An Explanation of “מה ענין שמיטה אצל הר סיני”, & Proof from this פרשה of משיח
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) בהר-בחקתי no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 59 English 55 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Shemitah is tied to Har Sinai because, like the giving of the Torah, it is a public, witnessed break in the laws of nature that proves the Torah true, but one that lasts in every generation.
The Rav returns to Rashi's question of what Shemitah has to do with Har Sinai and says last week's answer does not fully explain why Shemitah was chosen. First he shows hints of Moshiach in Behar-Bechukosai: the Arizal's hope for Moshiach before Shavuos, Yaakov written with a vav, and the Ramak's teaching that the fiftieth mention of Yetzias Mitzrayim is in this sedra. He then reviews why Jewish emunah, unlike faiths founded by one man, rests on events seen by multitudes: Yetzias Mitzrayim, the mann, and above all Matan Torah, where every Jew heard Hashem. The survival of Klal Yisrael and of Torah, and the Torah's daring promises, still testify. Shemitah is such a promise: the stories of Komemiyus and the rains of the sixth year show nature bending. So Shemitah is a lasting Har Sinai, and the Rav closes with Yovel, the return, and a brachah to bring Moshiach.
Topics: Shemitah and Yovel · Foundations of Emunah · Matan Torah at Har Sinai
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why Shemitah of all mitzvos? listed in the guide
The Rav recalls Rashi's question of what Shemitah has to do with Har Sinai and asks why the Torah did not use another mitzvah, such as milah or meat and milk. He reviews last week's answer linking Sinai, the fiftieth day, to Yovel and the shofar, and says he will approach it from a different angle. He then brings the Arizal's hope that Moshiach would come before Shavuos.
-
3:36 Hints of Moshiach in this sedra listed in the guide
Continuing the theme of Moshiach before Shavuos, the Rav brings Yaakov written with a vav in this sedra as a pledge for Eliyahu to herald Moshiach, and the Ramak's teaching that the fiftieth mention of Yetzias Mitzrayim, which stands for Moshiach, is at the end of the tochachah. He adds that the 49 curses are hidden blessings, like 49 gates of galus followed by the fiftieth.
-
8:29 Faiths founded by one man
Reviewing last year's emunah sessions on the Kuzari and the Rambam, the Rav contrasts Jewish emunah with other religions, each founded by one man whom people simply believed. He cites the Rambam, in a passage censored from Hilchos Melachim and in Igeres Teiman, that Christianity spread the idea of Moshiach, though a false one.
-
12:29 What multitudes witnessed cannot be denied
The Rav states the rule that an event witnessed by multitudes and passed down cannot be denied. He illustrates it with Alexander the Great, Julius Caesar and George Washington, whose details may be doubted but not their existence, and with the Holocaust, which governments treat its denial as absurd.
-
16:12 Yetzias Mitzrayim and the written Torah
The Rav explains that Yetzias Mitzrayim spans the fifty days from Pesach to Shavuos and was seen by millions, as were the pillars of cloud and fire and the mann for forty years. At the end of the forty years Moshe Rabbeinu wrote Sifrei Torah for every shevet, and the people who had seen it all could confirm what was written; that same Torah is in every Jewish community today.
-
21:28 Matan Torah: a nation of prophets
The Rav explains that the climax of the fifty days was Matan Torah, when every Jew became a navi and heard Hashem speak, something no other nation can claim. Hashem said this was so that the people would believe in Moshe forever; therefore Jews keep even milah because Moshe told them, not because of Avraham.
-
25:22 The survival of Klal Yisrael and Torah
The Rav says wonders still happen if one pays attention, and that learning Jewish history shows how Klal Yisrael outlived every empire; he brings the Yaavetz that this survival is a greater miracle than the splitting of the sea. Unlike Greek and Roman culture, Torah is alive, and after the Holocaust it flourishes again, above all in Eretz Yisrael.
