'טוב להודות לה - Because We See that Everything is Coordinated By Him
פירוש על מזמור שיר פסוק בפסוק
Catalog entry: TEFILA (English) no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 78 English 36 min
Listen
About this shiur
Going through Mizmor Shir L'yom HaShabbos verse by verse, the Rav explains that the psalm is the song of the future eternal Shabbos, when all the questions of history will be answered and it will be clear that everything Hashem did was for the good.
The Rav opens with the Mishnah that calls Mizmor Shir L'yom HaShabbos the song of the day that is entirely Shabbos: the seventh millennium after six thousand years. Menucha, he explains, does not mean rest but satisfaction, the feeling of lacking nothing, and our weekly Shabbos is a small taste of it. In that future time the questions that plague people today will dissolve. He lists the suffering of Jewish history, from the Churban and the Ten Martyrs to the Crusades, the Spanish expulsion and the Holocaust, and shows that tzaddikim knew hidden reasons for some of it. Moshe Rabbeinu himself was not shown why the righteous suffer. The Rav then explains each verse: thanking Hashem also means agreeing with Him, daytime understanding versus nighttime emunah, the happy and sad tunes of history, the flourishing of the wicked, the tzaddik like the palm and cedar, and the missing vav of 'avlasa', the connection we will only see later.
Topics: Hester Panim and Suffering · Kabbalas Shabbos and Shabbos Night · Moshiach and the Days of Moshiach
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Shabbos as a taste of the eternal Shabbos
The Rav brings the Mishnah that Mizmor Shir L'yom HaShabbos is the song for the day that is entirely Shabbos, the seventh millennium, and explains that menucha means satisfaction, not rest, bringing Naomi's words to Ruth and Rashi on the creation's completion. A true Shabbos is kept as if all one's work were done.
-
5:33 The questions of Jewish suffering
In the seventh millennium, the Rav says, there will be no more questions. He lists the troubles that raise questions in emunah: the Churban, the Crusades, the Spanish expulsion and the Holocaust, where precisely tzaddikim suffered, and he tells of the Ten Martyrs and Rabbi Yishmael, who asked Heaven whether to accept the decree.
-
10:22 Hidden reasons behind the decrees
The Rav explains that the Ten Martyrs were a gilgul of the ten tribes, atoning for the sale of Yosef, and that tzaddikim of a later generation said those killed then were a gilgul of the rebels in the Gemara in Gittin who refused Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai's surrender to Rome. For the Holocaust no one today can give the reason, but Hashem knows it.
-
14:53 Tov l'hodos: thanking and agreeing listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Gemara that Moshe Rabbeinu asked why the righteous suffer and was not told, and says that in the seventh millennium we will thank Hashem even for the suffering, as Yeshayahu says. He explains 'tov l'hodos' as both thanking and agreeing that Hashem's ways are just, and gives the parable of the fly on a painting.
-
18:28 Morning understanding, nighttime emunah listed in the guide
The Rav explains 'l'hagid baboker chasdecha ve'emunascha baleilos': in times of light one can examine and understand Hashem's kindness, while in the dark times, when tzaddikim suffer and the wicked prosper, one needs emunah. He then explains 'alei asor va'alei navel' as rich and sad tunes, and brings Rav Nachman of Breslov that every person's life is a niggun.
-
22:48 The song of history and the tailor listed in the guide
The Rav says the whole world sings a niggun through the seven millennia, and one must think into the tune history plays. Whatever Hashem does is for our good, like painful surgery, and knowing that He is doing it brings joy. On 'ma gadlu ma'asecha' he tells how someone answered a question after the Holocaust with the parable of a tailor cutting silk.
-
26:33 Why the wicked flourish listed in the guide
On 'ish ba'ar lo yeida' the Rav explains that a mortal cannot understand the Creator, like a watch that cannot understand the watchmaker, and does not even understand that he cannot understand. The wicked flourish only to be destroyed forever, like a turkey being fattened, while Hashem is above and His enemies will be lost.
