E Tanya
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH no. 43 English 35 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
Reading the Alter Rebbe's letter 'Lehaskil HaBinah' alongside Tanya chapter 26, the Rav shows how a Jew who believes that everything comes from Hashem is not moved by suffering, and how sadness over aveiros belongs only at fixed times, never in the middle of learning, davening or business.
The Rav opens in Tanya chapter 26 and brings the eleventh letter of Igeres HaKodesh, 'Lehaskil HaBinah', to show what the Alter Rebbe demanded of his chassidim: to have no desire for children, life or sustenance beyond what Hashem gives, since a person is recreated from nothing at every moment and nothing bad comes from above. The Rav admits that he himself cannot live this way, and tells of a Lubavitcher mashpia who steadied himself on the way to his daughter's levayah with the letter's opening words. He explains why the letter begins with Binah: the gevuros are sweetened at their root in Binah, and he connects this with the fifty gates of Binah, Pharaoh, and Sefirah. Returning to the Tanya, he teaches that sadness over aveiros during learning, davening or business comes from the yetzer hara, and that remorse belongs at set times. He closes on how Torah brings down the light of any Yom Tov at any time.
Topics: Simcha and Lowliness (Tanya ch. 26-34) · Serving Hashem with Simcha
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The letter 'Lehaskil HaBinah': no desires listed in the guide
The Rav picks up in Tanya chapter 26 and brings Igeres HaKodesh letter 11 to show what was demanded of chassidim two hundred years ago. He reads that a chassid should not desire children, life or sustenance, and should accept whatever life Hashem gives him.
-
5:06 Recreated every moment, everything is good listed in the guide
The Rav explains the letter: a person is recreated from nothing every moment, nothing bad comes from above, so he should always be happy. One who feels that he lacks something loves himself and wants to leave Hashem's hand, while one with true emunah sees the bad turn into good.
-
11:17 Beyond our level; a mashpia at a levayah Story
The Rav says he personally cannot live with such equanimity, and that he read the letter only to show what the chassidim then understood. He tells of a Lubavitcher mashpia who, walking to his daughter's levayah, shook himself with the letter's opening words 'Lehaskil HaBinah', and explains that the letter opens with Binah because the root of the chasadim is there.
-
15:05 Sweetening gevuros in Binah; Pharaoh and the fifty gates
Repeating a Shabbos talk, the Rav explains that gevurah stands directly under Binah ('Ani Binah li gevurah'), so harsh judgments can be sweetened by raising them to their root. He connects this with the fifty gates of Binah at Yetzias Mitzrayim, with Pharaoh who saw blood but not that it would become the blood of milah, and with the fiftieth day of Sefirah.
-
20:06 Sadness during learning and business is from the yetzer listed in the guide
Back in Tanya chapter 26, the Rav explains that one must serve Hashem with joy while learning or davening, and that even a businessman who suddenly feels sorrow over his aveiros in the middle of his work should know it is a trick of the yetzer hara. The yetzer wants him sad so that he will seek relief in desires such as overeating.
-
24:01 Remorse by appointment; the stain on the coat listed in the guide
The Rav explains that remorse over aveiros belongs at fixed times named in the Tanya: before sleep, Erev Shabbos, Erev Rosh Chodesh and Erev Rosh Hashanah, after which a person should believe Hashem has forgiven him and rejoice. He gives a mashal of a stain on a coat that matters more the higher the audience, and notes that one without a program has no appointments at all.
-
30:04 Torah above time; the Sukkah on Shemini Atzeres
The Rav explains that every time can hold every Yom Tov, since learning Torah, which is above time, draws down the light of Pesach, Yom Kippur or Sukkos at any time. He brings the Mishnah that one who did not eat in the sukkah the first night makes it up on Shemini Atzeres, explained in a Chassidish way as the sukkah escorting us into the house, and compares the Gemara to hidden streams that surface here and there.
The shiur, written up
The letter 'Lehaskil HaBinah': no desires
Recreated every moment, everything is good
The reason is that a person is recreated from nothing at every moment. How, then, can he think his situation is bad? Nothing bad comes down from above; everything is good, only so powerful a light that we cannot grasp it. So a person should be happy at every moment.
One who complains shows that he has his own idea of what is good for him. He acts for himself, not for Hashem; out of self-love he wants to leave Hashem's hand, which runs his affairs as Hashem knows is best. But when a person truly has this emunah, the bad is sublimated and becomes good even outwardly.
Beyond our level; a mashpia at a levayah
The Rav admits he cannot live this way; it makes a difference to him whether he is rich or poor, healthy or in pain. He read the letter to show what was demanded then, and that the chassidim understood it.
