”כי קרוב אליך הדבר וכו'” למה כל כך קשה לקיים תורה ומצות? והתירוץ - “עצבות.” עצות להיות בשמחה. כל יסורים באים מב' אותיות ראשונות שבשם הוי'.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH כ"ה no. 41 Pocket Guide p. 77 English 49 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains, on the end of Tanya chapter 25, how a Jew's readiness to give his life rather than worship idols makes every mitzvah 'very near', and why both the aveirah and the union of a mitzvah are eternal, while teshuvah restores the bond.
The Rav reviews that all positive mitzvos branch out of 'Anochi Hashem' and all prohibitions out of 'Lo yihyeh lecha', so every aveirah cuts a Jew off from Hashem as idolatry would. Since every Jew is ready to give his life against avodah zarah, he can tell himself, facing a temptation, that the far smaller sacrifice of giving up a desire is surely within reach; this is how 'ki karov eilecha hadavar' is fulfilled. Even a 'temporary' aveirah is not temporary, since above time everything is eternal. He explains bittul and 'Hashem Echad', the world as a mirage of hester panim, and that the union of a mitzvah, like the Torah, is eternal, while teshuvah undoes the cutting off. He admits the idea is hard for minds molded by this world. He then discusses why Selach Lanu is said three times a day, why the Tanya speaks of positive mitzvos, achta v'ashuv, why Moshe taught 'b'chol nafshecha' before Eretz Yisrael, and answers a question on teshuvah and forgiveness.
Topics: Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · Mesiras Nefesh · Teshuvah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Mesiras nefesh makes every mitzvah near listed in the guide
The Rav reviews that every mitzvah is a branch of the first two commandments, so every aveirah detaches a Jew from Hashem. Since every Jew stands ready to die rather than worship idols, he can tell himself that giving up a smaller desire is surely within reach; this is how 'ki karov eilecha hadavar' is fulfilled.
-
5:40 No such thing as a temporary aveirah
The Rav explains the Tanya's point that a Jew must give his life even for idolatry 'only for now', after which he would do teshuvah. Above, past, present and future are one, so an aveirah, and also refraining from one, is registered as eternal.
-
9:45 Bittul and Hashem Echad
The Rav explains that the purpose of avodas Hashem is to be nullified to Hashem: 'Echad' means there is nothing but Him, and the world that seems to exist on its own is a mirage, hester panim. One who gives up his desires to cleave to Hashem merits gilui panim and feels it in his soul.
-
15:54 The eternal union and the eternal Torah
The Rav explains that the union formed when a person withstands a desire is eternal, because Hashem and His will, expressed in the Torah, are above time and never change. An aveirah cuts a person off eternally, but teshuvah restores the bond; he answers a listener's question and compares the Torah's changing appearance to a cloud.
-
23:13 Accepting a hard idea with emunah
The Rav admits that this half page is hard to grasp, not because the logic is weak but because minds molded by this world take it as the world of truth. He says one must accept it with emunah, as one moves on past a difficult Tosafos, and warns that the next chapter will be similar.
-
27:08 Why Selach Lanu three times a day
The Rav asks why Selach Lanu is said three times a day if Hashem surely forgives the first time. He answers with the Tanya that even a masmid interrupts his learning in between, so new bittul Torah needs new forgiveness, and a deep teshuvah need not be repeated.
-
30:51 Growing teshuvah, stains, and achta v'ashuv
The Rav adds that one who grows is held to account again for old aveiros, and Yom Kippur brings teshuvah from a higher root. He explains that the Tanya speaks of positive mitzvos because prohibitions leave a stain needing more, with parables of a stained shirt and a broken bottle of wine. A person who knows he will likely fall again is not 'achta v'ashuv'.
-
39:24 B'chol nafshecha before Eretz Yisrael
The Rav asks why Moshe Rabbeinu commanded 'b'chol nafshecha' in Krias Shema to Jews about to enter Eretz Yisrael, where they were promised victory and faced no forced idolatry. He answers that it was an eitzah: the reckoning of readiness for mesiras nefesh would help them withstand every other temptation there.