-
31:11 The Torah dares to promise listed in the guide
The Rav contrasts the New Testament, which promises nothing except that Jews will never regain Yerushalayim, now its problem, with the Torah, which promises openly. The Torah promised that no one would covet the land while Jews went up three times a year, and it foretold where each shevet would settle, and both came true.
-
36:11 The promise of the sixth year listed in the guide
The Rav turns to Shemitah, which begins in Elul, and the Torah's promise that the sixth year will yield enough for three years though the farmer may not work. He explains that the sixth year prepares for Shemitah, Shabbos of the land, as the sixth day prepares for Shabbos, and says this miracle is seen and documented today.
-
39:22 The Shemitah miracles of Komemiyus Story listed in the guide
The Rav tells of Rav Binyamin Mendelson of Komemiyus: in the Shemitah of 5712 the neighbors' early planting rotted without rain while Komemiyus' old, wormy seed sown after Sukkos grew; in 5719 locusts devoured the surrounding fields and turned back at Komemiyus. He adds how the Jewish Agency's orchards in Komemiyus, left untended in Shemitah, flourished more than all others, as an official report records.
-
47:41 Shemitah today and the laws of nature listed in the guide
The Rav notes that more farmers keep Shemitah each cycle and that this sixth year brought unusual rain after years of drought. He explains that the root of emunah is Har Sinai, yet Hashem does not show open miracles in every generation, because nature itself is a Torah Hashem wants kept, broken only at special times.
-
52:02 Shemitah as a lasting Har Sinai listed in the guide
The Rav concludes that Shemitah in Eretz Yisrael defies nature like Matan Torah, but permanently, and this is one explanation of why Shemitah is tied to Har Sinai. He turns to Yovel, when every Jew returns to his portion, as an image of Moshiach, and blesses the listeners that Moshiach will point to them as those who brought him by staying faithful amid the street's impurity.
The shiur, written up
Why Shemitah of all mitzvos?
The Rav returns to Rashi's question, what Shemitah has to do with Har Sinai. The answer that every detail of every mitzvah was said at Sinai does not explain why Shemitah was chosen rather than milah or meat and milk. Last week he linked Sinai, the fiftieth day, to Yovel; now he takes another angle, opening with the Arizal's hope that Moshiach would come before Shavuos. a
Hints of Moshiach in this sedra
The sedra, the Rav says, carries hints of Moshiach. Yaakov is written here with a vav, as if Yaakov holds Eliyahu's letter as a pledge until he comes to herald Moshiach. The Ramak taught that the fiftieth mention of Yetzias Mitzrayim, which stands for Moshiach, is not the fiftieth in order but the one at the end of the tochachah. e
Faiths founded by one man
Recalling last year's sessions on the Kuzari and the Rambam, the Rav explains that no other faith stands on firm ground like Jewish emunah. Christianity and Islam each began with one man whom people believed. The Rambam writes, in a passage censored from Hilchos Melachim and in Igeres Teiman, that Christianity spread the idea of Moshiach, though a false one. h,i,j
What multitudes witnessed cannot be denied
Jewish emunah, the Rav says, believes no individual; it rests on facts. An event seen by multitudes and passed down cannot be denied. One may doubt the color of Alexander's horse, but not that he conquered an empire; the same holds for Julius Caesar and George Washington. Denying the Holocaust is ridiculous, he adds, because armies and survivors witnessed it.
Yetzias Mitzrayim and the written Torah
Matan Torah: a nation of prophets
The climax of those fifty days was Matan Torah, when every man, woman and child became a navi and heard Hashem, as the passuk asks whether any nation ever heard G-d speaking from the fire. Hashem told Moshe this was so the people would believe in him forever. Therefore, the Rav says, Jews keep milah not because of Avraham but because Moshe commanded it. m,n
The survival of Klal Yisrael and Torah
Wonders still happen today, the Rav says, if one pays attention, and it is a mitzvah to learn history to see how Klal Yisrael outlived Greece, Rome and every empire that sought to destroy it. The Yaavetz swore that this survival in galus is a greater miracle than the splitting of the sea.
