ארבעה דברים ששכח משה כי הם בחינת יובל
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע בהר בחקותי no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 11 תשל"ח (1977–78) Yiddish 1 hr 26 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that the four laws Moshe Rabbeinu had to ask about (the blasphemer, the wood-gatherer, Pesach Sheni and the daughters of Tzelofchad) all belong to the hidden realm of Yovel, which is beyond intellectual grasp, and draws from this the holiness of every Jew.
The Rav opens with the dispute of Rabbi Akiva and Rabbi Yishmael whether the details of the Torah were given at Sinai, and asks why, according to Targum Yonasan, there were four laws Moshe did not know. Rashi's question why shemitah is tied to Har Sinai leads him to Yovel: the Ramban says the fiftieth gate, which is Yovel, was not revealed to Moshe. Yovel corresponds to the first two letters of Hashem's Name, the hidden 'Atika' beyond grasp, where every Jew returns to his root. Each of the four laws touches Yovel. The daughters of Tzelofchad grasped with feeling what cold intellect cannot; the wood-gatherer was liable by law yet acted for Heaven; and the blasphemer, son of Shlomis bas Divri, mocked the nine-day-old showbread because he denied the holiness of the Jewish camp. The Rav ends with the tochachah, the days of Sefirah and preparing for Shavuos.
Topics: Shemitah and Yovel
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Four laws Moshe did not know listed in the guide
The Rav presents the dispute of Rabbi Akiva and Rabbi Yishmael whether the details of the Torah were given at Sinai, and the Targum Yonasan's list of four laws Moshe did not know. He asks why, if all was given at Sinai, Moshe had to ask about them.
-
3:45 Shemitah, Sinai and the blasphemer's exit listed in the guide
The Rav brings Rashi's question why shemitah is mentioned with Har Sinai, and the Zohar that 'yesh' stands for Yovel and Shemitah. He turns to the blasphemer at the end of Emor, the first of the four laws, and to Rashi's 'from his world he went out', asking what it means.
-
7:09 Mocking the nine-day-old showbread
The Rav brings the Midrash that the blasphemer came out of the parsha of the showbread and mocked a king eating nine-day-old bread. He asks how a man of about seventy, who had seen the Exodus, the splitting of the sea and Sinai, could fall to such mockery.
-
11:46 The camp as a living Sefer Torah
The Rav asks why the blasphemer was not allowed to camp in the tribe of Dan, and explains that the Jewish camp was arranged like the camps of angels around the Throne, a living Sefer Torah of 600,000 letters that a stranger would invalidate. He then adds that the mockery hid a denial of the miracle that the showbread stayed fresh.
-
16:04 Yovel, the fiftieth gate and the root listed in the guide
The Rav explains shemitah as the Shabbos of the land and Yovel as the fiftieth gate the Ramban says Moshe did not attain. Yovel corresponds to the first two letters of Hashem's Name, called Atika, beyond any grasp; on Shabbos one returns partly to the root, and at Yovel everyone returns to his root, as on Shavuos, the uncounted fiftieth day.
-
23:07 The large nun of the daughters of Tzelofchad listed in the guide
The Rav states that all four laws relate to Yovel, which is why Moshe had to ask. He brings Rabbeinu Bachya that the large nun in 'mishpatan' alludes to the fiftieth gate, and asks why the daughters of Tzelofchad knew what Moshe did not.
-
26:35 Wine and feeling, bread and intellect
The Rav brings the Maharal that the matzos correspond to the Avos and the cups of wine to the Imahos, and explains that wine is feeling and intuition while grain is intellect. Women grasp with feeling, but a ruling must come from cold intellect, and he tells of a posek who would not rule after a woman's tears stirred him.
-
29:54 A portion in the land, a portion in Torah listed in the guide
The Rav explains that a portion in Eretz Yisrael corresponds to a letter of the Torah and to one's root, which returns at Yovel. The daughters of Tzelofchad felt that no Jew can be cast off, as the wise woman told Dovid; Moshe's cold intellect could not reach it because it belongs to Yovel.
-
33:43 The wood-gatherer and Pesach Sheni listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the wood-gatherer acted for the sake of Heaven to teach that Shabbos still binds; by law he was liable, but in the depth known only to Hashem he was not, which is a matter of Yovel. Pesach Sheni likewise connects a Jew to his root, and those who asked 'lamah nigara' were right in feeling.