-
44:18 Teshuvah first, then forgiveness
Answering a listener, the Rav explains that teshuvah comes first and the request for forgiveness after it, so the bracha is made knowing it is accepted. He mentions vidui in Tachanun for individual sins and one collective sin, and says that unlike other requests, forgiveness is guaranteed.
The shiur, written up
Mesiras nefesh makes every mitzvah near
The Rav reviews that all positive mitzvos branch out of 'Anochi Hashem Elokecha' and all prohibitions out of 'Lo yihyeh lecha'. Even a simple Jew, history shows, would give his life rather than worship idols, and since every mitzvah is part of these two, any aveirah cuts him off from Hashem and puts him under the sitra achra. a
No such thing as a temporary aveirah
Continuing in the Tanya, the Rav notes that a Jew must give his life even if the idolatry would be only for a moment, followed by teshuvah. The reason is that above there is no before and after; past, present and future are one and everything is eternal. An aveirah that seems temporary is registered above forever, and so is abstaining from one. d
Bittul and Hashem Echad
The Rav explains that the goal of avodas Hashem is to be nullified to Hashem; whatever claims its own existence is not holiness. This is the meaning of 'Hashem Echad': in holiness one is the biggest number, for if a person or even a table stood beside Hashem there would already be two.
What we see is a mirage Hashem created so things seem to exist; this concealment is hester panim. One who forgoes his desires to cleave only to Hashem merits gilui panim, and to his degree feels it in his soul.
The eternal union and the eternal Torah
The Tanya now concludes that the union formed in the moments a person withstands his desire is eternal, not just five minutes of self-denial. Hashem and His will are above time, and His will is revealed in the Torah, so the Torah too is eternal and never changes; only in this world do we live under time. d
Stopping from Torah for a need like earning a living is itself a mitzvah; the cutting off is when a person turns to empty things. An aveirah cuts him off eternally, but teshuvah removes it and he is again eternally attached. d
Asked about this, the Rav says that only great tzaddikim grasp it. Where the Torah seems to change for us, it is like a cloud taking another shape while remaining the same cloud.
Accepting a hard idea with emunah
The Rav admits that this half page is hard to grasp, not because of its logic, but because years in this world have made us treat it as the world of truth, while Chazal call the World to Come the world of truth and ours the world of imagination. Until our hardened minds soften, he says, we accept it with emunah, like a difficult Tosafos, and go further; the next chapter will be similar.
Why Selach Lanu three times a day
Teshuvah brings a person right back, so in Selach Lanu one asks from the heart, sure of forgiveness. Then why repeat it at Minchah and Maariv, as if doubting? The Tanya answers that even a masmid interrupts his learning here and there, and this bittul Torah needs new forgiveness; a deep teshuvah itself would not need repeating. i,d
Growing teshuvah, stains, and achta v'ashuv
The Rav adds that a person must keep growing, and on a higher level his earlier teshuvah is no longer enough. The sefarim say a soul may rise in Gan Eden for a hundred years and then need cleansing again, since what is small to us is a sin for a great tzaddik. On Yom Kippur all Jews reach a higher root and do teshuvah even for others.
B'chol nafshecha before Eretz Yisrael
Teshuvah first, then forgiveness
Answering a listener, the Rav explains that teshuvah comes first; one cannot ask forgiveness while intending to sin again. Forgiveness is the fruit of teshuvah, so the bracha is made knowing it is accepted. In Tachanun's vidui one confesses individual sins and the one collective sin of not doing Hashem's will. Unlike other requests, forgiveness is promised.
Sources
Torah
Mishnah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 0:21 All positive mitzvos are branches of 'Anochi Hashem' and all prohibitions of 'Lo yihyeh lecha', so any aveirah detaches a Jew from Hashem as idolatry does.
- 3:36 Since a Jew is ready to give his life rather than worship idols, he can reason that giving up a smaller desire, a lesser 'mesiras nefesh', is surely within his power; this makes serving Hashem 'very near'.
