Elisha swears he will not. The Rav gives two reasons: it is a kiddush Hashem when gentiles see that the G-d of Israel works wonders through His prophets who take no money, and Elisha feared that Naaman's wealth might be mixed with idolatrous property.

6:05

Naaman then asks for earth of Eretz Yisrael to build a mizbeach in Aram, and for permission to bow beside his king in the idol's temple, since as a general he cannot openly abandon it. Elisha allows it, the Rav explains, because Naaman remained a non-Jew keeping the seven mitzvos, who is not commanded in kiddush Hashem; a Jew must give his life rather than even pretend to worship.

Gehazi's curse and the four lepers

9:29

Gehazi, Elisha's servant, pursued Naaman, claimed that young prophets needed support, and swore to it. Elisha told him that where he wished to make a kiddush Hashem Gehazi made a chillul Hashem; since Naaman's tzaraas went with the payment, it would cling to Gehazi and his children forever. b

11:13

The next chapters tell of four lepers kept outside Shomron because tzaraas is contagious, while the city starved under Aram's siege. The Gemara says they were Gehazi and his three sons. The Rav asks how the Gemara knows this, and sets the question aside. c,d

The lepers' reasoning and chayei sha'ah

14:01

The lepers reason that whether they stay or enter the city they will certainly die of hunger, whereas surrendering to Aram is only a doubt: they may live or be killed. The Rav asks why the Navi records this whole discussion, when it only needed to say that their going to Aram's camp broke the famine, as Elisha had promised.

17:22

He notes that the Gemara in Avodah Zarah learns a halacha from these pesukim: a patient who will certainly die, but could live a few days, may undergo a surgery that might heal him or kill him at once. Chayei sha'ah, a short span of life, gives way to the chance of real life, just as the lepers chose the doubt over certain death. e

Aram flees; the lepers bring the news

19:50

Reaching the camp at dusk, the lepers find it empty. Aram had heard a great noise of chariots and horses; Chazal say these sounds were held back when the hail in Mitzrayim stopped at Moshe's tefillah and reserved for this camp. Thinking Israel had hired foreign armies, Aram fled, leaving everything behind.

21:36

The Rav points out the greed again: like Gehazi with Naaman, they first hid gold, silver and clothing. Then they said that keeping quiet on a day of good tidings was wrong, and went and told the gatekeepers.

The king's suspicion and the officer's end

24:28

King Yehoram suspected a trap: Aram was hiding in the field to catch the hungry people and storm the open gates. His servants proposed sending five of the remaining horses, which would die of hunger anyway. The king allowed only two. The Rav asks why: five were proposed because a thorough search needed five, so two were not enough, and the king had nothing to lose.

27:50

The riders found the road to the Yarden strewn with clothing and vessels Aram had dropped as they fled on foot. The Rav notes that the lepers' report went to 'the house of the king', while the riders told the king himself, and says he will return to this.

29:19

The people plundered the camp and flour sold cheaply, as Elisha had promised. The officer who had mocked that Hashem would make windows in heaven was put in charge of the gate and was trampled by the hungry crowd; he saw the food but did not eat from it. f

Good tidings and Eliyahu HaNavi

32:12

The Rav brings the Me'or Einayim in Parshas Vayeitzei: whoever merits to bring good tidings that gladden people becomes a vessel in which Eliyahu HaNavi rests, since Eliyahu is in charge of good tidings, as said in the zemiros of Motza'ei Shabbos. That is why everyone rushes to bring good news: the soul senses this. It can be a turning point in a person's life, and the receiver gains as well. g,h

35:15

Eliyahu never died. The Maharal explains that whatever is subject to death or illness comes from the seven days of creation, while the eighth level, of Moshiach, is above them. Refuah is the eighth bracha, as the Gemara says, because all healing draws from that level where death does not exist. i

Why Gehazi was not healed; the king's refusal

37:13

Now the Rav answers his question. Elisha healed anyone in trouble, even Naaman of Aram; why would Jewish lepers stay lepers? Only because Elisha himself had cursed them forever, and he could not contradict his own curse. So the Gemara knows the four were Gehazi and his sons. d,b

39:16

This explains their words 'a day of good tidings, and we keep quiet'. All healing comes from the aspect of Eliyahu, especially of tzaraas; by gladdening a whole city they hoped to be rid of the curse. But a navi's curse has no remedy.

41:11

That is why the Navi records their logic: certain death against a doubt. The king should have listened, yet he refused, because accepting the tidings would clothe Gehazi in Eliyahu's aspect and bring healing. Not accepting it, he had no simcha from it, so it was not a besorah.

Two horses and 'the house of the king'

43:45

The Rav proves the refusal was irrational. In such a famine the gates should have been opened even on a slight doubt, yet the king would not risk even five horses. Then he sent only two, an insufficient search, and on the word of two riders opened the gates to the whole city. He relied on weak proof now, after rejecting strong logic before; this can only be explained as a spell so that Gehazi would not be clothed in Eliyahu's spirit.

