המשך ביאור לבטל הטענות כנגד מי שאומרים כ"ב שאין כל עבירה כע"ז ממש' מצוה ועבירה הם נצחיות.

Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH no. ⁨40⁩ Pocket Guide p. 77 English 51 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 51 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Learning Tanya chapter 25, the Rav explains why every aveirah is really like avodah zarah, why the hidden love of every Jew makes overcoming the yetzer hara near and easy, and why the claim 'I can do teshuvah later' fails, since a mitzvah and an aveirah are stamped into eternity.

The Rav announces that he will now go to the essence of Tanya, which speaks even to plain people of a very low generation like ours. He recalls that all mitzvos branch out of 'Anochi' and 'Lo yihyeh', and that every Jew, even the simplest, instinctively gives his life rather than worship avodah zarah. Since every aveirah places a person under the sitra achra, it is a hidden form of avodah zarah; sinning anyway is the 'ruach shtus' Chazal learn from the sotah. In chapter 25 he distinguishes faulty reasoning from plain forgetting, and teaches that the remedy is to arouse the hidden love, illustrated by the Avnei Nezer's explanation about a kohenes. The love includes fear, like a mother holding her baby. He answers the argument of later teshuvah: above time nothing is temporary, so an aveirah is eternal. The same applies to positive mitzvos, and he closes with the darkness of the Shovevim weeks.

Topics: Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · Mesiras Nefesh · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Going to the essence of Tanya

    The Rav says he will skip ahead to the core chapters of Tanya, which speak to plain people. He describes our generation as very low, with the signs Chazal give for the time before Moshiach, and says even so people like us can benefit from these chapters.

  2. 5:36 Mesirus nefesh for avodah zarah

    The Rav recalls that all mitzvos branch out of 'Anochi' and 'Lo yihyeh', and that every Jew, even the simplest, gives his life rather than serve avodah zarah, unlike soldiers or terrorists who must be trained. Yet every aveirah is a subdivision of avodah zarah, as the Ba'al Shem Tov says.

  3. 9:03 The sotah and the spirit of folly listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Gemara that one sins only when a spirit of folly enters him, learned from the sotah, and builds the kal vachomer: one ready to die for avodah zarah should surely bear a small discomfort to avoid any aveirah, which is the same avodah zarah in disguise.

  4. 13:21 Folly, forgetting and the hidden love listed in the guide

    Starting chapter 25, the Rav distinguishes two settings of sin: faulty reasoning (shtus) and simply not thinking (shikchah). The remedy is to remember and arouse the hidden love, since a person who sins forgets his bond with Hashem, like the sotah who forgets her bond with her husband.

  5. 17:40 The Avnei Nezer on the kohenes

    The Rav brings the case of a kohenes who remarried on the word of one witness and whose husband returned. The Avnei Nezer explains that a bond like chassan and kallah exists between every Jew and Hashem, felt more strongly by Shevet Levi, so she should have sensed her husband was alive.

  6. 21:06 Love that includes fear, a G-dly instinct listed in the guide

    On 'in your mouth and in your heart', the Rav explains that the hidden love includes fear, like a mother holding her baby tightly on the stairs, and works as a G-dly instinct, like an animal giving itself for its offspring. So a person can surely break a small desire; and he notes that love is the root of positive mitzvos and fear of negative ones.

  7. 28:28 The plea of later teshuvah listed in the guide

    The Rav takes up the argument that a small aveirah can be fixed with teshuvah, and brings the Gemara that one who says 'I will sin and repent' is not given the means to repent. He explains that this means no heavenly arousal is sent, but if the person pushes his way in, the teshuvah still helps.

  8. 32:15 No 'temporary' above time listed in the guide

    The Rav shows that even with avodah zarah a person could do teshuvah afterwards, yet every Jew gives his life rather than be cut off even temporarily. The reason is that above there is no time, so an aveirah is stamped into eternity, and the soul feels it would lose its eternity.

  9. 36:53 Fighting laziness in positive mitzvos

    The Rav applies the same reckoning to positive mitzvos, with the example of missing Mincha for a ball game. Laziness comes from the element of earth, the most passive element, and one must fight it with strength in Torah, tefillah and tzedakah, the three pillars.

  10. 41:20 Victory removes the concealment

    The Rav says overcoming the yetzer hara is near and possible for everyone, and after victory the concealment is lifted and one feels close to Hashem. He explains 'Hashem Echad': no place is empty of Hashem, and the darkness of this world is only a blanket covering Him.

  11. 46:42 Shovevim: piercing the dark curtain

    The Rav connects this to the Shovevim weeks, the darkest season, when the work is to pierce the dark curtain and find Hashem within it. Chanukah prepares for it; today the darkness has entered our homes, and in these weeks of reading about the exodus one should extricate one's own soul from Mitzrayim.