-
30:00 The tzaddik's flourishing and the missing vav listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the tzaddik will be like both the palm, which gives fruit, and the cedar, which grows tall, and will bear fruit even in old age. The psalm's last verse declares that Hashem is just; the missing vav in 'avlasa', the vav of connection, shows that now we do not see how events connect, but in the future everything will fit together like the Megillah or a puzzle.
The shiur, written up
Shabbos as a taste of the eternal Shabbos
The questions of Jewish suffering
In the seventh millennium, the Rav says, the questions that shake people's emunah will disappear. He lists them: the Churban, the Crusades, the Spanish expulsion and the Holocaust, where precisely tzaddikim suffered so much.
He recalls the Ten Martyrs. Rabbi Yishmael asked Heaven whether to accept the decree, since these Tannaim could have destroyed Rome with one curse; but a tzaddik does what Hashem wants.
Hidden reasons behind the decrees
The Ten Martyrs, the Rav explains, were a gilgul of the ten tribes, atoning for the sale of Yosef. Tzaddikim of a later generation said those killed then were a gilgul of the rebels in Gittin who refused Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai's surrender to Rome. g
Nobody today can explain the Holocaust, but everything has a reason that Hashem knows, even when the greatest tzaddikim do not.
Tov l'hodos: thanking and agreeing
Moshe Rabbeinu asked why the righteous suffer and was not told, as the Gemara relates. In the seventh millennium we will thank Hashem even for the pain, as Yeshayahu says. That is 'tov l'hodos': thanking, and also agreeing that Hashem acted rightly, the way a fly on a painting cannot see its beauty. h,i,j
Morning understanding, nighttime emunah
The song of history and the tailor
Why the wicked flourish
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
- a Tehillim 92:1 text index In the write-up: 0:00
- d apparently Rus 1:9 index In the write-up: 2:06
- j Tehillim 92:2 text index In the write-up: 14:55
- k Tehillim 92:3 text index In the write-up: 19:02
- l Tehillim 92:4 text index In the write-up: 21:07
- m apparently Tehillim 92:5 index In the write-up: 22:54
- n Tehillim 92:6 text index In the write-up: 24:59
- o Tehillim 92:7 text index In the write-up: 26:48
- p Tehillim 92:8 text index In the write-up: 26:48
- q Tehillim 92:9 text index In the write-up: 26:48
- r Tehillim 92:10-11 text index In the write-up: 26:48
- s Tehillim 92:12 29:42 text index
- t Tehillim 92:13 text index In the write-up: 30:10
- u Tehillim 92:14 text index In the write-up: 30:10
- v Tehillim 92:15 text index In the write-up: 30:10
- w Tehillim 92:16 text index In the write-up: 33:41
- y Megillas Esther (place not identified) index In the write-up: 33:41
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 0:55 Our weekly Shabbos is a small glimpse of the seventh millennium, the 'day that is entirely Shabbos'.
- 1:55 Menucha means satisfaction and gratification, the feeling of lacking nothing, not mere rest.
- 14:38 The suffering of tzaddikim throughout history has reasons that Hashem knows, even when the greatest tzaddikim do not, and in the seventh millennium they will be understood.
- 19:38 When things are clear one thanks Hashem from understanding; in the dark times one must rely on emunah.
- 24:25 Knowing that Hashem is the One doing everything, and that nothing is chance, is itself a source of joy whatever the tune.
- 34:43 In the future the connection between all the events of history will be seen, like the pieces of a puzzle put together.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:59 Why did Rashi say something was created on Shabbos, if the world was finished on the sixth day?
Answer: 3:11 What the world lacked was menucha; with Shabbos came menucha, and the work was completed.
-
Question: 9:29 Why did the emperor care that Rabbi Yishmael was asking Heaven?
Answer: 9:37 He asked to know whether to accept the decree; had Heaven said no, he could have saved himself, for these Tannaim could have destroyed Rome.
-
Question: 7:47 Why did precisely tzaddikim suffer so much at the hands of the Nazis?