47:14

This also explains the wording. The lepers planned to tell the house of the king, and it was told inside, but it was like speaking to the walls; the king did not accept it or let it reach the people. The good tidings came instead through the searchers, who told the king directly.

No Jew is lost forever

49:25

The Rav raises a great principle, said by the wise woman to David HaMelech: that no one is cast away. By his explanation so far, Gehazi has no hope and remains a leper with his children. But the Pri Tzaddik on the haftarah says they were healed in the merit of their teshuvah and their good tidings. The Rav says he does not yet know how this fits with Elisha's curse, but the Pri Tzaddik is certainly right: no curse lasts forever. j,k

51:18

He adds, with hesitation, what he heard from Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz in the name of the Arizal: even Yeshu will have a tikkun after fifty thousand Yovelos.

54:28

He then tells the Gemara's account, removed by censors, of Rabbi Yehoshua ben Perachya, who sent away a student for remarking on a woman's eyes and refused his pleas. When he finally decided to accept him, the student came during Krias Shema, took the silence as rejection and went astray. The Gemara faults him, and Elisha too, who pushed away Gehazi with both hands; later Elisha went to Damascus to bring him back, but it was too late. l

Gehazi, teacher of Klal Yisrael

57:36

The Rav returns to the Gemara in Avodah Zarah. Killing someone who could live until tomorrow is murder, yet one may risk his chayei sha'ah for a cure, and this is learned from Gehazi's words. Gehazi thus became the teacher of Klal Yisrael: his chiddush entered the Gemara, the Rambam and Yoreh De'ah. e,n

59:27

Murder may not be done even to save a life, and chayei sha'ah overrides Shabbos, as the Gemara in Sanhedrin says. If the healing of a Jewish body outweighs chayei sha'ah, which itself outweighs Shabbos, how much more must one go out of the way to heal a Jewish soul. Gehazi's own halacha argues that he be returned, because no one is cast away. o,j

1:02:13

The Gemara says Gehazi drove talmidim away from Elisha like a gabbai; once he was gone the place became too small for them, as the passuk says. Measure for measure, he who kept talmidim from Elisha now has all Klal Yisrael as talmidim, and each year this haftarah is read he rises one rung toward his tikkun. q,p

The trampled officer, Pesach and every Jew's tikkun

1:04:40

The Rema MiPano writes that the elder trampled in the Azarah on Erev Pesach, as the Gemara in Pesachim relates, was a gilgul of the trampled officer. Why Erev Pesach? Pesach is like Yovel, freedom, when everyone pushed away returns; had he lived until the night of Pesach he would have had his tikkun. r

1:07:22

These haftaros are read right before Pesach, the Rav concludes, to teach that every Jew will have his tikkun, and that Pesach can take every Jew out of the gates of impurity into the gates of kedushah.

Sources

Nevi'im

  1. a II Kings 5:14 text index In the write-up: 1:22
  2. b II Kings 5:27 text index In the write-up: 9:29, 37:13
  3. c apparently II Kings 7:3 index In the write-up: 11:13
  4. f apparently II Kings 7:1-2 index In the write-up: 29:19
  5. j II Samuel 14:14 text index In the write-up: 49:25, 59:27
  6. p apparently II Kings 6:1 index In the write-up: 1:02:13

Talmud Bavli

  1. d Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 11:13, 37:13
  2. e apparently Avodah Zarah 27b index In the write-up: 17:22, 57:36
  3. i apparently Megillah 17b index In the write-up: 35:15
  4. l apparently Sanhedrin 107b index In the write-up: 54:28
  5. m apparently Berachos 10b 56:55 index
  6. o Gemara Sanhedrin (place not identified) index In the write-up: 59:27
  7. q Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:02:13
  8. r apparently Pesachim 64b index In the write-up: 1:04:40

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. g apparently Me'or Einayim, Vayeitzei index In the write-up: 32:12
  2. k apparently Pri Tzaddik, Tazria-Metzora (on the haftarah) index In the write-up: 49:25
  3. n Shulchan Aruch Yoreh De'ah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 57:36

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. h Zemiros of Motza'ei Shabbos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 32:12

Key points

  1. 37:29 The Gemara knows the four lepers were Gehazi and his sons because any other metzora would have gone to Elisha to be healed; only those under Elisha's eternal curse could not.
  2. 17:22 The lepers' reasoning, that a doubtful chance of life outweighs certain death, is the source in the Gemara for permitting a risky treatment despite the loss of chayei sha'ah.
  3. 32:23 Whoever brings good tidings receives within himself the aspect of Eliyahu HaNavi, and all healing comes from that level above death and illness.
  4. 42:19 King Yehoram's refusal to act on the lepers' report was irrational, so that Gehazi would not become the bearer of the good news and Elisha's curse would stand.
  5. 50:54 No Jew is rejected forever: each year that Jews learn the halacha Gehazi taught, he rises a rung toward his tikkun.
  6. 1:06:10 Pesach, like Yovel, is a time of freedom when everyone who was pushed away returns, and it has the power to bring every Jew to his tikkun.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 13:38 How does the Gemara know that the four lepers were Gehazi and his three sons?