The shiur, written up

Going to the essence of Tanya

0:46

The Rav says he will now skip ahead to the essence of Tanya, the chapters addressed to plain people who cannot reach the levels described before; and we, he adds, are far lower still. Our generation already bears the signs that the Gemara at the end of Sotah and in Perek Chelek gives for the time before Moshiach, and compared with his youth every moral value has been broken down. Even so, people like us can benefit from these chapters. a,b

Mesirus nefesh for avodah zarah

5:36

All the mitzvos, the Rav recalls, branch out of 'Anochi' and 'Lo yihyeh', heard at Sinai without an intermediary. Every Jew, even the simplest, gives his life rather than serve avodah zarah; not because he was trained, like soldiers or suicide terrorists, but because it touches what he heard from Hashem Himself. Yet, as the Ba'al Shem Tov says, any deviation from the Torah is already avodah zarah. c

The sotah and the spirit of folly

9:15

On the passuk of the sotah, 'ish ish ki sisteh ishto', the Gemara teaches that a person sins only when a spirit of folly enters him. The will to live is stronger than any passion, so one ready to die rather than serve avodah zarah should surely bear a small discomfort to avoid an aveirah, which places him under the same Samech Mem. This, the Rav says, is the reckoning a person should make when tempted. d,e

Folly, forgetting and the hidden love

13:21

Chapter 25 of Tanya aims to remove this spirit of folly and forgetfulness. The Rav distinguishes two settings: one reasons wrongly that a doubtful ice cream is not like avodah zarah, which is shtus; another does not think at all, like an animal, which is shikchah, forgetting. The remedy is to remember and arouse the hidden love: as the sotah forgets her bond with her husband, the sinner forgets his concealed love for Hashem, dormant but present in every Jew. g

The Avnei Nezer on the kohenes

18:14

A kohenes remarried on the word of one witness, and then her husband returned. The Avnei Nezer explains that every Jew has a bond with Hashem like that of chassan and kallah, felt more strongly by Shevet Levi, none of whom worshipped the Egel. She should have instinctively sensed that her husband was alive; not sensing it shows the intuition was missing. i

Love that includes fear

21:06

'In your mouth and in your heart', the Rav explains, means Shema and Torah in the mouth and the hidden love in the heart, which one should stir up at every test. Avoiding aveiros needs both love and fear, and this love includes fear: a mother carrying her baby up the steps holds it tightly because she loves it. So a Jew fears damaging his love, and gives his life by a G-dly instinct, as an animal gives itself for its offspring without calculating. f

25:15

Surely, then, he can break a desire for a questionable ice cream, and the Rav urges learning these chapters over and over until this becomes one's own. He adds that love is the root of positive mitzvos and fear the root of prohibitions, which is why, as the Ramban explains, a positive mitzvah overrides a prohibition.

The plea of later teshuvah

28:54

A person might argue that he would die for avodah zarah but can do teshuvah for this aveirah. Yet no one worships avodah zarah planning to repent, though teshuvah exists there too. The Gemara says one who plans to sin and repent is not given the means to repent; the Rav explains that Heaven withholds the arousal to teshuvah, but if he pushes in with his elbows, his teshuvah still helps. j

No 'temporary' above time

32:15

Why, then, is this aveirah different? Knowing he could repent, a Jew still gives his life rather than stand under the Samech Mem even temporarily. The Rav explains that above there is no time, no before and after; an aveirah is stamped into eternity. Teshuvah, also eternal, can undo it later, but the soul instinctively feels it would be losing its eternity.

Fighting laziness in positive mitzvos

37:04

The same applies to doing good. One tempted to skip Mincha for a ball game must, as the Tanya says, muster strength like a lion against the yetzer hara that weighs the body down with laziness, which comes from earth, the most passive element. He must exert himself in Torah, in tefillah with all his strength, and in tzedakah even when it feels like too much: the three pillars. g

Victory removes the concealment

41:20

Fighting the yetzer hara, the Rav says, is near and possible for everyone, and after victory the concealment lifts and one feels close to Hashem. He explains 'Hashem Echad' of Shema: no cubic inch is empty of Hashem, not this table and not the air; were anything else to exist on its own, He would not be One. One who wins against the folly sees Hashem everywhere, and the darkness of this world is only a blanket covering Him. k

Shovevim: piercing the dark curtain

46:52

This is the avodah of Shovevim, the darkest season: to pierce the dark curtain and find Hashem within the darkness. Chanukah comes just before to prepare for it; today the menorah is lit inside, because the darkness has entered our homes through television, radio and the internet. In these weeks of reading about Mitzrayim, the Rav says, one should extricate one's own soul from Mitzrayim.