-
38:53 The showbread and the holiness of Yisrael listed in the guide
Coming to the fourth law, the Rav explains that the showbread alludes to the holiness of Yisrael: twelve loaves against the twelve tribes and the angels above, arranged six and six for yesod, and staying fresh because true holiness never decays. Hashem testifies with the letters yud and hei on every Jewish family, and the only blemish was Shlomis bas Divri.
-
47:28 Shlomis and Shulamis
The Rav brings Rashi that Shlomis greeted everyone and chattered with all, and the Chasam Sofer's question why Knesses Yisrael is called Shulamis. He explains that Shulamis is a passive form: Klal Yisrael receives greetings from the nations but does not mingle with them, while Shlomis' greeting everyone cost her son his place in the camp.
-
57:46 The showbread and kiddush of Shabbos day listed in the guide
The Rav says the showbread too is beyond grasp. The Shabbos day meal belongs to Atika and Yovel, which is why kiddush then is on wine and done standing, and why the Arizal's song for that meal mentions the twelve loaves.
-
1:01:02 The blasphemer's claim against the camp listed in the guide
The Rav returns to 'from his world he went out': from the 'chok olam' of the showbread, the world of Yovel. The blasphemer, lacking a root there, claimed the showbread was stale like a Jewish camp of mixed lineage; Hashem commanded the bread kept nine days to teach that all Jews are holy and must be loved.
-
1:07:11 Torah from Sinai: revealed and hidden listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Maharal on 'Moshe kibel Torah miSinai', that Sinai shows the Torah came down into this world, and asks whether the Yovel matters were then not given at Sinai. He answers with the Zohar that the four letters of Hashem's Name are bound together: the revealed Torah holds the hidden within it, so Moshe received everything at Sinai, though what is above grasp could later be hidden from him.
-
1:14:05 Why shemitah stands by Har Sinai listed in the guide
The Rav answers Rashi's opening question: shemitah, the whole parsha of Yovel, is tied to Har Sinai to teach that even its details, though bound to Yovel, were given at Sinai. That is why the parsha of Behar follows right after the blasphemer, the first of the four laws.
-
1:17:18 Turning the curses into blessings
The Rav links the forty-nine curses of the tochachah to the forty-nine bad middos that must be transformed during Sefirah through holiness. He tells of the Ba'al HaTanya's son who fainted on hearing the tochachah, having heard only blessings from his father, and of Reb Hershele Zidichoiver crying out at the tochachah.
-
1:20:57 Sefirah, Shavuos and returning to the root
The Rav describes the days of Sefirah as holy days like chol hamoed, the parsha ending with Yovel and 'b'Har Sinai', and Megillas Rus as a return to the root. He closes asking that everyone prepare for Shavuos with good middos, Torah and tefillah, and merit the fiftieth day.
The shiur, written up
Four laws Moshe did not know
The Rav opens with the Gemara's dispute: Rabbi Akiva holds that the general rules and all the details of the Torah were given at Sinai, while Rabbi Yishmael holds that only the general rules were given there. Yet the Targum Yonasan at the end of Emor lists four laws Moshe did not know until he asked: the blasphemer, the wood-gatherer, Pesach Sheni and the inheritance of the daughters of Tzelofchad. If everything was given at Sinai, why did these remain unknown to him? a,c
Shemitah, Sinai and the blasphemer
He adds Rashi's question at the start of Behar: what does shemitah have to do with Har Sinai? He brings the Zohar that 'yesh' in 'lehanchil ohavai yesh' stands for Yovel and Shemitah. Then he turns to the blasphemer, the first of the four, and to Rashi's words that 'he went out from his world', asking what world is meant. b,e,d,f
Mocking the showbread
According to the Midrash, the blasphemer came from the parsha of the showbread, which ends with 'chok olam', and mocked it: a king eats fresh bread daily, yet here the kohanim eat bread nine days old. The Rav finds this hard. This man was the son of the Egyptian whom Moshe killed; by the reckoning he was about seventy, had seen the Exodus, the splitting of the sea and the manna, and stood at Sinai. How could such a person stumble over stale bread? g,h,j
The camp as a living Sefer Torah
The Midrash also says he left Moshe's court condemned after trying to camp with Dan. Why refuse him space in so vast a desert? The Rav explains with 'shuvi shuvi haShulamis' that the camps of Yisrael were arranged like the camps of angels around the Throne, with 600,000 Jews against the 600,000 letters of the Torah. The camp was a living Sefer Torah, and a stranger in it would invalidate it. g,l