Answer: 14:38 Everything has a reason that Hashem knows, even when the greatest tzaddikim do not; the time has not come to reveal it, and in the seventh millennium it will be understood.
-
Question: 28:07 Why do the wicked flourish like grass?
Answer: 28:25 In order to be destroyed forever, like the turkey a farmer stuffs before Thanksgiving.
-
Question: 33:33 Why is the vav missing from the written word 'avlasa'?
Answer: 33:46 The vav is the letter of connection; now we do not see how events connect, but when Moshiach comes the connection will be understood.
Stories
-
8:39 Rabbi Yishmael asks Heaven about the decree
When the Roman emperor decreed death on ten Tannaim, Rabbi Yishmael Kohen Gadol, one of the ten, said he would ask Heaven. He wanted to know whether they must accept the decree, since otherwise he could save himself. The Rav adds that these Tannaim, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Yehuda ben Bava, Rabbi Chanina ben Tradyon and the others, could have destroyed Rome with one curse, but a tzaddik does what Hashem wants, and they were killed.
In the story: Rabbi Yishmael ben Elisha, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Yehuda ben Bava, Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon
-
12:27 Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai smuggled out of Yerushalayim
Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai wanted to make peace with the Romans so that the Beis HaMikdash and Yerushalayim would be spared, but the rebels, the biryonim, refused to surrender. He was carried out of Yerushalayim while people were told he had passed away, and then he could speak to the Romans and ask for favors: to save the Sanhedrin and to give Yavneh for their yeshiva so Torah would continue. He could not ask for Yerushalayim, as Titus would not have granted it.
In the story: Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai, Titus
-
25:50 The tailor cutting silk
Right after the Holocaust someone asked why Hashem had done this. The answer given was a parable: one who enters a tailor's shop and sees him cut pieces from a precious roll of silk might ask why he is ruining it. But the tailor is making a garment that is not ready yet, and when the garment is seen, one will understand why he cut.
Insights
- 2:06 Menucha is not rest but gratification, like a worker whose exhausting Sunday soccer game is his menucha; Shabbos menucha is the feeling of having reached one's goal and lacking nothing.
- 17:17 'L'hodos' means both to thank and to agree, as in 'the Chachamim agree with Rabbi Meir': in the future we will agree that whatever Hashem did was right.
- 19:06 'Boker' is related to 'bikur', examining: in the light one can inspect and understand, while 'layla' is related to 'yelala', wailing, the time when only emunah helps.
- 21:07 'Asor' comes from 'ashirus', rich and gratifying tunes, and 'navel' means wretched tunes; 'higayon b'chinor' means to think into the tune Hashem is playing, whichever it is.
- 23:54 The joy of 'simachtani' does not depend on the tune: it comes from knowing that Hashem's attention is focused on me, whether He grants happiness or surgical pain.
- 30:10 Fruit trees do not grow tall because they put their strength into fruit, while tall trees give no fruit; the tzaddik will have both, like the palm and the cedar together.
- 33:33 The vav missing in the written 'avlasa' is the vav of connection: today we do not see how events connect, but in the future the vav will be read and all of history will fit together.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 3:46 The Rav says one should keep Shabbos as if all one's work were done, not thinking about business or financial responsibilities, and enjoying being with Hashem.
- 4:58 The Rav says that a Shabbos limited to not doing the melachos, without feeling the menucha, is not the real Shabbos.
- 23:21 The Rav urges thinking into the tune that history is playing and knowing that whatever Hashem does is for our good.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Esther HaMalkah, Moshe Rabbeinu, Naomi, Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon, Rabbi Meir, Rabbi Yehuda ben Bava, Rabbi Yishmael ben Elisha, Rashi, Rebbe Nachman of Breslov, the Ramban, Titus, Vashti, Yeshayahu HaNavi, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms בריונים, גלגול, הסתר פנים, ו' החיבור, יום שכולו שבת, מכירת יוסף, מנוחה, מקרה, עשרה הרוגי מלכות, קרי וכתיב, רבונו של עולם