Sources

Torah

  1. c Shemos 20:2-3 text index In the write-up: 5:36
  2. d Bamidbar 5:12 text index In the write-up: 9:15
  3. f Devarim 30:14 text index In the write-up: 21:06
  4. k Devarim 6:4 text index In the write-up: 41:20

Talmud Bavli

  1. a apparently Sotah 49b (end of the tractate) index In the write-up: 0:46
  2. b apparently Sanhedrin ch. 11 (Perek Chelek) index In the write-up: 0:46
  3. e Sotah 3a text index In the write-up: 9:15
  4. j Yoma 85b text index In the write-up: 28:54

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. g apparently Tanya ch. 25 index In the write-up: 13:21, 37:04
  2. h Tanya (place not identified) 8:28 index
  3. i Avnei Nezer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 18:14

Key points

  1. 6:44 Every Jew, even the simplest, is instinctively ready to give his life rather than worship avodah zarah, without being trained for it.
  2. 8:30 Any aveirah, even a small rabbinic one, places a person under the jurisdiction of the sitra achra and is a subdivision of avodah zarah.
  3. 14:05 One sins either out of 'shtus', faulty reasoning, or out of 'shikchah', simply not thinking; the remedy is to remember and arouse the hidden love for Hashem.
  4. 22:45 The hidden love includes fear: one fears damaging the love, and it works as a G-dly instinct beyond reasoning.
  5. 28:54 The plea 'I will do teshuvah afterwards' fails, since a Jew would not worship avodah zarah even temporarily although teshuvah would help there too.
  6. 35:23 Above, there is no time, so an aveirah is not temporary; it is stamped into eternity, and the soul senses this.
  7. 37:14 The same reckoning applies to positive mitzvos: one must fight laziness, which comes from the element of earth, in Torah, tefillah and tzedakah.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 10:59 If a person is ready to die rather than worship avodah zarah, why does he not bear a small discomfort to avoid any aveirah?

    Answer: 11:23 It is not logical; it is the spirit of folly, since every aveirah is the same avodah zarah in disguise.

  2. Question: 18:36 Why is a kohenes who remarried on one witness's testimony, and whose husband returned, treated so severely?

    Answer: 19:07 According to the Avnei Nezer, she should have felt the bond with her living husband, especially as one from Levi; failing to feel it shows a lack of that intuition.

  3. Question: 28:20 Why should love be the root of positive mitzvos and fear the root of prohibitions?

    Answer: 28:05 A positive mitzvah is something done actively, which is love; therefore, as the Ramban explains, a positive mitzvah overrides a prohibition, since love is stronger than fear.

  4. Question: 31:43 If nothing stands in the way of teshuvah, what does it mean that one who says 'I will sin and repent' is not given the means to repent?

    Answer: 31:03 Heaven does not send him the usual arousal to teshuvah, but if he uses his mind and pushes in, his teshuvah helps.

  5. Question: 33:04 Since teshuvah would help even for avodah zarah, why does a Jew refuse to be cut off from Hashem even temporarily?

    Answer: 35:23 Above there is no time and no temporary; an aveirah is stamped into eternity, and his soul senses that he would be ruining himself forever.

Insights

  1. 8:44 Every aveirah, even a small rabbinic one, is a hidden subdivision of avodah zarah, because it throws a person under the jurisdiction of the sitra achra, the same domain as idolatry, only not its 'top' form.
  2. 7:34 A Jew's readiness to die rather than serve avodah zarah is not the product of training, as with soldiers or terrorists, but a G-dly instinct, like an animal giving itself for its young without any reasoning.
  3. 23:05 Fear of Hashem is a product of love: like a mother who holds her baby tightly on the stairs because she loves it, a Jew fears that his love should not be damaged.
  4. 19:07 From the Avnei Nezer the Rav draws that the bond between a Jew and Hashem is a felt intuition: a kohenes, from Shevet Levi who feel that bond more strongly, should have sensed that her husband was alive despite one witness.
  5. 31:03 'Ein maspikin beyado' does not lock the door of teshuvah: it only means no heavenly arousal is sent, but one who pushes his way in with his elbows is still helped.
  6. 35:23 Above, there is no 'temporary': since Heaven is beyond time, an aveirah is stamped into eternity, and the teshuvah that undoes it is likewise eternal; this is why the soul refuses even a temporary separation.
  7. 47:39 Chanukah, just before Shovevim, prepares for the darkest season; today the menorah is lit inside because the darkness has already penetrated our homes through the media.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 11:31 The Rav says that when confronted with the urge to sin, a person should make the reckoning: if he would give his life rather than worship avodah zarah, he should surely bear a little discomfort rather than do any aveirah.
  2. 21:23 Whenever one faces a test, the Rav says, one should stir up the hidden love and feel the bond with Hashem, not betray it like the sotah.
  3. 27:08 The Rav advises learning these chapters over and over until the comparison of every aveirah to avodah zarah becomes one's own acquisition.
  4. 37:04 The Rav says that even with a positive mitzvah, such as davening Mincha in the middle of a ball game, one should use one's logic to stir up and fight laziness.
  5. 47:13 In the Shovevim weeks, when the exile and exodus from Mitzrayim are read, the Rav says one should extricate one's own soul from Mitzrayim.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Levi (son of Yaakov), the Avnei Nezer of Sochatchov, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Ramban

Terms אהבה מסותרת, הסתר, הרהורי תשובה, למעלה מן הזמן, מסירות נפש, נצח, סוטה, סטרא אחרא, סמאל, עבודה זרה, עצלות, קל שבקלים, רוח שטות, שובבים, שכחה, תשובה

Report an error on this page