Yovel, the fiftieth gate and the root
Behar speaks of shemitah, the Shabbos of Eretz Yisrael, and of Yovel, the fiftieth year. The Ramban says Yovel is the fiftieth gate, which Moshe did not attain. The Rav explains that Yovel corresponds to the first two letters of Hashem's Name, called Atika, where there is no grasp at all. m
Shabbos already brings a return to the root, which is why the land rests. But one whom Shabbos cannot free is freed by Yovel, the 'Shabbos of Shabbosos', when 'each man returns to his holding' and to his root. So too Shavuos, the fiftieth day, is never counted, because it is above grasp, and it brings freedom and the light of the World to Come. n
The large nun
All four laws relate to Yovel, so although they were given at Sinai, Moshe had to ask again. On 'vayakreiv Moshe es mishpatan', written with a large nun, Rabbeinu Bachya says the nun alludes to the fiftieth gate, 'before Hashem', beyond grasp. The Rav then asks why the daughters of Tzelofchad knew what Moshe did not, as Rashi says their words were written above. o,p,q
Wine and bread
He brings the Maharal that the matzos correspond to the Avos and the cups of wine to the Imahos. Wine, the Rav explains, is feeling and intuition, the heart's contact with the soul, while grain is cold intellect. Women grasp with feeling, but a ruling must come from cold intellect; he tells of a posek who would not rule after a woman's tears had stirred him.
A portion in the land
A portion in Eretz Yisrael is a portion in the Torah: the land is divided against 600,000 souls and letters, and at Yovel each returns to his root. The daughters of Tzelofchad, crying 'lamah yigara', felt that no Jew is cast off, as the wise woman told Dovid. By cold logic Moshe saw no share for them, since this belongs to Yovel. r,s
The wood-gatherer and Pesach Sheni
The wood-gatherer used the same words. The Rav explains he acted for the sake of Heaven, to show that Shabbos binds even those who would not enter the land. By law he was liable and the court had to rule so; Heaven allowed it so that Shabbos be sanctified, but in the hidden depth known only to Hashem he was not liable. That is a matter of Yovel. r
The showbread and the holiness of Yisrael
Coming to the fourth law, the Rav says the showbread alludes to the holiness of Yisrael, which stems from the first two letters of Hashem's Name. Rabbeinu Bachya explains the twelve loaves against the twelve tribes arranged in the camp, as below the Throne twelve angels stand in four camps. They had to lie six and six, for holiness of Yisrael comes from yesod, the sixth middah. u
Shlomis and Shulamis
Rashi says she was called Shlomis because she greeted everyone and Divri because she chattered with all. Had she conducted herself with the inwardness of 'kol kevudah bas melech penimah' and limited talk, as in Pirkei Avos, the Egyptian would never have noticed her, her husband would not have been killed and Moshe would not have fled. y,z,aa
The Chasam Sofer asks why Knesses Yisrael is called Shulamis and not Shlomis, and answers that she may not bear the name of that wicked woman. The Rav asks why all generations should carry a twisted name. He tells of the Chiddushei HaRim, who refused to choose a child's name since a father names with ruach hakodesh.
His answer: as the Midrash and Akdamus describe, the nations call out 'shuvi shuvi', urging the Jews to join their society. Shulamis is passive, one who receives peace. Knesses Yisrael accepts their greeting but does not mingle, unlike Shlomis, whose greetings cost her son his place in the camp. l,ab
Kiddush of Shabbos day
The showbread too lies beyond grasp. The Shabbos day meal is the meal of Atika Kadisha, the world of Yovel, so its kiddush is on wine, the drink of feeling, and made standing. The Arizal's song for that meal invites Atika Kadisha and asks that the twelve loaves be revealed, though even the Arizal did not grasp their secret.
The blasphemer's claim
Now the Rav explains 'he went out from his world': from the 'chok olam' of the showbread, the world of Yovel, like the servant who serves 'forever', until Yovel. The son of the Egyptian had no root there and no share in the camp. f,h
Since the showbread stands for the Jewish camp, he claimed it was stale and moldy, as was the camp: among 600,000 families, surely others too were mixed with the Egyptians. Hashem commanded the bread eaten after nine days to show the opposite. The Rav says one must love every Jew and not look at their flaws.