    Answer: 37:29 Any other leper would have gone to Elisha to be healed, as even Naaman was; only those under Elisha's eternal curse could not be cured.

  2. Question: 15:33 Why does the Navi record the lepers' entire reasoning, when only the outcome, that their surrender broke the famine, seems relevant?

    Answer: 41:11 To show how logical their argument was, so that the king's refusal to act on it is seen as irrational, caused so that Gehazi would not become the bearer of good tidings.

  3. Question: 27:13 Why did the king send only two horses when five were proposed and he had nothing to lose?

    Answer: 44:58 Two horses were not enough for a thorough search, yet he opened the gates on their word; this shows his earlier refusal was not reason but an irrationality brought on so that Gehazi would not be the bearer of the news.

  4. Question: 28:44 Why does the passuk say the lepers' report was told to 'the house of the king', while the searchers' report was told to the king?

    Answer: 47:57 Gehazi's tidings were not accepted; they were like talking to the walls of the palace and never reached the king. The searchers' report was told directly to the king.

  5. Question: 49:33 If Elisha's curse was that the tzaraas would cling to Gehazi forever, how does this fit with the principle that no one is cast away forever?

    Answer: 1:01:33 Gehazi taught the halacha of risking chayei sha'ah for healing, which Jews learn every year with this haftarah; each time he rises a rung toward his tikkun, until he will have it.

  6. Question: 1:05:53 Why was the elder trampled to death specifically on Erev Pesach?

    Answer: 1:06:10 Pesach, like Yovel, is freedom, when everyone who was pushed away returns; had he lived until the night of Pesach he would have had his tikkun, but he died just before it.

Stories

  1. 54:28 Rabbi Yehoshua ben Perachya and his rejected student

    The Rav tells the Gemara's account, missing from censored editions, of a student of Rabbi Yehoshua ben Perachya who remarked at an inn on the eyes of the woman who kept it. His rebbe, angry that he was looking at women, sent him away and refused him again and again. When the rebbe finally decided to accept him, the student came while he was in the middle of Krias Shema and could not answer; the student took this as final rejection and went astray. The Gemara criticizes Rabbi Yehoshua ben Perachya for pushing him away with both hands.

    In the story: Yehoshua ben Perachya

Insights

  1. 37:13 The proof that the four lepers were Gehazi and his sons is that they were not cured: in a time when Elisha healed even a non-Jew like Naaman, only those under his own eternal curse would remain lepers.
  2. 39:08 The lepers' words 'this is a day of good tidings and we are silent' express their hope to be cured: since all healing comes from the aspect of Eliyahu, and the bearer of good news receives that aspect, gladdening a whole city could lift the tzaraas.
  3. 41:11 The Navi records the lepers' full reasoning to show how compelling it was, so that the king's refusal stands out as irrational; his later acceptance of a two-horse search proves the refusal came only so that Gehazi would not become the bearer of good tidings.
  4. 47:52 The first report reached only 'the house of the king', as if spoken to the walls, because the good tidings of Gehazi were not accepted; the second report, from the searchers, was told to the king himself.
  5. 58:41 Gehazi, who kept talmidim from Elisha, became measure for measure the teacher of all Klal Yisrael, since the halacha of risking chayei sha'ah for a cure is learned from his words.
  6. 1:01:00 The same halacha that Gehazi taught argues for his own return: if a Jewish body is so precious that its healing overrides chayei sha'ah, which itself overrides Shabbos, how much more must one go out of the way to heal a Jewish soul.
  7. 1:05:37 The elder trampled on Erev Pesach, a gilgul of the mocking officer, died just before the night of freedom; had he reached Pesach, which like Yovel returns everyone who was pushed away, he would have had his tikkun.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 56:29 The Rav says that one does not reject any Jew, no matter what he has done.
  2. 1:01:19 The Rav says Gehazi's halacha shows how far one must go out of one's way to save Jewish souls.
  3. 1:08:11 The Rav says these haftaros teach what to hope for on Pesach: that Pesach has the power to take every Jew out of impurity.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Dovid HaMelech, Elisha HaNavi, Eliyahu HaNavi, Gechazi, Moshe Rabbeinu, Naaman, Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl (the Me'or Einayim), Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Maharal of Prague, the Rema MiPano, the Vilna Gaon, Yehoram, Yehoshua ben Perachya

Terms אליהו הנביא, בשורה טובה, גלגול, הפטרה, חירות, יהרג ואל יעבור, יובל, לבלתי ידח ממנו נדח, מצורע, נ' שערי טומאה, ספק, קידוש השם, שבע מצוות בני נח, שבת הגדול, תיקון

Report an error on this page