No ancient culture survived as a living thing; Greek and Roman literature interest only a few professors. Torah is alive. After the Holocaust everyone thought it was finished, yet within fifty years it flourishes, above all in Eretz Yisrael, and its enemies cannot bear it.
The Torah dares to promise
The New Testament, the Rav says, promises nothing except that Jews will never regain Yerushalayim, which is why the Church now fights Jewish control of the city. The Torah promises openly: when families go up three times a year, no one will covet their land. Only the One who knows the future could promise that, and for centuries it held. Moshe Rabbeinu likewise foretold where each shevet would settle, and it all fits. p
The promise of the sixth year
Shemitah begins in Elul, the Rav notes, and the Torah promises a sixth-year yield lasting three years, though farmers may not work until after Sukkos of the eighth. As the sixth day prepares for Shabbos, the sixth year prepares for Shemitah, Shabbos of the land. Today, he says, this is documented. r
The Shemitah miracles of Komemiyus
The Rav tells of Rav Binyamin Mendelson of Komemiyus. In the Shemitah of 5712 neighbors using the heter planted on time and mocked Komemiyus, but no rain came and their seed rotted. After Sukkos Komemiyus had only old, wormy wheat that experts said would not grow; they planted it, the late rains came, and only their wheat grew.
In 5719 clouds of locusts devoured the surrounding fields and turned back at Komemiyus; the Brisker Rav asked that it be publicized. Later the Jewish Agency planted orchards there although Rav Mendelson warned they would be left untended in Shemitah, and an official report found them flourishing more than any others.
Shemitah today and the laws of nature
More farmers join each cycle, the Rav says; four thousand kept the last Shemitah. This sixth year, after drought, brought rain like none in years.
Shemitah as a lasting Har Sinai
Shemitah in Eretz Yisrael, the Rav concludes, defies nature like Matan Torah, but Sinai was temporary and Shemitah is forever; this is one answer to Rashi's question. Yovel, when every Jew returns to his portion, mirrors Yetzias Mitzrayim. He blesses his listeners that Moshiach will point to them as those who brought him by staying faithful amid the street's impurity. a,t
Sources
Torah
- b apparently Shemos 19:13 2:20 index
- e apparently Vayikra 26:42 index In the write-up: 4:15
- l apparently Devarim 31:9 index In the write-up: 18:51
- m apparently Devarim 4:33 index In the write-up: 21:48
- n Shemos 19:9 text index In the write-up: 21:48
- p apparently Shemos 34:24 index In the write-up: 31:49
- q apparently Bereishis 49:13 35:23 index
- r apparently Vayikra 25:21 index In the write-up: 36:28
- t apparently Vayikra 25:10 index In the write-up: 52:29
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- a Rashi, Vayikra 25:1 text index In the write-up: 0:00, 52:29
- h Kuzari (place not identified) index In the write-up: 9:01
- i apparently Mishneh Torah, Hilchos Melachim 11:4 index In the write-up: 9:01
- j Igeres Teiman (place not identified) index In the write-up: 9:01
- k apparently Ramban, Vayikra 23:36 index In the write-up: 16:22
- s apparently Ramban, end of Parshas Bo (Shemos 13:16) index In the write-up: 49:38
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 0:35 Saying that every detail of every mitzvah was given at Sinai does not explain why the Torah chose Shemitah to teach it.
- 12:29 Jewish emunah, unlike faiths founded on one man's word, rests on events witnessed by millions, which no one can deny.
- 21:48 Matan Torah, where every Jew became a navi and heard Hashem, is the root of emunah and of belief in Moshe Rabbeinu's prophecy.
- 33:30 The Torah makes promises that only its Giver could make, such as the safety of the land during the pilgrimages and the blessing of the sixth year.
- 52:21 Shemitah is tied to Har Sinai because, like Matan Torah, it openly defies the laws of nature, but unlike Sinai it lasts forever.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:45 If the point is that every detail of every mitzvah was given at Sinai, why does the Torah teach it through Shemitah rather than milah or meat and milk?