Revealed and hidden
The Maharal explains why the Mishnah says 'Moshe kibel Torah miSinai' and not from Hashem: Sinai shows the Torah came down to this world. Then, the Rav asks, were the matters of Yovel, above grasp, not given at Sinai? ac
He answers from the Zohar: mitzvah is Hashem's Name, its first two letters hidden and the last two revealed, all bound together. So too the revealed Torah carries the hidden within it, and whoever learns it receives what he cannot grasp. Moshe received everything at Sinai; only what is beyond grasp was later hidden. ad
Why shemitah stands by Har Sinai
Curses into blessings
Bechukosai's tochachah holds forty-nine curses, against the forty-nine bad middos to be transformed during Sefirah through holiness. The Ba'al HaTanya's son once fainted hearing it read by another, since from his father he heard only blessings. Reb Hershele Zidichoiver, reading it, cried out and saw the blessing within it.
Sefirah, Shavuos and the root
The days of Sefirah are holy, like chol hamoed. After the curses the parsha returns to Yovel, and it ends, as Behar began, with 'b'Har Sinai': the curses are in Moshe's hand, and every Jew who learns Torah can turn them into blessings, as the Ba'al HaTanya did. ae
Rus returned with Naomi to Eretz Yisrael, back to the root, which is why it is read on Shavuos. The Rav closes by urging preparation with good middos, Torah, tefillah and love of friends, to merit the fiftieth day.
Sources
Torah
- h Vayikra 24:9 text index In the write-up: 7:09, 1:01:44
- i Vayikra 24:8 7:40 text index
- j Shemos 2:11 text index In the write-up: 7:09
- n Vayikra 25:10 text index In the write-up: 19:22
- o Bamidbar 27:5 text index In the write-up: 23:24
- r Bamidbar 27:4 text index In the write-up: 29:55, 33:59
- t Bamidbar 9:7 text index In the write-up: 37:25
- v Vayikra 19:2 text index In the write-up: 42:12
- ae Vayikra 26:46 text index In the write-up: 1:21:24
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Targum
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- b Rashi on Vayikra 25:1 text index In the write-up: 3:45, 1:14:40
- f Rashi on Vayikra 24:10 text index In the write-up: 3:45, 1:01:44
- m apparently Ramban on Vayikra 25 index In the write-up: 16:12
- p apparently Rabbeinu Bachya on Bamidbar 27:5 index In the write-up: 23:24
- q Rashi on Bamidbar 27:7 text index In the write-up: 23:24
- u apparently Rabbeinu Bachya on Vayikra 24:5 index In the write-up: 39:15
- x Rashi on Bamidbar 26:5 text index In the write-up: 45:22
- y Rashi on Vayikra 24:11 text index In the write-up: 47:35
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 23:24 The four laws Moshe had to ask about were given at Sinai, but they were hidden from him because they belong to Yovel, which is above his grasp.
- 16:37 Yovel is the fiftieth gate and corresponds to the first two letters of Hashem's Name, the hidden 'Atika', where every Jew and all of creation return to their root.
- 27:34 Matters of Yovel are grasped through feeling, symbolized by wine, rather than through the cold logical intellect symbolized by bread; this is why the daughters of Tzelofchad sensed what Moshe did not.
- 39:15 The showbread represents the holiness of Klal Yisrael, and its staying fresh shows that the Jewish camp is never 'stale'; the blasphemer denied this.
- 1:12:09 Everything, including the matters beyond grasp, was given at Sinai, since the revealed Torah holds the hidden within it; this is why shemitah is tied to Har Sinai.
- 1:18:24 The days of Sefirah, especially the last two weeks, are a time to turn the forty-nine curses of the tochachah and the bad middos into blessings and return to the root.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:34 If, according to Rabbi Akiva, everything was given at Sinai, why did Moshe not know these four laws?
Answer: 23:24 They were given, but they belong to Yovel, which is above Moshe's grasp, so they were hidden from him and he had to ask again.
-
Question: 12:15 Why was the blasphemer not allowed to pitch his tent in the camp of Dan, in so vast a desert?
Answer: 14:16 The Jewish camp was a living Sefer Torah, each Jew a letter; a stranger placed in it would invalidate it.
-
Question: 11:03 How could a man who saw all the miracles of the Exodus and Sinai mock the showbread?
