אגרת "להשכילך בינה" - בענין בני חיי מזוני כתוב - “בטל רצונך מפני רצונו.” יש צער אחד שהוא אמת וזה צער שעבר רצון ה'. ומכל מקום - אל תעסוק בו הרבה.

Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH כ"ו no. ⁨42⁩ Pocket Guide p. 77 English 48 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 48 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav learns Tanya chapter 26: the yetzer hara can only be overpowered with the alertness that comes from simcha, the only true sadness is remorse over aveiros at set times, and worldly suffering is relieved by knowing it comes from the hidden world.

The Rav reviews how chapter 25 made serving Hashem seem easy, then turns to chapter 26: like a wrestler, or an ox against a lion, the lazy side loses, so the yetzer hara can only be overcome with alertness born of simcha, while sadness itself breeds craving. Sadness has an advantage only when it is remorse over aveiros, and only for its product, teshuvah and the joy of reconciliation, felt at set times such as Tikkun Chatzos, which the Rav explains at length. Sadness over livelihood or other worldly matters, by the Tanya's standard, is nothing. The remedy is to know that hardships come from the hidden world, too high for this world to bear, and to accept them with simcha, as the stories of the Ger Tzedek Graf Potocki and of the Alter Rebbe's arrest show. The Rav admits this level is very hard for our generation.

Topics: Simcha and Lowliness (Tanya ch. 26-34) · Serving Hashem with Simcha · Teshuvah · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Is it a cinch? The wrestler and the lion

    The Rav reviews chapter 25, that every aveirah separates a person from Hashem like avodah zarah, which seems to make being a tzaddik easy. He then opens chapter 26 with the wrestling analogy: a stronger fighter who is lazy and heavy loses, as an ox loses to a lion.

  2. 4:18 Overpowering the yetzer hara with simcha

    The Rav explains that laziness comes from sadness and a stone-like heart, while alertness comes from simcha in knowing one has a Provider in heaven. He shows how sadness itself drives a person to seek gratification, and says the Tanya's demand for a heart free of worry applies, to our degree, even in our generation.

  3. 8:14 The one true sadness: remorse over aveiros listed in the guide

    The Rav explains the passuk that every sorrow has an advantage: not that sadness is good, but that remorse over aveiros leads to teshuvah and the simcha of reconciliation, like two friends who make up. This sadness belongs only at set times, and he reads it into the pesukim of Tehillim 51 about a broken spirit leading to joy.

  4. 14:48 Tikkun Chatzos and the seudah of Dovid HaMelech listed in the guide

    The Rav explains Tikkun Chatzos, Dovid HaMelech's midnight tefillah, and parallels the tefillos of the Avos and of Dovid to the Shabbos seudos and Melaveh Malkah. Tehillim 51 is part of Tikkun Chatzos, where a person laments the churban and, more deeply, his own inner Beis HaMikdash ruined by his aveiros, and then rises to simcha.

  5. 21:10 Light after darkness; worldly sadness is nothing listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that joy after sadness is like light after darkness, and brings the curse for not serving Hashem with simcha. By the Tanya's standard, sadness over income or other worldly matters is a child's complaint over a broken house of blocks; he asks whether a person is sad over his aveiros or over his income, and admits this chapter demands more than we can offer.

  6. 27:34 Bnei, chayei, mezonei and the hidden world listed in the guide

    The Rav asks how a person can free himself from sadness over children, life and sustenance, and brings Chazal that one must bless and accept the bad with simcha as the good. He explains the two halves of the Shem Havayah, the hidden world and the revealed world: hardships come from the higher, hidden world, which this world cannot bear, and they bring a person closer to Hashem.

  7. 34:03 Those who rejoice in suffering listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that accepting hardship with simcha turns the hidden into revealed kindness, and that a person should say even of undesirable things that they are for the good. He brings the Gemara about those who accept suffering with love, and the passuk that those who love Hashem are like the sun going out in its strength: the tzaddik feels the pressure like a tight shoe but disregards it in his joy of closeness to Hashem.

  8. 37:30 The Ger Tzedek and the house of blocks Story

    The Rav tells briefly of Graf Potocki, a great Polish lord who became a Jew and was condemned to be burned. When the executioner asked whether he would take revenge, he answered with a parable of children's houses of blocks: this world is worth nothing to him, and he is going to a better world.