Answer: 52:21 Because Shemitah, like Matan Torah, is an open, witnessed break of nature that proves the Torah, but one that continues in every generation.
-
Question: 33:45 How could the Torah promise that no one would harm the fields while the whole family went up to Yerushalayim three times a year?
Answer: 34:30 Only because its Giver knows the future; and for centuries the promise held.
-
Question: 37:15 If the farmer cannot work from Elul of the sixth year until after Sukkos of the eighth, what will he eat?
Answer: 36:52 The Torah promises such blessing in the sixth year that it yields enough for three years, as the sixth day prepares for Shabbos.
Stories
-
39:27 The wheat of Komemiyus in Shemitah 5712
In the Shemitah year 5712 the farmers of Komemiyus, led by Rav Binyamin Mendelson, did not work their fields, while neighbors who relied on the heter planted at the usual time and mocked them. The rain did not come, and the neighbors' seeds dried up and rotted. After Sukkos Komemiyus had only old, broken and wormy wheat from the sixth year, which experts said would not grow, but Rav Mendelson told them to plant it. The rains came late, their wheat grew, and they had a great harvest while the farms around had nothing; he wrote it down in a letter.
In the story: Rav Binyamin Mendelson
-
43:28 The locusts that turned back at Komemiyus
In the Shemitah year 5719 the surrounding farmers did not keep Shemitah while Komemiyus did. When the crops began to grow, clouds of locusts swept from field to field and ate everything, but when they reached Komemiyus they turned around, and its crops grew. The Brisker Rav told Rav Mendelson to publicize it, and it was written up in the papers.
In the story: Rav Binyamin Mendelson, the Brisker Rav
-
45:03 The orchards of Komemiyus
The Jewish Agency planted fruit trees across Eretz Yisrael but at first refused Komemiyus, fearing that untended saplings would be ruined in Shemitah. Rav Mendelson persuaded the official in charge, telling him openly that in Shemitah they would not tend the trees, and the official warned that the investment was at risk. When the inspectors came at the end of Av, they found the orchards of Komemiyus flourishing more than all the others under his charge, and a written report records it.
In the story: Rav Binyamin Mendelson
Insights
- 4:58 The Ramak teaches that the fiftieth mention of Yetzias Mitzrayim in the Torah, which stands for the coming of Moshiach, is not the fiftieth in order but the one right after the tochachah in Bechukosai.
- 8:03 The 49 curses of the tochachah can be seen as the 49 gates of galus, with the fiftieth gate, the end of galus, following immediately after.
- 24:49 Jews keep even mitzvos given to the Avos, like milah and gid hanasheh, only because Moshe Rabbeinu commanded them, since belief in Moshe rests on Hashem appointing him before the whole nation at Sinai.
- 50:29 The laws of nature are themselves a Torah: a bird flies and a tree grows because Hashem commanded it, and He breaks nature only rarely, as one would set aside a mitzvah only when truly needed.
- 49:56 Shemitah is a Har Sinai that never ended: Matan Torah was a one-time open miracle, while Shemitah defies nature in Eretz Yisrael in every cycle for all to see.
- 33:32 The Torah's willingness to promise things that every Jew could test, like the safety of the land during the pilgrimages, is itself a proof that it comes from Hashem.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 26:00 The Rav says it is a mitzvah to learn Jewish history, to see how Klal Yisrael survived every oppressor.
- 25:48 The Rav says wonderful things happen today too, but one must pay attention to them.
- 7:13 Half in jest, the Rav tells his listeners to polish their shoes before Shabbos, since Moshiach might come.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Eliyahu HaNavi, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Shlomo Alkabetz, Rabbi Yaakov Emden (the Yaavetz), Rashi, Rav Binyamin Mendelson, the Arizal, the Brisker Rav (Rabbi Yitzchak Zev Soloveitchik), the Chazon Ish, the Ramak (Rabbi Moshe Cordovero), the Rambam, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu
Terms ביאת המשיח, יובל, יציאת מצרים, מתן תורה, קללות, רבונו של עולם, שמיטה