- 7:44 Above, Hashem and His will are beyond time, so an aveirah 'just for now' is registered forever, and so is the union of a mitzvah and the Torah itself.
- 20:20 An aveirah cuts a person off eternally, but teshuvah removes the cutting off and he is again eternally attached.
- 29:13 Selach Lanu is repeated three times a day because there is most likely bittul Torah in between, and because a person who grows needs new forgiveness for what he did before.
- 42:18 Moshe Rabbeinu taught 'b'chol nafshecha' to the Jews entering Eretz Yisrael so they could use the reckoning of mesiras nefesh against every other temptation there.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:45 How can the Torah say that serving Hashem is 'very near' in one's mouth and heart?
Answer: 4:05 A Jew who is ready to give his life rather than worship idols can reckon that giving up a lesser desire is surely within his reach.
-
Question: 28:22 Why say Selach Lanu three times a day, as if doubting that Hashem forgave the first time?
Answer: 29:13 Between one Selach Lanu and the next there was most likely bittul Torah, which needs new forgiveness; and a person who grows needs forgiveness again for what was once enough.
-
Question: 34:00 Why does the Tanya speak here only about positive mitzvos?
Answer: 34:05 For prohibitions, teshuvah brings forgiveness but a stain of damage remains that needs Yom Kippur or more, while for a positive mitzvah teshuvah already corrects the damage.
-
Question: 36:57 Is it 'achta v'ashuv' if a person does teshuvah knowing he will probably sin again?
Answer: 37:43 No; achta v'ashuv is when reliance on teshuvah caused the sin. One who sincerely regrets but fears his weakness is forgiven when he asks again.
-
Question: 40:00 Why did Moshe Rabbeinu command 'b'chol nafshecha' to Jews entering Eretz Yisrael, where no one would force them to worship idols?
Answer: 42:25 It was an eitzah: the reckoning of readiness for mesiras nefesh would help them withstand every other temptation in the land.
-
Question: 44:19 How can one be sure of forgiveness when asking, if he might return to the aveirah?
Answer: 44:43 Teshuvah comes first; once it is accepted one asks for forgiveness, its fruit, and unlike other requests, forgiveness is guaranteed.
Insights
- 4:11 'Ki karov' is explained through a reckoning: a Jew who would give his whole life against idolatry can surely give up the 'smaller nefesh' of a single desire, since nefesh also means desire.
- 8:26 Refraining from an aveirah for a few minutes is not a passing act; since nothing is temporary above, that moment's union with Hashem is eternal.
- 11:26 In holiness 'one' is the biggest number: if a person or even a table exists alongside Hashem, there are already two, so 'Echad' demands that the self be merged into Him.
- 22:38 The Torah never changes; where it seems to take another form for us, it is like a cloud that changes shape yet stays the same cloud.
- 24:14 The difficulty in grasping the eternity of a mitzvah is not in the logic but in a mind molded by this world, which takes the 'world of imagination' for the world of truth.
- 35:40 Teshuvah for a prohibition may bring forgiveness yet leave damage, like a host who forgives the guest who broke his bottle of wine while the bottle still must be replaced.
- 37:43 'Achta v'ashuv' applies only when the expected teshuvah is what allows the sin; one who sincerely regrets but fears his weak nature will fail again is forgiven each time.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 3:07 The Rav says that when confronted with the yetzer hara, a Jew should tell himself he is ready to give his life for Hashem, so he can surely forgo this desire.
- 23:23 The Rav says that what cannot yet be grasped in the Tanya should be accepted with emunah, and one should go further.
- 27:30 The Rav says that when saying Selach Lanu one should ask from the depth of the heart and believe that Hashem forgives.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Moshe Rabbeinu, Rashi, Rav Saadia Gaon, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov
Terms ביטול, ביטול תורה, הסתר פנים, חשבון הנפש, יחוד, מסירות נפש, נצח, סטרא אחרא, עבודה זרה, פועל דמיוני, קלקול, רבונו של עולם