  9. 40:50 The sun drawn from its sheath listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that for such tzaddikim all suffering is suffering of love, and that the spiritual sun will be uncovered from its sheath, so the hidden world will shine in this world on those who take refuge in Hashem's shadow. He sums up the Tanya's remedy: realize that worldly hardships are nothing and be happy with Hashem who is hidden in them.

  10. 44:47 Reb Shmuel Munkes and the Alter Rebbe's arrest

    The Rav admits this level is not for everybody, then tells how Reb Shmuel Munkes told the Alter Rebbe not to hide from arrest: if he is a Rebbe he need fear nothing, and if not, by what right did he take away thousands of Jews' appreciation of this world. He concludes that this paragraph may not be for our generation, and that other aids to simcha must be found.

The shiur, written up

Is it a cinch? The wrestler and the lion

0:33

The Rav recalls that chapter 25 explained the passuk 'ki karov eilecha' as promised on the title page: every aveirah, even a small one, subordinates a person to the sitra achra and tears him from Hashem like avodah zarah. So it seems a cinch to be a tzaddik. But the yetzer hara resists, and chapter 26 opens with a great rule: two wrestlers, where the lazy and heavy one loses even if he is stronger, as an ox, stronger than a lion, loses to the lion's energy. a,b,c

Overpowering the yetzer hara with simcha

4:27

Laziness, the Rav explains, comes from sadness and a heart stuffed up like a stone; the yetzer hara is overcome only with alertness born of simcha, the simcha of knowing one has a Provider in heaven. Sadness even breeds sin: an unhappy person, feeling deprived, reaches for another slice of cake. The Tanya demands a heart free of every particle of worry, and though we lack such a Rebbe and such chassidim, the Rav says we must try to reach it to our degree.

The one true sadness: remorse over aveiros

8:23

The passuk in Mishlei says every sorrow has an advantage. The Rav stresses that Shlomo HaMelech does not advocate sadness; sadness is no good, but it can be put to use. The only true sadness is remorse over aveiros, not over money or power, and even its advantage lies in its product: he resolves to mend his ways, and teshuvah brings him to simcha, like two dear friends who quarrel and make up. d

12:11

Even this belongs only at set times, by appointment, such as before sleep or on Rosh Hashanah, not all day. Then the broken heart breaks the iron wall between him and Hashem, as the passuk says that Hashem does not reject a broken spirit, and the earlier pesukim of that chapter, about being given joy again, come true for him. e,f

Tikkun Chatzos and the seudah of Dovid HaMelech

15:03

The Rav explains Tikkun Chatzos: Dovid HaMelech rose at midnight to lament the churban and then sing praise, a tefillah the Ramchal calls the tefillah of tzaddikim. As Yaakov's tefillah is optional according to the Gemara yet accepted as an obligation, so Dovid's midnight tefillah corresponds to Melaveh Malkah, the seudah of Dovid HaMelech, a mitzvah even with a cup of tea. g,h

18:33

Tehillim 51, the chapter of teshuvah, is part of Tikkun Chatzos. Why lament a Beis HaMikdash thousands of miles away? In the deepest sense, the Rav says, a person laments his own Beis HaMikdash, his neshamah, ruined by his aveiros, and then rises with the true simcha that follows sadness. i

Light after darkness; worldly sadness is nothing

21:21

This simcha is like morning light after a dark night, more appreciated than constant light, as Koheles speaks of the advantage of light over darkness. The Rav adds the Arizal's reading of the curse that came because Hashem was not served with simcha: they did serve Him, but without joy. j,k

23:53

By the Tanya's standard, who learns along with us as the Gemara says of a tzaddik whose teaching is repeated, any other sadness is nonsense: Hashem, by hashgachah pratis, puts a person where it is best for him. Such complaints are like a child crying over a broken house of blocks. Honestly, the Rav asks, is one sad over aveiros or over income? He admits this chapter demands more than we can produce, yet we must believe it is true. l

Bnei, chayei, mezonei and the hidden world

27:34

How can a person free himself from sadness over children, life or sustenance, so that he has vigor to overpower the yetzer hara? The Rav brings the Gemara that one must accept the bad with simcha just as one blesses over the evident good, for what happens is good though concealed. m

30:02

He explains: the Shem Havayah has two halves. The last two letters relate to this world, the revealed world we can grasp; the first two are the hidden world, so lofty that when it comes down here we cannot tolerate it, and that is the source of suffering. Yet it comes from Hashem who loves him and knows what is eternally good for him, and it brings him closer, only he is not yet conditioned to receive so great a light.