Answer: 15:42 He did not believe the bread stayed fresh, because the showbread represents the holiness of the Jewish camp, in which he had no root.
-
Question: 25:31 Why did the daughters of Tzelofchad know what Moshe did not?
Answer: 32:20 They sensed it with feeling, not intellect, and the share of every Jew in the land belongs to Yovel, which is reached only through feeling.
-
Question: 49:01 Why is Knesses Yisrael called Shulamis rather than Shlomis?
Answer: 55:30 Shulamis is a passive form, one who receives peace: Klal Yisrael accepts the nations' greeting but does not mingle with them, unlike Shlomis who greeted everyone.
-
Question: 3:49 Why does Rashi ask what shemitah has to do with Har Sinai?
Answer: 1:15:59 Shemitah is the whole parsha of Yovel; it is tied to Sinai to teach that even what is bound to Yovel was given at Sinai, and it follows the blasphemer's parsha for that reason.
Stories
-
29:19 A posek moved by tears
A woman came with a question to a posek, apparently the Noda BiYehudah, and began to weep. He excused himself from ruling, saying tears are a kind of bribe: his feeling had been stirred, and a ruling must come from the intellect.
In the story: the Noda BiYehudah
-
50:04 The Chiddushei HaRim on naming a child
Someone asked the Chiddushei HaRim what name to give his child. He would not answer, saying that every father who names his child does so with a measure of ruach hakodesh and hits upon the name of the child's root, so why give away that chance.
In the story: the Chiddushei HaRim
-
1:18:48 The Ba'al HaTanya's son and the tochachah
The son of the Ba'al HaTanya once heard the tochachah of Bechukosai read by someone other than his father, and fainted. When revived and asked why, he said that when his father read it he heard only blessings, since his father transformed the curses.
In the story: the Ba'al HaTanya, Rabbi Dov Ber
-
1:19:29 Reb Hershele Zidichoiver at the tochachah
Reb Hershele of Zidichov once read the tochachah in Bechukosai and could not restrain himself; at one of the verses he cried out to the Ribono shel Olam. The Rav says he saw the blessing within it.
In the story: Rabbi Tzvi Hirsh of Zidichov
Insights
- 23:24 The Rav identifies the four laws Moshe had to ask about as all belonging to Yovel, the fiftieth gate, so that they were given at Sinai yet hidden from Moshe because they stand above all grasp.
- 27:45 Wine stands for the heart's intuition and bread for intellect; matters of Yovel are reached by feeling, which is why women, the daughters of Tzelofchad and the wise woman of Dovid's time, revealed that no Jew is cast off.
- 34:14 The wood-gatherer was liable by the law a beis din must follow, yet in the depth known only to Hashem he was not, since he acted for the sake of Heaven; such judgment belongs to the level of Yovel.
- 1:03:47 Hashem commanded that the showbread be eaten after nine days, though it looked stale, to teach against the blasphemer's claim that the Jewish camp is 'stale' and mixed, and that every Jew is holy and must be loved.
- 55:22 The Rav reads 'Shulamis' as a passive form: Knesses Yisrael receives the nations' greeting but does not return it or mingle with them, the opposite of Shlomis bas Divri who greeted everyone and lost her son his place in the camp.
- 1:11:42 Like the four letters of Hashem's Name, the hidden and revealed parts of the Torah are bound together, so whoever learns the revealed Torah receives the hidden within it, even without grasping it.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 1:05:07 The Rav says one must love every Jew and not look at Jewish flaws.
- 1:18:24 The Rav says the days of Sefirah, especially the last two weeks, are the time to turn bad middos into good ones and the curses into blessings, through holiness.
- 1:25:39 The Rav urges preparing for Shavuos with good middos, diligence in Torah, tefillah and love of friends.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achimelech, Aharon HaKohen, Dovid HaMelech, Moshe Rabbeinu, Naomi, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Tzvi Hirsh of Zidichov, Rabbi Yishmael ben Elisha, Rashi, Rus, Shlomis bas Divri, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Chasam Sofer, the Chiddushei HaRim, the daughters of Tzelofchad, the Maharal of Prague, the Mitteler Rebbe (Rabbi Dovber of Lubavitch), the Noda BiYehudah, the Ramban
Terms הרגש, השגה, יובל, לחם הפנים, מחול, עתיקא קדישא, קדושת ישראל, שם הוי"ה, שמיטה, שער החמישים, תוכחה