Sweetening gevuros in Binah
Returning to a talk from Shabbos, the Rav explains that judgments come from the left side, and gevurah stands directly under Binah, as the passuk in Mishlei says, 'Ani Binah li gevurah'. One who experiences gevuros can sweeten them by raising them to Binah, where there is no evil; this is called sweetening the judgments at their root. d
Sadness during learning and business is from the yetzer
Back in the Tanya, the Rav explains that while learning or davening one must serve Hashem with joy, as the passuk says, and ignore thoughts of one's aveiros. Even a businessman, selling muffins in his store, who suddenly feels he is no good because of his aveiros, should know this is a trick of the yetzer hara. The yetzer makes him sad so that he will seek relief in desires, such as reaching for cake. a,g
Remorse by appointment; the stain on the coat
Taking stock of one's deeds and finding a lack can come from kedushah, but not sorrow in the middle of business. Remorse, the Rav says, is by appointment only, with a settled mind. The Tanya names the times: before sleep, Erev Shabbos, Erev Rosh Chodesh and Erev Rosh Hashanah. a
Afterwards he should believe Hashem has forgiven him, as he says in the bracha of the One who forgives abundantly, and this is true simchah. The higher a person rises, the more a sin shows, like a stain on a delivery boy's coat that must vanish before an audience with a king. A real rasha has no appointments, so sadness can strike him anytime. h
Torah above time
Every time can contain every Yom Tov, the Rav explains: learning about Pesach brings down its light, and Torah, which is above time, can draw down any Yom Tov. The Mishnah says that one who did not eat in the sukkah the first night makes it up on Shemini Atzeres. The Chassidish explanation is that the sukkah escorts us into the house, and the Rav compares the Gemara to underground streams that surface here and there. i
Sources
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 3:04 In 'Lehaskil HaBinah' the Alter Rebbe asks his chassidim not to desire children, life or sustenance beyond what Hashem decides for them, since a person lives 'against his will'.
- 5:06 Since a person is recreated from nothing at every moment and no evil comes down from above, everything is good, only too great a light for us to grasp.
- 10:30 When a person truly has this emunah, the bad is sublimated and becomes good even in its visible form.
- 21:18 Sadness over aveiros that comes during learning, davening or business is from the yetzer hara, which wants to push a person into desires.
- 25:30 Remorse over aveiros is 'by appointment only': before going to sleep, on Erev Shabbos, Erev Rosh Chodesh and Erev Rosh Hashanah, followed by simchah in Hashem's forgiveness.
- 30:04 Torah is above time, so by learning about a Yom Tov a person draws down its light at any time of year.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 13:44 Why does the Alter Rebbe open this letter with the words 'Lehaskil HaBinah'?
Answer: 13:44 Because the root of the chasadim is in Binah, and gevuros brought up to Binah are sweetened at their root.
-
Question: 24:22 If thoughts of remorse can come from kedushah, where does sorrow over aveiros that strikes in the middle of business come from?
Answer: 25:13 It is not the time for real remorse, which needs a fixed time with a settled mind; sorrow at the wrong time is the yetzer hara's trick.
Stories
-
12:02 The mashpia on the way to his daughter's levayah
The Rav tells of Reb Mendel, one of the great Lubavitcher mashpi'im, whom many people alive today still remember. He lost a daughter, and on the way to the levayah he was in pain over the loss. Suddenly he shook himself and said to himself, 'Mendel, Lehaskil HaBinah!', the first words of this letter, and became a new person.
In the story: Reb Mendel
Insights
- 8:31 Complaining that one's situation is bad shows self-love: such a person wants to step out from under Hashem's hand, which is running his affairs the way Hashem knows is best for him.
- 13:44 The letter opens with 'Lehaskil HaBinah' because the root of the chasadim is in Binah, and gevuros raised to Binah are sweetened at their root.
- 17:44 Pharaoh, after the plague of locusts, sensed something drawn from the fiftieth gate of Binah: he saw blood ahead of Klal Yisroel, but not that it would turn into the blood of milah.
- 25:30 Remorse over aveiros is 'by appointment only'; for a real rasha sadness can strike anytime, since he has no program and no appointments.
- 27:57 The higher a person rises, the more a small stain of sin becomes significant, like a stain on a coat that is unimportant for a delivery boy but intolerable before an audience with a king.
- 32:13 Making up the sukkah meal on Shemini Atzeres means, in the Chassidish explanation, that the sukkah escorts a Jew into the house.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 21:18 The Rav says that while learning or davening one should ignore thoughts of one's aveiros and serve Hashem with joy.
- 26:24 According to the Rav, remorse should be set for fixed times such as before sleep with a cheshbon hanefesh, and afterwards one should believe Hashem has forgiven and be happy.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Pharaoh, Rabbi Eliezer (ben Hurkenos), the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh
Terms בינה, גבורה, המתקת הדינים, חשבון הנפש, יש מאין, ישוב הדעת, עצבות, שמיני עצרת, שער החמישים