Those who rejoice in suffering

34:07

If he accepts it with simcha, Hashem transforms the hidden into revealed kindness, and he should say even of undesirable things that this is for the good. The Gemara applies to those who accept suffering with love the passuk that those who love Hashem are like the sun going out in its strength; His kindness is better than life. The tzaddik feels the barrier like a tight shoe, but disregards it in his joy of closeness. m,n,o,p

The Ger Tzedek and the house of blocks

37:38

The Rav tells of Graf Potocki, a great Polish lord who became a Jew and was to be thrown into the fire. The executioner asked whether he would take revenge in the world to come. He answered that a father laughs when one child breaks another's house of blocks; this world means nothing to him, and he is going to a better world. To such people, the Rav says, even burning is nothing.

The sun drawn from its sheath

41:30

To such tzaddikim all suffering is suffering of love. The spiritual sun, the Rav explains, will be drawn from its sheath: the hidden world will shine in this world on those who take refuge in Hashem's shadow. So the Tanya's remedy is to realize that worldly suffering is nothing, ignore it, and be happy with Hashem who hides within it.

Reb Shmuel Munkes and the Alter Rebbe's arrest

44:49

The Rav admits this level is not for everybody. When the Tsar's soldiers came for the Alter Rebbe, he wanted to hide, but Reb Shmuel Munkes said: if you are a Rebbe, what do you fear; if not, by what right did you deprive thousands of Jews of their appreciation of this world? He had immunized his chassidim against this world, and that power lies in these words, though this paragraph may not be for our generation.

Sources

Torah

  1. b Devarim 30:14 text index In the write-up: 0:33
  2. k Devarim 28:47 text index In the write-up: 21:21

Nevi'im

  1. o Shoftim 5:31 text index In the write-up: 34:07

Kesuvim

  1. d Mishlei 14:23 text index In the write-up: 8:23
  2. e Tehillim 51:19 text index In the write-up: 12:11
  3. f apparently Tehillim 51:10, 51:14 index In the write-up: 12:11
  4. i Tehillim 51 text index In the write-up: 18:33
  5. j Koheles 2:13 text index In the write-up: 21:21
  6. p Tehillim 63:4 text index In the write-up: 34:07

Talmud Bavli

  1. h apparently Berachos 27b index In the write-up: 15:03
  2. l Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 23:53
  3. m apparently Berachos 60b index In the write-up: 27:34, 34:07
  4. n Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 34:07

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya ch. 25 index In the write-up: 0:33
  2. c apparently Tanya ch. 26 index In the write-up: 0:33

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. g Tikkun Chatzos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 15:03

Key points

  1. 2:55 Like a wrestler who loses when he is lazy and heavy even if he is stronger, a person can only overpower the yetzer hara with alertness that comes from simcha and an open heart.
  2. 5:37 Sadness itself feeds the yetzer hara, because an unhappy person seeks gratification elsewhere.
  3. 9:40 The only true sadness is remorse over aveiros, and its value lies only in what it produces: teshuvah and the simcha that follows it.
  4. 12:23 Even this remorse belongs only to set times, such as before sleep or Rosh Hashanah, and not all day.
  5. 24:14 Sadness over children, health or livelihood has no place by the Tanya's standard, since Hashem's hashgachah pratis puts a person where it is best for him.
  6. 29:34 Hardships come from the hidden world, which is higher than the revealed one; one who accepts them with simcha will see them transformed into revealed kindness.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 1:59 If every aveirah is like avodah zarah, is it then a cinch to be a tzaddik?

    Answer: 2:10 The yetzer hara resists, and it can only be overpowered with alertness that comes from simcha, not with heaviness born of sadness.

  2. Question: 8:41 If the passuk says every sorrow has an advantage, does Shlomo HaMelech advocate sadness?

    Answer: 9:22 No; sadness is no good, but true sadness, remorse over aveiros, has an advantage in its product: teshuvah and the simcha that follows.

  3. Question: 19:51 Why should a person lament a Beis HaMikdash that is thousands of miles away?

    Answer: 19:43 Because his own private Beis HaMikdash, his neshamah, was ruined through his aveiros; the essence of Tikkun Chatzos is lamenting them.

  4. Question: 26:15 When a person is sad, is it over his aveiros or over his insufficient income?

    Answer: 24:14 Honestly it is usually the income, and by the Tanya's standard such sadness is complaining over nothing, since Hashem knows what is best for him.

  5. Question: 27:34 How can a person free himself from sadness over children, life and sustenance?

    Answer: 29:00 By knowing that what happens comes from the hidden world, higher than the revealed one, and accepting it with simcha, as one blesses over the good.

Stories

  1. 37:38 Graf Potocki and the house of blocks

    Graf Potocki, one of the greatest lords in Poland, became a Jew at a time when this was punishable by death. He was found and was to be thrown into the fire. The man charged with throwing him in sensed he stood before a holy man and asked him, by then called Avraham, whether he would take revenge on him in the world to come. He answered: of course not; when one child destroys another's house of blocks and the child cries to his father, the adult father laughs; what is life in this world to him that he should avenge his death, he is going to a better world.

    In the story: Avraham ben Avraham (the Ger Tzedek of Vilna)

  2. 45:00 Reb Shmuel Munkes and the Alter Rebbe's arrest

    When the Tsar's soldiers came to take the Alter Rebbe to prison, in the episode that ended with his release and Yud-Tes Kislev, he wanted to hide. The great chassid Reb Shmuel Munkes told him there was no use hiding, they would find him. The danger was real, the Rav explains, because the opposing forces had concentrated against the Alter Rebbe, whose teaching was spreading too much for the sitra achra, clothed in the Russian authorities. Reb Shmuel said: if you are a Rebbe, what are you afraid of; and if you are not a Rebbe, by what right did you deprive thousands of Jews of their appreciation of this world?

    In the story: the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), Reb Shmuel Munkes

Insights

  1. 3:15 Physical strength does not decide a wrestling match, energy does: an ox is stronger than a lion yet loses, and so too a person with greater spiritual strength loses to the yetzer hara if he is heavy with sadness.
  2. 5:37 Sadness is not only a weakness but a cause of sin: deprived of happiness, a person reaches for gratification, as an unhappy person reaches for another slice of cake.
  3. 10:30 The advantage the passuk finds in sorrow is not in the sadness itself but in its product, teshuvah, and the simcha after it is like the joy of two close friends who reconcile after a quarrel.
  4. 19:43 In its deepest sense, mourning the churban at Tikkun Chatzos is mourning one's own private Beis HaMikdash, which a person ruined through his aveiros.
  5. 31:35 Suffering comes from the higher, hidden half of the Shem Havayah; it is a closer contact with Hashem that a person is not yet conditioned to receive, so it arrives as pain.
  6. 46:56 The Alter Rebbe's power, which made him a target, was that he immunized his chassidim against anything this world has to offer, and that power is contained in the words of this chapter.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 7:19 The Rav says that, to the degree we can reach, we must try to look at things this way and be besimcha.
  2. 12:23 The Rav says one should not go around all day sad over aveiros, but feel it only at set times, such as before sleep or Rosh Hashanah.
  3. 34:30 The Rav says a person should say even of undesirable things that this too is for the good, though his mortal eyes cannot see it.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham ben Avraham (the Ger Tzedek of Vilna), Dovid HaMelech, Reb Shmuel Munkes, Shlomo HaMelech, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Ramchal (Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto), Yaakov Avinu

Terms גרים, השגחה פרטית, זריזות, יסורים, יצר הרע, לב נשבר ונדכה, מלוה מלכה, סטרא אחרא, עבודה זרה, עלמא דאתגליא, עלמא דאתכסיא, עצבות, רבונו של עולם, שם הוי"ה, שמחה, תיקון חצות

Report an error on this page